Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Still getting updates for my one plus 6. YMMV.


That phone is barely 2 years old from a reputable brand, I sure as hell hope it's still getting updates.

My older OnePlus 3 got updates for almost 4 years I think. Not bad, but it's not like apple's 5-6 years. Still, it was half the price of an iPhone with better hardware to boot so fair trade I guess.

I don't like frivolous spending on phones but I never keep a phone more than 4 years anyway. The progress of camera, microphone and speaker quality alone across 4 years is enough of a quality of life improvement for me to upgrade.

At this rate of Android security issues, my next phone will probably be the next iPhone SE but only if they update the display to a larger 1080p 90Hz panel and add an ultrawide camera lens, I don't care about anything else.


Still getting updates for my 7 year old ipad air 2. About to get ios 14 as well. Android has warped peoples perspectives on how long a device would get updated. On PC you can just keep installing updates until the device can't keep up anymore.


The iPad Air 2 was introduced just under six years ago. But even the original iPad Air, which was introduced nearly seven years ago, still gets security updates. The last update was released less than a month ago. It's stuck on iOS 12, though.


You are getting updates for the OS and kernel but not for device drivers. That's a big surface area for someone to hack your phone.


Imagine how good things would be if the drivers were open source and in the kernel. We would still have bugs but at least it would be possible to fix them.


Aside from the massive maintenance effort: what is keeping the community from taking all the driver code from the tons of official and unofficial code dumps and bringing them to mainline?


You can't just drop leaked code in to the kernel due to legal reasons. And even if the vendor does provide an open source dump of the source you still can't just drop it in to the kernel because it will not meet the code quality standards for linux. Vendors just hack it until it works and call it a day since they don't have to worry about unmaintainable code if they never plan to maintain it.


You definitely can drop crappy drivers to the kernel devs for later improvement as somebody else's problem. It is called "staging".


I just put Android 10 on my OnePlus One (via LineageOS). Best phone I've ever owned.


Be quite,Don't let Trump know!


This article misses the point of the django orm and migration system completly.

They are meant to allow for the dev of an ecosystem.

This is why you have so many django plugins, and why they are so easy to integrate and play together.

This is why it's easy to have a dev envs, tests, signals and api generation with django.

It trades performances and flexibility for this. It's nothing more than a classic technical compromise.

You may need raw sql later on in your django project. But if you feel like starting with it, just go with flask. Django makes no sense.


The other funny thing is how easy it is to write migrations in Python via the RunPython capabilities of the Django ORM you can migrate data over. I've yet to need to write any SQL aside from stored procedures and Database Views.

You can even export all the contents of your DB to JSON or YAML and import it in Django, so you probably very well could go from SQLite to MySQL / Postgres if you really wanted to.

Edit:

The other actually funny thing is, Django doesn't force you to use its own ORM. You can write code that doesn't use its ORM. You can override anything and everything.


> how easy it is to write migrations in Python via the RunPython capabilities of the Django ORM you can migrate data over.

Yes! This functionality is extremely useful in a number of cases and isn't all that discoverable. At least in my experience, devs often don't learn about it until they've spent at least a bit of time working on a Django project. Once you get the (basic) syntax down it's quite handy.


> You can write code that doesn't use its ORM.

You can, but what's the point using Django then? Everything is built around the ORM API, that's how admin is automatically generating pages, etc, etc. You lose the main advantage of Django if you don't use it.


ASP .NET Has the same issue, but you could always override the admin bits. If you really want another library to manage Django's database usage, you can go to town, nobody has bothered coding alternatives because the ORM is sufficient. Web frameworks are not what you use if you're even concerned with micro managing how you access a database, web microframeworks on the other hand are designed for that level of detail. Something like CherryPy or Flask is more what you'd want in that case.


For me it's too much easy to write them with sql or plpgsql.. and later I can use them from node, rust, go.. or whatever.. for me the dB (the model) it's the source of thruth that will lasts.. independent of the language that interacts with it...

Also the problem gets worst if you add to the mix something like elastic search. That it also has it's own schema and it's also has to be migrated..


But now you've got the issue that the code needs to match the DB. Django takes care of this for you. It's really quite nice.


That's the trade-off if you decouple the dB from the web framework you have to take care of both.. :) anyway, I prefer to trust the dB (real data on it) that a bunch of complicated things on the Django side.. (I suspect that happened something similar to me when I started reviewing crazy (shoot your food) class based elaborations..


You can always tell Django's ORM not to manage any of your data and write all your queries. You can also tell Django to give you the query it generates, tweak it (if / as necessary) and run from there.


But why? Granted if you have super complex queries, sure. But 95-99% of the queries are simple typically.


Agree. This article misses the use case of people using third party apps with migrations. For example. The Wagtail content management team can create migrations that can be applied to MySQL and Postgres databases. Not sure if that is possible writing SQL files.


Django is incredibly flexible, even if you decide not to use the ORM, or even to just use part of it and write a lot of raw sql, Django is a great choice. It can still be a great choice.


Or even if you ditch the SQL database entirely and use Elasticsearch or some weird custom back-end.


And then (with elastic) why you will use a synchronous web framework ;)


Synchronous web frameworks have been powering some of the largest websites on the internet for decades.

That said, Django is actively working toward async views and ORM. It's happening.


In fact, it was just released a few days ago.


Then you still need to upgrade Django.. (had seen so many sprint points spent on it.. :/)


I agree with you but I think Sqlalchemy/alembic do the compromises better than Django ORM

With Django I always ended up hitting brick walls and ugly hacks. Whereas Sqlalchemy more easily fit in any use case that I had over the years, mainly because of it having multiple layers of abstraction so I can choose and mix as applicable. Learning curve is a bit steeper i admit.

I haven't used Sqlalchemy drop in replacement for Django ORM yet, but would consider it for a future project.


I think one issue with SQLAlchemy is that, somehow, they are the worst of all worlds. They have multiple ways to run queries (iirc, the "model" way, the non-model way, and the raw way) but it is all the "model" way underneath so you end up with all kind of weird hacks if you don't want to use Python as the source of truth (i.e. if you run a query, have no data model in Python but want to turn the data into a dictionary). It seemed like a very flabby codebase (i.e. they started out doing X, and tried to add stuff on top...lots of classes that appear to do the same thing).

The only ORM that I have used that handled more complex stuff well was Jooq (Java). Having your database as the source of truth (and running a script to update Java Objects) works far better than the SQLAlchemy approach. I use Django now for a simple app but I used both Jooq and SQLAlchemy on something more complex (the issue was references to parts of the data models across components), and the former was brilliant (although learning curve) and the latter was just awful. I don't think SQLAlchemy docs are good either (again, started out as X and they just kept adding and adding).

That is just my experience. I used Django right now, there are no crazy cross-cutting concerns between components, and it works fine.


It is the other way around. The ORM sits on top of core, the sql abstraction.

This separation is what I like about it, if I know how to do something in SQL I can use the tools sqla provides and it maps very close to 1:1. Or I can use a more ORM driven approach similar to what Django does. I can adapt it over time as the project evolves.

But yes to write the queries in Python and not raw strings, you need to have either a Table or ORM Model defined, which you could generate from the database [1]. But I admit, except for some scripts, I have never used it where Python wasn't the source of truth, so don't know what it all involves.

I don't know about very old versions of SQLAlchemy, but at least in the last 4.5 years since I'm using it, I have been much happier with it for medium sized projects over any other similar tool in Python I have tried because of this flexibility

[1] Edit: Or use reflection to load schema information from the database

  >>> messages = Table('messages', meta, autoload=True, autoload_with=engine)
  >>> [c.name for c in messages.columns]
  ['message_id', 'message_name', 'date']


That's the nice thing around sqlalchemy, it's a lib, a toolkit.. you can start using it on whatever postgresql schema you found.. Django can't only work if things are done like it wants... You will also use Django for an old legacy PHP project with postgresql? You can use SA for taking on it.


You can absolutely use Django for an old Php project with PostgreSQL, just fake the initial migrations and it'll pick up right where PHP left off with the same schema.


Many of the points made apply equally to Flask/SQLAlchemy or any other framework (Rails, ...).

They optimise the wrong things and decrease security.


All of them optimize for different things (E.g. SQLalchemy and Django have very different philosophies), so are they all wrong? What should they focus on instead?


> They optimise the wrong things and decrease security.

They're not meant to optimize for every edge case, they're meant to be as generic as sanely possible.


In a system where money is power, and the economy encourages its concentration, you always end up with such unbalances.

The invisible hand cannot help here: demand will ask for cheaper prices (the 99% have a big stack of cash as a group, but a small one individually, so they seek savings), which the economy of scale will only make happen for the bigger players.

At some point, fair competition is not possible anymore.

Not to mention the ability to negotiate is driven by who you can afford to hire, who you know, how sustainable you are, etc.


> In a system where money is power, and the economy encourages its concentration, you always end up with such unbalances.

Is money really the only power? For all I know these companies depend on consumers’ attention and consumption. Not only that, the people who run them depend on continuous growth of those to keep their positions.

To the extent consumer interests can organize (which includes democratic, legal, informational organization and organizing consumption behavior) there are always ways out.

> The invisible hand cannot help here

Maybe invisible hand was never there to help. Maybe that is the origin of such a defeatist perspective.

Companies are not gods, markets are not forces of nature. They are more like semi-useful entities and processes that can also parasitize our stone age psychology for their own ends. It is on to us to realize our own part in that equation.


>Is money really the only power? For all I know these companies depend on consumers’ attention and consumption.

Which doesn't translate to any great power for smaller developers, who don't command much of consumers attention anyway. Try getting Amazon Prime, or Spotify out of the App Store and there will be a riot. Some smaller app few care about? Not so much...

>Not only that, the people who run them depend on continuous growth of those to keep their positions.

The people who run them will get their bonuses and golden parachutes even if they burn the companies to the ground. And after that they can retire or easily find other positions in different companies soon enough.

It's lesser employees that depend on growth to keep their jobs...


> Try getting Amazon Prime, or Spotify out of the App Store and there will be a riot. Some smaller app few care about? Not so much...

Which was my point. Their power doesn’t come from their money but the fact that their products are found useful by all those who would riot. I’m not saying it is necessarily fair, but it is not like that they are rent seeking in the app store, their apps are found widely valuable. If anything, app store was the rent seeker and now it is conceding due proceeds. Tough luck for the small developers who can’t band together for a lawsuit or a mass app-strike against that discrimination.

> The people who run them will get their bonuses and golden parachutes even if they burn the companies to the ground. And after that they can retire or easily find other positions in different companies soon enough.

Again, the point was the power is not in the money itself, it is in the growth obligation.

And you are wrong that growth is only a lesser employee concern, if anything having more captial means the opportunity cost of not growing the capital is much higher, so they are even more bound by the normativity of growth. Not necessarily growth of their immediate company, but any other investment instrument that eventually ties to the economy at large.


>Which was my point. Their power doesn’t come from their money but the fact that their products are found useful by all those who would riot.

That translates to money pooured though. Without huge VC investments there wouldn't be any Netflix or Amazon. And their huge followers mean more money, more resilience to Apple's demands (they don't depend on it 100%) etc. Whereas for a smaller developer house not of these are true.


>ability to negotiate is driven by who you can afford to hire, who you know, how sustainable you are

This is a good point, often subtly overlooked when discussing similar topics.


You mention economy of scale - that's why quantity discounts exist. It definitely is the invisible hand at work.


The UBI must be indexed on the cost of life and updated every year.


Exactly what will not happen, and a major reason why UBI will be a colossal failure if implemented. In our current political climate there is no way in hell UBI is implemented fairly and with rational checks and balances. The effort to implement UBI will be riddled with "pork" and what end up with in reality will be a sad, sad joke.


> The UBI must be indexed on the cost of life and updated every year.

That makes no sense at all. UBI is just an income redistribution scheme, thus it can only work if it's linked to productivity. Otherwise you create a system that's bound to fail and collapse in the times it's needed the most: an economic crisis.


A bit of a plug, but micro has been a nice alternative. Mouse support is enabled by default, ctrl+c/v works as expected, you only need to remember ctrl+e for other commands, as it opens a prompt where you can just type save/quit/etc.

Not in the repo though, which can be a no deal for many.


Oh right, it uses the operating system clipboard? That's kinda handy.

In other terminal editors I sometimes have to do a slight pause, to work out whether I'm using the editor-in-built yank chain, or pasting from operating system clipboard using the not-as-standard-as-Ctrl-V terminal emulator binding, Ctrl-Shift-V.


And then there's Vim which, depending on how it was built for the respective distro, doesn't seem to accept any way to copy or paste text.

As a daily Vim user I find this to be a huge mistake in terms of user friendliness; Vim provides ways to set the clipboard as default register and other quality of life improvements, but until then a beginner has to figure out some of the weirdest keybindings to make it work, or even recompile the program because that specific distro didn't include xclip support for some reason. It is infuriating.


I understand your practical frustration, but it can be very tricky with terminal apps to reliably interact with the X display. It's basically a completely foreign interface that requires the environment to be setup properly.

But in general I just install gvim (even if I only use Vim in the terminal) since it normally means that it'll have proper X support.


Middle click paste should "just work" and be transparent to terminal apps. It's not encouraging that vim is willing and able to break this in its default settings.


I could be misremembering but I believe that middle-click paste just makes the terminal feed the contents of the X selection to stdin of the running process. I could be wrong (because there's so much arcane knowledge in terminal emulators that I won't even pretend to have scratched the surface) but I'm not sure if Vi(m) can even tell where the input comes from. Well, maybe it could by using the speed at which the characters come in I suppose, although even that might end up being unreliable over remote connections and the like.

In my humble opinion expecting good X integration for a terminal application is bound to result in frustration. I use vim in the terminal but I also never use the mouse and I configure Vim not to interact with the X selection unless I specifically instruct it to using "*. If you want better integration with the graphical environment why not just use gvim? That's what it's for.


> middle-click paste just makes the terminal feed the contents of the X selection to stdin of the running process.

Recent versions of vim hijack this by default (`set mouse=a`). This makes the middle click paste the default vim register instead of the X selection. To paste from X, you must shift+click.

Personally, I can't understand why anyone would want this, but anyway. The best part is that you can't easily disable this globally, i.e. by putting `set mouse=` in /etc/vim/vimrc. Because if a given user does not have a ~/.vimrc of their own, then defaults.vim gets loaded after /etc/vim, overriding anything set there.


> And then there's Vim which, depending on how it was built for the respective distro, doesn't seem to accept any way to copy or paste text.

I install GVim, since it tends to be compiled with the most features enabled. You can still use the vim executable in a terminal and ignore the gvim one. Then it's just "+y / "+p to copy/paste, or add this to vimrc to map it to \y, \p:

noremap <Leader>y "+y

noremap <Leader>p "+p


I didn't know about the gvim "trick", that's good to know. Generally I just set the clipboard as default register so yanks and pastes work smoothly with other programs in every situation:

    set clipboard=unnamedplus


Try Ctrl+shift+c and Ctrl+shift+v


Unfortunately that does not work either in the worst case. I'm not quite familiar with the details behind all this, but I have had cases where it was basically impossible to get any text into or out of a Vim session aside from saving it in the text file.

I believe on Alpine OS I could get it working fine by installing some dependencies and recompiling Vim manually.

Others here have suggested to install the gvim package which seems to enable proper clipboard support in every case, I will try that next time I am in that situation again.


>on Alpine OS I could get it working fine by installing some dependencies and recompiling Vim manually maybe the mantainers of the vim package didn't use sensible build flags? vim copy-pasting usually works out-of-the-box on Debian/Ubuntu and Fedora, I avoid small and cutting-edge distributions exactly because of quirks like this


This works for me on Redhat, CentOS, and OpenSuse. I pretty much limit myself to these distributions. Work and Home Respectively.


I came to Mac relatively late and only after years of using Windows and Linux, but I really wish everyone else would copy Mac’s default English keyboard layout & shortcuts. Super+x/c/v for cut, copy, and paste, their relatively ergonomic combos for typing m-dash and various “special” characters using option/alt, and their screenshot shortcuts, especially.


>but I really wish everyone else would copy Mac’s default English keyboard layout & shortcuts. Super+x/c/v for cut, copy, and paste

Isn't this something that benefits mainly developers, at the expense of everyone else? Most people don't use the terminal, so they don't have any use for control-x/c/v. At the same time super-x/c/v is less ergonomic than control, at least for me. With control I can use my pinky + index finger, which is much more comfortable than using super, which requires me to awkardly use my thumb + index.


Admittedly it’s better on Mac keyboards, with Super directly next to the space bar. Less strain and movement to hit that with my left thumb than to stretch down to ctrl (if I hadn’t mapped caps lock to control). The rest of the layout is wildly better than any other I know of for composing text in English, which is a thing you’d think every default layout would be good at, but they’re not. Better than “standard” layouts on Linux and Windows, better than the “international” layout, and better than “alt-gr” layouts, at least.

[edit] every default layout for English, I mean. I wouldn’t expect a default layout for another language to be great for composing English text, obviously.


>Admittedly it’s better on Mac keyboards, with Super directly next to the space bar. Less strain and movement to hit that with my left thumb than to stretch down to ctrl

I'm not sure what you mean by "stretch down to ctrl". On a standard keyboard, with the control key in the bottom left corner, all you need to do is rotate your left hand slightly and use your pinky to press it. Doing so also puts your index finger in position to press the x/c/v keys. On a mac keyboard this is less doable because the control key is swapped with the fn key, but it also doesn't make pressing the command key any easier, as you still have to bend your left thumb to reach the command key (this is most apparent with c/v).

>The rest of the layout is wildly better than any other I know of for composing text in English

is this on non-US layouts? Looking at this https://store.storeimages.cdn-apple.com/4982/as-images.apple... or https://store.storeimages.cdn-apple.com/4982/as-images.apple..., the rest of the keyboard looks pretty close to standard ansi layout.


The cmd version with the modifier directly next to the spacebar involves no wrist rotation at all. I tried it to check before making my last post, and my hand feels way more tense doing ctrl+z/x/c than cmd+z/x/c, using a desktop PC keyboard for the former to make it fair. I can also move back into homerow position faster. If you’ve got super directly next to the spacebar, it’s both faster and causes less strain, as far as I can tell. Granted it’s a roughly neutral or very slightly worse change if super is between alt and ctrl.

Again, I did the standard Linux/windows thing for like 15 years before switching to Mac, so I don’t think I prefer it just due to familiarity.

[edit] the key to their layout being so good for writing is how Option/Alt is used. Option plus a character will often get you a common modified version of that character that’s very useful (so you can type, say, façade, or a —, quickly and easily). Holding option changes practically every key on the keyboard, and shift+option does it again to a different set of chars. They’re not perfectly discoverable and some are compose keys (but visible on the screen, not hidden as a key that seems to do nothing!), but if you forget where the cent sign or euro or or pound are it’s easy to remember they’re in the numbers somewhere near dollar and find them again in a second or two.

[edit edit] the international layout can be better for some people but is basically obsoleted by Mac’s “hold a key and see accented versions to choose from” functionality, and alt-gr is similar to what Mac’s standard English layout does, except worse.


What I really enjoy about micro is that it is one stand-alone static executable. It works well inside of a docker container just in case you need to edit a file in which the image did not ship with an editor (or volume is not mounted).

The Windows version also works very well.

Micro is great.


It is stable enough? I tried it a few years back, but it felt like a beta3 or beta4 software, crashing about once per day. But maybe things improved since then.


I've used it as my terminal editor for a few years and it's been good for me.


You should try it again. It is very stable now.


It is in Ubuntu 20.04.


micro > nano


Only if it is in the big repos.


Pure players are getting EAFP on us rather than LBYL, I wonder where they learned that frop...


They can collect the data as usual, and they will, but for once they would not even need to. They can just wait until no shop can make a living without it because they dominate the market. They they start charging.


Free until they dominate the entire market


You really think Google -- who has floundered in this space for years -- is going to dominate a market that is already dominated by a company (Amazon) with a 50% larger market cap?

Walmart and Target have been trying to chip away at Amazon's lead, and they're only getting buried deeper in the dust. Google doesn't exactly have a reputation for entering new markets and dominating them, either...


People don't search things on amazon, they search things on google, which link to amazon.

So yes, they have a huge potential.

They always have sucked doing things IRL, so it's not a certain win. But owning the road to the competition shop is powerful.

Not to mention they can force the hand of small shops: use our API or go down in ranking.


That's wrong. There was a study [1] on this exactly that found that most people (in the US I think) who search products start with Amazon and not Google. In one of the recent Amazon earning reports, they reported $10B advertisement revenue, which is another indication that direct product search on Amazon is huge.

[1] Google it :)


Actually Google is getting shittier and crappier every day. Btw. I usually look for things on Amazon, they search engine has the same issue as Google's. Only spam (they call it ad) in the first N positions. I would seriously pay for a service which has no PII data collection (still can measure the effectiveness of your engine), no ads and relevant results.


Is that still true? For most products Amazon search seems much improved to me, it used to be quite poor. Plus on mobile people may be biased to search via the app.


Most people don't even know what an URL is. They can't tell the difference between an app and a website. They think google is the internet. Hell, even the ones that do know better type the site URL into google to go to the site they want.


Most lists I've seen on the topic show Amazon as having the 3rd most trafficked search engine (after Google and YouTube)


>Google doesn't exactly have a reputation for entering new markets and dominating them, either...

Mobile OS's (Android)

Online Video (Youtube)

Online Maps (Google Maps)

Webmail (Gmail)

None recently, granted.


Google photos was launched in 2015 and hit a billion users in 2019 [0].

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Photos


Yeah but all those are not IRL activities, so there is a small chance that they mess that up. They are really not good with real people.


Google Maps is very much real life. And it was very easy to mess up. Big usability achievement.

In fact I think it's underrated. It truly changed my world. Earlier I was always nervous when driving and frequently speeding. It's so liberating to be able to call a friend and say "uh I'll be 8 minutes late, sorry".


I mean, looking at a map used to be an IRL activity.


Mapquest was already successful before Google maps.


So isn't that a perfect example of Google entering a new market and dominating it?


Don't for get calendar and docs


I feel like MS Word (offline) still has a majority marketshare for general documenting, and calendars outlook also has a big chunk of the market.

Depends on where you draw the boundaries in markets certainly...


Weren't they all acquisitions?


Gmail was internal. Maps was mostly built by a couple acquisitions, but it wasn't anything like Youtube, where the acquired companies were big established players in the space.


Gmail wasn't.


> already dominated by a company (Amazon) with a 50% larger market cap?

I wouldn't if Amazon was doing a good job. Between the astroturf reviews, fake products and fictional shipping times Amazon leaves a lot to be desired.

But I do agree Google won't be the solution. Google is too hidebound and suspect now to solve this one.

I think the future is in independent online retailers. The good ones will thrive and the rest will vanish, and they aren't going to suffer the FAANGs any more than necessary.


No, but with Shopify, Woo Commerce, and Big Commerce - maybe.


Or wipe out the low commission fee competition in the payment processor space.

If the US had better anti-competitive enforcement I feel like this is akin to the Internet Explorer/Netscape/Microsoft case, in them using one monopoly (search) to take over another market (same hook too: "free").

Plus you know they're going to reward sites for using this in their search rankings (or just outright place them at the top).


I think reward, but it is pretty cunning, the rewarded sites get better placement so better profit so it will be easy for others to see how google outperforms to other solutions.


Look like they aren't doing payment processing. They're partnering with Paypal and Shopify. So by "commission-free" that would mean the commission on top of payment processing?


Love how baseless allegations like "reward in search rankings" are heeded here. If I write something egregious without a source against Duck Duck Go I'd be downvoted to oblivion


Google is pretty strict about not artificially rewarding sites in the organic rankings. (ie. non-ads and non-infoboxes).

However, despite that those sites will get an implicit reward - if users go to these sites, and find a slick easy checkout and low prices, the site will satisfy their need. Google's goal is to put sites that satisfy the users search request at the top.

So, assuming this new Google service is any good, then sites that use it will end up upranked just because those sites satisfy users more than other sites.


Intuitively I don't like the idea of Google controlling everything but based on the reason you gave it sounds like this would be a good idea right? Customers get a better experience in the end.


Yes, although it ignores 2ndary effects (eg. Google takes over payments market, all other competitors go bankrupt, Google stops innovating because no competition, users lose out because no innovation).

That happened in things like Google Reader - users loved the service so much the industry for RSS readers died and stagnated, hurting users...


It would only be "baseless" if it hadn't happened before.

People learn from experience and the experiences of others.


Your vendetta doesn't make something real.


I have no vendetta. You're projecting.


AMP, quick search box, bread crumbs...

Google track record is not great in that regards.


It's not entirely baseless. Look at what's happening with AMP. Google aren't a charity, and at some point in the last decade they realized it.


What is happening with AMP ? The pages load faster. They made it clear they will reward page load times in ranking. They have made no such shopping related claim here.


Implement AMP and get rewarded with a carousel position (ie. better rankings). Implement a faster-than-amp experience using plain HTML+CSS and get... at worst: nothing. At best: you'll get up-ranked slightly.

But, no matter how much faster (or better) your page, you will never, ever, be above, or in the carousel.

How do you consider that "baseless"? It's obvious that Google rewards sites that do things the way it dictates.


". At best: you'll get up-ranked slightly." " you will never, ever, be above, or in the carousel."

Read what you write please.


It could have been expressed more clearly, but I'm not clear what's so obviously wrong with what I said that you felt the need to be rude.

What I said: You'll get up-ranked, but will always be below the carousel. Therefore being in the carousel is an unfair advantage of AMP.


Or until they get bored with updating it and EOL it.


I'm just glad there's someone to temper Amazon from world dominance... For now.


Unfortunately it's like Alien vs Predator. Whoever wins, we lose.


At first, me too.

But amazon doesn't have a search monopoly, millions of android devices, google maps, or youtube to drive the sales.

Neither do they have the huge amount of data google already have on people.

Now there is a possibility that google fails because sales require a lot of IRL stuff they suck at. So maybe it will be a balanced game.

But if they win, it's going to be a nightmare.

Unrelated, but I'm also quite worried about Apple deciding to become a bank one day.


> But amazon doesn't have a search monopoly, millions of android devices, google maps, or youtube to drive the sales.

Don't forget that something like ~70% of their income comes from AWS. They may not be as visible as Google on the net but they are pretty much the largest provider of web services.


Sure but they make this money in B2B, not using customers data.


It is a good move, until amazon starts taking blatant measures like banning traders with google shopping fronts.


Can you ?

Cause the patriot act has been reconducted for 3 generations of presidents since 9/11, including obama, along with legalized mass surveillance, torture and deny of habeas corpus.


I'll make the mandatory comment about how this is a case typically better served by a good library than a DSL.

This language is very niche, it will never get good support, tooling, doc, and maintenance.

I know making languages are fun, but unless fun is the main goal and adoption is not, craft a good lib with a clean and simple API.

Adopting this DSL would not be reasonable on the long run.


Comments like these are absolutely useless and contribute nothing to the conversation at all. There are benefits making a language, and people's goal doesn't always have to be "get as many people to use it as possible."


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: