Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Humans have been eating insects for a long time. In south africa they eat ants, china they eat scorpio, thailand they eat crickets...

The ants and the scorpio are quite tasty IMO.

On the other hand, I know of places where their casual vegetables are dangerous because their hold traces of animals feces with pathogens but you couldn't tell when buying them.

And finally, I remember eating the best eggs ever from my mother old neighbourg for years. One day friends from the city come, and eating them, get sick. So there is a strong habit component.

The study on insects is interesting but more informations is needed to draw conclusions.


> Humans have been eating insects for a long time. In south africa they eat ants, china they eat scorpio, thailand they eat crickets...

I'm in South Africa. I've never heard of the ants thing, but it is most definitely NOT NORMAL over here to eat those things; rich people may do it as a delicacy, like they would eat caviar, but it never was normal to eat insects over here.


https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33396313/

"Indigenous Knowledge about Consumption of Edible Insects in South Africa"

>Edible insects are a nutritious diet and play an important role in people's livelihoods in rural areas.

Just how many rich people are out there in SA's rural areas?


From that study:

> This might be the main reason why the consumption of insects is largely practiced in rural areas where high levels of unemployment and people with no formal education are found. In addition, people who are unemployed consume edible insects more because they have to do so to meet nutritional requirement needs.

Well, that actually explains why I have not seen or even heard of people eating insects in the 40-odd years that I've lived here: I'm not usually talking to unemployed people in rural areas who face famine without insects.

Unemployed rural people are still in the minority, and that still makes it 'not-normal'. The poor people and unemployed people I see in non-rural South Africa still don't eat insects.


Normal for who ? There are 11 official languages in SA, the population is very diverse, and indigenous people have different habits than city dwellers.


In Colombia, we (sometimes) eat ants. They taste like something in between pop corn, peanuts, and butter.

Google for 'Hormigas culonas'.

The only reason it's not more common, is the price, they are quite expensive.


These are trivial quantities that are unreasonable to reference.


That’s correct.

The startup Ynsect at the moment is targeting Fish Farming not human.

What would be the impact over many generations of that type of food ?

I’m scared of the “SuperBug” type of disease that would be resistant to antibiotics because it’s been dormant in us for too long...


Trivial quantities at the scale of the global population today, not at the scale of local indigenous people for millenia.

If we want to know if insect consumption can be adopted, just looking at industrialized insect farms production given to city folks is going to give us a partial understanding of what's possible.

We need to know things like:

- are those parasites massively more presents in farms than in nature (it's the case for fishes) ?

- what's the probability of the parasites to infects the average consummer ? (We eat parasites all the time)

- if this probaility is high, can a population adapt over time so that this probability goes down ?

Etc


That's the right question. And other food sources from similar farmers.


I think the brakes should be slammed until that is answered. Unless we want another pandemic. Given the rate of mutation and transmission in bugs with natural gestation and migration, the probability of catastrophic outcomes is exponential without a similar dataset in other human food sources.


> [...] the probability of catastrophic outcomes is exponential [...]

What does that even mean? Do you want to say that the probability is high?


exponential has come into popular usage to mean “really high”, i.e. not exponential. I frequently see it used to refer to single values that aren’t even in a time series, or in comparison to one single previous value (“exponentially higher”) when that is, of course, a mathematical impossibility.

It’s similar to how unconscious is now commonly used to mean subconscious (i.e. not unconscious) and literally is commonly used to mean not literally.

It troubles me that our specific words are getting watered down by pop usage, like sharp tools being blunted. This is different than my usual prescriptivist screeching.


> It troubles me that our specific words are getting watered down by pop usage

This is not a new phenomenon; I think we've been able to cope in the past by either clarifying precision by context or adopting new words with the precision we need until they get watered down as well.

> literally is commonly used to mean not literally

I realize at least one dictionary disagrees with me, but I think that's a mistaken analysis of the phenomena. Literally is quite frequently used as an intensifier even when the utterance is meant figuratively, but if it were left out the utterance would not be intended or interpreted as more literal.

I think what is happening is that "literally" is being used as hyperbole, much like any other bit of English can be. It doesn't mean "not literally" in the same way that when someone says "you left me waiting for days" we don't say "days sometimes means minutes" and fret about how anyone will ever measure time again; we rather say that people sometimes exaggerate. None of this, of course, should prevent you from objecting to this use of "literally" on stylistic grounds, or from objecting to individual confusing utterances of any sort.


Also the "literally" one is way older than people realize, being from at least the 19th century

https://www.dictionary.com/e/figuratively-literally/


Right, basically from the very beginning, which IMO supports my position that it's an ordinary use of the same meaning of the word rather than a change in the meaning of the word.


I suspect that is the case here. Though I had hoped that there would be some interesting mathematical model that Shaburn had in mind, because they mentioned something about rates:

> Given the rate of mutation and transmission in bugs with natural gestation and migration, the probability of catastrophic outcomes is exponential without a similar dataset in other human food sources.


> how unconscious is now commonly used

Freud and Jung used the term unconscious (das Unbewusste) - it is probably not a recent trend.


They used the German terms. Are you arguing about early translations?

Basically, just because the words are constructed the same, doesn't mean you can translate one direct part-by-part into the other.

For a similar example of the principle that logical structure doesn't translate naively one-for-one:

"Du darfst schlafen." <-> "You may sleep."

"Du musst schlafen." <-> "You must sleep."

"Du darfst nicht schlafen." <-> "You must not sleep."

"Du musst nicht schlafen." <-> "You may not sleep." [Though this last one is ambiguous in English.]


Dare is a model verb too in English


*semi-modal (I meant to type modal originally), but not originally a cognate with dürfen.


The new, certainly exponential variable, is the viral media growth in popularity of eating bugs. Viral(exponential) adoption of consuming bugs will increase the risk of (apparently already great) transmission of deadly diseases as an increasing rate.

This very conversation stands as of evidence of exponential adoption of disease transmission from bug consumption due to online media growth on the subject.


Sorry, could you point me to any exponential increase in the popularity of eating insects?

I don't really see how this conversation is proving anything of the sort. (If it did, could we please talk about eating a healthy balanced diet, too? I'd like to see an exponential increase in adoption of that, just from talking about it.)



The combination of factors makes the chances of a catestrophic outcome increasingly higher as the volume of inputs increases, thus, exhibiting exponential increase in risk until finality.


Also, exponential from the social adoption input alone. Popularization has reached meme status virality(exponential by default).


Probability is bound to be between 0 and 1. It's a bit hard to fit an exponential in there.


Still a period in which the increase in probability function could exhibit an exponential rate of growth though right?

At 1 we are all dead as well right?


In principle, yes.

In practice: in order for exponential growth (or any growth) to happen, things must have been smaller in the past.

Do you want to argue that the risks were so much in the past?

Eating insects is probably about as dangerous as it was ten years ago or twenty years ago. Not all that much has changed, or has it?

If more people are eating insects than before that might increase risks. Are you suggesting that the growth in number of people who are eating insects has been or will be exponential?

Or are you suggesting that risks are growing (exponentially!) from other factors?


So the counter argument you postulated(seemingly to undermine the validity of my argument with a tangential non-sequitur of math term application purism) fails on a principle basis upon further examination, yet we are persisting the thread with definitively unprovable practical application arguments that result from an (assumed) lack of objective related research and the reality that we are discussing forecasting probabilities using reason.

At this point I have to wonder, do you have any vested interest in the insect as food industry? I see you have accumulated many points over a decade and YC is running a few horses in this race.

And we are discussing public health and possible pandemic initiators predicated on nascent scientific research here, no? Dismissal through obfuscation and fallacious intellectual undermining leveraging local social clout?


Yes to both of your last 2 questions.

Mass production and consumption of insects is a recipe for disaster based on this research. The increased rate of mutation between insects and mammals is key driver for concern. Fruit flies are studied for genetic research due to observable rate of change and mutation is one of the key ingredients in catastrophic diseases.


The probability of Covid type pandemic become closer to 1 the more bugs farm they’re.

The lethality of of that type of outbreak become stronger the longer the we ignore that threat.

It’s just pure Maths to be honest.


I don't know whether what you are saying is true. But for the sake of argument, let's assume that it is.

Could you explain to me what is exponential about this process?


I love how the guy is getting punished for misusing a math term.


'Asien' didn't misuse any math terms. I don't know why they're being downvoted.

'Shaburn' made some claims that sounded like they want to be math, but didn't make any sense as math. Hence my confusion.

I recognise that people use terms colloquially, like 'exponential', but given all the (pseudo?) sophisticated, math-y language in the comment

> Given the rate of mutation and transmission in bugs with natural gestation and migration, the probability of catastrophic outcomes is exponential without a similar dataset in other human food sources.

I had hoped that Shaburn actually had a more concrete model in mind that they could explain.


1. Number of people eating bug(driven by mimesis pushed through a media narrative and thus typically viral(often exponential). 2. Number of variety of bugs being eaten(regionality and entrepreneurialism((often referred to as Cambrian explosions in perfectly competitive markets, thus exhibiting exponential growth functions)). 3. Number of geographies bugs for consumption being grown in. 4. Number of production methods and processes. 5. New combinations of genetics of peoples and insects/infectious organisms being consumed. Think Montezuma's revenge or lactose intolerance in certain regions of the world except possibly contagious and deadly Multiply all that by orders of magnitude faster gestation cycle and thus the chance for mutation, aside from technology developed to support existing food chain, Number of mutations per lifecycle, increasing the chances of deadly DNA combination by 12x, so order of magnitude.

Average lifespan of... A. Bacteria: 12 hours B. Insect: 12 months C. Mammal: 12 years (shortest being the primary disease harbinger, the rat).


Could you please point to any source for your claim that the number of people eating insects has grown dramatically?

I could find this study from 2015 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4552653/ which says:

> At least 2 billion people globally eat insects in over 113 entomophageous countries though this habit is regarded negatively or as revolting by others [4–6]. More than 1900 species are consumed by local populations globally but insect consumption (entomophagy) shows an unequal distribution.

There's roughly 8 billion people on the globe. Between 2 billion to 8 billion, there's not much room left for exponential growth.


Extremely probable as well as extremely dangerous outcome. Analogous to the risk of ruin in finance, not simply an undesirable out probability.

Should we not believe the research above to contain 1/3 insects tested carried pathogenic parasites? Does this not strike you as extreme. Potentially an order or orders of magnitude more dangerous?


Eating insects is about as dangerous as it was ten years ago or twenty years ago.

If more people are eating insects than before that might increase risks.

I don't really have any opinion on this, nor any horse in the race.

But, what does any of this have to do with exponentials?

> [...] the probability of catastrophic outcomes is exponential [...]

Exponential in what input variable?


The act in isolation. Yes. But When a society eating societies of bugs both increase you get exponential increases in probability of transmission of terminal diseases. This is literally High School biology in the US.


probably they mean

``` probability(catastrophic outcomes) == e ```

/s


If you eat any sort of processed agricultural produce (wheat, rice, juice, tomato paste etc), you're already eating lots of bugs that got processed along the way.


I was surprised to learn that it is not primarily raw eggs that make cookie dough potentially dangerous, but the flour. The raw wheat that sits in grain towers, that birds sit on top of and pests snack off of, doesn't go through a lot of processing before getting bagged or so I read.


Because we eat the latter, so we like them.

But fear the former.

At some point there were giant rodent in Australia. But they were probably tasty because they disappeared after we arrived.


It's just a come back of "Best Viewed With Internet Explorer"


It's far worse, back then stuff just rendered a bit weird and looked crappy but for the most part would still actually work (outside of corporate intranets jscript and other M$ only tech was not as widespread on the open web ). The difference is in the message "best viewed" vs "not compatible" vs "infinite captcha loop with americanisms" vs "not available in your country".

Now it's really common for stuff just to straight up not work or you are actively blocked and considered collateral in protection against spam and botnets, the latter is an entirely new phenomenon.


I remember when we used to say things like that about Google, circa 2000.


Google used to have that, probably lost it, and then they lost people like Brad Fitz.


Maybe Urs etc shouldn't have criticized Brad when he posted his well-intentioned "Do not buy Nest Protect smoke alarm".

https://twitter.com/bradfitz/status/566072337020112896?lang=...

The product was a terrible piece of crap that never should have been released.


I don't have an opinion on that product, but no smoke alarm is "hushable" due to state laws, as far as I know.


I'm not aware of any state law that prohibits a hushable smoke alarm.

Short-term (<15minute, repeatable) hush modes are considered a safety feature. They prevent angry homeowners from removing the smoke alarm entirely, a far more dangerous situation than a short term hush.

NFPA 72 recommends a desensitization method for ionization smoke alarms and requires one for smoke alarms installed near a cooking appliance, and several states have followed in codifying this into law. Hush is not required for photoelectric smoke alarms, under the theory that they are less prone to cooking and shower-related false-positives, but this feature is still allowed and they are a common user convenience.

UL 217 allows smoke alarms to be provided with a <15 minute desensitization feature which prevents an alarm from triggering unless obscuration/ft exceeds 4%.

Also... the Nest v2 got an in-app hush feature. My understanding is that V1 had some kind of false-positive issue that triggered a ">4% non-hushable" alarm, though, so this wouldn't have mattered.


So what happens when the alarm goes off? Hope it’s a fire and the device gets burned down?


And Avery (CEO), who was by far the best presenter (and thing-namer) I ever worked with at Google.


Earning large sums of money corrupts everything. Eventually people realise that being 'evil' is highly profitable.


I think it might be being a public company more than it is about earning large sums of money. The people who own public companies ultimately have control of the company, and typically care only about how much money is generated.


Yup, this what what I eventually grew to dislike the most about working for a public company. At the end of the day the stock price was the only thing that mattered. It would have been easier to stomach if the shareholders had a long-term vision of a healthy successful company whose value accumulates over time by making good long-term business decisions. But, quarterly returns were the name of the game. The executive compensation was tied to that performance and that cemented it into the basic strategy of all decisions.... (And this was for a large (20000+ employees), well established (40+ years old), corporation in a relatively stable sector (health care tech).


The problem with public companies is they effectively have no shareholders; none that can actually do anything to affect the company. Which leaves the company to be run by the managers for the managers.

Bogle (the father of the index fund) talks about how the index fund and friends has warped the benefits of ownership to leave companies effectively "unowned".


How is that any different from a typical private company?


A private company (and some public companies) have shareholders/owners that are large enough and active enough to control the company (Ford, famously).

Most just are kind of "managed", especially after a "star CEO" or similar moves on.


VCs and other private investors are usually more active.


Yeah, I guess I was thinking more bootstrapped/Koch-like/small business than private-with-investors


The alternatives to index funds are either that ordinary middle-class people can't participate in ownership of companies at all, or that they have to pay extortionate fees to fund managers. No thank you.


The choice isn't between index/active fund ownership - the question is how to make it so the company is not managed for the benefit of the managers, but actually for the benefit of the owners, however many or few there are.

Some companies in Europe have what might be part of the solution, with the union et al having board representation.


I've heard this before: "The product isn't the product. The stock is the product."

This can be true in VC-backed private companies too, but with public companies it seems to be even more amplified since the investors unlike angels/VCs often don't even know let alone care what the company really does.


Once the MBAs and accountants take over a company things like that can't happen anymore.


I gave Google the benefit of the doubt right up until they introduced their real name policy, haven’t had an active account since.


So after node, the ion, then the merge, then deno, now bun.

JS started to get a bit sane, but I guess we are going back to fragmenting and madness pretty soon.


Not really. Know your history first. Node split to io.js due to team disagreements and fragmentation. io.js made an immense amount of progress, adopted semver, and had all the momentum. At the time, Node was stagnant. The choice to merge was rational and good. Deno is a separate project, and while has a node compat mode, is meant to be a TS-first ecosystem with many different rules and methodologies. Bun is an experiment to see if it's possible to build node greenfield today. Only the brave will use it in prod, and only the wild mustangs of management will allow it.

Try not to give into FUD. The JS universe is fine.


1 GB+ files to create a react app seems pretty crazy to me. That's an order of magnitude more than Rails.


perfectly reasonable to choose not to use react for that reason. CRA is also known to be very bloated. See Vite et al.


So do more work for free to protect users because MS put them at risk for money.


Similar observation a few years ago in the sea sky: some ligh moving very high, with a strange flying pattern (like a very fast bee), for 20 minutes, above my head, then disapearing. No apparent light beam, support for light reflection, animal presence or mechanical vehicule. Clear weather conditions.

It was, to my eyes, an object that was flying and that I couldn't identify. So UFO applies.

The problem is not seing those.

The problem is making interpretations out of those.

Humans often prefer to create explanations than say they just don't know.

Centuries ago, somebody spot lightning and said it was Thor. We are mocking them now, but we are doing the same.


I saw similar lights in the sky off the eastern coast of Sri Lanka back in 2017. I assumed it was military aircraft since that area is a hotbed of military activity.

But then it abruptly turned almost 60 degrees at a sharp angle - like a cue ball bouncing off the walls of a billiards table.

I don’t know of anything that can move like that.


were you looking out into the sea? don’t know if you realize, but without good horizon references you lose sense of scale (relevant: supermoon is now) and you also can’t easily distinguish 3 dimensions. contrails going mostly horizontal can look quite vertical, for example.

so this abrupt impossible 60* turn might just be the projection of a normal maneuver


No, it was right overhead in the sky. Small enough that it appeared like a star


My observation seems very close to yours then.

Nice to know it might be a repeating occurrence.


I've also seen 3 lights fly in formation then the two on the wings make instant 90 turns and fly off into the horizon.


Search light hitting a cloud?


Make dsl is terrible, it's the yaml of build systems.

If you are a python dev, give doit a try.


Interesting that everyone who recommends an alternative to Make picks... something different. I doubt there will be two people recommending the same thing in the whole discussion.


Indeed, which supports the idea that make is so popular because it was first, and is still installed by default on most unixes.

Like JS is so popular because it's the main language on the web clients, and by default on most of them.

Also, because doit assumes you have a python project, and make is language agnostic, the latter will have a broader potential user base.

However, doit is not that far from make in the sense it doesn't assume each language workflow. It just gives you a declarative syntax to setup tasks and optionally your dag of dependencies and targets: you then do whatever you want with it. This gives it simplicity and flexibility and power, which are similar qualities that I think make nails.

I do think it would gain from being a stand alone executable so at least you were not expected to have python installed on your machine to run it.


What is so "terrible" about it? I think the rule syntax is as simple as it gets.


Required tabs, lines are each their own "script" instead of blocks (allowing variables), not allowing other executors (i.e. python, TCL, etc would be better than sh).


Actually you can tell GNU Make not to create a new shell for every command using .ONESHELL[0] and you can also select a different shell executable to run said commands[1]

[0]: https://www.gnu.org/software/make/manual/html_node/One-Shell...

[1]: https://www.gnu.org/software/make/manual/html_node/Choosing-...


Tclmake, a partial Make clone in pure Tcl:

https://github.com/TclLab/tclmake


Check (GNU Make) .RECIPEPREFIX, (GNU Make) .ONESHELL, (POSIX Make) SHELL=


Just got out of a python training session with one of my student running w11. Can confirm. So many problems.

Seems like one version out of 2 of windows being trouble stills stand.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: