In Python it's the opposite, as we good serious bootstrapping problems, and people complain for different reasons.
In C, people complain because tooling is too complex, in Haskell because 3rd party tools are unreliable, in PHP because it's riddle with security issues, in JS because it breaks compat regularly, etc.
In this era of quick outrage, thank you for doing the job of trying to figure out what is really going on, at the risk of taking the less socially acceptable side.
Interesing project, but I wish it would show me more about what doesn't work.
The bottom of the readme indicates the list of control flow instructions it supports, but it would be convenient to have in the table the ones it doesn't as well: yield, yield from, with, try/excep, match, lambda...
Does it support "else" in loops? Does it support unpacking?
Hard to know how much Python does this Python does.
> The bottom of the readme indicates the list of control flow instructions it supports, but it would be convenient to have in the table the ones it doesn't as well
Totally true. Some people would like to contribute to the project, and knowing what's lacking is a good way to make people know how to help.
Not to mention remote interviews, and with a result solely based on the company rating about perceived communication performances. This has pretty much the equivalent scientific value of a twitter poll.
I assume HN responses are based in experience, while this article shows only one thing: "companies rate communication in a certain way in remote technical interview".
The "Does communication matter in technical interviews?" is not even deserved. It's a terrible article, most likely an ad, with an artifical conclusions about a low quality biased data source composed of a one-sided, subjective star post interview star rating.
As for my experience, I've been hired to perform technical interview on behalf of companies, I hired people for my companies, and I've been interviewed many time.
And the answer is: it depends.
It depends of the person, of the job, of the context, and what you consider communication.
I have an ex that is incredibly incompetent and not very bright, but she is amazingly sexy and dresses well, and gets hired very easily. I have another one that is the best at her job, she is an angel for customers, but she is shy, doesn't explain things well, and is not as sexy. She tanks interviews regularly. Is that communication?
When I was young, I traded my contact lens for glasses and noted that, as a geek, people took me more seriously in interviews with glasses. Is that communication?
Last month, I interviewed a guy who said "I like to work at home, this allows me to be at ease when I want to code 12 hours straight". I knew he was boasting - people capable of focusing for 12 hours are very rare - and rejected him because I want to avoid BS. But he came from a trading firm, where this may be what you are supposed to say. Was it good communication?
"Communication" is not unidimensional. It's what you say, and don't say, when you say it, how and to whom. It's also what you convey by you body, your look, your voice. Being late is communicating something. Saying "I don't know" is communicating something. And the context in which you are saying it is as important as what you are saying. A good job here could be a social mistake there.
A few star rating is communicating to me that one knows nothing about the topic.
There is nothing scientific about the setup, it implies bias front and center, the conclusion is completly flawed and the title doesn't even state the result correctly:
Indeed, at best, this is not about how well a candidate does at interview depending on how good at communicating they are.
This is about how companies rate canditates on communication depending on if pass their interview or not.
You can't post a comment on HN without people obsessivelly asking proof about your opinion, numbers, studies, data...
I live in Nice, a city at the border of France and Italia.
My area is full of beautiful buildings that would never be built anymore:
- the fancy wall sculptures, round corners and marble stairs would be way too expensive to build today.
- they have a lot of volume: high ceiling, corridors, spacious stairways, that would be "optimized" today into the required minimum allowed by law.
- they are not too high, because they didn't have the mean to do that. So I see the sky, and the sun reaches my windows.
- they have "buffer areas". Entrances, places with green, fancy chiseled property doors, around the building. I don't come out and arrive right on the street. My bike rack, mailbox and trash disposal area are behind a light and elegant fence.
- there are a lot of windows, and large ones, so I have a lot of light.
- some rooms have old style wooden floor. It's pretty, and warm to the feet. It would be ruinous to add that today, you would get a premade cheap one at most if you had the budget.
- I have a spot in a tower. It's useless, nobody in their damn mind would build that anymore. I love it. And all my friends are always mentioning it when we talk about the flat. For some reason, it's very pleasing.
Mostly, they are charming to live in, those old buildings.
One could value that or not, but after living in a lot of different places, I find I often prefer older buildings even if they are less comfortable. They bring me more joy.
Unfortunatly, it's not just about the cost: we are loosing the skill we used to have to make those.
Not to mention we used to treat construction workers very badly so it made building a lot of things possible at the time that would be indecent today.
I live in the old Lyon district and I agree entirely, but it's hard to buy into the argument that "we can't build this anymore because it'd too expensive", as if the people at the time were all incredibly rich. As far as I know people back then were much poorer than we are today, especially in the cities.
Now I'm not saying I understand why it was done this way -- it's honestly quite puzzling how we seem to have abandoned these myriads of techniques that made everything we built so beautiful.
My theory is that it was more likely a culture thing -- back then, you wouldn't conceive of an entrance door without some wood sculpture or at least some elegantly carved stairs. That just wasn't something any architect or artisan/builder would do.
Also in these times of "climate crisis" it's striking how old urban planning makes the temperature much more balanced and the air flows much more nicely. There's a 3°C difference between the town center and my old district, because mine has very few concrete (old paved ways), no cars and has stone walls. My friend in the city center has 27°C in her kitchen. I'm still at 20°C.
In Lyon it's even more obvious. There are some restaurants with truely huge spaces that you rarely see anymore in France, like near the sucrerie, or the brasserie georges.
But I think it's definitly about money, not culture.
Today, we are more numerous, and there are more building to buid. Hence the projects are in competitions for the resources to build them, like stone or wood. Cement being cheap compared to stone, it wins.
For the same reason, space is now a premium, and so it's expensive to have big volume for new constructions.
What's more, a rich country mean rich people, and so richer workers. 80 years ago, you could abuse your workers so much, and pay them so little, it was much cheaper to build things that took a lot of time. Today, time makes or breaks a project rentability way quicker.
Add to that you have to make everything up to code now, which is even more expensive. And with insurances everywhere, on top of that, environmnent risk evaluations, etc.
And of course, a lot of building used to be constructed either by the state, or rich families. Now, you must borrow money to build, which mean you add the cost of the financial system.
100 to 200 years ago labour was so cheap to the upper class as to cost zero. A truly upper class family could have dozens of full-time servants. An upper-middle-class family could have 3 or 4. Even 50 years ago it was common for a middle-class household family in Lisbon to have a live-in maid for pennies. Try having even one full-time maid on an engineer's salary today. Or just supporting a family of 4 on a single salary, for the matter.
Old middle-class and above buildings were beautifully built because expert craftspeople and old-growth materials were practically free. They used them all up and we're left with more efficient (but uglier) ways of building. Which is a good thing, means we're not exploiting workers or cutting down forests and mountains quite at the same rate any more. But until we achieve another technological revolution in manufacturing and are able to spec custom parts at the same price as mass-produced ones, we won't be building things as prettily as a century ago.
In C, people complain because tooling is too complex, in Haskell because 3rd party tools are unreliable, in PHP because it's riddle with security issues, in JS because it breaks compat regularly, etc.
There is always something it seems.