Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

The article is very superficial about cost. It's not just about money, it's about freedom and democracy.

A cashless society, like everything with computer, information control or centralize power, is fine when you are riding the happy path.

As soon as you are not inline with society, or that slthe system itself become no more adapted to it's context, it's a nightmare.


This rigidity of computers is exactly why we must not let them control society.

Society is responsible for each and every member of it. Having 0.001% of population's lives ruined because of an error is not acceptable.

Humans may be slower and less efficient than machines (and require living wages), but humans are flexible and understand context. Replacing them with machines will only remove the useful human capabilities that we need so much in this society where most of the rules are still ad-hoc and implicit.

Imagine being assaulted by a robot policeman whose crime detection facility has malfunctioned, while you can't even complain to his robot colleague because it hasn't been programmed for malfunction of other robot policemen.


> Imagine being assaulted by a robot policeman whose crime detection facility has malfunctioned, while you can't even complain to his robot colleague because it hasn't been programmed for malfunction of other robot policemen.

To be fair, that's pretty much how it works with human cops


You can experience that every time you fill a form online. If it works, it's a joy. Saved time and energy. So much more efficient.

If something goes wrong however, there is no flexible human to fix it, give you an alternative solution, or perform a workaround. You are now in for a long and painful trip.


In short:liberty.

You can have cashless shit but don't take cash as an option for the rest of us. Another way of sayinf cashless is "tracked and logged payment transactions with regulated participation in commerce".

Straitght up, revelations level scary stuff.


On a recent trip to London, I was surprised on the number of places that DO NOT take cash (some bars, major chain coffee shops). Family members explained that this was due to COVID. However if the server doesn't wear a mask, then this is a moot point.

I just sighed and left.


Good on you. I need to start leaving yelp/google reviews for this stuff.


Indeed. This is why a digital currency is only viable if you have the ability to make anonymous third party transactions. Until then, I remain a hard no. But even bitcoin doesn't truly offer that.


Even then, is your participation in that system regulated? Do you need a smartphone with government issued id as a requirement? And internet usage and access? With cash you just need the person to hand you the currency paper. Will there be physical representarion of the anonymous digital currency that can be used by anyone that posseses them without authentication?


> when you are riding the happy path.

You've mistyped "when you submit to the correct groupthink."


It doesn't have to be that dramatic. Sure, abolishing cash is problematic from a civil rights perspective, but a simple thing like a payment major processor having a two-day outage would be disastrous in a cash-less society.

Many proponents of abolishing cash seem to think that one can avoid outages by simply requiring that payment processors aren't allowed to have outages. Unfortunately, outages tend to happen even when they're inconvenient. And that's just technical issues -- add the risk of cyber attacks, acts of war, or the Sun ejecting a load straight in the face of Mother Earth, and it's not a matter of _if_ there will be an outage. It's just a matter of when and how we deal with t.

Cash is a very good backup plan for such occasions.


Indeed. Or even just economic crashes. If you have cashless society, the average human cannot easily remove it from the banking system in case the gov pulls out a Greek plan.


I recently bought a roti on store credit when a major internet outage hit my city. The owner said he was out 1500-worth-of-sales for the day, recognized my friend as a regular, and wrote our names down in a book. We went back the next day to pay up.

It was like visiting a retro store in the 90s.


It's that of course. But also: when there is not an outage, when your situation has a well known good solution, and so on.


I'm going to implement a captcha that requires proof of life.

You need to send a severed finger by mail to pass it.


This is requiring a subscription, and it mac/windows only.

Sublime-merge supports also Linux, is a very nice git ui, and you pay once for the licence.

If you like Sublime text, it's the same type of experience, but for git.


Don't ban. Tax it and make the money go into carbon capture and green energy. Each time they flight, make them remove in Co2 the equivalent of a 100 times their consumption and produce a 100 time the energy consumed. Then make it very trendy to have your own jet, like the highest level of social status.


"Taxing" for change rarely works.

what happens is the "jet fuel tax" goes into general government revenue. Politicians seeking re-election use said money to create new programs instead and effectively "buy votes" with your own money.

Can you provide an example of this ever working? I can give you several of it being an absolute failure and having no impact.

In Canada we have "sin" taxes (Alcohol, cigarettes, gasoline).

- Smoking has declined, but more because of the negative marketing (ugly pictures on a pack of smokes). It is also less "socially acceptable" and so young people dont pick up the habit.

- Alcohol - Slight downtrend, but sales are still very strong https://www.statista.com/topics/2998/alcohol-consumption-in-...

- Gas https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=231000.... Covid caused a decline, but it will trend back up.


> - Smoking has declined, but more because of the negative marketing (ugly pictures on a pack of smokes). It is also less "socially acceptable" and so young people dont pick up the habit.

These things don't happen on their own.

Canaday's Tobacco Strategy, presumably funded with money that has to come from somewhere (e.g. sin taxes): https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/publications...


Are you saying that price has no effect on demand?


There's been talk about taxes on aircraft fuel, but here in the EU the proposals have involved an exception for private jets.

I think this is quite unreasonable, because ordinary jets are like carpooling. If anything, it's they who should have the exception.


One more reason to learn the command line.

Once you know how git cli works, any UI is easy to understand.

No vendor lock in.


A gui adds a lot on top of a git cli for me. Scrolling diffs/history and adding/removing staged lines alone is better. Using a gui doesn’t mean you didn’t arrive there deliberately.


I actually do almost everything in the CLI (checkouts, pull/push, branches, most no-conflict merges, most rebases, tags, etc), however when you're rebasing, messing with branches and merges, nothing beats a visual medium to just even look at the graph and make sense of it.


Amusingly, I get creative new ideas when I glue things together and ignore what I thought I understood about their relationships.


Happens to me too -- it's a great way to make new things. However, the "creation" I'd argue happens when you look at the pile of random stuff and generate a new understanding, and decide that it is valuable. The difference between trash and art only exists in the head of the artist. Same thing happens with DALL-E output, really.


Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune have a lot of it already.


Problem is, burning methane releases CO2, unlike hydrogen.


It’s exactly the CO2 that was captured when synthesising the methane from hydrogen.

So it’s CO2 neural


Assuming you are getting the CO2 from capture and the methane from synthesis.

Meaning you would have to make sure all companies from all the countries in the world won't try to make money by using a cheaper and easier to access source of methane once there is a huge market for it.

Unlikely.


That’s what carbon taxes are for.

I mean, of course you have to track where the methane came from but that’s pretty easy.

There are also ways ways to make hydrogen that emit lots of co2. So either way you have to track and tax.


The carbon taxes haven't worked so well until now. There is no reason to believe they will in the future.

And again, you need all the countries in the world to behave. The USA, China, India, Russia...


You have the same problem with clean hydrogen.

Carbon taxes work extremely well, btw, but i agree they have to be combined with an equivalent carbon import duty.


The USA are not the world. Even if suddenly they managed to taxe all the carbon in their economy, and all imports coming into their countries, you cannot force the world to follow.

China, Russia and India exchange massively between them, with Europe, Africa, and internally. Those product would be cheaper, since no carbon tax, so no incentive.

It's a hard problem to solve.

If we get a big hydrogen market, the problem never needs to be solved.


> If we get a big hydrogen market, the problem never needs to be solved.

And you force China, Russia and India into that big hydrogen market how exactly? I like hydrogen, but your argument is incoherent.


That's why you do carbon import taxes as well.

Plus, Europe has a carbon tax already, so there is already a chance to set up a transatlantic cooperation.


Banking on all politicians in the USA and Europe to vote and maintain forever a carbon import tax is a big bet.

And it won't affect exchanges of goods between Asia, Russia, South America and Africa, or internally in each country lika China or India. Internally use goods will not be taxed, and be cheap, so they will import less, use more internal good, and pollute more.


Well considering current hydrogen is produced from methane and release CO2, you need to solve that problem either way.


It's like saying don't build solar panels because we use petrol for them.

It's a chicken an egg problem.

We are using methane to produce h2 because synthesizing fuel (any fuel) is incredibly energetically inefficient. Otherwise we would be using electrolysis for h2.

Either you decide it's a problem, and you don't synthesize any fuel, or you will, and you'll oversize the energy grid and improve the synthesis process efficiency.

This thread assumes we decided we should synthesize fuel (I'm not sold, but I'm debating in that context).

If we do, then synthesis will never beat sourcing in efficiency for methane, since it's a direct process. But if there is a huge market for h2, there will be a incentive for over-sizing the grid and improving on electrolysis to the point that it can be competitive against sourcing methane + synthesize from that, which are 2 steps instead of one.

However, there is no way we can find a way to compete against sourcing methane (and no more step) alone. No good incentive to create.


Synthesizing h2 from methane is also done by electrolysis, it's just cheaper to electrolyze methane than water. This is fundamental - it takes less energy to release hydrogen from methane than from water, to such a degree that even though water is free it's still not economical. If you are concerned about people using fossil instead of synthetic methane to cut costs, you should be concerned about people using methane instead of water to cut costs. Either you can get people to comply with regulations or you can't.


> Synthesizing h2 from methane is also done by electrolysis

Most hydrogen is currently synthesized from steam reforming of methane [1], not electrolysis.

[1] https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-na...


Fair point. I guess I underestimate how cheap sourcing methane is if it as no change of offsetting the difference in electrolysis efficiency in the future.


methane is not cheap, ask the germans


Yeah no, "scientists", this wonderful general category that means nothing and everything, in general, are not turning to Rust.

Programming is a niche. Rust is a, albeit amazing and gaining traction at a fast pace, niche in this niche.

99% of mathematicians, physicists and biologists I have worked with have not even tried programming yet. And if they do, they will start with the stuff their friends are already using: python, fortran, etc.

Hell, 99% of the dev have not heard of rust yet. I go from companies to companies, every time I talk about rust, I have to explain what it is.

It's not even living in a bubble if you think that, it's living in an bubble from another dimension.

Having generalization from anecdotal evidence in nature.com is kinda ironic if you think about it.


Full agreement here. My past experience in the bioinformatics field taught me pretty much that "scientists" at large are just as afraid of the terminal as the average person. The science-folks more specialized on informatics typically are folks focusing on being able to use one language. Not use it well, mind you, just able to produce functional, untested code.

Given that, I highly doubt any of them are even aware of languages beyond python and java and maybe they're aware that C and C++ exists but are scary.


Must be scientists out of school in the past 15 years with the remark about C and C++ being scary, since engineering and science curriculums in the 80s taught Fortran, C, and C++. 'Numerical Recipes: The Art of Scientific Programming', and books like it, were books I turned to do science or engineering. But, I guess you're right, since I learned to program in 1978 on a Commodore PET 2001, computer science and web development have made pushed friendlier languages like Python, Ruby, JavaScript, and so C, C++, and now Rust (I prefer SPARK2014 or Zig), are considered 'scary' for scientists. BLAS (Fortran) and CBLAS (C) are under the hood of all the dressed up Python code up front (Numpy -> CBLAS).

Real Scientists use assembler, C, and Frink! ;)

Sad to say the engineering firm I worked at for 6 years was filled with 20-something and 30-something engineers with only one of 15 of them able to code. Excel use, sure. Coding, no. It wasn't that way 25 years ago.


Agree that "Scientist" means nothing. I assume that they're basically saying "people who used Python already to solve some sort of problem, but are not programmers".

Which is a very small part of the overall "scientist" world I think, who are probably not programming, or who may use matlab or python.


I would expect that new graduates in more or less any numerate subject do some programming these days.

I just looked, we (a major UK university) as well as having a Computer Science department to teach programming to obviously Computer Science and Electronics students as well as related disciplines such as Mathematics, other departments have their own staff teach programming for Physicists, Chemists, Psychologists, Geographers, and a bunch of social scientists who need Statistics. I just asked the API for courses about "programming" and then checked they didn't mean some other type of programming. So if say Law has a course named like "Coding in Javascript" for some reason I wouldn't have seen it.

The most obvious numerate discipline I thought of which doesn't teach programming was Medicine, and I guess they just couldn't find time to add yet another entire discipline's knowledge into the timetable.


It's not that bad.

First, of course, you have cloudflare and recaptcha, which are free and very efficient, as the author say.

But even if you don't want to use them (some of my services don't), most bots are very dumb:

- require JS, and you lose half of the web ones

- silly tricks like hidden input fields in forms that worked in 2000 still work in 2022. Use a bunch of them, and you can yet again halve the bot traffic.

- many URL should have impossible to guess paths. E.G: just changing the /admin/ url to a uuid in django or the /wp-admin/ in wordpress, you save so many requests.

- bots are usually not tailored to your site, meaning if you require JS, you can actually embed anti-bot measure in the client code and they will work. E.G: exponential backoff + some heavy calculations if too many fast consecutive ajax requests.

- fail2ban + a few iptables rules (mitigate syn flood, etc) will help

- varnish + redis gets you very far to shave excess dummy traffic

It's not great, but it's not an apocalypse.

Unless you are under targeted attack.

Then it sucks and you die.


One of the things I’ve done before among the other suggestions is to put a hidden link like /followmeifyouscraping.html in the landing page to get a bit of info about scraping volume and then you can use fail2ban filters to block if it’s visited if you want


I would add that link to robots.txt as an exclusion.

That way well-behaved search engines won’t be affected, but naive scrapers get auto-banned.


> First, of course, you have cloudflare and recaptcha, which are free and very efficient, as the author say.

Recaptcha has been almost useless, in my experience. If you read the spam logs, you'll quickly learn about the spam software they (claim to) use to bypass Recaptcha, because that's what they end up promoting. I started tagging in logs if Recaptcha had validated on messges, and sure enough these spam posts had all successfully passed it. Great opportunity to rip out more Google dependencies from my website.

I've found my own custom written filters to be vastly more effective than Recaptcha.

Lots of the bots are running full Chrome with JS, lots of HeadlessChrome being used lately. The fact that they're using HeadlessChrome is something that makes them easy to detect, ahem.


Those are very specific bots, recaptch will stop a lot of casual ones. Most of them in fact.


That really hasn't been my experience, perhaps I'm just getting hit more by the sophisticated bots than the naive ones. I'm glad that it works for some people.

Recaptcha was also filtering out some legit humans (I logged all posts regardless of captcha status to be reviewed later), so it just wasn't worth reducing the user experience when the captcha bot detection rate was so low.


No, then you hide behind CloudFlare, because only the CSPs and network operators have the infrastructure to deal with volumetric attacks.


Very nice list of countermeasures. I agree that doing these small things like hidden input fields really go a long way.

I would add to that:

- block signups/comments from known throwaway email domains

- block known datacenter IP ranges, at least for POST requests. Honestly on our sites 50% of spam was coming from AWS EC2 IPs

- use a proxy/vpn/bot detection service like https://focsec.com


Please don't make blocking VPNs plan A. Between snooping ISPs and public wifi networks that have indiscriminate content filters, I'm on a VPN about half the time. Many other legitimate users are as well.


Yup, in adtech, "IP is an AWS block" was a bot 99.999% of the time.

The 0.001% was that person using EC2 as a proxy or VPN server.


It's not only AWS. Also happens on Azure and GCP.


True, but at the time, 3 - 4 years ago, Azure and GCP IPs were minimal.

Guess the fraudsters were vendor locked lol.


> block signups/comments from known throwaway email domains

Throwaway email services have caught up to the point where even bigger players don't manage to block them, i.e. they rotate the domains used for the emails.


But then you end up forcing people to use Gmail.


Also, attackers are rarely going to try to guess your URLs - they’re going to find them via Google or Shodan, or, if you’re a good rest citizen, via “/<yourapp>/“


Any website gets probed for wp-admin.php etc, even if you don't use WP


In fact, if someone is probing for wp-admin, you should insta ban them, no matter the site.


I get quite a lot of guesses in my logs, probing in /solr/ and so on (fairly pointlessly, I might add, as I run bespoke software).


>Also, attackers are rarely going to try to guess your URLs -

because then the attack becomes DOS as they cycle through dictionaries of words?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: