Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

On the other hand, the RS-28 is the Russian state of the art now, and is probably as deadly as the Tsar, but very practical. However, it is yet to see if it will work as advertised.


I’m not a weapons expert so I DuckDucked RS-28, and apparently it’s a missile not a warhead? Wikipedia says it can have a payload of:

> 10–15 MIRVs[3] Unspecified number of Avangard HGVs

I don’t know how to make use of this information.



Not what I meant, those were linked directly by the bit of Wikipedia I quoted.

I don’t know the implications of having these as a payload.

What size warheads can be mounted in this particular missile’s MIRV option? Are they typically all warheads or are most decoys? If multiple, are they likely to be redundantly targeting the same location, or is this used to target multiple locations from a single launch? The Wikipedia page on MIRVs basically answers “yes” rather than expanding my intuition for how these are likely to be configured.

The Avangard article specifies warhead payload range, but I have no idea how it’s intended to be used even if the maximum count per missile was not unspecified.


IANANWEONWP, but:

For the number of decoys vs warheads, I /think/ the only real design limit is the throw-weight of the missile and volume of the fairing. This[0] has slightly more information on decoys. The 'it depends' remark is based on the fact that, AFAIK, the choice of decoy:bomb ratio depends on what the attacker thinks they need. Since the US ABM stuff is currently just for very limited strikes, I would guess they wouldn't waste too much space on that. But, they have an option to increase the ratio of decoys:bombs if the US ABM gets denser.

The SS-28 missile has a high throw-weight, in either case; it's replacing the SS-18, which had the record.[1] The wiki page on Russian warheads is mostly filled with 'Unknown model XX megaton warhead', so there's not much detailed info on mass for that side of the equation.

For the Avangard, the advantage that hypersonic vehicles give over a bog-standard ICBM warhread (which themselves travel at hypersonic speeds) is that they're manoeuvrable, so that they can approach a target from an unexpected trajectory . They don't have to fly on a simple arc, and they can change direction, for example, launch from North Korea, fly over the ocean, then attack South Korea from the west. A couple places I heard them discussed was on The Diplomat's podcast[2], and a CFR podcast[3].

One last thing, if you need more things to not think about: FOBS, which poses a similar threat as hypersonics.

Edit: one last last thing: One way to think about decoys/hypersonics/etc is that they are, in a backwards way, a good thing, since they /re establish/ mutually assured destruction. Without MAD, the whole situation becomes more unstable.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_aid [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-36_(missile)#R-36M_(SS-18) [2] https://thediplomat.com/2021/10/the-inter-korean-missile-rac... [3] https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/hyperventilating-over-... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_Orbital_Bombardment...

* I am not a nuclear weapons engineer or nuclear war planner


Thanks :)


Because I looked it up, you are correct: 50Mt total yield (across all the MIRVs), which is indeed the same as the Tsar, with benefit of carpeting an area rather than a single big ka-boom.

It was supposed to be test launched (hopefully not with real warheads!) in 2022. So it's unlikely it will matter if there's nuclear war this year.

I'm really not sure this gives Russia any advantage over the US though, or over what it's replacing. There's already enough nukes to obliterate both sides, no? Just launch more of the existing ones.


They forgot the most important one IMO: document the intended duration and schedule of your cron in a comment above. Most people can't decipher the cron syntax by heart or without making a mistake, and among those most people, there is probably you when you are tired.

Of course, there is always crontab guru (E.G: https://crontab.guru/#*/12_*_*_\*), but still, it's easier to find out with a comment next to it. Besides, it documents the intent, which may shows that there is a mismatch with the reality.


I'd love to learn more about this. Any good doc or tutorial ?


The Arch wiki is decent, provided you know how to work with systemd and making your own unit files https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Systemd/Timers


Technically, yes. But this is forgetting how much of this is related to social contracts.

It's not necessarly:

> I have a question about Java but I'm too lazy to actually formalize it in words unless there's someone on the channel who might be able to answer it

But it could be:

"I have a question about Java, but nobody knows me around here, so instead of flooding the chan with a wall of text, interrupting the flaw of all the discussions around, I'm doing to introduce my interruption progressively"


This can be done much more effectively than just “hey does anyone know Java?”

Something like “Hey I’m having trouble with X. Is anyone able to take a look?” is much better since you’re actually describing your ask.

Sure, I may know Java, but I may not know the answer to your problem.


I applaud your patience, as the thread was really clear about this from the beginning, and comments were missing the point one by one. This is a beautiful HN moment were people managed to have a debate about a very touchy topic, and everyone stayed very polite.


I have a website bringing a lot of money using ads. I don't attempt to detect adblockers, or deter users from using them, and use them myself.

ublock origin is wonderful. If one day, everybody is using it and I can't make money from ads anymore, I'd say it would be a sad day for my wallet, but a great day for humanity.


Wrong, no. It's a compromise. Addons have the ability to filter advertisements that cannot be identified by their domain name or ip. They also can take actions to compensate for website failure when ads are blocked.


> Instead of trusting me - think of the corporate incentive to do well here. Consider how much it would cost a company like Microsoft if employees were exposed to confidential customer data (our customers can work with medical data, so a fairly expensive legal nightmare)

The last 3 decades of big players misbehaving taught us they usually get a slap on the wrist for pretty much everything at worst, and a fine of half the money they made from the feature at best.

I'm not sold.


So true, maybe i am an old grumpy guy, but at least i learned something from the past.

Not sold too ;)


The problem is they are very hard to identify.


It depends of your criteria. E.G: old appliance are bulky, noisier and suck more juice. You could say modern ones are then better. But my mother still own stuff from decades ago, that are consistently sturdier, last longer, are easier to repair, and have a better UI.

I just bought a food slicer. The motor was connected to the saw using a very soft plastic gear. Its teeth became smooth after a month of use, rendering the machine useless, and no way to buy a new gear on the internet.

This is modern tech at work: you getter a cheaper machine, but to get there, the materials used suck. And there is no stock for replacement parts because it's expensive to keep them around.


They're probably deep in planned obsolescence since most people will use them about 3 times in 30 years.

The more common everyday things like kettles, vacuum cleaners, toasters, etc all seem to have very good options for not much money.

I've never driven a car, but my family seems to need less trips to the mechanics by far than when I was a kid. Computers definitely seem better in every way, and of course all small electronics like tape players have been phone-ified and seem to be much more reliable.

It may well be that slicers are niche enough that consumer versions are worse.

Still, nylon gears can be very durable(Unless any ozone gets on them, that seems to kill them).

A truly modern slicer with the same crappy materials would probably be using the MCU to predict the gear temperature based on motor current and limiting the duty cycle, and it would last a long time and perform acceptably well.

Either that or they'd have some direct drive scheme for then really nice ones, or maybe even some kind of no moving parts linear motor.

Modern power tools do this all the time. They shut down or reduce power for what seems to be no reason or a minor reason, but the computer probably detected some subtle overload condition I wouldn't have. It's a bit annoying, but it makes them cheap and durable enough to not think twice about buying used.

The stuff at Wal-Mart usually sucks, but there's almost always some affordable modern version that beats the older tech.

It does seem that 3rd party gears exist though, for some slicers.


I suppose there is also the problem that those same appliances were pricey at the time. Lots of cheap options today, but you get what you pay for.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: