One of the recurring arguments from anti-vaxers is that big pharma is setuping us for a vaccine version of netflix: Shot As A Service.
After being told one dose of the vaccine will prevent us from catching covid, then that actually it needs a second dose the same year, well actually you could catch it, wait actually you will probably catch it but it's less deadly, oh I forgot you'll need 3 doses. Ah, now 4 in 2 years... Also, the FDA wants 55 years to process FOIA request over the vaccine data.
Those people need to get their communication act together, because they are loosing credibility at the speed of an R0 of 3. The public is already squirmish, not to mention tense because of the economic and social impact of the pandemic.
It's like they have a secret wish for people to explode in their face.
Alternatively, it's just really hard to communicate uncertainty to people prone to "this or that" binary thinking.
If they hadn't immediately started trials for boosters and then deployed them when they were shown to be worthwhile, the situation would be worse than it is.
It's not hard, it's just that politicians and businessmes don't want to say "we don't know", "we are not sure", "we take the chance of a probability x". If you say "I'm going to solve all of your problems tommorow", you'll get better ratings today, so they choose that instead of managing expectations, explaning to adults the process that is undergoing, and giving the data and sources etc.
Now we have trust at an all time low, in a period of social media outrage and a conspirationnist gold era.
Which means more death and a prolonging crisis.
I do understand that the public have a limited attention span and a lack of critical thinking, but those in charge are nurturing it, for the worse.
The covid, IMO, is as much a social crisis than it is a health one.
Suddenly, the reason for the recent employee purge seems more clear. They never fired anybody for bad behavior before, and now, just soon to be aquired, they do.
> A summary of those personnel actions was scheduled to be released by Activision before the winter holidays, but Chief Executive Bobby Kotick held it back, telling some people it could make the company’s workplace problems seem bigger than is already known, the people familiar with the situation said.
Another thing is that people defending a believe don't necessary hold it true deep inside. But it's part of their identity, so they play their role, and defend it.
Once you pick it up, you'll start to notice it for a lot of things: racism/sexism, welcoming immigrants, climate change is a hoax, I'm a busy person, my boss is terrible, I just love to do < hard thing >, capitalism is bad, I'm concerned by the planet...
E.G:
I have a friend who keeps insisting she prefers women, has a lesbian dominated social circle, but mostly have sex with males. She is joining protests for all things hurting migrants, but one was sleeping in a car in our street, and after getting her bike stolen, she decided with no proof he was the culprit and called the cops on him and got him deported.
I know a vegetarian that eats meat when he travels, because nobody can see him.
I had a flatmate who was writing her memoir on the way women were badly treated in India. She eventually dated our Indian other flatmate, and took great care of cleaning his _disgusting_ bedroom and doing his laundry without any reciprocity, for the entire relationship.
I know 2 guys that, if asked, will declare they are for peace and think war lords are a bad thing. I mean, who doesn't ? Both considered working for weapon dealers, one actually accepted, and the main clients are the Emirates.
All those persons are people I love very much: humans are weird creatures, full of contradictions, doing plenty of bad things. I'm sure those flat earthers can be good friends too, maybe even great citizens for some things I'm terrible at.
I'm certainly an asshole competing in several categories, believing idiotic things, pretending to believe others.
I think people who see themselves differently have huge blind spots which help them go on the hate train.
We all suck. Even when taught critical thinking, which I manage to abuse regularly for terrible results.
True, we are not all at the same level on the Gaussian idiocy curve. At least according to ourselves.
Yet, in my experience, education works only if freed from contempt.
So let's have compassion for "stupid people in large numbers."
Honestly you can go very far with unmettered data plans. We consume 2GB/S, maxed out, which ends up being 5184TB a month. We have millions on users a day, all on a streaming video platform.
It cost less than $2K/Month.
The cloud is crazy expensive. Private servers are beasts, and they are cheap.
Of course, for this price, you don't have redundancy and horizontal scaling.
You also don't have to maintain and debug a system with redundancy and horizontal scaling.
> We consume 2GB/S, maxed out, which ends up being 5184TB a month. We have millions on users a day, all on a streaming video platform.
> It cost less than $2K/Month.
The solution in this article is serving on the order of 100TB/month for $400/month including a high speed global CDN, their API and database servers being hosted reliably, and redundancy and backup being handled by someone else.
Your solution is hosting on the order of 1000s of TBs of month (ignoring the database and other aspects of this website), but the price is an order of magnitude higher. You’ve also given up all of the automatic redundancy and hands-off management, and you don’t have the benefit of a high speed global CDN.
But more importantly, you have significantly higher engineering and on-call overhead, which you’re valuing at $0.
If anything, that only makes Polyhaven’s solution sound more impressive.
> Of course, for this price, you don't have redundancy and horizontal scaling.
Which is a huge caveat. The global CDN makes a big difference in how the site loads in global locations. Maybe not a big concern if you’re serving of static files with a lot of buffering, but they have a dynamic website and a global audience and they said fast load times are important.
> You also don't have to maintain and debug a system with redundancy and horizontal scaling.
But you have to do literally everything else manually and maintain it yourself, which is far from free.
All of these alternative proposals that value engineering time at $0/hour and assume your engineers are happy to be on-call 24/7 to maintain these servers are missing the point. You pay for turnkey solutions so you don’t have to deal with as much. Engineers don’t actually love to respond to on call events. If you can offload many of your problems to a cloud provider and free up your engineers for a nominal cost, do it.
A python that knows python and linux is enough to support the up time needs and evolutions of this particular product. Actually a part time one.
The entire team is composed of half of one dev.
I'm 100% sure it's way cheaper than anybody that has AWS on resume.
Of course, some things have to give, like the global CND, and some data guarantees.
Everything is a compromise. It's all depend of what is important for your project.
EDIT: also, my comment was not meant to oppose the article, but rather confirm the view that you should calibrate your setup to your project. Doing so will lead to great savings in hosting, and project complexity. A lot of projects don't need the cloud.
Who is on-call 24/7/365, never takes vacation ever, and is always available to fix the website?
It’s weird how much HN hates jobs with on-call requirements, but every time cloud services come up the solutions always involve forcing someone to be permanently on call to save a few hundred dollars per month in hosting costs.
This one dev is literally on call 365 days a year and can never be away from a computer on vacation. If he leaves, the project has no one.
How is that not a problem? Surely you can see that this isn’t reasonable for anyone who wants to run a business, or any employee who doesn’t want the website to be their life.
> If the system has a problem during the night, the users will wait until the morning.
> It just looses a bit of money and users are grumpy for a day
If you’re running a website where extended outages are no big deal and you don’t care about lost revenue, then it’s not really a valid comparison to the typical business website.
Your situation is unique, not a model by which other companies should follow.
> If you’re running a website where extended outages are no big deal and you don’t care about lost revenue, then it’s not really a valid comparison to the typical business website.
I think you're severely underestimating how many businesses make a significant amount of money from their website, but doesn't actually have full-time developer available. An extended outage would cause significant revenue loss, but it's typically not a problem because outages are surprisingly rare when you (1) have a very stable traffic pattern and (2) you don't spend a lot of time adding features and refactoring. Pretty much every cloud outage we've seen was caused by a human configuration error, not fault machines.
> I think you're severely underestimating how many businesses make a significant amount of money from their website, but doesn't actually have full-time developer available.
No, I’m well aware. But there’s a simple solution to this problem: Don’t try to run and maintain your own servers. Pay a little extra to use cloud hosting and let it be someone else’s problem.
I take issue with these calls to setup and maintain your own custom solutions and servers, while also suggesting that the cost of engineering and maintaining such a custom setup should be ignored.
Running your own servers and not having developers is a recipe for an endless stream of contracting invoices that are going to cost far, far more than just using a hosted cloud solution.
I'd be on board with "pay a little extra to rent dedicated servers", but "move to one of the big-three cloud providers" doesn't sound like a sound financial decision for the case presented.
> But there’s a simple solution to this problem: Don’t try to run and maintain your own servers. Pay a little extra to use cloud hosting and let it be someone else’s problem.
But that's only if it IS a "problem" in the first place. You have defined it as such, although Bitecode themselves said that for them, it simply isn't. (To paraphrase: "If the site is down, then it's down; so what? We'll fix it when we're in the office again.")
Just plain ignoring whether something is "a problem" or not is hardly being "well aware".
> An extended outage would cause significant revenue loss, but it’s typically not a problem
This just seems like a bad decision from a business perspective. You are willing to endure a significant outage that will cost a lot of money but not pay to prevent it? Machines can and will fail.
It seems it's criminal to run a service on the cheap, there must be a terrible human being behing it.
Well no, the dev is not attached 365 days on its computer.
A freelancer is hired part time for the duration of the vaccations. It cost a full dev salary for one month, taking in consideration training time, that's all.
> If you’re running a website where extended outages are no big deal and you don’t care about lost revenue, then it’s not really a valid comparison to the typical business website.
Most services can actually go down once a month, and be a viable business. You are not google or facebook.
In fact, most human service goes down for days: bakeries, lawyers, teachers, plumbers.
The fact your think internet services should be up all time is only in your head. Humans adapt perfectly.
It's not that a big deal. Most of our softwares are not as important as we want to think.
If you really want a 99.99999% up time, you going to increase your service quality by 10%, and your service cost by 1000000%.
The funny thing is, the downtime of ourservice has not being more than github's downtime in the last few years. So honestly the freelacer is mostly hired to have drinks on the house. Because monolythes are very reliable in the first place.
> Your situation is unique, not a model by which other companies should follow.
Every situation is unique, I never, ever stated it was " a model by which other companies should follow". You did.
There is no such thing as "a model by which other companies should follow". You must adapt to the situation and goals. Engineering is about compromises.
My post is simply stating the reality that you can get very far with good old tech.
And a lot of projects don't need the cloud, or high availability. Yet they pay premium for it.
> A freelancer is hired part time for the duration of the vaccations. It cost a full dev salary for one month, taking in consideration training time, that's all.
You pay a full dev salary for one month every time someone wants to take a break?
It’s baffling that anyone can read an article about someone spending $400/month on cloud services and then start proposing things like this as an alternative.
Engineering labor is expensive. Cloud is surprisingly cheap once you factor in engineering costs.
One month part time once a year as an additional cost is way, way cheaper than anything else.
> Cloud is surprisingly cheap once you factor in engineering costs.
No, it's not, since you need somebody qualified to operate it. And such qualificatied employees is very expensive. And you will need them on call anyway, since it will break, just in different way than a bunch of private servers.
I'd argue the cloud would be more expensive, even if hosting were not, because you need a more expensive team to run it.
He never said they don't care about lost revenue. I am willing to guess they considered the lost revenue, weighed it against the cost of having someone on-call 24/7, and considered that the lost revenue was cheaper.
If you look at how frequently sites like Reddit used to have downtime, it doesn't seem to matter too much for consumer products. Having half a day downtime once a year might be completely acceptable.
You can host on AWS and still get hours-long downtime, as has happened recently.
Whether the cost of trying to add another 9 to your uptime is worth the marginal benefit is for each company to decide. Each 9 gets exponentially more expensive. A lot of companies who think otherwise actually can afford (and will, sooner or later, be forced) to be down once in a while.
The company I work for has a lot of stuff in the cloud. We seem to have quite a few position's worth of people permanently on call.
The percentage of "data center"-type on-call situations has perhaps gone down somewhat since moving into the cloud, but it has not gone to zero, and it was never the majority of problems anyhow.
It seems like you're sneaking the idea in that if they would just pay a lot more money, the person on call wouldn't have to be on call. I'd like to know what cloud you're using, because it doesn't seem to be any of the ones I know of. If your service is critical to your business or project, you've got someone on some sort of call (maybe not overnight call, which is the really rough bit), period, or you've got a business that can disappear at any second.
I think it's bizarre you're giving cloud marketing material to a person, whose in a position to know their own situation, as-if you were describing their situation.
Like.. what are you expecting to happen? You'll just gaslight them into thinking they dont know how their business works?
Whether or not a site is hosted in the cloud, it will break from time to time. S** invariably happens, no matter what. So, even if you host in the cloud, you're going to have problems, but they will be different problems. A developer to backup and support the site will be required, one way or the other. Case in point: polyhaven.com (the subject of this article) is not reachable as I write this.
The entire $400/month bill for this linked website will only get you 2-3 hours of consulting time. They’re getting an enormous value by just offloading the work to someone else and not having to worry about it.
You have to do an apple-to-apples comparison though. If you're comparing a single colo'd machine vs a 3000-EC2 instance fleet with a load balancer, api nodes, database nodes (and requisite db admin team), and Kafka and DynamoDBs somewhere in there, then the cloud is going to be more expensive to manage.
Barring in-depth research (which I'd love to read if someone has any links), it's not clear on a 1:1 basis what's cheaper. Paying for someone's time to research hardware and talk to vendors, run POs for them, figure out where/how to install them (Equinix is expensive), and RMA hard drives as that comes up; versus not paying for that and instead paying a cloud vendor for that privilege. Throw on top a changing hiring landscape (how much 'sysadmins' cost vs 'devops') and it really depends on the size of this hypothetical fleet that we're trying to manage, and how complicated the backend of the site is. If there's no real backend to speak of, Cloudflare's CDN for static assets is going to be way cheaper, and available now, vs anything you could possibly build from scratch, that would maybe be ready in a couple months.
Thanks! Exactly that! I always tell that customers and their response is:
-But google/facebook/amazon...
-But uptime needs to be 99.999
-But everyone uses cloud
Most businesses are not a trading-market, have less then 100 peoples (aka you are probably not another amazon), and no bonus using a cloud/kubernetes etc.
But it's the same old story, in the 00's i used the ~same arguments against buying OracleDB ;)
And you can tell them all of those are possible, but they need to have a massive budget, not just for the monthly bills but also to hire experts to set things up with those constraints.
I worked at a company once that, from higher up, said that they had to have five nines of uptime. We had some really good cloud engineers there (one guy set up a server / internet container for the military in Afghanistan; in hindsight he said they should've just sent a container of porn dvd's), and they really went to town. For that five nines uptime, you're already pretty much required to set up your infrastructure to use multiple availability zones, everything redundant multiple times, etc.
Of course, the actual software we wrote was just a bunch of CRUD services written in nodejs (later scala because IDK), on top of a pile of shit java that abstracted away decades of legacy mainframes.
Either your compute demand is highly elastic, or your revenue and profit scale with usage, otherwise the Cloud is probably not for you. At least not in the longterm or for running websites.
Isn't AWS down like every two months for a few hours? That's far off the 99.999% mark. No one can guarantee 100% uptime and sometimes it's even better to have that under your control (eg. have a dedicated server and a backup one from different providers).
My point is that, if you want the highest possible uptime, you shouldn't rely on a single (cloud) provider.
Well most of them are Non IT businesses, so they just know what peers/family etc told them what todo (or what they do), then read some (oneside-)sponsored media and now they ~know whats best, it's Azure with WindowsServerDatacenter-edition, SQLServer-enterprise and McAffee antivirus ;) but who can be mad about it? It's just not their field of expertise or even interest.
If they didn't but cared about their business (they know I hope) and make hard requirements to IT, that would help. IT should then come up with solutions to those real-world problems. We're not talking just about hobbyists, do we?
That's what Eric Evans talks about in DDD as I got it.
Oh absolutely true, you don't want to look completely clueless in front of people who take your money to setup an infrastructure ;)
>and make hard requirements to IT, that would help
That would make stuff so much more easy. Often it even lacks even a inventory of used applications/hardware....network.
Just one example:
Made a plan for new hardware and network (new cabling etc), then i walked around the workshop and there was that dusty machine running...i asked what it is...a dos-machine with...wait...TOKENRING. That machine was an integral part of the whole workshop ;) However we made a virtual FreeDOS machine and buy'd a software converter for the machine protocol, the 25yo cnc-machine needed a new card (ethernet instead of token-ring, very lucky we found that thing) so there was that one little DOS-machine no one though about who could stop the whole "modernization".
I say server, presumably it’s the entire solution of however many servers, storage, network etc.
If it’s 2k/month for a non resilient solution, it’s in the order of 4k for a resilient solution (you need to relocate assets both ways but it’s in that order of magnitude)
You can have redundancy and horizontal scaling with private servers and still end up paying less than what you would on AWS and the like.
I have some clients who use AWS and others who prefer colo and/or dedicated servers from traditional datacenters. The latter group can afford to over-provision everything by 3-4x, even across different DC's if necessary. DC's aren't yesterday's dinosaurs anymore. The large ones have a bunch of hardware on standby that you can order at 3 a.m. and start running deployment scripts in minutes.
Not including extra human cost in the analysis is just disingenuous. I think to manage private servers of that size you would need at least two extra experts totalling at least $20k/month.
> I think to manage private servers of that size you would need at least two extra experts totalling at least $20k/month.
What? You set up the deployment once, and then you only need to touch it when things go horribly wrong, which is every couple of months, or to make minor quick tweaks and run some updates. Let's be generous, and say you need 10 h/month, which is about 1/16 of a person-month. And if things go horribly wrong, everybody drops what they are doing to fix things, anyway, no matter if you're on AWS, dedicated/colo or run your own data center.
When you significantly change your architecture/deployment, then you need to put in more time again, but if you build your code with need to scale and such things in mind from the get-go, then that won't come up much or at all.
> What? You set up the deployment once, and then you only need to touch it when things go horribly wrong, which is every couple of months
Right, which is exactly why people pay extra for cloud managed services.
If things are going “horribly wrong” every couple of months then you must necessarily be on call 24/7 and never take vacation or time away. In practice, you need at least two people to manage on-call coverage so you’re not completely uncovered if someone gets sick, decides to take vacation, wants to travel away from a computer and so on.
Things go horribly wrong with AWS hosted stuff as well. And a lot of companies have a single-point-of-failure AWS person. While you're not wrong in general, nothing you just wrote is specific to running on dedicated servers vs AWS.
We're talking volunteer-run projects, though. Who cares if it's not available 24/7? Best-effort is good enough. Those managed cloud services also fail often, you just have no information and no recourse about it.
What?! Maybe if you hire SV-skilled engineers on location in Sillicon Valley, but you can easily serve 2GB/second (on infra worth $2K/month) with one sys-admin dealing with it, and for way less than a whopping $10k/month.
Why would it be necessary to have an engineer on call 24/7 ? If you do your risk calculations and an outage of 12 hours is acceptable in the expected frequency you just let the engineer have a nice evening and night an deal with the outage in the morning.
If outages are only to be expected once a year an you can tolerate 48 hours of outage you don't need any on call engineer. Most outages are cause by changes. You can test those and plan putting these in production and have elevated monitoring after this to catch problems early.
Only problem remaining is hardware outages. And those are very rare as long as you do decent lifecycle maintenance.
As others said before. Not everyone is Google or Amazon and needs 99,999% uptime.
Pretty much anything. How about a Dell R340 with a dual-10G NIC and some SSDs? That's not commodity, that's cheap, a commodity server would be a dual-Xeon but that's overkill for serving 16gbps.
I think that is the problem with modern day's Web Dev. ( Sorry )
With Cloud and SaaS. They are so abstracted from Hardware that their knowledge on basic hardware and server, everything from CPU, Storage I/O and Network are close to zero.
You need high skilled people who are comfortable in AWS or other cloud offering as well. Have to care of tons of things, set them up etc. They are not one button setups in real life when things get complicated.
I went the other route: I used to be minimalist, now I even bring my kettlebells, game pads and different pairs of shoes on my business trips.
Even in the moutain, I now have a heavier bag. E.G: my latest knife is way bigger, sturdier and so weights a lot more, I also have a smaller one as a backup now.
Being minimalist is not an end goal, it serves a purpose. E.G: to make your life simpler, easier, to help with focus, or to go green.
But I feel like people are more and more travelling light for virtue signaling at this point. You cannot just travel light. Everybody must know you do.
How would you expect it to work? The police are not everywhere at all times. If there's a report of something, they have to investigate and try to interview witnesses. If one of the witnesses has a video, why wouldn't that be evidence?
In my country (France), there are very specific conditions for videos to be accepted as court evidences. One of them is that if you are a private party, the video recording must have been advertised to the person on film prior to the begining of it, and must be declared to a special authority (CNIL), to avoid abuses.
"Pour assurer la fiabilité de la preuve soumise via un dispositif de vidéosurveillance, la qualité de l’image s’avère également déterminante ; plus précisément, elle doit comporter 704 x 576 pixels de résolution au moins et une cadence de 12 images par seconde et plus. L’installation d’un tel système doit être justifiée par un besoin de sécurité ou de protection (personnes, biens, locaux, mesure d’anti-terrorisme). Dans le domaine privé, les personnes concernées doivent en être avisées et vous devez déclarer le dispositif à la CNIL."
"dans le domaine privé" could mean "by private party" or "on private properties", and since IANAL, I don't know which one. The first one would match my understanding, the second would mean the public street would be ok.
Thanks for the link! It's labelled «vidéosurveillance» though, it feels like it only applies to fixed permanent cameras, not smartphone or GoPro ad-hoc evidence.
EU countries in general are much more privacy focused compared to the UK. UK law & culture is that you have no expectation of privacy in public, and people can take pictures/take video of you anytime you are in public, for any reason.
In the EU, there is an expectation of privacy in public spaces. The gas station CCTV is only allowed to film private property, and maybe a tiny slitter of public space if there is no alternative.
Most countries also require registration of cameras to a governemental agency and warning/consent of the people being filmed. That's at least the theory.
There's lots of nuance though. CCTV that just records all the time is not the same as someone recording because of a specific incident. And then you get things like rules for dashcams that allow dashcams to keep an e.g. 30s buffer that gets saved on button press or if a crash is detected, ...
There has to be a sign at the gas station that shows that this area is filmed (at least in Europe). The sign has to tell you who is responsible and why you are filmed.
On this basis you can refuse to enter the area.
The fundamental difference is that you can at least in principle choose not to go into an area where you are filmed and know it beforehand while the other person's did not know that they are filmed. I guess they wouldn't have texted while driving in this case. They assumed privacy in their own car and on their phone.
I doubt this, and I think it's detrimental to state so in the long run.
I used Psilocybin, and it was worth it. I would recommand people to give it a try, and I helped people around me, including one parent, to take it.
Yet.
Every time I took it, I could feel my speech ability to decline for a while. The side effects faded slowly, and disapeared eventually every time. But traces of it are noticeable after even a month or two sometimes.
It's like when people claimed that marijuana was not addictive. The deny didn't help at all. I know of several people that are addicted to smoking pot now. It's a negative side effect on their life.
There is no such thing as a free lunch. Powerful products have powerful effects, and this means some harm can exist.
Yes, psilocybin is way safer than the reputation is has been given in the 70'. Yes, taking it (in the right conditions) can benefit you a lot.
But pretending there is zero detrimental effects is wishful thinking and will lead to people abusing the thing, believing it's just funny candy, and they may end up damaged.
> But pretending there is zero detrimental effects is wishful thinking and will lead to people abusing the thing, believing it's just funny candy, and they may end up damaged.
I think you're mostly reacting to the framing of this headline, which isn't accurately stating the finding of the study.
It would be more accurate to say the study "did not find any short or long term negative effects" which is not the same as a positive assertion that such effects do not exist. This is a similar level of safety as you might find with aspirin or acetaminophen - both of which could be fairly described as not having short or long term negative effects and which can have serious health consequences if used incorrectly [edit: I said "if abused" which is the wrong way to put it].
> There is no such thing as a free lunch. Powerful products have powerful effects, and this means some harm can exist.
There's nothing in this study that contradicts this idea - because studies like this don't claim to detect every form of harm. Instead, they look for particular forms of relatively objective harm. Another example to consider would be SSRIs: they tend to increase suicide attempts when patients start taking them. That's the kind of harm this study would find! But - even if a patient doesn't experience suicidal ideation - no doctor would suggest that it logically follows that patient should certainly go on SSRIs. The choice is always more complex than that.
> did not find any short or long term negative effects
I think what the original comment refers to is that measuring long term side effects is kind of impossible without waiting a long time and wishful thinking.
I mean, I understand why someone might say that, but I think that's actually a critique of western medicine in general rather than this study in particular. In that I think it's understood that studies like this are measuring harms with commonly understood (but hard to rigorously define because you don't know what you don't know) limits.
We've found new harms for medicines or treatments many times, and in each case we generally had previous studies that missed those harms. It's always possible, so calling it out about mushrooms in particular feels odd because the same critique applies to the western approach to every other medicine.
You keep saying 'western' medicine. Is this to imply that some other method exists to study long term harms? I suppose long traditional use might, but this doesn't seem meaningfully different from running medical testing over a long period of time.
> Is this to imply that some other method exists to study long term harms?
Not that I trust? But I think it's important to note that this study has epistemological value within a certain set of axioms and not everyone in the world agrees with those axioms.
The reason it's important to say is that, to some degree, I feel like BiteCode_dev could be questioning an underlying axiom of western medicine (i.e. how to think about anecdotal harms we can't find in population studies). The western tradition has an opinion about the question, but none of us have to accept that opinion, but if we don't we should be honest that we disagree with the tradition in general as opposed to finding a flaw in this particular study.
I'd read the study conclusions again, in particular the dosages and circumstances:
> "Psilocybin, in 10mg or 25mg doses, has no short-term or long-term detrimental effects in healthy people... The research, published in The Journal of Psychopharmacology, is an essential first step in demonstrating the safety and feasibility of psilocybin – a psychedelic drug isolated from the Psilocybe mushroom – for use within controlled settings alongside talking therapy as a potential treatment for a range of mental health conditions, including treatment-resistant depression (TRD) and PTSD.'
Notice that very large doses were not studied, and the studies were conducted under controlled settings, with one-on-one support from a trained psychotherapist, in groups of up to six people simultaneously.
As the study was not flawed, then, under these conditions, psilocybin certainly seems like a safe and effective option for treatment.
I'd be curious to know how many mg's an average sized magic mushroom contains. I've taken a stem and had an enjoyable couple hours. I've taken several mushrooms 3.5-7g and had a rather intense set of experiences that I'll never forget, along with some very dark and scary moments -- And I can see how these moments would permanently change someone (even a 'healthy' person).
Ultimately, how many mg's of psilocybin does an average magic mushroom contain? The very first line of text in a google search said 10mg psilocybin per 1g of mushroom. 35-70mg psilocybin for the two standard street dosages - so on the street, your minimum suggested dosage is, at minimum, like 40% stronger than this study looked into? Could make for some less than favorable experiences for people hearing about this 2nd hand and not looking into it.
I wonder if the researchers in this study had people consume mushrooms on an empty or full stomach, as well. Also makes a big difference in terms of intensity and duration (in my experience).
And like you mentioned, those in the study also had 1-on-1 support from a trained professional.. On the street, you've got your goofball friends and maybe one wise, old trip-sitter if you're lucky. And honestly, I'd prefer a seasoned trip-sitter whose taken the drug many times over a trained professional who has is much less likely to have that kind of firsthand experience. The company you keep can have just as much of an impact as the potency of the hallucinogen (again, in my experience).
I think there are some other rare side effects, like vision abnormalities.
The proper way to phrase their findings is that psilocybin has a favorable safety profile and should be studied in more detail with larger numbers of participants.
Marijuana is addictive, I know that many people will deny it, just like they say it's not unhealthy to smoke, it is, there is definitely harm done.
That said it's almost impossible to abuse mushrooms, there just isn't a desire to redo them often and it doesn't work well anyway. I've never heard of someone being addicted to psilocybin.
Sure while you're on them it can be very intoxicating, and temporary loss of speech abilities and all kinds of horrible feelings might occur, particularly in the beginning. Usually you feel better about it later.
I think it has been shown to be the least harmful drug in studies and has proven itself to be not very harmful to people or society.
>That said it's almost impossible to abuse mushrooms
nonsense
>there just isn't a desire to redo them often and it doesn't work well anyway.
please don't talk about your anecdotes as if they were facts. go to any psytrance festival in europe and marvel at people tripping for a week straight
>I've never heard of someone being addicted to psilocybin.
and I've met bucket loads of people "addicted" to living in the unreality of psychedelics. I guess that's not being "addicted to psilocybin" but if the end result is eating mushrooms x times per week then the effect is the same
> I've met bucket loads of people addicted to living in the unreality of psychedelics.
Same here. I used to be good friends with one person in particular who couldn't go more than a couple days without using psilocybin or LSD to change their reality. That's when we drifted paths. But, I heard a year ago that he had switched to heroin and died due to a fentanyl overdose. Getting addicted to altering your perception of reality is dangerous.
Yeah MDMA is addictive, not very but it is. You can use 2cb and speed quite frequently. I know about that. But with shrooms taking a dose the next day or two hardly works at all, there is extreme short term tolerance. Trying to do it frequently was not pleasant in my experience, you just dont have a magical or interesting trip.
There is no such thing as "emotional addiction" or "physical addiction". There is addiction, and some substances have withdrawal symptoms when discontinued.
Its been proven that repeated use of psilocybin quickly builds up a tolerance to it, along with cross tolerance to LSD. Your statement about festivals in Europe is just plain false, by the end of the week you have to consume significant amount of mushrooms to get the same effect. Festivals feature a wide variety of drug use and taking small dosages of mushrooms for recreation for recreation isn't abuse.
As far as addiction, there is chemical addiction, and psychological addition. The former isn't present for a lot of drugs. The latter is very hard to control for, because it really depends on the individual. People can definitely find comfort in escape from reality that psychedelics offer, which can lead to dependence.
However, given an addictive personality, psilocybin use is still safer than comparable drugs, including weed. First, the method of intake through digestive tract is generally better for health than smoking. Secondly, there are no negative withdrawal symptoms from stopping, even with micro-dosing (so in the case of your festival goers, the supposed straight week of use produces no negative withdrawal effects). Thirdly, the desire to get a stronger escape from reality will involve someone taking a higher dose, which isn't a euphoric experience like weed or MDMA can produce - its fairly exhausting even when you are having a good time.
So in the end, given the society view to alcohol and its comparable effects, psilocybin should absolutely be decriminalized and promoted as medicine for use, especially with therapy.
As I said in another comment, tolerance just means a higher dose each day. It would probably be hard to do with mushrooms for any serious dose, but with LSD it would work.
The point isn't that taking drugs on festivals is abuse, but rather that on festivals I've met people who've been taking psychedelic drugs on a weekly basis for years and their perception of reality is so twisted you have to wonder if they will ever "come back". They are willing participants in all of that, but I have to wonder if its healthy or morally sound to wave them off on their trip with no return.
>So in the end, given the society view to alcohol and its comparable effects, psilocybin should absolutely be decriminalized and promoted as medicine for use, especially with therapy.
Disagree, decriminalisation is not enough, all drugs should be legal.
But that is completely beside the point of our topic of danger.
>but rather that on festivals I've met people who've been taking psychedelic drugs on a weekly basis for years and their perception of reality is so twisted you have to wonder if they will ever "come back".
Research shows that there is a likelihood that if they stop, they will generally be fine.
Andrew Callaghan of the youtube series All Gas No Brakes used psilocybin heavily in his young teenage years, which is dangerous because it affects the brain development, and as a result he suffers from PPD, however he is able to carry on life and have a job, especially one that involves being self employed and producing content.
Like I said, there are personalities for which ordinary common things like video games are "dangerous", but we don't consider video games dangerous as a qualifier. Psilocybin should be viewed in the same way.
> Your statement about festivals in Europe is just plain false, by the end of the week you have to consume significant amount of mushrooms to get the same effect.
You think it's impossible that people at festivals are consuming significant amounts of mushrooms by the end of the week..?
That being said, the vast majority of even the heaviest users probably take a break after the festival.
This is kinda anecdotal, but if you have ever done shrooms/LSD, you would understand how extremely unlikely this is. I generally should never say "false" with absolutism, since it is plausible, but in this case, given the users previous statements, I would bet significant money that he has no evidence of festival goers doing this with mushrooms.
A good trip is usually around the 3.5 gram mark based on average experiences. If you do this, you are going to be fairly "fucked up" as people say. Its not gonna be a purely positive experience like MDMA, where once the effects wear off, you are going to want to do more to get back to your happy place. Most reality warping trips end up with person wanting it over because its so exhausting.
The next day, if you really want to have the experience again, you have to do something like 5 grams to get the effect. The next day its going to be like 8 grams. Over a week, you are going to be ingesting something like 30 grams - in many places where shrooms are illegal, bringing that much to the festival is likely going to get you involved with security as intent to sell/distribute.
LSD is way easier to do this with, as dosages last longer (12 hours on the average), and multiple tabs or it in liquid form is way easier to sneak in. However, again, the reality warping trips are not exactly pleasurable and quite exhausting, and you still have to do a boatload towards the end of the week, to get the same effect, which costs money and is a waste of a drug (and money).
The way people consume psychedelics at festivals is usually in smaller dosages, where they are certainly not disassociated even remotely Doing this for a week is arguably less harmless than drinking enough beers to get a buzz every day.
Weed/alcohol/mdma are much more common things that get used on a repetitive basis since the effects are pleasurable and you can redose to get back to euphoric state.
There are definitely people that abuse psychs in general, but this is more of a personality issue than a drug issue. People can abuse generally harmless things like video games, and ruin their lives.
I think their point is that anecdotes are not very valuable and then gave examples of anecdotes that differ as a way to show that individual experiences / perceptions can be vastly different, which isn't at odds with their original point.
The point being that you can easily summon anecdotes for or against virtually any proposition, so they tell you very little about the incidence of a phenomenon. Emptyfile also pointed out a venue where it would be easy to find counterexamples to Synaesthesia's claim.
IIRC tolerance builds extremely quickly (after just one use) and is cross-tolerant with most other 5-HT2A agonists so I think tripping a week straight is not really possible.
Tolerance just means you double the dose each day. People do it with LSD. Folks do crazy shit with drugs, in all honesty I think most people could hardly believe what kind of stuff drug users get up to.
I appreciate the newfound silicon valley, positive, scientific approach to drugs, but over here on the party continent it's a lot different.
> That said it's almost impossible to abuse mushrooms
Untrue. People can and do get hooked on the deliriant and escapist effects. Some people get addicted to the idea that the trip is revealing important information that they need to continue receiving.
It may not be common, but it's very much possible.
It's important to use precise language when talking about addiction. It sounds like you're interpreting "addiction" as "habit forming", whereas I believe GP means "physical dependency". I see a lot of people talking past each other in this thread.
> It's important to use precise language when talking about addiction. It sounds like you're interpreting "addiction" as "habit forming", whereas I believe GP means "physical dependency". I see a lot of people talking past each other in this thread.
I directly quoted the part I disagreed with. They very specifically said:
> That said it's almost impossible to abuse mushrooms,
Trying to change the topic to specifically physical dependency is a straw-man argument. The topic was literally about "abuse".
The canadian report into the misuse of drugs (a pelican book from the 70s) drew a distinction between addiction and habituation which I think has stood the test of time. Addictive things cause change in the bodies own processes, such as the replacement of ?dopamine? by opiod drugs, and a decline in the bodys own production due to homeostasis: this means the withdrawal is a real physiological effect, lack of dopamine until the body restarts production.
Some drugs (I mean drugs in the wider sense not recreational drugs) can cause PERMANENT change in the bodys own hormone cycle and so you cease production of a function entirely. Menopause is an instance of this but there are others I believe, the endocrine system is fantastically complex. I believe some bone anti-demineralisation drugs have this side effect and so deciding to take them has huge longterm consequences (again unsure I have the right background drug issue here)
Habituation is the mental binding of pleasure or some other desired state (numbing, dissociation) to the repeated effect (as I understand it) and is a different thing: It feels good because you've learned the response, might be the way to put it. This is NOT the same as a homeostatic change in body function.
> It's important to use precise language when talking about addiction.
Agreed. Adding to this: GP characterized psilocybin's effects as "deliriant". This word has a specific meaning, and psilocybin doesn't fit -- it's a psychedelic, not a deliriant. There are some mushrooms that produce deliriants (e.g. Amanita muscaria / muscimol), but these are not typically consumed in the same context as psilocybin mushrooms.
"Marijuana is addictive, I know that many people will deny it, just like they say it's not unhealthy to smoke, it is, there is definitely harm done."
I agree with this, but I think some of the pushback may be coming from people in recovery from alcohol, meth, cocaine, opiates, etc. We only have so many words to choose from, and those "addictions" more often drive death, divorce, abandonment, insane decisions, and so on. So adding marijuana to the list feels like it might dilute the message, or diminish someone's view of the dangers, etc.
"almost impossible to abuse mushrooms"
No personal experience with that, but I can attest to how different people's experiences with anything are. There's plenty of heavy users of my list of substances above that never seem to slip into the kind of hell that other people do.
If marijuana is addictive how is it I’m able to take weeks and months off each year (I live in a legal state) without withdrawals?
It stores itself in fat and I’ve definitely noticed it takes a few weeks before I’m entirely off the effects.
That’s a lot different than meth where addicts have mental breakdown without it.
Routine interaction with others is chemically stimulating and withdrawal into isolation can hurt. Is having friends addictive? Lockdown isolation has been harder than going without weed when I needed to.
I think the normies should stop trying to be experts. Experience and ability are relative just like physics. Seeing patterns in reality isn’t interesting; we all do it inherently as part of our innate biology.
Agree that the pro-legalization movement likes to claim "not addictive" but what they always have meant (which if pressed, they generally will acknowledge) is that it is not physically addictive.
It is, of course, psychologically addictive because literally anything can be.
Surprised i had to scroll so far down the comments to see this reply among the sea of “but weed is addictive, despite everyone claiming otherwise”.
You are fully correct, people talk only about the physical component of addiction when it comes to drugs, because, as you said, literally anything can be psychologically addicting. Videogames, movies, tv shows, work, etc., all of those. If it is an activity or something you interact with, it can be psychologically addictive.
In light of that, I am confused by all those “but weed is addicting” comments. It is kind of obvious that the article is talking about physical addiction exclusively.
I think what most people are referring to with cannabis, in terms of it not being addictive, is physiological dependence. Cannabis has very little in terms of withdrawal symptoms, and thus has low propensity towards physiological dependence. I’ve heard people state depression for a few days as one of the few withdrawal symptoms for heavy users. So while the people you may know may be addicted, it’s not because of a physiological dependence but a mental one.
Mushroom drawl is a pretty classical tell of usage, but I wouldn't consider it a de facto detriment.
For some people, being a little slower to speak means they're more careful with their thoughts, less likely to be carried away by engagement or perpetuate useless ideas, and more prone to patient reflection.
Mushrooms can't magically confer any of those skills, but some things are easier to learn when we're not leaning on only what comes most naturally to us.
> Mushroom drawl is a pretty classical tell of usage, but I wouldn't consider it a de facto detriment.
> For some people, being a little slower to speak means they're more careful with their thoughts,
It takes some wild mental gymnastics to try to flip a drug-induced speech impediment into a good thing.
It's also fascinating to watch how some of the psychedelic enthusiasts will vehemently dismiss the idea of mushroom-induced speech issues, while others will readily acknowledge that "mushroom drawl" is a classic, well-known phenomenon but it's okay because it's good actually.
> For some people, being a little slower to speak means they're more careful with their thoughts, less likely to be carried away by engagement or perpetuate useless ideas, and more prone to patient reflection.
I speak fast when my mind is sharp and active, and speak slow when I am tired or sick and can't think straight. Bet you most people do the same. So you probably should read it that he had long term retardation of the brain, not a calm nature.
> It's like when people claimed that marijuana was not addictive.
Marijuana is not physically addictive. That was and is also the reasonable claim made by reasonable people. Then lots of people seems to have conflated this claim with psychological addictiveness.
I claim that HN isn't physically addictive. The fact that it is psychologically addictive doesn't amount to me "pretending".
Anecdotally, I spent ~10 years as a daily pot smoker. I then moved to another country where it's illegal, so I stopped cold turkey in one day. I didn't experience any physical side effects or cravings. YMMV, but at least for me, it was a psychological condition. Once I told myself that I wanted to live in a place where it was illegal, and I wasn't willing to break the law of my new country of residence, that was it.
As a personal anecdote: been smoking for 10 years and everytime I take a break I have huge night sweats for 3 or 4 days until I become normal again.
I'm talking like waking up twice in the middle of the night to change bed sheets and t-shirt so I'm not sleeping in a pool of sweat.
> Flawed drug awareness campaigns of the 1990s claimed that cannabis could be psychologically addictive but not physically addictive like other drugs. However, cannabis does predictably cause physical dependence—the hallmarks of which are tolerance and withdrawal—and heavy users may have great difficulty in attempting to reduce or end their use, leading to compulsive, continued use and related consequences
Prolonged cannabis use produces both pharmacokinetic changes (how the drug is absorbed, distributed, metabolized, and excreted) and pharmacodynamic changes (how the drug interacts with target cells) to the body. These changes require the user to consume higher doses of the drug to achieve a common desirable effect (known as a higher tolerance), reinforcing the body's metabolic systems for eliminating the drug more efficiently and further down-regulating cannabinoid receptors in the brain.[7]
Cannabis users have shown decreased reactivity to dopamine, suggesting a possible link to a dampening of the reward system of the brain and an increase in negative emotion and addiction severity.[8]
(...)
Cannabis withdrawal symptoms occur in one-half of people in treatment for cannabis use disorders.[15] Symptoms may include dysphoria (anxiety, irritability, depression, restlessness), disturbed sleep, gastrointestinal symptoms, and decreased appetite. It is often paired with rhythmic movement disorder. Most symptoms begin during the first week of abstinence and resolve after a few weeks.
Whether or not there is strong evidence of physical addiction, the withdrawal experience is very real, and often unpleasant. Couple this with psychological dependence, and quitting can feel quite daunting.
The main issues right away:
- Problems sleeping due to REM rebound (vivid disruptive dreams or nightmares)
- Appetite issues
- General irritability
- Heightened anxiety (especially if using cannabis to treat anxiety)
If you’re using semi-medicinally, it’s extremely easy to hit these roadblocks, conclude “see I shouldn’t quit, weed isn’t so bad anyway”, and fall back into the habit.
I’m convinced that the reality of cannabis addiction/withdrawal is aggressively glossed over by the community of users who are very invested in what they’re doing being just fine. The truth is a bit murkier/darker.
I say this as a recreational-bordering-medical user (it does help calm down my PTSD) who enjoys using it, but who dislikes the inconvenient reality of trying to take a tolerance break.
I recently quit a pretty heavy constant background dose of THC (which I used to leverage myself off a pretty heavy constant background dose of alcohol).
sleeping is a big one
piercing headaches
similar effect to quitting alcohol - heightened sensitivity to light and noise
its also quite an adjustment to be dumped back out into the world again after living for years in your little blanket of quiet satisfaction.
its not the worst, and I've quit weed before without going through anything..but its not nothin
As does gambling addiction. The chemicals being internally generated by a psychological process doesn’t mean there aren’t severe withdrawal effects. Panic attacks and depression can have severe physical side effects. That doesn’t make any of those things chemically addictive substances.
> Marijuana is not physically addictive. That was and is also the reasonable claim made by reasonable people.
That's not true at all. Heavy marijuana dependency and withdrawals definitely produce physical withdrawal effects.
They're not equivalent to, say, alcohol withdrawal, but they will exist.
There's actually a lot of research into various adjunct medications to dampen the physical withdrawal to help addicted marijuana users quit.
But regardless, if you have to qualify the type of addiction, you're not escaping the fact that something is addictive. Too many people have used this false physical/psychological dichotomy to talk themselves into marijuana dependencies, psychological or otherwise.
Based on what? I believed it was common sense that our mental state was a product of the neurochemical interactions going on our brains. If you get addicted to gaming, are you really addicted to gaming, or are you addicted to the huge amounts of hormones like dopamine and serotonin flooding your brain when you win a match? Is this really "psychological" addiction? If the answer is yes, should I decide to inject serotonin intravenously, is it still psychological addiction?
I don't think we are talking about the same thing. I'm specifically talking about addiction, but it seems you're talking about withdrawal, which is related but not the same.
Focusing too much on the distinction can lead to false conclusions like “I can use cannabis without any concerns about addiction.
Ignoring the distinction can falsely equate the severity of dependence with harder drugs.
I think it’s important to leave room for both: 1) Yes, there’s a difference between physical/psychological addiction and 2) Sometimes the end result is still addiction, with all of the negatives that come with it.
Physiological addiction is more real in that your body forms a physical dependency on something that can kill you if you don't have it. This is CRUCIAL to understanding why we need stuff like Methadone or Kratom to help ween people off of Heroin/opioids.
Mental addiction is treated entirely differently and is far less severe.
Both are real? Of course. However: Psychological addiction can drive you to kill yourself but except in the most extreme of corner cases can I imagine how you could involuntarily die. Physiological addiction can straight up execute you (see alcohol or benzo withdrawal).
"Most" seems like a high bar. Corner case I guess is unfair wording because it's totally undefinable. The DTs does choose to execute some people, especially if they can't reach treatment. I guess psychological stress can as well in rare events, although for an otherwise healthy person I would always pick the most crushing psychological stress over suffering untreated DT.
Well for one because alcohol and alcoholics are virtually all over the world and it isn't clear to me that the majority of alcoholics in the world both know about the risks of DT and have access to treatment. But it is my understanding even with EARLY appropriate treatment there is an expectation 1+% of those suffering DT will die.
AA specifically works with health care workers specifically because of this and other problems. If "most" is your bar then death is only a corner case of attempted suicide. Although I thought I admitted that "corner case" was just a poor choice of undefinable wording on my part.
~%5% odds of getting DTs and then 25% of death untreated and 1-5% chance treated don't sound great to me. Treated death of all alcoholics rate looks somewhere between flu and covid death rate and untreated death rate is much worse than covid death rate in populaton. People seem worried about covid death and not considering that a corner case.
>You are trying to claim that psychological addiction isn’t as real as physiological addiction, not just for alcohol.
I never said such a thing and this is just a malevolent and calculated lie.
>What isn’t clear is why you want to deny the difficulties of people who have psychological addictions to any kind of drug.
It's not clear because no such denial exists, and it's only alleged as part of a malevolent and calculated lie.
My original comment said they were both real. I'm saying regarding being straight up executed, the numbers game is that psychological addiction doesn't look nearly as likely to straight up execute you. I've said nothing to say psychologist addiction isn't a difficult for some people.
I don't know about you, but I think it's extremely important, ESPECIALLY FOR PEOPLE WITH EXPERIENCE IN PSYCHOLOGICALLY ADDICTIVE SUBSTANCES who have perhaps had insanely hard struggles with things like opiates to understand that no amount of willpower will spare them from the very real chance of involuntary death from benzo or alcohol withdrawal.
You've built a straw man as tall as the wall of china is wide.
I thought it was clear that I said both were real, but I understand maybe it was not interpreted by you that way. I wasn't saying your comment was wrong, I was speaking with thought in mind of some inferences that might be made based on your statement.
I was worried it could be inferred the flat out execution would be the same level of "real" for psychological as it is for the physiological. I was worried someone who has gone through insanely torturous psychological opiate withdrawal for instance would think that if they're both just as real, that means their odds of involuntary death from psychological withdrawal and physiological withdraw looks the same and they can just mentally power through physiological addiction like some strong-willed people may be able to with psychological addiction.
Of course this is wrong. You can't willpower your way out of delerium tremens. You can be executed, no matter what conscious decision you make.
I do not believe this is what you wrote. I was adding to the conversation. Do you believe it is ok to add to the conversation? Not every comment is meant to literally attempt to disprove the person above them. I was not disproving your statement.
This doesn't mean anything. It's not evidence of anything. You can't go to court and argue there's no such thing as a free lunch.
There's free lunches out there, literally, somebody puts a literal free lunch out next to the dumpster for the less fortunate all the time. There's losers and winners with no reason to be found for why. Some guy buys Bitcoin at 5 bucks, becomes a billionaire and doesn't turn into the archetypal power-mad lunatic burning his fortunes on lambos.
Here's the actual woo: desperate attempts to overlay patterns of meaning to a universe that does not subscribe to Abrahamic values.
Some people will take psychedelics and have enduring negative impressions, sometimes for the rest of their life. Others, like myself, will use it to shapechange out of a history of abuse by their parents. No one can know which of the cards they'll pick.
But I can tell you, from the many I have directly known to take it, a fraction succumbed to permanent, negative, distorted beliefs. Some got a free lunch, some few did not.
No free lunch carries some weight in this context. If there is a chemical that has a very positive effect in humans, there is probably a reason that humans didn't evolve to produce that chemical or exist in the state that the chemical induces.
That reason could be related to what you suggest, that the actual effect is a mixed bag and doesn't wind up worth it. It could be that our environment has changed to make it beneficial and evolution hasn't caught up. It could be that dreams are already the same thing and we're not sleeping enough or the right way, so psychadelics are filling the gap. In general, though, it's that the benefits are outweighed by costs. No free lunch is a reasonable prior in biology.
It's "not addictive" in the sense that physical withdrawal symptoms are minimal compared to booze, nicotine, and other drugs. But you can make a daily habit out of anything pleasurable and ruin your life around it. I've seen people ruin their lives with both gaming and gambling habits.
It's a drug that sort of shakes up your mind. It lets you make all sorts of connections that you aren't going to sober, unless you spend a ton of time reflecting. At the end, you gain this incredible emotional clarity which helps you regulate your emotions. This is probably why it's being studied for use with depression and anxiety.
> Virtually all of the clinical trials and robust research studies psilocybin in conjunction with 10 or more non-psychedelic therapy sessions.
Tangential, but I've noticed that all the psilocybin trials I've read about are combined with therapy as well; my knee jerk assumption is that there are legal/moral/funding powers at play causing that. Not sure a study would get funded if it consisted of "we're going to get a bunch of depressed people to take shrooms and see what happens!".
The more scientific approach would be to separate the therapy group from the shroom group.
I agree completely and did not mean to imply otherwise (hence my phrasing of "it can help with" rather than "it can cure"). Yes, that research involved combination treatment of psilocybin alongside psychotherapy.
That said, the anecdotal effects I listed are just from personal use without psychotherapy. But of course they're anecdotal :)
From brain scans regarding psychedelic mushroom use, it shows a huge increase of brain activity, indicating a lot more neural activations, which is why visuals usually involve seeing resemblance of things you know in things like wall or carpet textures. There are also some reports that the blood flow to the region that is responsible for parsing reality is decreased and increased to other areas, which makes your internal thoughts feel more like reality.
If you think about it in terms of neural networks, your day to day life is a set of standard inputs that result in predictable emotions/outcomes. However, on a shroom trip with significant dosage, both the outside effects and internal thoughts get enhanced in both strength and with additional features, which can be enough to start moving your internal synaptic weights enough to effect different thoughts or behaviors.
This is analogous to something like going to a different country with a different culture, and living there, which in turn will change your perspectives opinions and behaviors based on experiencing life differently - after about a month or so you will likely be doing things slightly differently and thinking about concepts in a slightly different way. Magic mushrooms essentially condenses this process in a shorter timeframe.
So given the right setting, this process can provide positive effects. Of course, the trip could also exaggerate negative emotions and thoughts, however, because of no withdrawal symptoms or long lasting effects, people generally just remember it as a bad trip and don't wanna do it again. Even there, sometimes the meta effect is experiencing the bad feeling strong enough during the trip that it doesn't seem as bad when you are sober.
In general, the argument for use is that the probability for negative effects is low, but probability for positive effects is significant. So rationally it makes sense to go through the experience.
It's different from people to people, and from session to session.
I've seen a variety of positive effects, but this is annecdotal, as they are reported by the people taking the substance themself.
There is also the problem of long term vs short term. There are plenty of positive side effects that fade away after a few hours, days, or months.
Often though, people report practical insights about oneself or life, that they could not get before, and those can be lasting.
Some people report physical benefits as well. Paul Stamets famously said his speech impediment disapeared after a session.
On a personnal level, what lasted for me were:
- the understanding of some needs I had, and that I was not allowing myself to have.
- the smoothing of autistic symptoms such. E.g: welcoming of physical contact.
Both significantly improved my quality of life.
I have to insist on the right conditions, though. There affect heavily both your immediate experience and the benefits you may get. If you intend to give it a try, get an experimented, serious and benevolent person to assist you.
There are some groups that are specialized in the matter. I've done my first session with the psychedelic society: you pay them, and they organize a whole 3 days seminar for you. They were competent, caring, and amazingly benevolent. Unfortunatly they exist only in Europe.
I don't have data but first hand experience and for me it is truer to say: it enhances your level of consciousness and it allows you to experience reality from beyond your mental-emotional conditioning. Which are two things that may sound very cryptic to many people reading this, as it cannot really be described in words. It is a explaining an orgasms to a person who has never had it kind of thing.
It obviously needs more formal research, but anecdotal reports of tryptamine-based psychedelics indicate strong potential for stress management and/or general mental health recovery.
an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of abject confusion in this realm as fifty mind numbing years of the US Drug War sponsored by RAID Shadow Legends has rendered any independent attempt at scientific validation of the conditions applications and hazards of most recreational narcotics a fever dream of retraction, deflection, and outright lies.
For 50 years psychedelic drugs were the devils dingaling and always accompanied by a well-wishing naysayer who insisted the other shoe was filled with the cloven hoof of Mephistopheles himself. This is quality peer-reviewed research, the same kind used to ostensibly validate things like hydrocodone and Flintstones vitamins...but this sort of thing is happening alongside the haggard burro of western drug policy which makes it all the more precious. Any knowledge of the conditions and terms related to something like this as it pertains to PTSD is invaluable as 30 years ago such seditious mumblings would get you branded a communist hippie.
so yeah, terms and conditions apply and just as with everything else, theres a ladder of risk, but castigating the machine shop for their nefarious chainsaw sure to rain terror upon the good fae of the woods is a little silly.
> It's like when people claimed that marijuana was not addictive.
I quit both weed and nicotine and only the nicotine was the problem to shift. Weed can be habitual, sure but there's a huge difference in physical and habitual addiction.
Quitting nicotine is absurdly overblown. I'm sure me saying this will annoy somebody, but I think it's much more of a habit than a physical addiction and people hide behind the physical addiction as an excuse. Maybe if you smoke a pack a day it is a different beast but daily smoking is really not hard to kick.
Maybe it is overblown, I can generally go a while without a smoke, and could probably quit with relative ease if I wanted to. Surely it’s no heroin withdraw and certainly not as bad as alcohol withdraw, but it’s the quickest I’ve ever come to developing any physical addiction symptoms. The withdraw is real too, but mostly bearable.
well it took me ~four years to comfortably quit nicotine from wanting to, to absolute zero. Weed is considerably easier to turn on and off whenever. I get that we're all weird but for some people there is a significant difference here.
I wonder how much of that is addiction and how much is just forgetting what something is like. I have 1 cigar a month (never more, occasionally less) and have done so for about 12 years. I suppose some may say that means I'm addicted. Or does it mean I simply enjoy a cigar? I honestly don't know the threshold. When I see a cigar I'm usually reminded of the enjoyment; I guess that is some addiction in and of itself. It calls into question, what is a memory in and of itself -- and if memories and the desire to relive them are just an incarnation of addiction.
IMHO addiction is where you don't feel like you can adequately function without. For a daily nicotine smoker, being without is a negative consequence that seriously alters mood and efficacy. This is what makes that sort of addiction particularly ravenous as opposed to your measured once a month.
I wonder what you think the point of HN is? Do you think that this is a community for sharing peer-reviewed studies?
If you're not interested in reading opinions and comments from an open forum that anyone can join, then maybe it is better for you to stop reading these comments.
For me, I think OP's comment was completely reasonable, and at any rate, the headline with which the conclusions of this study appears is at best incomplete, and deserves to be criticised.
I don't think the point of HN is for people to share scientific articles and then for the comments section to be like "I disagree because of my personal experiences."
Where does a conversation that uses personal anecdotes to refute scientific evidence even go? That's not adding anything to the conversation _at all_.
Hacker News is where I go for intelligent discussion. Literally anyone can hop on the internet and say "hmm...I disagree because this one time..." and I tend to stay away from places that foster those kinds of value-less conversations.
I don't agree. I've never taken psilocybin, and I'm interested to hear the subjective experiences of folks who have, in addition to reading scientific studies, so this does add to the conversation. If I only wanted to read the study, then I'd subscribe to the Journal of Psychopharmacology.
However, there are some (in my opinion) huge flaws in this study and its presentation:
1. This study was conducted on a small sample (60 people who received the psilocybin, and addition 29 who received the placebo - of whom 4 did not actually complete the study).
2. The study looked at short term effects and followed up at '29 or 85 days', (my emphasis). I'm not sure that I would be comfortable saying there had been 'no detrimental effects' after less than a month.
3. The study limits the scope of 'detrimental effects' to cognitive functioning or emotional processing.
4. The study was supervised and all participants took part in mandatory preparation and therapy sessions.
5. All of the participants were self-selected, and 35 participants had already taken psilocybin out of the 89 total participants (including those who had taken the placebo), which is about 13 times higher than the estimated population lifetime use in the UK.
6. Importantly in conjunction with point 5, participants were screened for pre-existing medical and psychiatric conditions, meaning a highly significant proportion of participants had already taken psilocybin without detrimental effect at least once before, and other non-first time users who had experienced detrimental effects previously would have been excluded from the study.
7. Four participants in the placebo arm did not complete the study, meaning the control group was only 25 people.
8. Efficacy of blinding was not assessed, and given the nature of psilocybin and the fact that up to 41% of the people who completed the study had taken psilocybin before, it seems quite likely that a significant proportion of the participants were unblinded.
9. Particularly worrying in the study is the statement: "An AE [Adverse Event] of substance induced psychotic disorder was reported for a participant who became behaviourally disinhibited during the acute drug experience. After a medical assessment, 2.5 mg oromucosal midazolam was administered. This event was not considered to be an SAE [Serious Adverse Event]." It would be unusual to administer buccal midazolam to someone who was not experiencing any 'detrimental effects'.
In a study which is potentially only looking at 25 people taking psilocybin for the first time[0] at low doses, I don't think we can really discount personal anecdotes, especially when they're clearly and properly presented as such.
[0]: Admittedly worst-case scenario where all of the placebo group turn out to have never taken psilocybin before.
> I'm interested to hear the subjective experiences of folks who have
Okay, I have taken psilocybin and I agree with the study wholeheartedly.
Thanks for the second part of your comment which is much more of what I go to Hacker News for but not really relevant to my comment. Plus, since my personal experiences reaffirm the study, I'm going to ignore all of those critiques and just stick to my personal opinion.
After being told one dose of the vaccine will prevent us from catching covid, then that actually it needs a second dose the same year, well actually you could catch it, wait actually you will probably catch it but it's less deadly, oh I forgot you'll need 3 doses. Ah, now 4 in 2 years... Also, the FDA wants 55 years to process FOIA request over the vaccine data.
Those people need to get their communication act together, because they are loosing credibility at the speed of an R0 of 3. The public is already squirmish, not to mention tense because of the economic and social impact of the pandemic.
It's like they have a secret wish for people to explode in their face.