Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

There's a fundamental difference. Radio broadcasts are generally considered public performances, and generally handled under blanket licenses with ASCAP, BMI, and the like. There is also a separate blanket licensing scheme for digital streaming radio, SoundExchange. There is no blanket licensing for digital downloads; thus, to provide digital downloads that contain music, PRI would have to negotiate separate contracts with each of the copyright holders.


They didn't ask people for their evaluations before the test; they asked after the test, and after it had been scored, to see where people thought their score ranked relative to the rest of the people who had taken the test.

So, people already knew how many things they had gotten right and wrong when making their judgement. They just judged that most other people had also gotten a similar number wrong.


They can't possibly know the makeup of other test takers. I could be 95th percentile of the total population but still 10th percentile in a test room.


Congrats you've discovered the other half of the Dunning Krueger effect. The smartest people in the test will assume others might know more than them, because they know enough to know they aren't experts.


So?


According to Mozilla's most recently released financial reports (https://static.mozilla.com/moco/en-US/pdf/Mozilla_Audited_Fi...), they spent $197 million on software development in 2013, and $213 million in 2014. $385,000 is a tiny fraction of that.

Developing high-quality software, which runs on as many devices and is compatible with as much content as Firefox is is a hell of a lot of work. And Mozilla isn't just working on Firefox; there's Thunderbird, though that's in the process of being spun off, Firefox OS (also in the process of pivoting), Mozilla Research (Rust, Servo, Emscripten, asm.js, and more). There are continuous integration systems to test all of this against dozens of combinations of platforms and versions, and huge numbers of tests on each (https://treeherder.mozilla.org/, http://buildbot.rust-lang.org/waterfall, http://build.servo.org/console), all of which needs to be maintained and triaged. There's standards work, to negotiate new standards in standards bodies with users, other browser vendors, and the like. There's advocacy work, of times when you find bugs that are simply due to broken websites that happen to be relying on other browser's bugs, to reach out to developers and try to get them to change in a more compatible or standards compliant manner.

$385,000 is, what, the yearly salary, benefits, and overhead of maybe two full time engineers in SFO? Complaining about $385,000 given to deserving projects, given the amount of investment and energy Mozilla is actually putting into Firefox and other substantial, valuable projects, is a bit of a stretch.


Yeah, I've worked next to a lunch place that describes itself as "plant inspired" rather than "vegan." It turns out that everything they serve is vegan, and they'll confirm it if you ask, but by taking the word "vegan" out of anything public-facing, it's a lot easier to get people to be interested in eating there.

I personally eat a low-meat diet (no more than 3 servings of meat a week), but don't generally feel the need to eat any kind of meat-substitutes; there are plenty of delicious, already vegetarian or already vegan foods. It does help eating only vegetarian and not fully vegan; cheese and eggs are good sources of both flavor and protein, and make a good "center" of a dish or "main course" of a meal that is sometimes hard to do with purely vegan food without substitutes, but I've also had plenty of delicious fully vegan meals without meat substitutes.

And even when getting closer to meat base dishes, I'm personally more likely to order a "black bean burger" or "chickpea burger" than a generic "veggie burger"; it helps to know what I'm getting, while a lot of the meat substitutes are complicated and processed. And for those processed items that do more often act as a stand in for meat, I generally prefer the more minimally processed ones like seitan, tempeh, or tofu, rather than a "tofu burger" that has a whole bunch of other things in it to make it more similar to a hamburger.


I am similar. I eat a 60-70% plant-based diet, but am also a fan of burgers and the occasional steak. I am really not that interested in an artificially created burger or steak. It is just not appetizing. If I am having something vegetarian, I prefer any of the excellent options you can prepare in your kitchen.


Yes, but there are many reasons to be vegetarian. I can easily imagine a lot of people that would like to skip meat for ethical reasons (including me, to a certain extent), but do not want to give up the flavor palette that meat offers.


No, it's not recommended for coding; it's a display font, to be used for headlines, titles, and the like, things where you want a little bit of stylistic flair. Here's the description from the link:

  About

  Space Mono is an original fixed-width type family designed by Colophon 
  Foundry for Google Design. It supports a Latin Extended glyph set, 
  enabling typesetting for English and other Western European languages.

  Developed for editorial use in headline and display typography, the 
  letterforms infuse a geometric foundation and grotesque details with 
  qualities often found in headline typefaces of the 1960s (See: 
  Microgramma[1], Eurostile[2]), many of which have since been co-opted by 
  science fiction films, television, and literature.

  Typographic features include old-style figures, superscript and subscript 
  numerals, fractions, center-height and cap-height currency symbols, 
  directional arrows, and multiple stylistic alternates.

  [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microgramma_(typeface)
  [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurostile


it's not recommended for coding

You're not kidding! Code displayed in this font looks downright bizarre[0]!

[0] https://i.imgur.com/6HHFhCw.png


I think that looks lovely...



I'm a user with 150k rep on SO. I'm not a casual user.

However, I have been discouraged from using the site in recent years due to too many disagreements over closing and downvoting questions when actually just getting a little bit more clarification from the person asking the question would have helped a lot more.

I've answered over 1,000 questions, ranging from very simple beginner level to some things that took a good deal of research or debugging to answer. I've seen my fair share of poor questions. If a question is completely off topic, then sure, I click the "close" button immediately.

However, if it's on topic, and about some identifiable issue, but not specific enough, too poorly worded, or doesn't include a code sample, or the like, then I post a comment requesting clarification, and listing how they can improve their question. In some cases, they actually work with me, improve the question, and then I or someone else can answer it. In some cases, they just ignore my comments or continue with requests to just give them the code or the like, in which at that point I find it worth a downvote or close vote.

But a lot of the times, I've seen perfectly good questions that were just a little confusingly worded, however I was able to tease out what they were getting at, I've done some research to find the answer, and come back, only to find the questions closed. Now I have an answer for the question, but can't actually post it. If I vote to reopen, sometimes even after editing it to clarify or getting the OP to edit it, it will generally languish with one or two reopen votes. Sometimes I'll then post on meta to complain about this behavior; people being way to quick to close. This will frequently lead to enough people clicking through to reopen it, but also a torrent of complaints about how the question really is bad and how we shouldn't let this kind of stuff on the site because it's destroying the community.

The thing is, bad questions don't destroy the community. If they're bad questions, they'll generally fall off the front page and get forgotten about. They don't really cause much in the way of problems; they're just a few extra bits. But this hostile behavior does destroy the community. It pushes beginners away, who may ask better questions later once they get a bit more of a handle on what they're doing. And it pushed people like me away; people who are there to help, and willing to do so even for beginners.

I think that Stack Overflow is a very different thing than MathOverflow. Professional programmers sometimes run into thing that they need to do that they are complete beginners at; you may have years of experience writing Java, but then you wind up needing to integrate with and write a plugin for something written in Ruby, and you really have very little experience with it and so don't know where to look. Due to the huge numbers of different languages, APIs, platforms, and so on, rapid pace of change, and shortage of qualified people with the exact relevant experience, almost everyone is a beginner at something they are doing at some point in their career.

Furthermore, some people just don't know how to ask good questions online. It's a skill that takes some time to learn. If you're asking a question to someone in person, they may already have more context about what you're doing, or will be able to more easily ask you questions to clarify and sit down with you to work through it, while asking good questions online can involve a certain amount of preparation in advance to narrow the issue down to a self contained, reproducible test case, to phrase the question appropriately, and so on.

So while I agree that complete junk should be closed and delete, and people who just post "plz gimmeh teh codez" should be discouraged, I am really frustrated by the way people extend that to things that are just beginner questions, poorly worded questions from people who aren't good at asking questions online or aren't good at English, or the like.


Also note the White Keyboard Layout, which was released recently as a reaction to the Workman layout due to some concerns about the optimizaiton parameters.

https://github.com/mw8/white_keyboard_layout

He defined a somewhat different set of scoring, then ran a simulated annealing algorithm to find a layout that optimized that score, then did a few manual tweaks for consistency and learnability. The code for the optimization is available, so you can define your own scoring and run it yourself.


Even if you're not interested in switching keyboard layout, the writeup alone is well worth a read. THanks.


Yeah, I just use plain old QWERTY, but I love reading these things to see how other people approach their own pain points.


As it says, at this point it's getting pretty subjective, and so you'll need a blinded subjective test to really judge which one is better:

  The improvement in quality compared to the previous 
  status update is quite obvious. Daala is now much better 
  than both WebP and JPEG (libjpeg-turbo is the most 
  commonly used JPEG encoder). As for Daala vs BPG/HEVC, 
  the artifacts are obviously different and hard to judge 
  from just four images. Opinions are likely to vary based 
  on the viewer and the input image. At this point, what 
  we'd really need is a full subjective test. Fortunately, 
  this is exactly what is going to take place shortly, as 
  Daala has been submitted as a candidate for the Image 
  Compression Grand Challenge at ICIP 2016. The results 
  should be available in September. In the mean time, you 
  can read the paper we will be presenting.
What I generally do is toggle between three images, the original, Daala, and HEVC, and focus on a different area each time. There is always some obvious distortion from the original, so I try to determine for each area I'm focusing on, which one is closer to the original perceptually. It is a subjective process, but if you make this evaluation for each area of the image, count up your judgements over the whole image, do that over multiple images, and have multiple people all do that and combine their results, you can come up with a reasonable evaluation of the quality.


One good example is the hair on the forehead of the "woman" image. IMO, Daala does better than BPG here, but obviously overall there's no clear overall winner (but JPEG is a clear looser :)

Very excited to see another Daala update. I look forward to a competivite alternative to HEVC.


But PIR, which runs the .ORG registry, does operate in the US, and thus US law applies to them.


Which is an odd scenario, isn't it? A US private firm (the RIAA) applying pressure to a US technical registry for US interests when The Pirate Bay doesn't infringe per the letter of the law, nor resides within the United States.


>The Pirate Bay doesn't infringe per the letter of the law

This is your opinion. So far I haven't seen any US precedent for this, and it's by no means obvious that it's not infringing.


Hey did you know that you can go to pirate bay website and find links to content that may not be legal?

^ Am I obviously infringing as well?


I never said they're obviously infringing. I said they're not obviously non-infringing.

Your comment I would classify as obviously non infringing. Two obvious differences (not the only two): you haven't linked to anything, and you aren't being paid any money for your comment.

Did you know TPB founders have gone to prison for copyright infringement? I think the judge did not feel their actions were "obviously not infringing".


> Your comment I would classify as obviously non infringing. Two obvious differences (not the only two): you haven't linked to anything, and you aren't being paid any money for your comment.

If that's not linking, then the pirate bay doesn't link either. They supply a description and a SHA1. You have to locate the content yourself. You have to locate the people that have the content yourself.

What if TPB didn't have ads?


>What if TPB didn't have ads?

Then it's more complicated, and depends on other distinctions I alluded to above.


Which is a horrible precedent. If any piece of your infrastructure exists in the USA, even another service serving you, you're guilty of whatever they want.

The internet is global. If N. Korea shouldn't be able to extradite you for promoting democracy, the USA shouldn't have any legal power to influence DNS.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: