Curious if you believe that because it's not working today it means we shouldn't talk about it as a path forward?

A decentralized identity system that works will be a very significant component to the dweb stack.

But people that have experience building decentralized protocols will tell you that it's a very hard problem to solve, for many reasons.

This is an engineering community, so I believe that it's important to focus on things that exist today. Not on speculative solutions.

I agree it's a hard problem to solve, and we've got no illusions about that.

This post (also, coincidentally by Vitalik) talks about different levels of collusion (from unsophisticated to sophisticated) https://vitalik.ca/general/2019/04/03/collusion.html

Gitcoin's approach thus far has been to stop collusion from unsophisticated actors, then progressively get more organized (as more money gets involved, and as we learn from each round) about stopping collusion from more sophisticated actors.

This thread talks about some collusion that we founnd in Round 5. https://twitter.com/owocki/status/1250097472694702080