We still have poverty, but not your granddad's poverty. It used to be, the poor suffered under-nourishment. Today, poverty can stem from obesity so severe as to be disabling.
My mom and i were just discussing my dog's visit to the veterinarian. She said that her father would never have taken a dog to the vet for those symptoms, but my dog got a blood analysis and a stomach X-ray. I spent a lot of money on all this, which paid the vet and their staff and the lab and the equipment manufacturers. Conclusion: increased wealth creates increased opportunity to work.
Medical is a special market due to emotional heartstrings. At a certain point, people will pay anything when death or health are involved.
At a political / social impact / behavioral hacking level, there's probably an argument to make near human grade medical services for domestic pets free, as it would likely assist with the reduction in human population growth (aside from companionship, etc.).
I am consistently amazed how cheap and fast medical services are in developing countries. The equipment costs so much less outside of western regulatory oversight, and to the consumer standard blood test batteries are often ~5-10 minutes and ~free.
> I am consistently amazed how cheap and fast medical services are in developing countries. The equipment costs so much less outside of western regulatory oversight, and to the consumer standard blood test batteries are often ~5-10 minutes and ~free.
This makes me wonder how much other countries indirectly benefit from the regulatory oversight that exists in the west. It's the regulatory oversight, compounded with capitalism, that produces medical equipment. Then the oversight over its usage probably adds to the cost of deploying the equipment.
Does the lack of, or reduced, latter oversight contribute in any major way to the pricing discrepancy for procedures for which that medical equipment is necessary?
We in the east are well aware that we benefit in some ways from the extremely risk averse regulators in the US and Europe and others. It's often explicitly acknowledged with labels like "treatment developed in the US" though it can also be hard to separate the real from the false claims of such.
On the other hand, not only does the east manufacture many of the pharmaceuticals sold in the west, it is a vast market which provides additional revenue with a convenient geographical separation which is difficult to arbitrage (Ibuprofen costs nothing in India compared to the US, but you don't see Indians flying to the US with suitcases of pills for sale).
> Medical is a special market due to emotional heartstrings. At a certain point, people will pay anything when death or health is involved.
This is a common misconception of what healthcare services are. People pay more for unsafer cars every day or decide to travel by plane that carries life&death risks for the pleasures of tourism. Life is a currency we pay with anything, from eating garbage to smoking and drinking and fundamentally, taking risks.
That being said, I don't like commuting by bike because of all the dorks going 50-60mph in a 35mph area. Not worth it. Also makes you think twice before slamming the accelerator when I myself drive. Something like every 10mph faster you go equates to like 50% higher risk of fatality- and when your knees and back are the crumple zones, no thank you!
Risks are an inherent part of life. I've dealt with a popped lung before- likely because of athletic activities- and I wouldn't not do those because I might get hurt. If you don't take risks, are you really alive?
Of course. Thats why the whole line of "a healthcare provider can get your entire life's savings and future earning because otherwise you die" is an idea that doesn't make any sense in theory or in practice.
I rarely come across such a terse, yet clear, argument why socialism requires force. But it is a false dichotomy, to conclude that the alternative is not to do anything.
Also I think maybe I didn't explain what I was trying to say clearly. My point is that all political positions, not just socialism, amount to trying to force the laws to reflect how you feel society should operate.
It seems like a losing argument, from whichever direction. Who would not be ashamed to confess, that they took only their own interests into consideration when voting?
This reveals that it is possible to combine the Persuasion and Zero Sum methods that the poster above described: "Once I have persuaded 51% of voters to my view, I no longer need to care about your view."
For as long as journals refuse to publish negative results, researchers will scrounge for some type of positive result, even if it's causally questionable, because to do otherwise is to see years of work go for nought. Until these incentives change, the rest of us are right to be skeptical.
Skepticism is about inquiry, not denialism. You're not practicing skepticism if you make a decision that something is false. The point is to defer decision (or threshold your decision probabilisticly) on the evidence as it becomes available.
Saying "no" to everything is no different than saying "yes" to everything from a logical perspective.
> Saying "no" to everything is no different than saying "yes" to everything from a logical perspective.
This is incorrect. The base rate of true findings when talking about causal models is extremely low. If you say "no" to every published finding, you will be right much more often than you're wrong.
Now, that doesn't mean you should say no to every published finding. But the idea that "yes" and "no" should be equally weighted in your priors across the board is an inaccurate representation of the state of research, and the underlying facts of the universe.
I agree with this, but we're not talking about equal weighting here. We are talking about absolute bias is towards no or yes without any inquiry.
The actual prior distribution of effective to ineffective models is extremely hard to infer from everyday life. We don't have access to unbiased data sources. That's why we should focus on inquiry rather than canned responses.
As an example of how this can be misleading common the average person sees only a tiny fraction of the proposed models that are much more likely to be valid because they've passed far enough along the process of publishing to have received some scrutiny and some credibility in the average case.
I think we probably actually agree. I am also opposed to any sort of inquiry-free canned response. I do think that, if you don't have time or desire to investigate, your baseline should still be that results like this are probably false. Even given the bit of investigation i've done into this study, and even though I think it's decently well done and reasonable, if I had to bet money on it, i'd bet that it's false.
However, I would say that if you don't have the time/desire to investigate, your comments in public forums probably aren't worth listening to. So, I do agree that people that simply respond with "correlation != causality" without reading the study probably shouldn't be doing that.
> As an example of how this can be misleading common the average person sees only a tiny fraction of the proposed models that are much more likely to be valid because they've passed far enough along the process of publishing to have received some scrutiny and some credibility in the average case.
Ya, that's definitely true. The base rate of true models in published research is almost tautologically higher than the base rate of true models amongst all possible models. I was going to say that it is tautological...but I suppose it's actually not. All published models could be false. But I certainly agree that the research process is a pretty good filter, and the base rate of true models is almost certainly higher. But i'd be very very surprised if it was higher than 50%, even if you use a fairly high standard for "published research".
Researcher here (in ML), our field is so full of noisy results due to this issue. Everyone talks about it, but you can't get around the fact that you no longer can get away with a low amount of publications.
The math equivalent of a negative result would be more like "I tried for months to prove this theorem, and it didn't work".
The difference is that in math "here is a proof" is all you need, while in sciences people are typically sharing what amounts to collections of observations. If you publish the collections that lead to interesting conclusions, but not the ones that are boring, people looking at what's been published are misled.
A negative result means simply they didn't find compelling evidence for their hypothesis. Nothing is proven or disproven (although it adds weight to the idea that the hypothesis is not true), so people think it is unexciting. For that and other reasons, the system incentives not publishing these, which is a pretty big problem.
But consider Hyman Minsky’s theory that in capitalist economies stability engenders instability. It could be true, that good times plant the seeds of bad times, similar to the way that forests that go many years without fires, build up tinder.
There are many ways to prepare for climate catastrophe, but here's one you could try:
1) Read Paul Ehrlich's book "The Population Bomb". If you don't have time, just watch the movie "Soylent Green" to get the gist of it.
2) Look around you for any sign of planet-wide famine.
3) ???
4) Profit!
It appears that we have already given up. Efficient, low-carbon-emitting natural gas power plants have been replacing coal-fired plants in the USA, largely due to cheap and abundant fuel extracted via fracking. If that were important, we would not be discussing bans on fracking.
They're only efficient and low-cabon if you compare them to coal, not if you use basic sanity that building any kind of new fossil infrastructure is madness.
Even the low carbon of fracking is questionable given methane leaks.
The only viable kind of gas is biogas which you have to sequester anyway. Other kinds speed up the catastrophe. There cleaner than some coal and oil but that's about it. They're not even close compared to nuclear or renewables.
Why do you need gas? Can't use the electric vehicle or appliance? If you need trace gases for manufacturing, you can sequester them instead.
No, you can create Methane out of thin air with electricity and store that in the existing infrastructure for strategic gas reserves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-to-gas
It's a very convenient way to store large amounts of energy for dark, windstill winters. If you then have a decent number of gas plants you can turn it into electricity to run the heat pumps in your homes.