Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Unless the AI can talk tot the patient to get some context, it's going to be taking decisions with only very partial information, no matter how good it is.

Still, I'm thinking that as it improves, it's going to show that doctors are not that good at their job on average, and that's going to be fun to watch.


> Still, I'm thinking that as it improves, it's going to show that doctors are not that good at their job on average, and that's going to be fun to watch.

Medical AI is trained on labels generated by doctors. Can you explain how it will exceed the performance of doctors on average? Are you assuming that the labels will be generated by the "top x%" of doctors? If so, how will you identify those individuals? Or is there some other mechanism you're expecting to improve the performance?


Medical ML is not about making decisions but about informing decisions. It is a tool for the doctor, not a replacement.


I think AI should always be a support tool, but people are always talking about replacing doctors...

And a high volume if diverse quality data is fundamental: https://en.capillary.io/posts/ai-medical-diagnosis-guide/


>I think AI should always be a support tool, but people are always talking about replacing doctors...

Because Americans are trying to solve their healthcare crisis by attacking the doctors and literally not the entire rest of the industry which controls the spiraling healthcare costs. The end of result if we manage to eliminate doctors is still spiraling out of control healthcare.


That's what it should be, that's not how it's being sold, and how it's going to be used.

Just like for wikipedia.


Radiologists aren't talking to the patient either and don't have earlier scans available, they "just" comment on the image; so the doctor who does have the patient, their history and the radiology report(s) might as well receive the report from a ML system instead of a human radiologist.


That’s how it is in the US, and it’s terrible.

In other places, e.g. Mexico, India, the radiologist can very much be talking to the patient, and can have information from earlier scans.


For preserving comments, use redbaron: https://github.com/PyCQA/redbaron

It's lossless, besides, the API is much nicer.


This is a recurring joke with my brother. One day he was giving me an advice that was technically true but absolutely impossible to follow.

I told him: "You know how to win a race again Usain Bolt? Just run faster!".

Now we regularly use "just run faster" as a punchline.


I think my classmates in IT school learned much more from bypassing the network restrictions to play WoW in class than from the teachers themself.


Above all, it's much more usable now, especially with 3.10 around the corner:

- you can use list[] instead of typing.List[]. Same for dicts or sets.

- you will be able to use bool | str instead of typing.Union[bool, str]

- mypy has saner default, is better supported by IDE and is way faster

- a lot of edge cases are now covered, including protocols for duck typing, vartype, etc.

- fantastic libs such as pydantic, fastapi and typer make using them a ton of fun


That's basically how most modern frameworks do it.

Django-Rest-Framework does that with view + serializer + validators.

A more recent example, with a leaner and cooler implementation is FastAPI, where type hints are also use to declare validation on your end point, while a model is used for serializing the response.


A bit of a plug, but if you are using python in your project already, give a try to pydoit (pydoit.org/). It completely replaced make, task runners or build systems for me.

Pydoit is the sweet spot for most of my use cases:

- it scales up (graph of deps, file watcher, etc) but above all, it scales DOWN (simple stuff are dead simple)

- it promotes a declarative task definition

- it embraces the shell yet let you use python if you need to

- it gets out of your way and doesn't try to rule your project. It just runs what you want and disapear.

- the doc is nice

The biggest drawback is that you need to pip install it, which means non python devs will avoid it. I wish it was provided as an stand alone executable


a meta-plug is in order for pipx, then: https://pipxproject.github.io/pipx/

which wholly abstracts "pip install this thing that has an entry_point without hating your life."



Having to work with multi-language codebases cures one real fast of any interest in single-language build systems.

Still, make kinda sucks. I've yet to meet a build system that ticks these boxes: multi-language, simple, fast.


pydoit is not single language in the sense it limits your to tasks for your language. It's completely agnostic in that sense, and I use it for non python projects as well.

Even the fact it's using python to declare your tasks is not a problem: it's basically a function signature and a mapping, nothing you can't master in 5 minutes, and certainly simpler than make files DSL. Also easier to get right and debug.

The problem is the fact you need python to install it and run it, which non python dev will rightfully not care to do.




More details for those who are interested. The physics package is about the size of a grain of rice.

https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2017/05/09/VCAT-...

Many teams around the world are actively developing improvements on this technology.

https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2019/05/nist-team-demo...


UFO are cool, they don't need to be from aliens to be cool.

New weather phenomena? So cool!

Strange illusion? Still cool!

Technical prowess from a foreign gov? Super cool!


Luis Elizondo, former head of the Pentagon's Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program, has publicly stated that they're 99% sure that the 5-10% of the crafts they are not able to identify are not technologies from foreign governments. He's also mentioned that the Pentagon is aware that Russian and Chinese governments are also in the same position and have been working to figure it out.

These craft pull 500-800Gs and have been measured to be going 13000-20000mph+, so it's highly unlikely that they're made by humans, unless we've figured out a way to not turn into goo at that force, and use materials that could withstand that force as well.

Whatever these things are, they're not weather phenomena, nor illusions, especially when they've been visually identified by countless navy and air force pilots, and picked up/measured by military radar, satellite systems, and other instruments. Pretty sure the military would have easily ruled out weather phenomena/illusions given their budget and capabilities.


From Wikipedia:

“In the 2021 New Yorker article, reporter Gideon Lewis-Kraus writes that after talking with Elizondo, it was difficult to tell what AATIP had accomplished, and when pressed, Elizondo "invokes his security oath like a catchphrase". When in 2019 Elizondo was interviewed by Tucker Carlson, Elizondo stated that the government had fragments of a UFO, "then quickly invoked his security oath".[4] Colavito writes that Elizondo "still speaks of demon cabals, otherworldly beings, and UFOs operating beyond human perception — just not on 60 Minutes", and characterizes Elizondo's claims as "bad science and dangerous as government policy, the kind of magical thinking that leads to lunacy and disaster".[30]”


it's kind of dodgy if you can point to one flawed human and say, "see i found some dirt" and use that to convince yourself that everything you can somehow tenuously connect to that human must be false. radical simplification of reality. i understand the motivation, but i don't think it pass muster.

"breathe a sigh of relief, people, the US government today, can announce, that after decades of so-called unexplained sightings, radar data, navy witnesses, civilian encounters worldwide numbering in the millions, we have finally been able to come to a conclusive and final answer that will explain once and for all the previously mysterious phenomena known as UFOs. Here it is, folks: Luis Elizondo has been proven to be a crank. Now all of us can rest in the surety that UFOs must therefore be false, and no further study needs to be done about any of it. Thank you."

it's like a "omg i can't take this truth" fantasy to think this kind of stuff. Just be a little bit open, if it scares you, just ignore it...but pretending it's not real....closes yourself off to reality.


which wikipedia article?


My comment is not trying to characterize any UFO in particular.

I'm just stating that the whole concept of UFO is exciting, regarding of interpretation.

I'm open minded about any theory, in any case, it's a lot of fun.


> Technical prowess from a foreign gov? Super cool!

... and depending on your viewpoint, super scary!


I think some of the people behind the current "disclosure" are definitely pushing that angle.

Russians have flying saucers! Fund us plz & thank.


To be clear, the pentagon for the last 70 years has kept a tight lip on any UFO information, and is only now creating a report after forced compliance.

Even the stuff Harry Reid did a while back was fought against by the pentagon.

Their position seems to be, anything we don't know that is in our airspace is a threat, and none of it is the public's business


The TTSA disclosures of videos were snuck out without going through proper channels, if not exactly fully unofficial. And they did get groused at for that.

But there was a point, I think in late 2019, when they made a very unforced admission that the videos were real. it would have been much more normal and typical of their previous behaviour to just stick to "we can neither confirm nor deny".

And that, in itself, is interesting.


They could also be the ones behind the developments. So not only can you scare the population into securing more funding, but they serve as an implicit threat to other governments: if these things can evade an F35-A, what hope does a MiG have?

Plus, it's a good sales tactic.


could also be technical prowess from a private company or part of our government that is so secret it doesn't want to tell the military what it's doing, so it can be classified.

And that would also be cool

I've met a few people that really believe in aliens, and they are insufferable. It's like trying to talk to a young earth christian about dinosaurs. In general, I like when people question the official story, but not when they have their own answers to their questions. I have a feeling that this article is in response to that crowd. Though I can't read it because nytimes and all.


Unless I missing something, there are a ton of open source client side encrypted pastebins around.

E.G: 0bin.net (https://0bin.net/), with a lot of good faith in the FAQ (https://0bin.net/faq/), a basic and open source code (https://github.com/Tygs/0bin), zero JS stats on the main instance and alternative instances already in the wild. It does feature self destruct.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: