Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

When they moved from Unity to Gnome shell, you could read all over the OMGUbuntu comments that people actually liked Unity and wished they would keep it.

It's always the same, you hear people complaining the most.

Ubuntu has been a success because they took some risk.

The first one has been to make installing proprietary drivers easy. Something they got a lot of heat for.

And since they managed to become the most popular Linux distro ever, I think critics should maybe ask themselves why.


I'm using Ubuntu 20.04 with Unity right now. Unity wasn't bad. I disliked it at first because it lacked features and it wasn't polished. After some time a lot of people started liking it.

But they messed up with Unity 8 and Mir. They didn't want to work with the community, they didn't care if they were working on stuff that already existed. Instead of working with the upstream devs, they worked alone. Where did they end up? Back to Gnome Shell with a lot of years of effort down the drain.

And this is even worse. More info here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23433794


EDIT: As a reply to this pointed out, these predate the things I claimed were created from NIH syndrome. Please disregard.

Original comment:

They also created their own init system Upstart, only to replace it with systemd later. They have their own source control system, Bazaar.

I really appreciated Ubuntu back in '06 when my laptop's wifi and graphics drivers just worked out of the box. I've used Ubuntu in various forms for a long time. But their management has some serious NIH problems.


> They also created their own init system Upstart, only to replace it with systemd later. They have their own source control system, Bazaar... their management has some serious NIH problems.

Citing these as a case of NIH is inaccurate -- Upstart and Bazaar predate Systemd and Git, respectively.

It's fairer to say that Canonical's technology, for whatever reason, often doesn't seem to catch on with the broader FOSS community.


Ah! That's my error; thank you for pointing that out. I hadn't realized that. I'll edit my comment.


I would agree with you in this about snaps IF snap were somewhere close to production level software.

Nobody can assemble some new kind of app packaging, slowing the starting speed to 5-10 seconds and call that "good rounded software"

"It is just a couple of seconds more sometimes, not a big deal" isn't going to cut it. Most of the Internet using Ubuntu, already knows that.

I think Canonical is again in denial.

It already happened a couple of times: MIR, Unity (buried by not being community driven probably), Unity8, the mobile project or something, all but forgotten now.

This snap thing is probable the pet project from a couple top guys in Canonical. Maybe hundreds of powerpoint presentations have been watched about some "big strategy" for the next years, but they didn't know the thing (snap) is unbearable slow.


Apt sucked when it started. Give it some time.

It's a complicated endavior, and it will need many iterations before becomming a decent solution. That's why we have to start ASAP.


I was annoyed at many of the moves Ubuntu made and voiced that, but at the end of the day, I kept using it. When 20.04 came out, I uninstalled snap. If I'm forced to use snap, I'm gone.

There's no comparison.

The recent I ran Debian and now Ubuntu will be gone. Evaporated in a poof of smoke. I'll be elsewhere. Probably back to Debian.


Statistically, proprietary software is regular software.

But yeah, snaps is a great solution for that, espacially because getting a non FOSS software is not possible in official distro repos, and hosting your own repo is HARD.

And that's what's happening. I installed Telegram using a snap because of this.


> Statistically, proprietary software is regular software.

Statistically, proprietary software in the world of Linux is a black swan. Free software is the rule, proprietary software the exception to the rule which tends to be used only when there are no alternatives.


There is an opt out feature: diversity.

You can always use only the system package manager, or use a distro that doesn't use snap.

All those complaints feel so moot.

It's really hard to be in FOSS nowaday: you can't make a move without your users judging you all along the way, because a lot of them are idealists that expect a lot from you, yet don't think about the non tech saavy users.

It's way easier to make proprietary software: most of your users don't criticise any single decision you make, you don't have to justify yourself, you get much more users, and you make money out of it.


> It's way easier to make proprietary software: most of your users don't criticise any single decision you make, you don't have to justify yourself, you get much more users, and you make money out of it.

Why on Earth would you think that users of proprietary software don't criticize it? I'm pretty sure that Windows gets more criticism than Ubuntu...


Take zoom: in HN we heard a lot of complains for ethical reasons, but the biggest part of the user base doesn't care and are just happy with it.

On FOSS, you'll have complains about the software it self AND ethics from most of your users, because they are mostly technical, and contains way more idealists than the average user sample.


Something can be both.

And we can enjoy the bright side of it, while not being naive.


I can only say - be very careful in how you approach these issues. Similar actions in india resulted in not so great outcomes from the government and corporations. And we are still stuck with the prejudice and discrimination - for some even greater than before.


I've been using Linux for 15 years as my daily OS, I love the package system, but this point of view is missing the point.

Those arguments are always from very tech saavy people.

They are a good exemple of purity over practicality, completly ignoring all the problems apt/yum have for the average user or dev publishing software.

If you are looking for reasons as why Linux on the destkop never happen, well, this is one of them.


It's assuming the police will do anything about it.

But the probability they even take the time to listen to the old man story is pretty slim.


I have a friend of mine that has been beaten up badly, twice.

10 years ago by his neighbours, in front of a witness. He got his jaw broken.

5 years ago by a random guy in the street, in front of a security camera that caught the dude car's plate. He got his nose broken.

In both cases, the police at best did nothing, at worst tried to activaly prevent action (loosing the case file, not registering it, not passing it around, or asking my friend to not go further).

So I'm expecting that for an old guy receiving pizzas, they have zero incentive to even think about it.


Where is this? (Btw, if your friend is getting beaten up every 5 years and the last time was 5 years ago I'd tell him to hide or stay low for a while.)


France, which shares lot of similarities with Belgium.

And franckly, this comments feels loaded with assumptions.


Indeed, It was a joke. My bad.


Happens to me all the time. Hard to convey tone using text only.


I think it's a joke..


Arf, an emoji would have helped.


Several possibilities I can imagine:

- they don't handle ordering and delivery: those are outsourced, and so they don't get the address. Or they do manage ordering, but not delivery, and the ordering system has a bug.

- they benefit from those fake sales because they are laundering money through their restaurant

- they benefit from those fake sales because they have an insurance that pays for those

- they are using those addresses, that they know don't cause problems, to test something.

- they use the pizza delivery as an excuse to be here, and do something illegal (surveillance, delivering drugs, territorial presence, etc).

- it's a fake/exagerated article/testimony


A relatively famous example of the fourth option was the Four Square Laundry in Belfast in the 1970s, which was actually a security services front which tested clothes for traces of gunpowder and explosives.

They had to run a book of initial 'customers' in order to capture the interesting trade.

Eventually it was outed with fatal results, but until then it had turned up a lot of intelligence.


That would be a lot of testing for the fourth option. :)


Indeed.

But the testing may have nothing to do with the pizza business itself.

Maybe it's a way to do hiring.

Maybe they test delivery gears.

Maybe they test the time it takes to delivery using said vehicule on one terrain.

Maybe they test the time it takes for some kind of product to be cold, or not tasteful anymore.

A serious test must be down for a long time, accross terrains and seasons.

And if you test a lot of thing, you will need a lot of deliveries for a long time.


Maybe the shops are laundering money, and pretend they are loosing money with their "victims", while actually registering a sale to allow dirty money to come in.

This solves the problem you get when laundering money with a food joint: you need customers.


Money laundering is often used as an explanation for seemingly bad business, but often it doesn't make any sense. Why would you send a pizza to a person who didn't order it and who will not pay? You can make fake orders without actually delivering any pizza. Actually producing and delivering the pizza is only expense and will increase the risk of attracting attention for specious orders (as in this article). If you really need to deliver an actual pizza for some reason, why not to a friend or relative rather than a random person?


maybe they just drive there with an empty pizza box and say here's your pizza. It would suck if one time after years and years of saying no thanks, if he said "you know what, I would like a pizza. yes" and then tried to pay.


What would be the purpose?


I agree. I'm just speculating for fun here.


The point of laundering money is to hide the origin of the money, and the way to do that is to exchange it for clean money.

You can launder money with a business: you pay vendors and employees with the dirty money. But then your receipts are the clean money.

That means you need real customers giving you money. So you do need to run an actual business.

(There are other ways to launder money, usually that involve spreading it around between various accounts so it becomes hard to track. But those don't require anything as elaborate as actually hiring employees, just a fake storefront so you can get a merchant account and some paperwork done.)


I always assumed the point of laundering money is that dirty money becomes clean once the government has a legitimate source for it. There is after all nothing technically different between clean and dirty money, it's the same bills.

So a business that is cash based claims $5 million in income from sales to customers. The business pays taxes on that $5 million. That $5 million in fact came from selling illegal drugs for cash. However, to the government the money is now clean as it originates from a legitimate source. The owner of the business can then send the profit to whatever place he wants with no worry. No real customers are needed.

edit: More specifically, a drug dealer cannot just deposit $5 million in cash into Wells Fargo without police intervention, a cash based business can.


I presume it's about making the income appear to be plausible to a tax inspector.

If you actually sell illegal drugs as a business, but claim to have a pizza place on your tax returns, the government might inspect you someday. If they find that you don't have any big pizza ovens, routine large orders for ingredients, staff of delivery drivers, piles of receipts from customers, etc, then they'll probably get suspicious very fast.

If you do make and deliver at least some pizzas on a appropriate scale, then things get a lot harder. They'd have to run down all of your customers and ask them if they ordered and received pizza, check if the dough order receipts are real and match the expected volume, are the delivery drivers real and how much work do they do, etc. Much more work to run down, and who has time for that? You could probably get away with it, for a while at least, as long as you didn't screw something else up.


Using the money to "pay vendors and employees" does not hide the source of the money. Laundering typically involves inflating reported income so that you can slip the dirty money into your income stream. If you run a pizza business, you sell one pizza for $10, but in your receipts you claim you sold two pizzas for $20. Now you've laundered $10; it's hard for the government to prove that you didn't sell two pizzas that day, and the income will seem legit.


Why would they not just randomize the addresses? Or just deliver to an office where they could claim 100€+ deliveries?


I don't know, the restaurants I suspect of laundering money around me don't bother faking customers. They are just empty most of the time.

Maybe they noticed that those adresses never cause problems (single old people) and are close enough to not be too annoying to deliver to?

Maybe they are just too lazy to do more, and it's enough for it to work?

Maybe they are using a lot more addresses but we don't get that information? But there is a limit to the addresses you can use, and you are supposed to have repeated customers.

Maybe there is something special about those adresses we don't know about?


I’m wondering how this works actually. Are they actually delivering pizzas or are those pizzas with expired ingredients or just fake boxes? I guess the latter doesn’t make sense since you’d notice more registered sales than what your raw materials are able to yield.


No, under the assumption the pizza business is laundering money, they are real pizzas. Key to business laundering money to appear real to audits, surveillance, etc.

Reason to give away pizzas would be to cutdown on marketing costs, since then you’re only filter for a “customer” is people that take random free stuff.

Similar but different setup is a fake lottery, where the winner was is preselected to win and the tickets are given away free to the public who have no chance of winning but provide there information. As long as the method of controlling the winner remains secret, it would be hard after the fact to prove the “randomly” selected winner was not random; clearly people do get caught and there are ways to detect people are doing this.

One last example would be a dry cleaning service, where they offer limited amount of to good to be true offers, then stock the rest of the clothes being “laundered” via cheap used clothes purchased at second hand stores.

A lot of these patterns show up in due diligence for business acquisition, especially mom & pop lines of business.


I'd assume eat and share what you can, and just waste the ingredients when you can't.

When you launder money, you loose some of it. It can't be helped. And criminal probably don't care about not being green.


It may be a bot? Either one with a bug, or a way for the authors to kill some competition?

The article doesn't say if the pizzas were ordered online or by phoning directly the shops.

At the begining, the bot would not have been able to call, but I assume now it's possible to make bots smart enough to handle pizza orders. It may even be a nice way to train one.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: