Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

You can see the same misconceptions when people expect mindful meditation to always:

- relax them

- make them happy

- make them less emotional

But with practice I learned that some sessions are extremely emotional, full of stress or sorrow. It's not uncommon to feel pain, distress or to cry deeply during intense meditation retreats.

The process improves one existence by making us live those aspects of our life better. Not by taking them away.

Now of course, on the long run, it will make people more relaxed, happier, etc. Making you fitter to live with yourself.

But not by removing, ignoring or suppressing suffering.

It's still here. It will always be here. That's the point of meditating.

Mindfulness forces us to observe it as it is. You see your contradictions, your scars and your urges. You see your masks, conditioning and reflexes.

If anything, it removes dichotomy. Not add to it.

In fact, from what I witnessed, meditation tends to make people remove layers in general. I rarely hear meditators talking about adding ones.

And mindfulness is certainly not emotions vs reason.

It has nothing to do with either.

Emotions and reason are here. You observe them, and yourself using them. But the fact you use them is not part of the technique. It's just a part of you, and like all parts of you, you are invited to observe it.

Like everybody, when I started years ago, I confused "be detached" with "don't feel", "label it unimportant", "try to relax". That's not it.

What you feel or the label you use are just not part of the teaching. They don't matter at all (for the practice). What matters is that you observe it.


Thank you, this is the most compelling argument for meditation I've ever seen.

Don't want to sound too ignorant (although I might be), but more often than not I encounter much simpler interpretations of meditation and its goals that (to me) sound more like instructions to wall off rather than to find peace with yourself. They also sometimes come with a tacit shaming of strong emotions, but as the saying goes: "when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure". I think that pushing for no strong emotions at all (at least on the surface) does promote walling off rather than actually understanding yourself better, which sometimes requires you to be out of balance. Like in math, always going up can lead you to a local maximum only, and to reach a global maximum you have to walk downhill once in a while.


> more often than not I encounter much simpler interpretations of meditation and its goals that (to me) sound more like instructions to wall off rather than to find peace with yourself.

I've notice this at several occasions.

It is not specific to meditation though.

Agile software development, as practiced behind corporate walls, is very different what Beck and Schwaber talked about in the 90'.

Thanks to MMA, we know now that many modern martial art teachings are not practical from a self-defense perspective.

Many may claim they follow the ideal of the same famous religious figure, and confronted with each others, will end up with opposite opinions on how to live one life.

As soon as something become mainstream, it is bound to be adapted into different variations of what it was initially intended. Yet we keep the same name for it.

For what I know, what I'm practicing is also a variation of a variation of a variation of something.


> Thanks to MMA, we know now that many modern martial art teachings are not practical from a self-defense perspective.

I don't disagree with the general point that there are martial art schools that do not teach effective self defense - but I'm not sure how MMA figures in to it.

Self defense is about situational awareness, coping with multiple attackers, probably armed. Often you may have a way of de-escalating the situation (eg: give them your wallet).

I suppose in the instance of a single un-armed rapist (often the case when the victim knows the attacker) MMA has increased the focus on grappling (ie: judu/jujutsu/bjj and various wrestling techniques).

I'm not sure what else the popularity of MMA has thought us about self defense.

Now, if your talking about ring fighting with a particular ruleset, one on one, with a referee... That might be something else.


I am not an expert, but some sources on meditation describe states of extreme emotion, as intermediate steps towards enlightenment. In Wikipedia, the first and second jhana are described as "rapture and non-sensual pleasure" (with or without internal speech respectively). So the proper path to balance seems to lead through mastery of the emotions, not suppressing them.

I think the idea is that you are not your emotions, and you don't have to be ruled by your emotions, but rather the emotions are something that happens to you, and something you can control. Doesn't mean you have to turn them off, it just means you have the option to do so if necessary. Or perhaps you feel the emotion, but are not compelled to act on it.


Walls get such a bad rap. They are how we do resilience. They are how we prevent cascade failure. They are how we can keep sailing even when a compartment floods.


That is a great description of the reality and mirrors my experience doing a lot of meditation for mindfulness in college.

Three years ago, I picked it up again for about 18 months years and once again let it slip.

It took me a long time to realize why, which is this: I have not found meditation to have been very useful in actual day to day life despite the multiple attestations from people that it brought them ... something. I got something out of meditation also, but unlike weightlifting, for me it has never been a continuing something.

There's the eye-opening moment of really becoming aware of the ephemeralness of so many impulses that inflict us day-to-day. That is a great lesson and probably helped a lot with self control. It's like the first time you realize that you can change your mood - you don't have to ride the tiger, you can stop the process, it is subject to your conscious influence if you want it to be, but you don't need to practice this once you learn it.

In practical terms, I think those impulses are actually very valuable because they tap into faster, broader lower-tier reasoning, and mindfulness, at least as I understood it and practiced it, ended up disempowering them in a way that was mildly negative, especially in interpersonal situations where the side-effects of added latency and inevitably reduced amplitude have consequences.

YMMV, obviously. Possibly I am just lazy.


Very lazy too, so I get it. I try to take so many shortcuts, and often it leads me taking more time that I would have if I did the hard thing first.

I've been meditating for 13 years, and sometimes I meet people with 3 years of practice that seem decades ahead of me.

One time, I think after my 2nd or 3rd retreat, I practiced in such a way that instead of helping myself, I got into depression. Took me a few months to change course.

I don't thing there is a "standard experience" for meditating. YMMV seems like a good summary for it.

Could be a t-shirt.

"Your Meditation May Vary"


Mindfullness is formally and best described here: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2631787720929704


I can relate.

Meditation at its core is a very mundane activity, no more special than taking a shower, going hiking or talking to your therapist.

However, humans love to create mythology or add deep meaning to anything. In doing that, we can turn a simple healthy practice into a load of BS.

That doesn't mean showering doesn't have benefits though.


Yes, but you need a google account, which means you add to the google personnal stash.

Google has enough data about me, I'm not going to pay so it can get more of it.


So you don't want Google to monetize your data, you don't want to pay for the service and you also won't stop using the service?

????


I'm just explaining my motivations, not pretending to have the moral high ground.

This is the strategy I use purely because it's what's best for me, selfishly.


I think the issue is that Google takes your money and monetizes your data anyway.


> you don't want to pay for the service

I'd be happy to pay for YouTube, if it didn't mean signing a contract whereby they own my life. (Minor exaggeration – they don't get exclusive rights to it.)


Give it to me for free and sell merch on your store like everybody else, Goog


Musk companies are working like agile software teams, except with hardware. I'm excepting that they actually launched the satellite before being able to make them work.

They tend to figure things on the way. Or not :)


Yeah even their 20ms number, the first I saw of it was when they applied for some government money, it's possible that number didn't exist until someone saw the requirement on the paperwork ;)


Geeks are a wonderful marketing vector.

And he is promising them a better internet.

I would not worry about that.


Once you are in an ocean covered with miles of ice, how do you send a signal?


Why would you dig deep into an ocean covered with miles of ice without a tether to a station?

Suppose it looks like this:

    ----- upper ice surface -----
     ice ice ice ice ice ice ice
    ~~~~~ lower ice surface ~~~~~
Then a tether station might look like this with a conduit/shaft between

         beep
         /|\
    ------|----------
          |
    ~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~
         \|/
        beep
Then you can have a swimmer-rover:

         hi!
         /|\
    ------|----------
          |
    ~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~
         \|/
        .
    <-> hi!
sorry I'm just a software dude :|


It would be my first instinct too, but I'm assuming miles of cable in frozen ice that probably move will not last for long.

But maybe setup a wireless relay? Not easy through that much ice.


This mission is starting to sound really expensive


Yup! It definitely would still be an expensive mission! But I think getting there is no longer the biggest expense :)


Ice carries radio waves a lot better than water. Once sunk through the ice, the entire probe, or a small buoy, could float up to the underside of the ice and transmit clearly to the surface.


leave sending station above ground. send down hot ice melting probe (no drilling) attached to long cable.


The meltwater would have to be removed, or the cable itself heated.


Instead of trying to pierce that, would it be a good strategy to send a radioactive weigh that will melt the ice over a decade?

Ok, that's how to get in, but not really how to get a data out :)


I like this idea! As it would take quite a while to melt its way down, you'd basically have to sink the entire rover or a submodule down with the radioactive heat source (not melting a hole then exploring it). If it's a one-way, single-purpose trip then it's not clear to me that the ice would necessarily pose any sort of issue with non-line-of-sight (aka radio) communications.

Water in and of itself isn't a great communications barrier, but the conductivity of sea/salt water causes it to act like a Faraday cage and kills/significantly dampens any radio waves attempting to pass through it.

Under the assumption that Europa's oceans are in fact salty, the frozen sea ice isn't actually all that salty. Ice in general isn't a good conductor as it's actually almost entirely the pure water that freezes leaving the salt behind (I'm not clear on whether it would precipitate but remain suspended between the the H2O molecules or if - given the lower density of Ice I - the water would freeze from the top down leaving the liquid seawater beneath it ever so slightly saltier while forming a layer of pure frozen ice on the top).

In all cases, keeping a base station while sinking a second module with the radioactive heat source then proxying all communication via the base station would be possible even if the ice did form some form of a Faraday cage that severely limited communication from beneath.


Maybe leaving a series of repeaters in a vertical line downwards would allow the information to make it to the surface where we could achieve LoS with an Earth satellite. I'm guessing taking 16 miles of some kind of cable is less realistic.

In any case it seems like there'd be astronomical expenses and many moving parts


That was my initial thought but my point is that it actually shouldn’t be necessary. 16 miles of non-conductive water should be fine for a single point-to-point em transmission at low bitrates.


> radioactive weigh that will melt the ice over a decade?

I've thought about this as well. I think there are "Prime Directive" type concerns with this approach though.


Wouldn't that have a huge impact on the ecosystem of the moon? (if it has an ecosystem)

Thinking that soon or later (after 1/10/100/1000) years the probe will for any reason release its radioactive payload into that environment, therefore contaminating it. (kind of similar as well if it keeps generating warmth at least partially for years and years and years => maybe in that case bacteria might start to increase/evolve because of that warmth, and any later observation would have to take that effect into account, which might be difficult to separate from all the local&natural causes - or it could be as well the opposite, with the probe "burning"/killing existing bacteria because they're not used to that warmth)


Rather, OP is probably already using one and don't see the point of migrating to yet another closed system.


Hypothesis has an open API - https://h.readthedocs.io/en/latest/api/


It's not the matter.

If you use a saas, unless it's open source and you can self host, you are at the mercy of it.

If the service is good enough and the team behind it seems in good faith, it can give you confidence for the switch.

But promising to adopt a standard then not doing it doesn't inspire confidence.

The system being closed source (no open API can change that), they need to build trust with some users. Particularly the tech saavy ones that have been burnt in the past and hold data that is precious to them.


Both the frontend and server seem to be open source.

https://github.com/hypothesis/h

https://github.com/hypothesis/client


Then I stand corrected.

If it's open source, and it's just a matter of following a standard, I don't think it's a reason for not giving it a try.


I tried the docker some time back and it was broken. Has anyone ever managed to set it up or are there any tutorials or blogs of any one outside the org using their own setup?


It's ok, it means you are not the target.

Things like that are good filters to find you user base and focus your resources.


Or it means they got this decision wrong.


I love the presentation text.


> Perhaps they plan to introduce custom domains in future? Maybe this just didn't fit into the initial release?

Most probably.

This is how basecamp always did thing, even back when it was called 37signals: they release a MVP, they generate money as early as they can, then they start agile feedback loop, improving the product throught many iterations.

They were one of the teams that made agile popular after all.

They also promote the philosophy of rejecting features and not noting the requests for them down.

Only a feature that has been requested and rejected enough times pass their "filter" of something that should be added to the product.

I'm betting a custom domain name will pass such filter and end up being implemented in one year or two.


It seems it's already on their roadmap, see DHH's tweet: https://twitter.com/dhh/status/1232840836733292545


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: