Like the difference between crossbows and longbows, they were superior in some ways and inferior in others.
Since they were composite, they were dependent on glue and cord holding them together; they were somewhat more susceptible to weather. They were also more expensive to produce. However, as recurves they had better power with less stacking (force required to hold them at a full draw), and they were also shorter so could be used from horseback, a huge advantage for a nomadic people on the steppes.
Your point is well taken, however, that the paper is really only comparing a very limited portion of Europe over a fairly limited amount of time. It's an interesting analysis, but I don't think it has enough data or broad enough application to make it definitive.
I think that the way this paper discusses on the longbow as being the superior weapon may obscure a key fact here. Man for man, a crossbow is a superior weapon; requires less skill to operate, has longer range, much easier to aim, better penetrating power. The main advantage of a longbow is how simple and cheap it is.
Speed of reloading is another advantage the longbow has, but I think this article overstates it. While some crossbows do require using a stirrup or crank to load them, there are others that you can reload against your hips, and shoot from there, to increase your speed considerably, at some cost to accuracy. I know people who have managed to get 6 bullseyes at 20 yards on a crossbow in 30 seconds. Meanwhile, archers would not be firing at the maximum possible rate in battle; ammunition is a limited resource, and with the draw weights of warbows fatigue would set in quickly. Overall, with the archers they had and bows they had at the time, it is likely that the longbows were able to be a little faster than the crossbows, but it's not a night and day thing; and the range, accuracy, and penetrating power on the crossbows were better.
The simplicity became an advantage in a few battles, which came after substantial rainstorms that caused problems with crossbows more complicated mechanisms. But the main advantage was how cheap and fast to produce they were; you could easily arm a large populace quite quickly. In order to take advantage of the longbow, you had to do that; you needed a very large number of archers to effectively take advantage of longbows, while you needed fewer archers to be effective with crossbows. But because it was cheap and simple, it was feasible to do that.
I think that cost and simplicity of the longbows were their biggest advantage; speed perhaps a secondary factor, but the sheer numbers were likely to be more important.
There is, of course, an interesting parallel here with some trends in modern military spending. The Joint Strike Fighter is a technological marvel; one of the most advanced pieces of military equipment ever. However, they are staggeringly expensive, and not actually the best dogfighters in the sky. You wonder how much more effective spending that money on more and simpler weaponry might have been.
Actually, some papers written about crossbows seriously doubt that the penetrating power was that much better -- if at all. The poundage certainly was, but it had to be -- crossbow arms are short and the arrow doesn't travel as long, thus less time is available to transfer energy.
And "large populace" makes it sound like they just handed out crossbows to peasant levies, instead of them being very highly paid mercenaries.
I mean, I can hand a bill or halberd to a peasant, too, but that didn't stop the Swiss from getting hired by most of Europe...
Hmm. I'd be interested in seeing your source for that. Yes, the power imparted to the arrow is the integral of the poundage supplied by the bow or prod, over the distance that it is propelling the arrow, and that distance is shorter on a crossbow than a longbow. But you can have a much higher poundage and still be usable with a crossbow; you have two arms to draw together, and are supporting none of the draw weight while aiming. I've seen the analysis of draw weights of longbows on the Mary Rose; do you know where there are sources for that of crossbows?
And yeah, sorry, I didn't mean to make it sound like they were just handing out longbows. Longbows do require significantly more training. In part, the tradeoff for longbows is that you have cheaper weapons but need to put more into training the archers.
Payne-Gallwey's "The Book of the Crossbow" is at least in the same category as the paper's cited "Great Warbow". At one point he tests a 15th century siege crossbow with a draw weight of 1200 lbs, which is probably close to the upper limit (and requires a heavy cranequin). IIRC the Mary Rose longbows were about 150 lbs.
But that's a steel bow, which is stiffer than wood, and the draw length is pretty small.
W.F. Paterson published a test that compared a 70 lbs bow with a 740 lbs crossbow, and the initial velocity was about the same.
Now how that equates to actual damage is another issue, and I haven't seen a really good test about that. One major factor that one has to consider is that damage varies with range, too. So what might look comparable at close range might be completely different at far range. (I think the Genoese were out-ranged by the English at Crecy.)
In fact http://www.bowyers.com/bowyery_longbowOrigins.php says the contrary to what you are claiming, and in their account of the Cercy battle they clearly mention how the longbow outranged, and out-powered the crossbow (look for paragraph "Crecy 1346: the Longbow's Finest Day").
Excerpt 1: "The crossbowmen had a lethal range of up to about 80 yards, and took up an initial position 100 yards from the English, in line across the field. Unfortunately for them they quickly found out that the longbow now had a lethal range of well over 100 yards. "
Excerpt 2: "They were shocked to find that the longbows could now penetrate French armour, and could also down the horses."
The French army moved forward late in the afternoon, around
4pm after it had formed up. As it advanced, a sudden
rainstorm broke over the field of battle. The English
archers de-strung their bows to avoid the strings becoming
damaged; the Genoese with their crossbows could take no
such precautions, resulting in damage to their weapons.[26]
The crossbowmen began their advance, however they had left
their pavises back in the baggage train, and thus had no
means of protection as they loaded their weapons.[27][28]
The Genoese moved within range and discharged their
weapons. Damaged by the rain, the slackened crossbows had
little effect on the English line. The English archers shot
their bows in retaliation, inflicting heavy casualties on
the Genoese, causing them to retreat. The knights and
nobles following in Alençon's division, seeing the routed
mercenaries, hacked them down as they retreated. Froissart
writes of the event:
The English, who were drawn up in three divisions and
seated on the ground, on seeing their enemies advance,
arose boldly and fell into their ranks... You must know
that these kings, earls, barons, and lords of France did
not advance in any regular order... There were about
fifteen thousand Genoese crossbowmen; but they were quite
fatigued, having marched on foot that day six leagues,
completely armed, and with their wet crossbows. They told
the constable that they were not in a fit condition to do
any great things that day in battle. The Count of
Alençon, hearing this, was reported to say, "This is what
one gets by employing such scoundrels, who fail when
there is any need for them."[29]
So, it doesn't sound like the crossbows were in pristine condition. Rather, their range was limited by the fact that their strings had gotten wet, while the relatively simpler (and easier to string) longbows were able to be protected from the rainstorm.
First, this research paper is about a game theory analysis about a political situation that may have made the French and Scots leery of being vulnerable to usurpation by arming a large population. The material on pages 691-693 is all background material, not the actual research material of this paper.
I did read 691-693. I am not contradicting any of the information in it; merely saying that I think they are overstating the direct superiority of the longbow. Strategically and tactically, it's clear that arming a large number of archers and using them in the early battle is superior, and the cost and simplicity of the longbow makes that much easier; but it's not because a single longbow is better than a single crossbow. I think that the longbow was a superior weapon, in the sense that the armies that adopted the longbow strategy clearly beat those that relied on crossbows, but I think that the way that the paper couches its introduction makes it sound like, side by side, a longbow was a superior weapon to a crossbow.
I'm not talking about modern crossbows, I'm talking about reproduction medieval crossbows. I do medieval recreation as a hobby, I shoot longbow, I know people who shoot crossbow. The longbow is faster, though as I mention, I know people who can reload and shoot from the hip and get 6 accurate shots off in 30 seconds. And the crossbow is more accurate, gets better range, delivers more power, and is easier to shoot.
Now, I don't shoot a 160 pound warbow, I don't have the strength for it. If I did, I would get some more power and range out of it, at the expense of accuracy and speed, as I would fatigue much more quickly. With a crossbow, you can use both arms and brace against your hip to draw, so even without any stirrup or crank, you can shoot a much heavier crossbow than you could a longbow. That extra power means more penetrating power and a flatter quicker flight (or more range if you increase your angle), and the fact that your muscles are not straining to hold the bow drawn means you can aim more accurately.
It also doesn't make that much sense to begin with. Part of the cost of using the longbow is the years of training and feeding the longbowman, and the cost of that training could easily buy multiple crossbows. If it weren't much more effective than a crossbow on a per-soldier basis, they would not have seen much use.
I've seen a few articles on it recently, and know of at least one couple in my social network that does separate beds.
It seems like my grandparents' generation slept in separate beds a lot, my parents' generation swung to the single bed model, and in my generation single bed is still more common but awareness of sleep issues is leading to some people starting to try out separate beds again.
Please don't do things to make titles stand out, like
using uppercase or exclamation points
and:
Otherwise please use the original title, unless it is
misleading or linkbait.
I think the idea behind this change in title is because the original is perceived as being linkbait; it has an explanation point, is very opinionated. The kind of thing that really tempts you to click through, or come and post a scathing rebuttal, because of how strongly worded it is.
Not saying I necessarily agree with the new title, but it is milder, and I think that in general moving away from clickbait titles is a good thing. There's enough clickbait junk going around the rest of the internet, having at least some standards at HN is fine.
But the new title doesn't have the same meaning. The original title means "Don't Make Users Configure Your Application", not "Don't Configure Applications". The latter is a much more unusual statement, to the extent it made me click. I would not have clicked on the original title, nor any accurate restatement. So what's "clickbait"?
I love how he says that it's not throttling, while comparing it to economy mode on a car. Which is, well, literal throttling to give you less performance but better economy.
I would not mind them offering the feature if they were honest up front about what it is. It is throttling; it is reducing the bandwidth available for particular downloads, in order to use less or none of your data plan. Now, there are still some net neutrality problems with the fact that certain service providers use none of your data allowance while others do still count against it.
But anyhow, why try to sell this as not throttling when that's exactly what it is; throttling, but you get some benefit in that you don't have to pay as much for those throttled streams?
Elected officials represent the will of the people in a democratic government. Their policies are the legitimate policies of the government. The security and defense wings of the government are strictly subservient to the policies of elected officials, or it's no longer a democratic government.
Huh? That the police investigate criminal wrong-doing by elected officials is obviously consistent with the police force being under control of ("strictly subservient to") the elected officials. Why would national security be any different?
While I agree with the principle, and have severe objections to the security services being allowed to engage in that kind of surveillance because of the significant threats it poses - I would rather take the risk of extra terror as I see it as far smaller -, this does still not preclude elected officials from being terrorists or having close contact with terrorists.
Nothing says that terrorists, or their supporters, never represents the will of at least a sufficient part of the people to gain representation.
In fact, we have many prominent examples where terrorists or people with close associations with terrorist groups have been elected to public office. Some you might sympathise with, others not so much: IRA's ties to Sinn Fein, which has seats in the UK parliament, for example. Or the ANC, whose armed wing used to carry out bombings targeting civilians. Or Hamas. Or most prime ministers of Israel (most of whom were parts of terror organizations like Irgun or Haganah in their youth).
In the US, a republic, our system of checks and balances can and does cause situations where security personnel who are subservient to some elected officials can and does conflict with and enforce rules against the policies and/or actions of other elected officials.
>What prevents a member of the domestic government from being a terrorist, or having ties to terrorists?
That's a good question. I would say that nothing does. But that's the wrong question.
Imagine that the NSA found a conversation between a member of Congress and a foreign intelligence agent. However, because that Congressperson supports the NSA, they leave it alone. On the other hand, they see another member of Congress talking to the same intelligence agent. This Congressperson already hates the NSA, so the NSA won't lose any supporters by checking them out.
Then, because of the information revealed about the second Congressperson, they lose their next election, and the next Congressperson is perhaps more friendly to the NSA. The NSA looking at Congress can distort decisions made about the NSA.
I feel nervous about the NSA spying on Congress for exactly the same reason I would feel nervous if the NSA were spying on the FISA court judges. It's a separation of powers issue.
I would guess that more terrorists have been created, funded and supported by the US government than by any other group of Americans by a long shot. Dealing with terrorists aren't even particularly historic, with the early days of the civil war against Assad being supported and look what that turned into.
Indeed, many in the house claim affiliation to a party that has a stated mission of being anti-government and backing people who say radical things. That we don't categorize "preppers", christian fundamentalists and separatists as terrorists is a matter of national convention.
SSN and credit card numbers should not be considered secret. Anything that must be shared with a third party in order to make some kind of transaction cannot be considered secret; compromises happen, and once compromised, there is no way to make them secret again.
Brian Krebs, as a high-profile author on security who actively antagonizes black-market groups on the internet, is a common target. He has had all of his basic personal information posted on the internet publicly for some time. The credit cards that were used for this attack were all old, disabled ones, since he disabled them after the numbers were leaked; but apparently PayPal still has them listed on the account and so you can use knowledge of them to "prove" your identity to PayPal.
> actively antagonizes black-market groups on the internet
Sounds to me like they're both at fault then. It's really nice and idealistic to have this mentality that you're doing it in the name of infosec, but it's a position held from an ivory tower.
If he's in software, what did he expect? This isn't a wise approach. This is the advanced stupid I'm talking about. Someone who thinks it's wise to antagonize, but then cries and writes an article over it when they're attacked. It's a joke. Conventional wisdom here is nonexistent.
Lets reduce this first to understand it. First, why would you antagonize black-market groups on the Internet? Why would you actively make yourself a possible target? Does that seem wise?
To me, that's a far less complicated question than anything security related at a technical level. You can literally ask a child this question and they'll tell you it's not smart.
Brian Krebs is a security researcher partially responsible for uncovering some of the biggest credit card leaks in recent history. It's his job to "antagonize" the credit card black markets.
He's not just some internet troll, he's doing real good that you very well may have personally benefited from as a result.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stochastic_neural_analog_reinf...