Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

They didn't say EE (electrical engineering). They said electricity and magnetism (E&M).

The AP physics curriculum has AP Physics B, AP Physics C (Mechanics), and AP Physics C (Electricity and Magnetism). At my high school (a fairly well-off public high school), in the AP Physics class, we were supposed to do both Mechanics and E&M, but we fell behind and had only just started E&M by the time the test rolled around. Some people just took the mechanics test; I took both, and got a 5, but the college I went to didn't accept AP Physics for credit, just for placement in the honors physics track. In college, E&M was the second-semester physics class in the honors track.

So, I don't think it's too unusual to expect a talented high school student or first or second year college student to have taken an E&M course.


>They didn't say EE (electrical engineering). They said electricity and magnetism (E&M).

A lot of people are picking up on that. I didn't type the whole name out partially because I didn't know a better, standardized abbreviation for it, and partly because I was typing on my phone at the time and didn't want to spell it all out. I hoped everyone would know what I meant, but apparently not. My blue ribbon high school didn't have E&M physics classes.


There is a difference between subreddit admins banning you from a particular subreddit, and Reddit admins banning entire subreddits. Each subreddit is administered by different admins, and each subreddit may have different policies for what is acceptable content or not.

The difference here is that now Reddit has banned subreddits for encouraging people to post "creepy," though not necessarily illegal, content. It's always been the case that subreddit admins could ban you for whatever they wanted.


Note TrustWave, a widely trusted certificate authority, has recently explicitly acknowledged selling devices with subordinate root certificates that allow them to spoof certs for any domain that they want in order to allow companies to snoop on their employees. http://blog.spiderlabs.com/2012/02/clarifying-the-trustwave-...

If they are willing to sell these to private organizations, who's to say that one of the many certificate authorities have not sold such devices or certificates to repressive governments?

SSL is basically a joke at this point. Because it requires you to trust every single certificate authority for every single domain, it basically means that you are only protected against the average script kiddie, not a dedicated attacker. There have been plenty of CAs compromised, who continued to issue MD5 signed certificates well after it was broken, who are within the control of authoritarian governments, or who are willing to sell subordinate root certs for the purpose of snooping to any company who is willing to pay enough.

And that's not to mention that even if the information is properly protected in transit, putting this information on your servers makes you that much more vulnerable to attackers who may want access to this information, the government of the country in which it is hosted, legal process, or any number of other threats. Even if they had properly secured the information in transit, and SSL were secure, it still vastly increases your customers exposure to upload this information to your servers.


No, don't leave the app developers alone. Apple has merely failed to protect its customers; it is Path, Instagram, Voxer, and whoever else who have actively taken advantage of this lack of protection to abuse the trust of their users. Yes, Apple could do more to protect their customers, but the fault lies with those people who are uploading address books without permission.

When I install an application on my computer, I do not expect it to upload arbitrary information from my disk to the developer's servers. If an application did, I would be quite upset, even though any application that I run on my computer will generally have access to all of my data with no substantial platform-provided protection.

Why should I suddenly give the developers a break because the application is running on the computer I carry around in my pocket, instead of the computer I put in my lap?

Would you forgive a company if their application grabbed your cookies, and uploaded those to their server, so that they could log into your Gmail account to find your contact information? Decided to upload all of your documents to their servers and convert them to a convenient HTML format to make it easy for you to share them with one click to your friends? Rooted around your hard disk, uploading your tax information to their servers?

So why do you say that we should forgive companies for making the deliberate decision to grab private information from your phone, and upload it to their servers, just because the platform vendor never implemented a feature to explicitly forbid that?


one might argue that by not protecting the user's personal data by default, when how to protect such information is quite well known, the vendor and market maker is clearly the liable party


Would you argue this for your desktop or laptop as well? For any breach due to you installing an application from someone who abused your trust to read your files and upload them, that your OS vendor (Microsoft, Apple, your Linux distro, or whatnot) is the liable party?


Or, you know, the professor could just post notes themselves online, cutting out the middle man. Some people learn better from a live class. Some learn better from offline notes that they can peruse at their leisure. Why not cater to both?



Form matters, but so does plagiarism. It's one thing to paraphrase and present information from another source in an easier to read manner; it's another to lift entire phrases word for word without attribution. As others have pointed out, the attribution was only added after the complaint here on HN, and only addressed those particular phrases, it did not list any other sources that may have been used.


I would go so far as to say that calling YCombinator "training" is an outright lie. It's a business incubator and angel investment program; they pay you to develop a prototype, and introduce you to potential investors.

I feel misled after reading the article. Not knowing the context, I assumed that he was actually referring to some sort of training; something like business school, in which you pay to be taught. Instead, being given an initial investment to form a corporation, write a prototype, and shop it around to venture capitalists is pretty much the definition of "doing business," even if it is only the first few steps.

I can imagine why CBP officers would feel misled as well. And it doesn't help that he is saying he had no intention of keeping the business in the US. Starting up a business in the US just to take the capital and move the business overseas? This isn't something that a lot of border officers are going to take kindly to, nor is there likely to be much in the way of laws encouraging it.

I would absolutely like to make it easier for successful, smart, and educated people to immigrate to the US, and make it easy for people to immigrate to the US in order to start a business. But going to the US to hit up investors, work for three months to get a prototype going, and then move the business elsewhere? You're going to have a hard time selling that.


He's still making his US investors a huge profit in the process. Somebody else does the work, we get rich. How can you not want this? :-)


Right now America doesn't. You're making a philosophical argument in the context of a US Border cross where predetermined visa categories have already been established.


Just a note to everyone: this isn't "Reuters" writing this. If you notice the byline, "By Brent Lang at TheWrap", this is content syndicated from "The Wrap", which appears to be some Hollywood celeb gossip rag.


This story appears on Reuters.com with the Reuters layout and Reuters branding. Whether it is syndicated or not, it is Reuters-endorsed content that, in my opinion, should bear the same weight as the Associated Press. It's kind of sad that content of this quality has made it to their site.


Here's the announcement about how The Wrap is the "main entertainment news provider" for Reuters:

http://www.thewrap.com/media/column-post/thewrap-replaces-th...


The problem is, even most interesting people to follow retweet random crap about their personal life at times, and when they do tweet interesting content, I sometimes want to have a conversation about it, which I can't do there.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: