Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Besides, associating meditation to religion is like assuming fasting == religion.

They are both practices that can exist without mythology, sacred texts or believes of what happens after death.


> They are both practices that can exist without mythology, sacred texts or believes of what happens after death.

While I agree with your main point, that they are equating things that and not the same, you seem to be to be making the same mistake. None of the things you list are required for religion either.


I think you have the sense of things reversed. The point is that mythology, sacred texts, and afterlife beliefs usually aren't a thing unless religion is involved.


> Besides, associating meditation to religion is like assuming fasting == religion.

Meditation and fasting are both integral parts of Sanatana Dharma (called hinduism by westerners).

Dont mix these with you perception of Christianity.


Intersection != Equality

I fast. I meditate. I'm not religious.

One may be religious and not fast nor meditate.


That's an interesting design, it seems like the best of both worlds. Zip has really neat ideas. I wish it didn't go the "case as you want road" though.


> I wish it didn't go the "case as you want road" though.

That's almost inevitable given its desire for close interop with C (as in, the Zig compiler includes a C compiler and can directly #include C headers).

The standard library has a relatively consistent case style though, which the Zig guide recommends.


In Python at least, you can easily call an async function from a sync function:

    result = asyncio.run_until_complete(func)
Also, having explicit async/await are a wait to tell you: here are the point in your code that have something doing unreliable side effects down there.

You can then use this information to:

- move that code and group it, so you get the rest of the code sansIO style

- put that in a try/except, because this code WILL fail at some point

- think about the perfs of this part of your code, which is what you are doing async io the first place

I do wish that python coro would schedule themself automatically, like JS does, and return a future that you can await explicitly. But that ship as sailed.


You can do that in pretty much every language, it's just that in most of implementations, blocking on an async call can easily dead-lock, .NET is particularly notorious in this regard: you call GetResult(), the scheduler tries to schedule the task to the thread that have just called the GetResult() on it -- and this thread is now deadlocked, because it waits for itself. But since a threadpool has many threads, such degradation takes some time until the whole of the system deadlocks, and it's not even guaranteed to happen: the task scheduling in .NET is very convoluted.


I've been burned by this so many times that I just simply will never use async in any code that is beyond trivial complexity and/or has performance requirements attached. I'll recommend breaking your solution into small pieces that execute separately and pass data to one another via messaging, to isolate the "colors" from one another at the process level.


I'm not a huge fan of async/await (though I have to write a fair amount of it) but that's throwing the baby out with the bathwater. The way to avoid "sync-over-async" deadlocks is to not do sync-over-async, i.e. don't call blocking methods/properties like Wait() and Result on tasks from threadpool threads - it's not what they're for (though they have valid, necessary uses and therefore can't simply be removed).

I've never written code that's deadlocked in this way. I've fixed a ton of such deadlocks, though, and every one boils down to somebody not following this simple rule, and more generally not thinking clearly about what their multithreaded code will actually do when it runs. (Encouraging people to be sloppy in their thinking about these issues is one of the reasons I mildly dislike C#'s concurrency facilities - but nonetheless it's perfectly possible to write code with them that isn't riddled with deadlocks.)


> more generally not thinking clearly about what their multithreaded code will actually do when it runs

The whole reason people are trying to build better concurrent/parallel computational abstractions is because they're sick of having to think about that stuff. But to be able to stop thinking about it you need to arrive at abstractions that don't leak: that is, their failure modes should themselves be (non-leaky) abstractions of the lower-level error details. Async/await still forces you to learn about thread-pools and scheduling — while in Erlang one has to learn about scheduling only to optimize performance, and deadlocking requires one to explicitly write a "receive" without a timeout.


An exception for the rich people to be able to ignore what's best for humanity while we ask all the regular people to make sacrifices. How surprising. Never seen that one before.


> ... able to ignore what's best for humanity while we ask all the regular people to make sacrifices

What is the purpose of life without joy?

If we pass a working planet onto future generations, then those of the future who want the thrill of a finely tuned ICE engine should have an opportunity to experience it. After all, we did.

The greatest tragedy of the environmental movement is it has allowed its well-funded adversaries to cast it as a a dour, sacrificial dogma. We can and should leave room for joy.

Because, in the broader calculus, occasional joy + usual responsibility >> no joy + all responsibility.


> After all, we did.

And we destroyed much of the planet doing it. Maybe it was a bad idea when we did it too. When joy becomes an argument for leniency you imply there is really no urgency. That is probably why the environmental movement is not very joyful. They want change now.


They've wanted change now, since the 1970s. And while there have been some wins (air, water, ozone, banned pollutants), there has been little action on the part of the public. Other than an awareness of recycling, which is the least good lesson to take away. At some point, practice needs to be informed by results.

Leniency is distinct from tolerance.

The former allows rules to be broken; the latter formulates flexible rules that still accomplish the overall goal.


Most driving enthusiasts, once they experience the instant torque of electric cars, never look back. That's joy.

Perhaps a tiny minority are more interested in exhaust notes than accelerating out of a corner, and I suppose they will remain petrol heads, but with classic cars, since ICE technology is a dead end now.


> Most driving enthusiasts, once they experience the instant torque of electric cars, never look back. That's joy.

What is this based on? Really isn’t the case in any auto enthusiast group I know of except ones that are extremely casual/Tesla-fanboys. If it were, all the people I know wouldn’t be buying GT3s, Huracans, R8s, etc. I know 0 who bought electric. I’m in the market myself for another car but I’m not looking at an electric car - gonna buy another ICE sports car because they have a lot more emotion and character. Not like any electric sports cars even really exist at this point anyway… or are still in production I guess.


I have read several reviews where people comment that, "driving is way better without the complications of an ICE and a transmission between you and the road". Instant torque changes your relationship with speed: it is ground, tires, suspension, torque and you. Before, there was a complicated interplay of RPMs, turbo spin up, clutch adjustment, gear ratios, etc between you and the suspension.


Plenty of joys will be left alone. We don't need to make new special exceptions for rich pigs to preserve their rare decadent pleasures.


> If we pass a working planet onto future generations, then those of the future who want the thrill of a finely tuned ICE engine should have an opportunity to experience it. After all, we did.

For a start, most people have not experienced the thrill of a highly tuned internal combustion engine. A few rich people have. Second, do you really want to define what people should be able to do by what people have done in the past? Really? You might want to think that through a bit more. There are plenty of things people did in the past that people are still apologising for today, generations later.


If you just compared driving gasoline powered engines to slavery, I'm not sure we have much ground for discussion.


Or you could say it's petty envy. It's about a tiny minority of vehicles that can easily cover in their price several times all the negative externalities.

I want non polluting transport. Far more than you do, I'm pretty sure. I lived for years in Bucharest, the most polluted and congested city in Europe, with two air purifiers working non stop in my apartment. But I don't see anything productive in your comment. Mostly pettiness.


> Or you could say it's petty envy. It's about a tiny minority of vehicles that can easily cover in their price several times all the negative externalities.

I'd be kind of on board with the exemption if there was a (high) cost paid for it, and that the cost was used to fund some sort of environmental project, but is that what Italy is actually asking for, or are they simply asking for an exemption, no strings attached?


Not wanting two sets of rules, one for the rich and one for everyone else isn’t “pettiness”. Especially when we’re taking minimal steps to save the planet and the rich are already asking for special privileges.


Yes it is. You can own it if you want, but it's specifically about equality of outcome, not about having clean air.

As for why it's harmful - it's hijacking the conversation. Like somebody else said below, we're fighting over 0.1 percent pollution, while ignoring hugely more advantageous moves.

Want examples? Let's talk about taking all combustion cars, old or new, out of the cities. Bam, 10-40% reduction in damage to health. Let's encourage and build infrastructure for bikes and other small e-vehicles. Ocean commercial traffic. Waste burning in unsafe incinerators. Construction-related pollution. Each of those is a double digit share of either health impact or global pollution. But no, let's stop the rich from playing with toys instead.


> Yes it is. You can own it if you want, but it's specifically about equality of outcome, not about having clean air.

How/When did wanting equality of outcome become "pettiness"?

Also, how did this get projected and extrapolated to I'm not only petty but now I'm also against effective action like fighting urban sprawl (which is the real reason we need cars in first place).

Also, my fundamental issue is that the rich will dodge all that other stuff you want as well; the way they are already getting the bulk of green incentives and abusing carbon offsets (see, for example [1] and [2])

This is going to be a long and difficult journey with many, many steps. And at each step of the way, people who claim to be allies will be saying "don't be petty" and "this is but a distraction, the real solution is over here"

[1] https://www.nationalreview.com/2016/06/wind-energy-subsidies...

[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2020-nature-conservancy-c...


Equality of outcome is not petty, it's evil.

It's ok, I know what you mean :) you're talking about non-corruption, equality in the face of the law/rules and so on. I pretty much agree with it. I also mean what I said about hijacking the conversation - I happen to care very deeply about health-related pollution (less so about carbon), and I really really don't want the discourse led astray.

I think carbon offsets are a fundamentally good idea that probably works. I see this kind of news you linked as proof that it does - in a working system I'd expect occasional abuse. I'd expect to see no abuse only if the system was so inefficient as to not be worse gaming. Is it efficient overall? For this you'd need statistical analysis and lots of data. But I like a framework where everybody can decide how much emiting carbon is worth to them - this way you can easily reach all the low hanging fruits, while still keeping those industries with high value per emission. For example I'd never want a blanket ban or quota to interfere with medical equipament manufacturers or high tech. Having the occasional rich guy buy a ferrari is a very small price. Plus, performance e-cars are already much faster.


This constant "eat the rich" mentality is doing more harm than good, and can't see the forest for the trees. If Ferrari were to close down, the impact is not on the rich guy that can't buy a new high-powered car, but the thousands of workers without a job, with the resulting hit to the economy.

If it's not pettiness, it's short-sightedness and black-and-white thinking.


>This constant "eat the rich" mentality is doing more harm than good

asking for the same rules for the rich and the poor is "eat the rich"?


And it's not even that! It's about the same rules for all auto manufacturers.


It appears that is where we are now: trying to level the playing field between rich and poor is oppressing the rich. Actually it may be worse, trying to prevent the rich from gaining new privileges is now oppressive.


I would argue that almost all of society’s woes can be traced to wealth inequality and the legal trappings necessary to maintain that disparity, but, sure, fighting that is doing more harm than good.


Yes, and it would be a great way to convince the populace to take climate change seriously if the rich also needs to follow the rules.


I don't understand. Why would you support an exception to clean air rules simply because they can purchase something expensive if you claim that clean transport is important to you? How is this petty?


Because in the grand scale of things, high-end supercars are a microscopic percentage of carbon emissions. And being affordable only to the very rich, can be taxed _a lot_ to offset that microscopic percentage.

Should Italy prefer to reduce their carbon emissions by 0.1% while destroying one of the last few industries they're the best known for, with associated loss of jobs and livelihood for thousand of families? Of course they don't.


That offset tax money would be better off spent into electric car research. If the rich want to keep their Ferraris, they can fund the research to make it abiding to the law. This would also preserve jobs if they ever cared.

Allowing the 0.1% richest people to be above the law, because in the grand scale of things it's insignificant, seems outrageous for the average abiding citizen who have no choice. The rich would then always have an exception for all the sacrifices and cuts society has to do to preserve new generations.

If a law is needed to save humankind, don't make exceptions to it purely based on capital of people, unless it's to help those in disadvantage.


> can easily cover in their price several times all the negative externalities.

Any calculations to demonstrate that this is indeed the case?


Romania is a tiny minority country, guess they could be exempt too then from all this whole climate change deal.


We already have similar exceptions, in Europe at least. Old cars past a certain age (usually over 30 years old AFAIK) are considered old timers and are often excempt from modern emissions and safety regulations so someone driving a priceless exotic like a '69 Boss Mustang V8 could end up paying less tax and insurance than your Average Joe middle classer pays on his 10 year old 1.6L family econobox.


(first let me say I'm all for the ban if ICE are banned and I'm against an exception for Ferrari).

But.. common... everybody knows oldtimers cars aren't really on the road. Most collectible cars belong to people who own several cars and they very rarely hit the road.

That is precisely why the insurance is so cheap. I've got both an old Porsche and an old Ferrari and I pay 160 EUR a year to insure them both (100 for the first one, and 60 for the second one, as I've got a "fleet": two is a fleet, that's kinda funny).

People not only never drive these cars, they're also ultra cautious with them when they take them out. It's because they do so little kilometers/miles yearly and because people are so cautious that the insurance costs next to nothing.

They're more art pieces / garage queens than cars: remnants of a less civilized era.

Also... My insurance is ultra cheap but there's a gotcha: I need to have an insured daily less than 15 years old, otherwise I need to pay the regular insurance price for my two oldtimers. So it's not really true that people pay less: they pay less but only because they need to have a "real" car to benefit from the cheaper insurance.

These old cars are also typically huge gaz guzzlers, doing easily 3x to 4x the fuel consumption of a modern car: so using it on a daily basis would, in the end, cost you much much more than using a modern car.

I hope these exceptions for oldtimers will stay and that, at least once in a while, they'll be authorized on the road: say maybe allowed on the roads one saturday every month or something like that.

P.S: btw it's not just the insurance that is cheaper: oldtimers are typically exempt from the yearly road tax (in the countries where such a tax exists).


> doing easily 3x to 4x the fuel consumption of a modern car

No, that's because of the type of car, not because of the age, a Ferrari or a Porsche made today will still consume a lot of fuel compared to a more normal car made today. They've always been gas guzzlers simply because an engine that can make that kind of power isn't going to be made for fuel economy and the drivers don't care because typically money for gas isn't very high on their priority list.

I'm curious what type Ferrari and what type Porsche you've got, are you willing to disclose?


> But.. common... everybody knows oldtimers cars aren't really on the road. Most collectible cars belong to people who own several cars and they very rarely hit the road.

That's true. And I actually think that maybe the issue isn't that we drive around in ICE cars, but rather that we drive around.

Sure, there are people with mobility issues, delivery, etc. I'm not talking about those, since I think they're not the majority of traffic, so likely not a huge problem. I'm talking about "regular people". I think the issue is that the vast majority of traffic is people commuting to work, so instead of trying to build a faster horse (use cars that pollute less) there should be more emphasis on actually driving less.

By that I mean encouraging companies to allow working from home and developing public transportation.

The issue with laws like this is that they don't take into account the various situations.

In my case, I own a motorcycle that won't be allowed in Paris and other major French cities starting in 2024. I rarely use it during the week since I actually commute by transit. But I sometimes go on long trips and stay overnight in big cities. I wouldn't be allowed to.

Would buying a new motorcycle, which I don't need since my current one works perfectly, be actually good for the environment? Sure, it would probably pollute somewhat less per km ridden, but it would have to be produced in the first place and then shipped halfway around the world.


The ban is obviously for the sale of new ICE cars, it's not economically or structurally possible for 300 million cars to get fully replaced over that period, and the infrastructure to manage charging for 300 million EVs is simply not there.


That’s not “similar”. It would be similar if we granted emissions or safety exemptions to new cars from a different manufacturer. My uncles 1942 Jeep is exempt for historical purposes, not so rich people can play with fast, expensive cars.


double standard

if your uncle can keep driving old, low efficient, highly polluting vehicles why can't a rich person buy a ICE ferrari?

Makes much more sense to charge on "pollution/gas usage"

Kind of wealthy tax but without intervening in the market and picking winners or the "right solution"


Because the general expectation (and current reality) is that old cars will break and be scrapped eventually. Only few remain and those few don't matter in regards to global emissions as they are mostly not daily drivers. They instead contribute to keeping tiny bits of history alive.

I'd compare it to old houses which are often designated as landmarks. We don't demolish them just because they are not energy efficient by modern standards.


“We allow this thing that existed before the rules were made to continue to exist” and “we won’t allow only rich people to create new rule breaking things” is NOT a double standard.

Why are you trying to position high end sports car owners as oppressed?


"gas engine ban"


I don't know the rules in every country, but to get the exemptions it's generally required that the vehicle isn't used much — driving only to shows or museums for the biggest discount, or limited to a fairly low annual mileage.

That will continue to be the case for old cheap and expensive cars, and we justify it to preserve industrial history. There's no reason to introduce a similar exemption for certain new cars.


Ontario has historic plates ... lots of rules but generally what you just described.


It isn't the same. Most old cars aren't rare models, but models that were decently popular, and a lot are ones that defined the style of the time and/or hold up well enough to meet some popular beauty standards. Heck, my own car has less than a decade to go to hit that 30 year mark and we just buy cheap cars. Most are certainly not an exotic car, in no small part because most cars are not exotic.

Which is realistically a reason fairly poor folks can have an old car.


>someone driving a priceless exotic like a '69 Boss Mustang V8 could end up paying less tax and insurance than your Average Joe middle classer pays on his 10 year old 1.6L family econobox.

lol. It's funny to think of them as a 'priceless exotic' as those cars are basically mass produced items with an engine option.

Let's consider the cost. A decent Boss 429 is probably around $250k-$300k. The sales tax in California is around 10 percent, about $2k/year for the license, $4-$5/gallon for gas at around 8 mpg, collector car insurance at roughly 1% of stated value.


I think an emission allocation plan can be worked out where there's a limited spots for ICE cars and whoever wants to run one pays very large allotment fee. That way we have emissions cut when we still keep some legacy when transferring some wealth to those who give up access to the ICE.

The number of spots should be truly limited though, you don't want to create a class of people who pollute and pay for thanks to inheritance or luck like the way society is divided into people with large homes and people who share rooms.

The carbon footprint of the super rich's personal consumption is negligible. 1000 Ferrari cars don't pollute as much as 3000 economy cars.

Banning Ferrari is like saving the planet by using paper straws. It makes sense to take 290,000,000 ICE cars off the street of Europe and leave a spot for a few thousand exotic ICE cars as a cultural artefact. The emission difference that would do is at a rounding error scale.

Actually, using paper straws probably has larger impact. People don't actually ride these cars that much, they move them around with trucks to keep the milage down.

[0] https://www.fleetnews.co.uk/cars/Car-CO2-and-fuel-economy-mp...


Sounds like a reasonable proposal to me. Instead of exemption, paying a high price for it could give other people a sense of fairness.

(edit) Using that money to finance switching to battery/hydrogen/whatever powered cars for people with less resources could even offset it fairly. Let them help the rest improve the situation for everyone and they can keep their toys.


> The carbon footprint of the super rich's personal consumption is negligible.

The same holds for the carbon footprint of any minority group. And everybody belongs to some minority group in some way. Does that mean everybody is exempt from the law? (No).


I don’t suggest exemption from the law but an arrangement that doesn’t break the goal and preserves some legacy for those who want to keep it and are willing to chip in.

It’s like not demolishing the Parthenon and some other old buildings even if they don’t meet the modern construction requirements.


See my response here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28652958

Putting some Ferrari's in a museum or on some restricted racing track is ok. But forcing everybody to follow the law and letting some rich people on TV ignore all the rules seems like a bad way to fight climate change.


It’s not ignoring the rules if the rules are structured in a way to solve the problem but at the same time allow some exceptions in exchange for something.

I guess it comes down to what you are trying to achieve. Do you want to cut down the emissions dramatically or are you after some kind of engine equality ideal?


I believe that setting the right example is of paramount importance when fighting climate change. No realistic amount of financial compensation can make a difference, because it sends the wrong message.


This has nothing to do with that. Especially considering how electric cars are still way too expensive for the working class.

The EU is just out of touch with car manufacturing. They are to blame for the SUV-epidemic in Europe. Basically they are making laws that sound good on paper but unrealistic in real world scenarios. Consumption and emission levels are skewed by the hybrid motors in the SUV. The laws are written so the mini cars like the Volkswagen Up are just not financially worth to produce. So in conclusion, the laws that were supposed to reduce the CO2 emissions actually made everything worse.

More on this: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidrvetter/2020/08/04/just-ho...


The manufacturers do share some blame as well, they have failed to see what the spirit of the regulations are and done a goalseek on the spreadsheet to where we are now.

I do wonder if they went too far too fast with some of the regulations. If it is beyond the edge of what is possible, the incentive becomes seeking loopholes, juicing numbers. However, the gains have been incredible the last 10-20 years in just raw efficiency.

Beyond the regulations, society and virtue signaling appears to have had a strong impact, on all side of the political spectrum. Capitalism does sometimes work, and the current 'desire' is to have either an electic clean car or to roll coal and shoot your m50 at commies in their liberal prius.


Yeah, a Tesla after all is the car of choice for the poor working joe.


I'm not sure what's your rejoinder is supposedly about. The article is specifically about Europe's (hopeful) ban of gas engines, and one of the members asking for an exemption for its home-grown luxury brands.

Tesla has nothing to do with it.


> An exception for the rich people to be able to ignore what's best for humanity while we ask all the regular people to make sacrifices.

So at the moment it is the regular people are driving around in electic cars and the rich in the gas cars ... no and if there is a class war at work it is the other way round.

At this moment the ev revolution is being driven by the rich, this will trickle down over time naturally, but the choice to go electric means paying more. Tesla dont have a comparable product but VW do, pretty consistntly $10,000 more for electric. If 'regular' people are making sacrifices as the previous person suggested it is by spending so much more on a car (or lease) and not eating or being broke, because it is the only way they are participating at the moment.


You do realize pretty much all car manufacturers either are already selling electric cars or are working feverishly on designing one?


Tesla is a luxury brand. China produces a lot of electric cars, some of the cheaper models are sold for under $5000.


They will most definitely eventually fill the used car market.


Will they? Where I live even hybrids don’t do well at all in the used market, replacing the battery is a huge cost


Where I live (Finland) hybrids on the other hand retain their value the best, with diesels being the worst. The fuel savings are so significant that people do flock to them.


As long as they pay for it, why not?

Also a ban on new petrol cars I think might not really be necessary if petrol is properly taxed with carbon pricing.


As if a hundred rich people rarely used Ferrari can make a dent on the pollution from million paesants buying AliExpress trinket shipped overseas in what's likely the most polluting form of transport.


Yes seeing millionaires go up in space doesn't help to get normal people motivated to change their habits.


The cars are a rounding error, where's at is aviation.

They're fixing to stick it to general aviation - mass market plane travel.

Perhaps only after private jets are outlawed - what, no?


It is year 2030. HN is advocating that we should all kill ourselves in the developed nations for the sake of poor people and their well being, of course, for the planet as well. It will reduce climate emissions by 75%! Government kill-yourself pills will be forcefully distributed and mandated. Having kids was banned in 2025 so that's already taken care of. Total wokeness extravaganza.


It's doesn't limit the use of the software, it limits the use of their instance.

The licence is GPL, you can use it the way you want on your own machine.


>It's doesn't limit the use of the software, it limits the use of their instance.

Same same, it's Not a Service but Software, so it's MY instance.

>The licence is GPL, you can use it the way you want on your own machine.

That's the problem..i cant (5 User limit)...and btw it's AGPL


Is the limit in open source code? If no, where is the problem, if yes, remove it, it's open source.


It's not hosted afaict. They're selling support.


Dell service quality is getting down.

Warranty is something they were proud of.

Now, it's just came an absurdly inefficient, frustrating, and wasteful experience.

I have an XPS 2-in-1. Nice machine, except for the so-so battery life and the unsupported webcam on linux, it was a good working laptop.

I paid for the biggest config at the time, and included a $300 premium guarantee with on site servicing.

One year later, the keyboard starts acting up, then the touch pad.

I contacted their support, and while the people on the phone were polite and competent (!), their ludicrous booking system to get a person on site to change my keyboard was a nightmare.

Took me a month of frustrating cat and mouse game to finally get someone at my door.

They changed my keyboard (and for some reason my speakers and battery O_o), routine stuff. "No need to do a backup for that", they said.

Took them 3 hours. They were operating blind, no manual, no spec, no pictures taken before removing parts.

Of course, once done, the machine would not boot anymore. Also the touch pad stopped working completely (tested in the UEFI).

They let me with an unusable machine and left. This was my main working machine. Thankfully, I haven't listen to them and did my homework, I had 2 full data backup and a fallback laptop, albeit way less appropriate for my freelancing missions.

One month and dozens of phone calls+emails later, they come back. Change the whole thing again. Machine is still FUBAR.

They leave again.

2 weeks later, support contacted me to offer me an exchange with a brand new laptop (remember, I didn't need a backup). They should take an appointment in 48 hours.

I'm still waiting as of today, no appointment email, a broken laptop, doing work on a machine were I have to kill the browser regularly because it swaps, doing web dev.

All the staff were nice, but their process, boy, their process sucks.

The worst thing is, it's probably made to avoid some kind of abuse of the system or to save money, but they spent to much time with me they wasted tons of cash, and end up replacing my machine anyway.

Everybody loose with a service like that.

If people are still wondering why the framework laptop is appealing, there it is. I know what my next machine will be now.


> I contacted their support, and while the people on the phone were polite and competent (!)

I contacted Dell support recently when my new laptop didn't send an image to my (Dell) external monitor.

The support guy asked me what cable I was using. It's DisplayPort on the monitor end and Thunderbolt USB-C on the laptop end. It works with the Dell laptop the recent one replaced.

The support guy proceeded to look up the new laptop's product page on Dell's public website, see language saying that for the Thunderbolt port to work with DisplayPort, you need to buy an adapter, and recommend that I buy a USB-C to MiniDP adapter. It was left unexplained how I would plug my USB-C Thunderbolt cable into the MiniDP adapter.

I wouldn't trust Dell support to know how to put on pants.


So, don't use the sleep mode for what it's for on your $1500 machine?


My 9500 is more like $4000. And it can't sleep properly.


> The fraud bots will keep the ecosystem running

It's like that everywhere.

Yesterday a friend of mind was revealing to me that crypto currency exchanges were pressuring them to create bots so that their coin trading volume would go up or they would be delisted.

There are bots to write comments on trip advisor and to star on amazon. Bots to follow on twitter. Bot to click on referal links and bot to farm in games.

I'm pretty sure if we all suddenly went offline, half the internet would seem to keep going as usual.


One aspect that shouldn't be lost - the implicit framing of the platforms being "under attack" by the bots is wrong - the bots are likely a net positive for the platforms - they're very much complicit with the fraud, or at least condone it. They sell views and clicks - if bots create more views and clicks, so be it. It's the advertisers who bear the cost.

Taking Facebook as an example:

Creating an account, linking Oculus Quest to it and leaving the account dormant - accounts locked en masse.

US account that logs in from Indonesian IPs, never posts anything, likes 5000 random things ranging from a shampoo to a cafe in a small Ohio town, to the new shirts of an Albanian soccer club - in Facebook's view that's a perfectly legitimate account.


The people bearing the real cost are the people trying to sell products with ads. Facebook more or less sets up the system to pass that cost along.


To be fair the cost of ads varies based on demand; advertisers wouldn't pay more than the ROI they're seeing from their ads, so the prices have the cost of ad fraud somewhat priced in?


Most marketing departments I've met don't check their ROI. They request budget, spend it on campaign, then make power points to tell the rest of the company that they were successful.


Dunno who you’ve worked with but in 2021 that’s patently false. Optimizing Facebook ad performance for ROAS is a precise science. Marketing budgets are heavily scrutinized and hard to defend precisely because of dismissive attitudes like this, so you better believe most marketers are working their tails off to measure and deliver ROI.


Maybe in the short term it works like that, but ultimately a platform's value comes from its real users. And bots make the platform less attractive to real users.


But Facebook, like most social media platforms, is addictive, so it is not obvious that in the long term a reasonable usage of them will emerge.


Lack of movement in sales after paying Facebook for advertisements will emerge, and that will certainly be noticed.


You may overestimate the sophistication of ad buyers, and underestimate the ability of Facebook to convince buyers that their ads are working


The increased ability to track the efficacy of ads is the value of the tracking that the internet enabled, hence the value of Facebook. Hampering this ability to match ads to purchases reduces the price these ads can be sold at, it is what the whole article and situation are talking about.


Movies make billions of dollars from users who don't contribute any content. As long as users consume content, who cares who makes it?


> I'm pretty sure if we all suddenly went offline, half the internet would seem to keep going as usual.

That could be a good Black Mirror like scifi movie, everyone dies but chatter and social media just keep living on.

"Did you guys see that amazing sunset last night? Check out this book to capture these amazing moments!"

"Can't wait to see the new [dystopian movie] this weekend!"

"Amazing shows to see this weekend. Download our event app to log on and find the fun!"

"The [other party] are a it again today... protests should be intense today at the capitol."

... no one there ...


I love these kinds of stories

> CGI 3D Animated Shorts : "LAST DAY OF WAR" - by Dima Fedotov https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IjJmTeBSEzU


sounds a little like autofac by philip k dick[1]. there's an electric dreams episode about it, ironically streaming on amazon[2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autofac

[2] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6902176/


> I'm pretty sure if we all suddenly went offline, half the internet would seem to keep going as usual.

Seems like a reasonable estimate if half the internet is porn.


There's a name for this: The Dead Internet theory[0]

It postulates that the majority of the "organic" content is actually generated by bots, and the number of human interactions online is a tiny subset. We are all wandering unknowingly through a wasteland haunted by robot ghosts.

[0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2021/08/dead-...


In this case at least the article implies this not to be true, one of the interviewed ceos said he used to generate 80% of his revenue from Facebook ad buys and now it’s only 20%. This would imply he’s getting his ads in front of real people.


Beep beep boop boop. I regular person, like your comment!


There are massive bot farms that watch videos, click on ads, sometimes even do a download of the app after clicking and open the app. I've sometimes thought Google could cut out the middleman and just allow creators to outright buy 'views' on YouTube. You could pay like $100 to get 10,000 additional views which would translate to some additional ad revenue, which ad companies would know is inflated so they would discount the rates appropriately and no money would need to be sent to bot farms. This would also be far greener and need less servers and bandwidth and would be an overall win-win.


It's one thing to read about the click farms, but nothing can prepare one to actually see the videos of them in action - just visceral. It has an eerie Matrix-like feeling to it.

13 sec video of a Chinese click farm (quite loud):

https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1072114511212109824

10 sec - thousands of phones (not loud):

https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1148447866366464000


And the scene from Silicon Valley


That is laughably sad. I've been depressed, but for some reason started to laugh.


This has been since what feels like forever. Once a couple of people I worked with found and penetrated one of these "click farms". We saw all the stats, the number where impressive.

I had a private contact within google's SRE team and spilled all the beans, ask where I should dump the information within google. The answer was as blunt as telling: no one would be interested since it would hurt their bottom line.

Tried to inform a couple of Googlies at different cons in the months following: as much as they liked the tricks we pulled to get in, as little did they want to bring the subject up in their teams.

Clicks are Google's Crack.


But what about the workers. It's likely that those working at the bot farms aren't wealthy, and that they're from less wealthy countries. So this is good, addressing the immediate problem of energy waste, but doesn't address the underlying problem of wealth inequality that - in general - drives people to work on systems to rip others off.

Those who run the bot farms will find other scummy work, and no end of desperate workers.


It makes sense. If that happened, who would lose in the short term?


How do you make 4%?


Under law you currently get the "federal short-term rate" + 3%


Step one: Overpay by enough that 4% of the total is your entire tax burden.

Step two: Pay no taxes for few decades, adding funds as required.

Step three: Withdraw your capital and retire.


IRS interest rate


The IRS interest rate is better than my saving account interest rate, and is guaranteed. That's crazy.


We did that, it was called PHP, and it turns out DSL are pretty limited outside of their sweat spot. Also they don't evolve as fast as libs and framework.

Case in point: PHP worked well, but framework like Rails and Django became very attractive because their offered more, and used languages that could be good outside of their niche.

And what did the PHP community to stay relevant ? They developed great frameworks, and improved the non web language capabilities.

Turns out the web moves fast, and coding a web app is more than web programming anyway.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: