> Inbox Zero might be impractical every day, but Inbox Organized happens without breaking a sweat.
My experience is the absolute opposite. Organising mails is a strange game, and the only winning move is not to play.
I get the information out of the emails as soon as I can, and put it into a system that is actually manageable.
GTD had it right from the start. Thank you David Allen.
You want harsh feedback ? I'll never pay for your system, because it would lead to more work for me on the long run, not less. Emails are not todo list: todo list are mostly signal, while emails are mostly noise. Your system organize noise, and automatically. This has no value to me.
But you could build a system that I actually need. An inbox that I would enjoy.
Indeed, I don't need a system that help me organise my various sources of informations and tasks. I have so many of them that would be terrible even if it worked, anyway. Managing 20 organized systems in parallel is hell.
I need systems that make it easy to extract the relevant informations from them, and put the result in one central organized place for action, and another one for archive. A system that filters noise, and get me in control. That's it.
Eventually, my life is just that: being, doing and knowing. I don't need a system for the first. I don't want more than 2 systems for the 2 last.
I've been using Shortwave in Alpha for about five months and I think you're reacting far too strongly to one line in the blog post. The product does a bunch of things that encourage an Inbox-zero workflow. Emails are organized as a to-do list, and the archive feature is way more prominent than in Gmail, so the most natural workflow is to go down your inbox and check things off. Most of the organization described happens automatically. And the organization helps getting to zero - all of the confluence notifications I get, for instance, are grouped in a single thread and I can scan and archive them quickly.
I get to inbox zero 2-3 times a week, and that wasn't happening before when I was using the Gmail client.
> I need systems that make it easy to extract the relevant informations from them, and put the result in one central organized place for action, and another one for archive. A system that filters noise, and get me in control. That's it.
Yes! In my experience Shortwave is better at this than the client I was using previously. I think it actually addresses some of your issues with email.
I think GP is correct. This essentially takes the idea of a lean to-do list and constantly barrages it with junk (email). I've used the Get Things Done ideas for years with a plain ol' email account and Microsoft To-Do. Each does its job well. When you try to make one thing do multiple jobs, it's often done poorly in both.
So true. I found that if an issue is really important, then they will find a way to contact you or it resolves automatically. If I really need to get a context, I'll search for the recipient's name and get instant context on the "issue".
My solution is just to never delete any e-mails. Inbox zero is a complete waste of time for me.
It’s a modern Sysyphus scenario. I could do it, if I did nothing else, and it would not contribute to my doing any useful work and I’d be at the bottom of the hill tomorrow morning.
I couldn't agree less. I've tried so many task and todo systems and ultimately have come to the conclusion that the most effective todo list I've ever had is my email inbox. I pick one up and then fail to fully embrace it because forming new habits can be hard. Email on the other hand, is impossible to avoid, I have to be in it every day. I've yearned for a better way to manage it and I think this product addresses that.
Unfortunately I won't be a customer though because I hate Google and am a happy Fastmail user.
This is also just a complete misread of the original Inbox Zero talk, and something Merlin Mann complains about every time he tries a new email app that does confetti when you hit "inbox zero". He himself is a deep GTD/David Allen acolyte anyway, but at this point people's misread of what "inbox zero" means is too mainstream and cargo culted.
Well, yes and no. There was a time when we could shop online without all this nonsense. It's getting worse every year, instead of better.
And also, going to the store has its own rewards. You get to talk to real people, see and touch the things you want to buy, etc.
Now we're alone behind a screen, jumping through absurd and arbitrary hoops that keep getting harder and harder (tried to solve a captcha lately) and fighting "AI" systems fed with stupid data.
That's if you understand it entirely, including the legalese, on the first read. That's for the kindle only, not for amazon the website, nor alexa or prime.
I accepted 3 TOS last week, as a dev, it's almost part of my job description, but let's focus on normal people and say they don't accept TOS for Github, FIGMA or AWS, but only for stuff like youtube, gmail, msoffice, whatsapp, instagram, etc.
Let's be _very_ optimistic and say you have 20 TOS (excluding IRL contracts such as the bank, insurance, etc) forced on you every year by services: Apple, Google, Microsoft, Mozilla, Telegram, Facebook all have different TOS for difference services.
Then you have the TOS updates, that don't come as a diff of the previous one, but as a haystack with the changes as needles. So let's say 10 more to read, again.
Let's average reading time to 5 hours (I'm being very generous), and assume you understand the implications (at this point, it's not generosity, it's abnegation). That's 30 * 5, or 150 hours, that you are supposed to spend each year on reading those ? What do you do, take 3 weeks of vacation just for that ? Also don't forget to sleep, eat healthy, exercise, educate yourself, and socialize.
And what if, after reading the ToS, they object to some clause? Their only recourse is not using the service. Object to more than a handful, and soon your only option is living in a cave.
That, or push for legislation that limits what may be put into contracts, clickthrough or others. But since contracts are sacrosanct, and the highest purpose of society and the law is enforcing them, that option is off the table.
Even if you hire a lawyer to review that ToS, that would be a waste of time because every ToS has a clause "we can change the terms any time we want for any reason we want and it's your responsibility to read the new terms on our website". Most ToSes also refer to "additional terms" written elsewhere.
Then don’t use the services. I wouldn’t sign a contract without reading it. “Your honour, I had no time to read the contract, therefore it’s void” seems a bad excuse.
Or society can just treat shitty ToS clauses as invalid because the good of the individual is far more important than being fair to powerful ultra corporations.
Ok it is obvious that there are one of three possible ways you handle terms of service:
1. You do not read any terms of service, like most people, and thus when you end up getting screwed over by a service you will accept that because you should have read the TOS, or perhaps you think the likelihood of you being screwed is minimal so you are willing to take the risk.
2. You read all TOS, do not accept those you disagree with, accept others you agree with.
3. You mix reading and not reading TOS dependent on how central you think they should be to your life, those that are not central you do not read because obviously those that are not central you can afford to have removed at the will of the corporations that own them.
But of course, you stated quite clearly that you wouldn't sign a contract without reading it, this must mean that you are doing number 2. You read every TOS you sign and some of them you refuse. That's great!
It's great because the parent poster you replied to made suppositions about how much time a person who did that would have to put aside to doing it, those were just suppositions though, you possess the cold hard facts and can tell us and them exactly how close their guestimates were, as well as answering the extremely important question as to how you manage your time to have enough of it to read and sign all those TOS, and in the cases where you have decided that a TOS did not fulfill your needs how you have handled it - how do you find services to replace them - have you ever been in a situation where you had to refuse a TOS even though your job may have depended on the usage of the service - how did you handle that?
Sure are a lot of things to find out about here, and finally someone who can help us out.
on edit: from reading further down the thread it seems when you said "I wouldn’t sign a contract without reading it." you actually meant that you would, but you would not complain when the company that you did not read the contract of screwed you over. Well that's sad. So I mean there is absolutely nothing a company could do to you that was not illegal that you would come complain about? Really?
So you are ok with a system that is created to legally bind you to something you don't know and can be used against you later unless you take tremendous efforts to not be?
In that case, ok.
Most people are not, and it's reasonable.
In fact, it's terrible that we have to rely on lawyers because the law is so complicated you can't know or understand it all, just to live you regular life.
But TOS are even worst. Because they are asymmetrical. You don't get some right and some duty. Only duty for you, and rights for the other party, which is already economically and socially in a position of strength compared to you.
And no, it's not acceptable to tell people to accept that or live in a cave.
I don't have a google account attached to my android phone. This makes my life more difficult in all sort of ways, because society assumes more and more than I do.
So I'm just being punished because I don't want to give my life to a big corporation.
I understand people think it's BS. You should not have to do that.
You already have that right. At least in my country, by law.
The TOS is a layer on top of that right that corporations abuse to make that right conditional to their own laws.
EDIT: Arf, just looked at your comment history and now I understand I'm loosing my touch. One person answered:
"Could you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments to HN? You've been doing it repeatedly, and we ban that sort of account because it's not what this site is for."
Sometimes it's not about how long does it take to read it, but even how it is interpreted by one of the parties, or if it includes clauses that are unreasonable.
For example, contracts signed by seniors who didn't have the knowledge or mental faculties to understand what they were signing, may be voided.
If you don’t have the legal expertise or the time to read a contract you hire a lawyer to have him see if the contract is reasonable, or you don’t sign it.
They will take the fine, deduct it from their huge profit, and carry on. The EU will be happy to pocket the fine, they need the money. It worked in the past, what new thing could make it go wrong for Apple?
Very useful, especially since CBV have terrible ergonomics. They have hidden code path, state and flow everywhere in their thousands methods, MRO to follow, they are verbose and hard to debug (good luck putting a breakpoint in the right place).
I miss generic function views, but you can almost use CBV like them: in your view fuction, do "return YourCBV.as_view(params)" and you are good to go. Much easier than subclassing.
Of course, with FastAPI, we know that there an even better API for that: DI. It's more composable, easier to follow, to test and with less side effects.
I'm against OOP, I use it myself, but you should use it for what it's good at: multiple operations around a central state, crafting an api with __dunder__ methods, and namespacing related data and operations.
I wonder if it listen to audio or use the video feed to record noises you make, or your pupils dilatation and evaluation the autonomous nervous system arousal that emerges from the reaction to the content.
Because time spent, scrolling rhythm and likes seem like too weak of a signal.
You have to actively like content you like and follow people you want to see more of. Have a motive and plan of what type of content you want to consume and you get that kind of stuff.. I like and followed people who are nearby and visit beautiful places close by... This is like 80% of my feed and I like it...
My experience exactly, and my friend's experience too. I'm inclined to think every "tiktok is soo great after you put time into it" comment I see is some form of Stockholm syndrome..
The content you like might not be very available on tik tok. From personal experience, it’s able to hone down on niches you like pretty quickly.
Most impressively, without having an account or liking specific videos, it can narrow down the information. Especially since they have to use some kind of algo to contextually understand videos without hashtags or subtitles.
> Most impressively, without having an account or liking specific videos, it can narrow down the information. Especially since they have to use some kind of algo to contextually understand videos without hashtags or subtitles.
I think they use some kind of object recognition to sort videos . Like if you watch videos with one particular object, you are more likely to see videos with that object.
I found that my initial foryou feed was pretty terrible and I ended up in political content pretty quickly. Once I nudged the algorithm by searching for my own hobbies, my foryou feed has been pretty great. I think probably every now and then it gets stuck in some local optimum, but it's pretty responsive to when you search for a specific niche going forward IME. Ultimately though like other commenters have mentioned, the content can be pretty shallow compared to other media
> Ultimately though like other commenters have mentioned, the content can be pretty shallow compared to other media
My one time experience felt like browsing the youtube trending page continuously. Which I know must be something a lot of people like, because the videos in there have hundred of millions of views.
But this kind of content is the opposite of everything I enjoy. Does tik tok show a different face deep inside the algo tree?
TikTok has lots of content for nerds (though I think they prefer the term neurodivergent). But there is certainly a trend that TikTok content is comparatively shallow. For example Hank [1] and John Green [2] have quite nerdy content, but it's much shorter less developed thoughts than their youtube channel [3]. Or NileRed: his most recent TikTok[4] (eating capsaicin) is in no way comparable to his most recent YouTube[5] (synthesizing cotton candy from cotton balls). In terms of nerdy content it probably shines more with life advice than with science facts, simply because of the short video format.
Not sure about the age group, most of TikTok is probably targeted at ages 12-40.
Speaking as a tiktok-using millennial nerd, it only took about a week or so for my feed to exclusively send me content on D&D, tech advice, science fiction skits, history lessons, and the occasional book review.
The content is there, but sometimes you do have to help the algorithm a little by using the search feature and liking the sort of videos that you actually want to see.
I think it's just broken in some cases for whatever reason. Like 9 months ago I mentioned trying out Tik Tok for some weeks and despite lots of "not interested", likes etc, I got swamped by 99% garbage, including videos I specifically said I don't want to see.
- else keywords in loops, which nobody knows even exist.
- raise from (empty, or with params).
- yield from (espacially with send())
- comprehension lists
- advanced unpacking. This is valid: (a, (b, *c)) = [1, {*range(4)}]
- advanced slicing. This is valid: foo[2:8:2] = bar[:4]
Most of which existed in Python 2 already !
But it has never been a problem before. Why ?
Because the community doesn't abuse features, it's part of the creed. But also because half of the python coders don't even know they exist (they are just trying to solve their problem, but dev is not their job), and are productive without it, so they just don't use it.
In fact, a lot of tutorials on the internet never even mention those.
Since the walrus came out, I used it once, and never saw it on a client code base.
But when the community do use the features, they usually make things better: decorators made flask/click what it is, slicing made numpy/pandas what it is, type hints made fastapi/pydantic what they are.
Those worries are mostly that: worries. They don't reflect what happens in practice.
You are right. Let's be real, if you're teaching Python to kids and bootcampers, you're going to only cover a little bit of what's in Python 2, and that's fine.
The other stuff is mostly designed by framework authors to by used by framework authors. And having nice libraries and frameworks is what really makes this language so useful for everyone.
It's trendy to claim Python is meant to be some kind of "pure environment" where the source code of Flask or SQLAlchemy or NumPy should just like a tutorial, but Python has never been that in the 10+ years I've been getting paid to use it.
I thought that was the aspiration of Go. As far as I could tell, Hacker News commenters hated Go and now it's mostly ignored and forgotten here.
> Inbox Zero might be impractical every day, but Inbox Organized happens without breaking a sweat.
My experience is the absolute opposite. Organising mails is a strange game, and the only winning move is not to play.
I get the information out of the emails as soon as I can, and put it into a system that is actually manageable.
GTD had it right from the start. Thank you David Allen.
You want harsh feedback ? I'll never pay for your system, because it would lead to more work for me on the long run, not less. Emails are not todo list: todo list are mostly signal, while emails are mostly noise. Your system organize noise, and automatically. This has no value to me.
But you could build a system that I actually need. An inbox that I would enjoy.
Indeed, I don't need a system that help me organise my various sources of informations and tasks. I have so many of them that would be terrible even if it worked, anyway. Managing 20 organized systems in parallel is hell.
I need systems that make it easy to extract the relevant informations from them, and put the result in one central organized place for action, and another one for archive. A system that filters noise, and get me in control. That's it.
Eventually, my life is just that: being, doing and knowing. I don't need a system for the first. I don't want more than 2 systems for the 2 last.