Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Pareto, context and objectives are importort factors in that decision.

Coding a 5 lines bash script in rust brings safety but it's not a win.


If the bash script had an incorrect value due to an implicit conversion, then yes, the rust implementation is clearly a win.


So, context.


Then why use a kindle at all ? There a better and or freer brands if you don't use amazon ecosystem.


Define better. Eink, lightweight, and perfectly sized for books. What is missing?


Nicer screens/features and hackability mostly. The Kindles so far are midrange hardware at best (and their pricing reflects that). Only the Kindle Oasis 3 approaches a resolution on which you can open a comic/manga/pdf full page and read smaller fonts. Entirely missing from the Amazon lineup (and where we're entering the $400-$1000 range) are ebook tablets.

Having gone through a dozen different reading devices, I can say that I prefer Kobo devices. They admittedly have a special place in my heart for being fixable after I soft bricked one by messing around with the OS via ssh - their "internal" storage is an actual physical micro sd card sitting on the board that you can pop out after opening the device. A kind stranger on a forum sent me a good firmware and a 'dd' later I had a working device again.


Kobo and PocketBook readers have all those features and can be fed with every format you wish just by plugging them to any computer without conversion or by sending them anything by email, or Dropbox.

And you can turn pages by pressing a good old button standing right under your finger.


I never understood the no-epub stance of Amazon. Some carefully edited epubs gets botched when transformed by Calibre.

That said, at hardware level the Kindle is hard to beat.


Dialing in the precise transformations needed for every copy got so annoying I eventually accepted the botching.


Not having to fight the device to stop it from phoning home might also be a feature that's missing from Kindle devices.


The essential page-turn keys.


I pcik up refurb Kindles for 30-50 EUR. Plus Calibre makes for a fine and hassle free experience.


My paperwhite 3 was the best choice at the time for a pocket-sized waterproof reader.


Extreem changes in a system deeply adapted to a current situation is always a problem, that's why you hear mostly about the down and not the up.

Slow or local changes are ok because life adapts nicely.

Brutal or global changes will also see adaptation, but will cause much pain and damages.

Moving a cristal glass on a few yards or meters at the average speed of 4 miles or km an hour may be fine for the glass or not, depending if your speed is mostly constant, or not.

If you move the glass excrucingly slowly first, of throw it brutally at the last inch/cm, it will be bad for the glass. You won't hear about the good stories about this, because there are not aligned with the nature if the situation.


No, Apple fully understands the situation, and in fact, you don't see many Apple fanboys in the comments defending the firm for once because even they know it's wrong.

Apple just communicates this message because that's what they need to say for their business, that's all.

And they can do so because they also know this uproar will disapear like tears in the rain in a short time if they keep smiling. Their bottom line will not be affected because people don't care.

Remember that now, Bill Gates, who we used to associate ti Satan in the 90s, is now viewed as a hero.

Remember that about 1 american out of 160 is working at Amazon, a company with the reputation of treating their employees terribly. Most people hence knows somebody impacted by this, but don't stop shopping at amazon.

Remember you could say you grab them by the pussy and be elected president.

Remember people gives in mass their data to someone who said "they trust me, the dumb fucks".

Remember that when somebody risked his life to unveil a massive conspiracy to spy on the entire world, the person has been hunted as a traitor.

Remember that one president can lie about WMD, go to war against the vote of the UN, kill thousands of civiliands, spend 600 billions of dollars there while poverty is rising at home, and suffer no consequence whatsoever. Most people have forgotten already. Hell, my girlfriend don't even remember the name of the guy.

But it's you that have to be monitored all the time for CP. And you will be punished harshly if you behave badly, not just according to law, but also according to social contracts, both which powerful people can escape now with money and PR.

That's the world we are living right now.


The problem is not perceptual hashes. The problem is the back door. Let's not focus on the defect of the train leading you to the concentration camp. The problem is that there is a camp at the end of the rail road.


Na they will ruin your life even if you are found innocent and pay no price for it.

That's the problem: the terrible asymetry. The same one you find with TOS, or politicians working for lobbists.


Who would a company hire: the candidate with a trial for CP due to a false positive or the candidate without ?

And this is just to address the original concept of this scanning.

As many others have pointed out there is too much evidence pointing to other uses in the future.


> Who would a company hire: the candidate with a trial for CP due to a false positive or the candidate without ?

First time I've seen it abbreviated like that; took me a while to grasp. Well, more of a plausible "Enemy of society" than what I came up with: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28060995


Unfortunalty if our experience from the past with such events teaches us anything, it's that a minority of us will stop using apple products (or keep not doing it) but the rest of the world will quickly forget and carry on as usual.

Worse, if your decision to not use an iphone makes others people life slightly anoying for 2 seconds a week, many will bash on you.

As a FOSS user with no FB nor whatsapp account that ask to avoid photos to be taken of him with smartphones, I can tell you I pay regularly the price the price for what I think is doing the right thing. It's just easier to let the abuse go on.

And we have other fights in life. I didnt pick up smoking (pot of cigarets), stopped drinking alcohol, became vegetarian. They all come with social challenges. Add then you have your familly, job, health and goals that needs your care, attention and time.

At some point you just want to say "screw them", create your own bubble of freedom and let them enjoy their distopia. Except we kind of live in it, don't we?

I'm usually an upbeat person but these types of event arrive in a never ending stream, and today I feel tired.


There is no viable option if you want a quality smartphone.

Androids spy on you already.

Apple will be spying on you.

The dark side of economies of scale.


We are not here by accident. Those are symptoms of a public that doesn't care. We have been explaining the consequences of each choice for techs during the last 20 years. I've had the talk with my friends and familly many times. Very patiently. Very nicely.

Nobody cares. It's just an annoyance for them.

And it requires an enormous more amounr of energy to live your live this way than not caring. Even more if you gotta explain.

And so here we are.


Most people believe they are good and conforming. They don't believe anything would happen to them because of what Apple does and they don't want to be seen as those defending abusers right to privacy.


Yes, as a society we are giving up privacy for convenience.


How would the public demonstrate caring about this?


Acting concerned in discussions would be a start. Choosing what services to use, what product to buy, what media to consume, not just because that's the easiest. Limit their involvment in this, even professionnally, if they can.

It doesn't need to be perfect. People have constraints, and life is hard.

But politicians and busines people don't care about being good or bad. They just follow the wind.

Now being gay is trendy, well, they are pro gay.

More people care about organic, they sell organic.

Just caring a little, demonstarting a little that we disaprove and want something else orient their decisions. Because their decisions are not driven by moral, it's just business.

Also, even if you don't do any of this, and I can believe I have to even state this, not teasing or shaming those who do would be an improvement.


Voting with their wallets and a lot of leg-stomping


Android ROMs like GrapheneOS do not spy on you, verifiably.


Verifiably? Are people still swapping ROMs on XDA developers like its 1990? Are folks still having to dump binary blobs from devices to get the things to work with non-stock ROMs? Are some people still relying on jailbreaking tools they have to “just trust”? Does the modem on all these SOCs still run it’s own network facing machine with full RAM access?

Things might be better, but it’s not all roses.


It's non-trivial to unlock, root, and install a custom ROM - unless you are technical, very few people are going to be able to do this.

Also, it's been several years since I used a custom ROM, but I thought rooted devices were not permitted to use the official Google Play Store? (happy to be corrected if I've got this point wrong!)


Rooting and installing a custom ROM are two independent things, you don't need one to have the other.

Rooted devices can use the official Play Store yes, though most people use Aurora Store to access the Play Store because they tend to remove Google Play Services from their phones as well.


A good first step, but that the public won't take. We've seen it with linux on the desktop already.


Linux on the desktop is pretty viable now, but yeah, still hard to convince the public without marketing shenanigans.


Moving good sense (good sense, not "good" conclusions - abilities, not partytaking) to the median is the massive endavour.

What is to be preserved as core is to have the alternatives. Note: in some areas they are already fading...

(I have this flash of Mr. Pink first trying a "We are professionals, right?", than shielding himself behind concrete.)


There's puri.sm, pinephone, fairphone with /e/.


There are multiple open source Android variants. You can use LineageOS with no Google services.


A Pixel with CalyxOS is a viable option in my experience.


The fact that Apple ordered upwards of 90M new iPhones tells me they took all the backlash from techies into consideration and still found it beneficial.

Something tells me that this could be used as marketing, e.g. "protect your children from abuse", "be aware of when pictures of them are taken", and "protect your children from pornography".


And we know how this has went in the past: wooops, our system has made a mistake and ruined your like, we apologize and won't do it again. No consequences and they'll do it again.


Not to mention even if we could somehow trust them now, there is an infinite variables on the futures for this to change.


So you mean the company that was part of PRISM, that has unfair business practices and a bully as a founder was not really the world savior their marketting speach said they were ?

I'm in shock. Multi-billion dollars company usually never lies to make money! And power grabbing entities have such a neat track record in human history.

Not to mention nobody saw that coming and told repeatadly one should not get locked into such a closed and proprietary ecosystem in the first place.

I mean, dang, this serial killer was such a nice guy. The dead babies in the basements were weird but appart from that he was a stellar neighbour.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: