Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | hanshan's commentslogin

One could indict every major world power for foreign election interference. Laws are meaningless if no one follows them.


If US embassy in Korea did anything similar to influence Korean election, and if it was found out, you can be assured that people will throw some major shit and there will be protests, both on the streets and in the national assembly, and heads will start rolling.

America understands this, and does not try to influence Korean election (or, if they still do, they are really careful not to get caught), because the risk of it backfiring is simply too much.

...And South Korea was basically America's puppet state during the majority of its existence.


>One could indict every major world power for foreign election interference

And yet the rest of the world still complains when America does it.

If it's a problem when America does it, it's a problem when Russia does it.

>Laws are meaningless if no one follows them.

Laws are also meaningless if no one enforces them.


>>Laws are meaningless if no one follows them.

>Laws are also meaningless if no one enforces them.

And still, Rule of Law requires that those who enforce the law, follow the law.


>And still, Rule of Law requires that those who enforce the law, follow the law.

Countries that believe the US interferes with their elections are free to try to do what the US is doing, and attempt to prosecute a case against whomever they can catch.

Otherwise... what conclusion are we meant to reach? That countries which engage in espionage or which interfere with other countries' elections shouldn't have espionage laws or should allow any interference in their own? There's no argument of equivocation one could make to excuse or exonerate Russia in this case that doesn't also do the same for the US.


I could be wrong, but "Hacking an election" is not by definition illegal per say. However, accessing a computer illegally or defrauding people with the intention to meddle in an election is indeed illegal.

If <insert country here> had an election and the US-CIA had hackers put malicious code in their voting machines, and that country had laws against tampering with voting machines, then I would fully expect that country to indict those involved. Obviously in a geopolitical environment, that usually means through sanctions or some other means.


>Laws are meaningless if no one follows them.

The truth to that statement has to do with power and influence. The average Joe isn't gonna get out of a speeding ticket by saying everyone speeds.


Right... That's something the USA does all over the world.


>The Internet allows foreign adversaries to attack America in new and unexpected ways,”

>“Together with our law enforcement partners, the Department of Justice is resolute in its commitment to locate, identify and seek to bring to justice anyone who interferes with American elections.

Sounds like Don Quixote is fighting the internet now. Unless you just shut it down how is it possible to not have world wide "interference" on the world wide web? Perhaps we need to think about how the instantaneous global communications network is obsolescing the concept of the nation state which was formed as a result of the printing press.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gutenberg_Galaxy

>Free and fair elections are hard-fought and contentious, and there will always be adversaries who work to exacerbate domestic differences and try to confuse, divide, and conquer us.

That sounds like a fitting description of mass media/news corporations everywhere.


Thanks for your genuine opinion, 4-day-old account in a heavily bombarded thread.


From the comment guidelines [1]:

> Please don't impute astroturfing or shillage. That degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about it, email us and we'll look at the data.

Also, your own account is all of 40 days old and you have a grand total of 8 comments, so you don't really have a leg to stand on here.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


[flagged]


We've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.


Wow, when a foreign government tries to influence our elections, you handwave it away, but when American journalists weigh in on politics, suddenly they're being "adversarial".

Think long and hard about what you're saying here. You're dismissing foreign interference, but critisizing domestic political involvement.

The key difference here is that Russia isn't the United States and has no say in our policies, while American journalists are citizens and voters who have a societal duty to participate the democracy. When the former gets involved in an election, we call it "foreign interference", when the latter gets involved we call it "democracy".

So which do you prefer? Foreign manipulation of public will, or democracy?


>So which do you prefer? Foreign manipulation of public will, or democracy?

That's a false dichotomy which implies you missed my point. There is no such thing as sovereign democracy in a globalized world with omnipresence and instantaneous communication.


Their best for you, or for advertisers?


>The study of money, above all other fields in economics, is one in which complexity is used to disguise truth or to evade truth, not to reveal it.

-John Kenneth Galbraith, Money: Whence it came, where it went (1975)


>we could watch the people that watch us.

If this were possible, there would be no authority


Careful, this might sound intuitive but be deathly wrong


Care to elaborate on your concerns? We're obviously speaking theoretically here at a high level of abstraction


My concern is that it might be possible to watch each other while keeping authority. You say it's not possible as if there was some kind of proof.


If everyone can watch everyone with equal transparency, that would seem to imply a distributed system with information symmetry, which is antithetical to centralized authority. If there was a central authority/super admin in such a system, how would you keep them from covertly creating information asymmetry?


That's a lot like saying FB and GOOG are charitable because they give their products away for "free". How much money/data are those product donations extracting from the people they donated to?


It's not like saying that. This is literally Google donating money to charity. That's the definition of being charitable.

Even so, many would agree that Facebook and Google are charitable for giving their products away for free even if they extract value from them in other ways.


>This is literally Google donating money to charity.

I specifically said "product" donations.

>Even so, many would agree that Facebook and Google are charitable for giving their products away for free

And they would be ignorant of the value of their information, attention spans, and technology in general. Many such people would also agree that "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to worry about"


>The negatives are less tangible: giving up your personal data (this is complicated by the fact that the data didn't exist until you used their services), targeted advertising, I'm not sure what else there is.

You forgot about the elephant in the room: the imminent danger of cyberwarfare.

The reason the Holocaust was so efficient at mass murder was because of "giving up your personal data".

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust

These tech companies have aggregated the most detailed demographical and psychological profiles in history on billions of people.

Let's not pretend they're impervious to hackers.

The "weapons of mass destruction" of the future will be algorithms loaded with the dual-use munitions we call "big data".


Holocaust only needed personal data because of the weird racism. You don't need personal data if you want to just invent "communist" or "counter-revolutionary" victims to persecute or to murder everyone with a different nose shape from the group in power.


So, a subject matter expert with a cellphone video?


Well sure. But expertise takes time and money.


Time is more important than money, and expertise does not depend on the funding of a newspaper or media company


Money gives you time. If you aren't being paid to do the journalism then you are getting paid to do something else, or you aren't getting paid at all, which sucks.


>Money gives you time.

Being alive gives you time.

>If you aren't being paid to do the journalism then you are getting paid to do something else

Yeah, you're getting paid to do whatever it is you're a subject matter expert in.

Reporting on it in important situations is simply a public service which people do all the time with blogs and such.

Implying people only want to do things if they're paid money is silly.


You may be greatly underappreciating how a large group of people, each contributing a small change, can manifest collective expertise far exceeding one or two hired experts. There is also far less bias in the final product.

Yes, it takes time and money. But it is not concentrated in a few individuals that are paid by someone. It is actually made up of thousands of small contributions, from people who know something.

CASE IN POINT

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hessian_matrix

I started this article back in 2005 I believe, while I was a math grad student in NYU. I went on to do other things besides math. The article is now much more expanded, each diagram improved several times, the Talk page discusses various things, all over the span of years with dozens of experts contributing.

I still like to come back and see that a tiny bit of the original language and page structure I put together has remained, but a lot of it is simply beyond what I knew at the time and certainly what I know now about it.


Where the problem arises is the degree to which one is affected by these emotions. Too much anxiety can lead to paranoia, schizophrenia and anti-social behavior, too little can lead to life threatening situations. Too much aggression can lead to irrational mass murder, too little can lead to slavery.


"The internet would not exist without advertising"


Utterly wrong. The Internet wouldn't exist without gigantic state funding. The early Internet was completely free of commercial influence.


In case you didn't realize, my comment and the parent's comment are satirical.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: