> So they can get a warrant to come into your house while you're not home and put a keylogger in your keyboard USB cable, or put a bug on the UART of your router, etc. Or just hacking your cheap Netgear router with one of the hundreds of vulnerabilities that exist.
That's actually not that weird.
If you are a suspected criminal and a judge give a warrant targeting you specifically, it's quite natural the police can now gather information on you by any mean possible.
It's not warrant-less, it's not mass surveillance, it sounds like regular police work. Or am I missing something?
Not being a legal expert, I can’t tell where the boundary is between enabling legitimate police work and giving (accidentally or deliberately) the police the power to plant fake evidence, the latter being what some of this sounds like. But, I’m not a legal expert, and “sounds like” is a way to make very large mistakes when looking outside of one’s own domain of expertise like I’m doing here.
(Also doesn’t help that I hear about stories like this from people who don’t like them, so I get a potentially biased first impression).
I have no idea how Australia handles this, but in the U.S., the process of discovery is what is supposed to keep the police from just planting evidence. Prosecution needs to present all evidence that will be used against you, including exactly where it came from and chain of custody. If they can't, it gets thrown out. The only exception is they can't be compelled to give away the identity of confidential informants. But a confidential informant also can't testify anonymously, so the police would always need additional evidence beyond the word of a CI.
It's not a perfect system by any means. The police can and do plant evidence. But a lot of convictions also get thrown out and this is often why obviously guilty people get off on "technicalities" because the police don't follow procedure down to the letter.
The opposite end of the spectrum, not giving the police any power to do covert surveillance at all, is effectively just giving a license to the Mafia to do whatever it wants, as anyone who just commits all of their crimes privately will get away with it as long as they can sufficiently scare or kill anyone who would otherwise have been willing to testify.
It's a tradeoff either way, and we try to let there be a middle ground, where the police can bug your house, tap your phone, hack your router, but they need a warrant that has to be granted by a completely separate branch of government that is not in the same chain of command, and they have to prove to your lawyers that they obtained all of the evidence they have against you legally.
Indeed, I have no issue with the police having the power to read whatever data a warrant grants.
My problem is the linked page says:
> A DATA DISRUPTION WARRANT enables the agencies to “add, copy, delete or alter” data on devices.
Copy is fine, it’s the other three which are scary. Perhaps they shouldn’t be scary, perhaps they have well-defined meanings in law I’m just not familiar with (like how “Hacker News” has nothing to do with cyber crime), but I can only respond within the limits of my knowledge, and that seems scary.
I think the reason they want the ability to add, delete, and alter is so they can disrupt certain users, software, or services legally, like botnets or arms deals. It's probably too broad and could be abused though.
> A DATA DISRUPTION WARRANT enables the agencies to “add, copy, delete or alter” data on devices.
With the exception of the word “copy”, this makes it seem like the plan is to make it not merely possible but also legally acceptable for anyone given such a warrant to create/place that evidence (or delete things to make real data look incriminating by lack of context).
Again, I really know I can’t trust my interpretation of any legal text, all I can say is it does sound bad to an outsider like me.
It's certainly better than simply compromising everyone but it's not like they're going to stop their mass surveillance activities. This is just a step towards legitimization of those activities.
It's time for computer security to include nation states in their threat model. We need tamper-evident hardware.
Remember that Apple is putting photo scanning and reporting into their hardware. They just postponed it because they phone their big event and new phone to sell, then they will do it.
Could you mention what? As they said, the shortcut to bring to front is OS configuration and spatial organization is in tab groups addons (though without arbitrary spatial locations), and the fuzzy find seems similar to what Vimium provides. I'm open to the idea that there's value in grouping such features together - but unless I'm missing some other feature, this seems much better implemented (and has a better chance to be long term supported) as a Firefox profile with those addons installed and perhaps a tiny program to capture the shortcut and execute that Firefox profile.
That's like saying we must pay them because we said we will pay them, which is the definition of debt.
My question is more, that given your comment and others suggest it will never been paid completely, why then pay at all? What's the threshold for "we pay this, but not that"?
Nope, when I'm on the go, I certainly have a way better communication using phone calls than whatever VOIP du jour.
Phone numbers, like emails, are very robust and reliable, interoperable, not centralized to one entity, and the quality of service vs cost ratio is excellent.
Not to mention text messages:
- they work no matter if the person is using whatsapp, telegram, signal or the new hype stuff
- no GAFAM is collecting my text history to sell me ads
- they require no internet connection
There are 3 things that we must absolutely cherish and preserve in this race for tech: cash, emails and phone numbers.
They are a beacon of stability in this sea of ever moving innovation greed.
And I say that while I'm thinking about setting up an IFPS website, compiling python 3.10 beta to test it and buy a secondary e-ink screen for my laptop. I'm not technophobic.
> Email and SMS aren't reliable, you've no way to know if they've been read.
Most people do not want this feature. 9/10 of my iMessage contacts turn off read receipts; I bet the number would be similar on Facebook/Whatsapp if they allowed it.
> Email and SMS aren't reliable, you've no way to know if they've been read.
For me, ephemerality, one-shot, and unidirectionality are characteristics, not issues.
> SMS is unencrypted so someone's harvesting your data.
There is not a single entity that is getting all of it, which is the most important to me. Encryption is nice, but for most of my communications, that's not the most important feature.
> They require a cell tower connection, that's only 1 step away from an internet connection, probably 0 in many cases.
I'm regularly in situations where the phone works, but not internet. On the move, or in the country side.
> Cash and Phone numbers are trivial to steal.
Sure, and so is a bike. But I don't always want to take the bus.