Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

They've fixed all of the bugs I've reported to them.

They are a popular software product, with a public bug tracker. They are likely to get more bug reports than they can deal with. Every software project gets more bug reports than they can deal with. I have never found a software project in which there weren't people who were unhappy with how quickly they fix or respond to bugs. Could they hire someone to sort through their bug tracker, or hook it up to an analysis engine to look for potential duplicates? Maybe. But that would be a lot of time and money spent, for not much gain.

I don't see Chrome as being much worse than any other random project you can name; and in fact, their automated testing is good enough that I am comfortable running their Dev Channel browser as my primary browser, and have run into very few problems doing so. Once or twice it broke for a few days in ways that I never tracked down to report, but was fixed within a week; and there have been a couple of bugs that I have reported that have also been fixed within a week or two. I've been running Dev channel as my primary browser for about 3 years now, with no show-stopping bugs, and only a handful of minor ones.


They fixed the bug we reported too, one day later! It's possible they already had a fix in the works, but we were surprised at the quick turnaround nonetheless.


> Batteries are still too heavy

> Changing. Rapidly.

It doesn't matter how rapidly they are changing; the original comment was saying that they are too heavy now. You can hypothesize about where they will be in 5 years, but that's uncertain and doesn't apply to cars that are available now.

>take too long to charge

> Improving, rapidly. Much more rapidly than, say, gas mileage.

Again, rate of improvement doesn't have much to do with what's available now. And even if it is improving now, where will it top out? I can fill my tank in a minute and a half at the pump; will I ever be able to fully charge a car in that amount of time?

> Sorry to be a broken record, but this too is improving rapidly.

And again, it doesn't matter how fast it's improving; what matters is whether in the end, it will wind up such that it's cheaper than fuel-powered cars.

> Tesla's range is already over 250 miles; this is getting very close to that of many gas guzzlers. And again, this is rapidly improving, even though we're not working very hard on it as a society. Imagine what would happen if we tried!

This doesn't matter to me if I need to take a 500 mile trip. Then, instead of just filling up for a minute or two at the pump, I have to wait for hours for a charge every couple hundred miles.

> Uh, you can transport electricity to people, too. We have power lines for that.

It's a lot easier to clear a road to get trucks past than it is to repair a full power grid.

> Charging time: This doesn't have to get much better at all; you can recharge at night.

No, I can't. I don't have a parking space where I live. I have to park on the street, and can't rely on being able to park in front of my house. Unless we get recharge stations installed at every parking space, an electric car will never be practical for me.


What does "the batteries are too heavy" even mean? Too heavy for what?

Tesla just released a really big car with a heavy battery that goes 265 miles on a charge (under the very strict new EPA rating; at older methods of measuring range this number would be much higher). So I ask the batteries are too heavy for what exactly?

Also, if you are paying attention, you know that Tesla has just opened to the public a number of Supercharger stations that will charge the Model S battery 50% of the way in about 20 minutes. So your complaint of "wait hours for a charge" is already solved, today, in 2012, at least if you live in California (and Tesla plans to expand the Supercharger network rapidly).

There have been anti-EV arguments for years, but the arguments keep changing, which is how you know that EVs have won. The main argument used to be that EVs would never go far enough, that people would have too much range anxiety. That has been solved. Then the argument was that the cars are too expensive. That is in the process of being solved right now, as you see from Roadster->Model S. There are other problems but they are much smaller. "I park on the street so I don't have a place to charge my car" is not very hard to solve: it is obviously just a matter of will.


Not only do the Supercharger stations charge the batteries rapidly, they charge them for FREE and the electricity is from the SUN, not coal..


Just imagine if people in 80's had a similar attitude about internet, where would we be now?

If we were to wait for things to get perfectly ready. 90% of the things in this world would never get ready at all.


However, part of the perception that EV cars are almost here is caused by people having gotten used to the blistering pace of innovation in IT. Batteries to heavy? Mwah, "wait a few years and it will be good enough".

In reality, if you look at the weight/power density curve of batteries it has been improving at a pace that 10 times slower than what happened in IT. So it may take decades more to get where we need to be. Just trying to be realistic here.


Note that no one had to be given a $5000 tax credit to buy a PC, a modem, and an AOL account.


No, but most of the early infrastructure for the internet was publicly-funded (between government labs and universities).


> the original comment was saying that they are too heavy now.

I beg to differ:

> The Tesla Model S is a great-looking car but, unlike some, I still don't see electric cars as being the future.

The comment is arguing that electric cars are not the future because batteries and energy delivery and what not is not ready now. Guess what, now is not the future. It would be like arguing that ICE cars were not the future in the 19th century.


The important thing is that those who believe that electric cars are viable be able to finance the enterprise. The sooner the taxpayer is no longer forced to subsidize them, the better.


When do I get to opt out of subsidizing ICE cars and the infrastructure needed to keep them on the road?


Hopefully soon. Its wrong to subsidy the automobile, whether it is electric or ICE powered.

Yes, we do pay gas taxes, put I doubt they are enough. And even if they were, it makes no sense to charge the same regardless of when one travels.

Most of the road building is to accommodate rush hour traffic. It makes sense to more at that time, just as hotels charge more when demand is high.

The way roads are currently paid for winds up wasting enormous amounts of time at rush hour. Charging a price that reduces the traffic to the level that the roads can efficiently handle will save everybody a lot of time.

Of course, that issue has nothing to do with how cars are powered.


Isn't much of the subsidizing of infrastructure (roads) via fuel taxes? How should EVs be taxed?


Good point. If fuel taxes pay for roads, how will electric car owners pay for their share of the wear and tear?


I would not consider that to provide adequate notice of a change in the TOS. If it's just a link that never changes, you won't have been notified if it updates.


According to the article:

  Using Clickthrough Agreements.  Zappos had an easy way to 
  form a clickthrough agreement.  As shoppers are checking
  out of the store with their shopping cart, Zappos could
  say "By clicking the 'purchase' button, you agree to the
  Zappos terms of use" with a link to the document.  It's as
  easy as that.  No custom coding, no interstitial web
  pages, no real risk of abandoned shopping carts.
Considering that the author is a professor of Law at Santa Clara University, I would think that the TOS in the login dialog would hold water in court.

http://www.ericgoldman.org/biography.html


What if it included the date of most recent update? Worst case, you could store the user's most recent TOS agreement version or date identifier, and force them to agree after logging in if they want to continue. This seems to be how Apple operates for the App Store.


When I was at Yahoo years ago, and we handled billing for premium servies, we'd explicitly store the version of the TOS the user had indicated express consent to as an extra precaution (express consent in this case meant the user had ticket a checkbox to confirm they agreed and then submitted the form).


First of all, the login experience should not change if the TOS is the same as before.

If the TOS has changed, you could accept-reject the login (lock the credentials in the fields) and say "to continue, please read the TOS change and press 'accept' to continue". Or just have this as a separate screen after the login.


Well, it makes a little less sense on phones, since unless you switch the SIM card, you are still treated as the other person as far as the phone network is concerned. It would be a little odd to be logged in as one person, but the phone network treat you as the other. And since there are features like importing and exporting contacts from the SIM card, those would be more complicated in multi-user scenarios.

I think there's a certain sense that a phone is a much more "personal" device than a tablet. While it would probably be possible to add multi-user support, it would be more difficult, and be less useful, than on a tablet.


While I personally find it annoying, I know many parents that hand their phone to their young children to play games or music. Multiuser support is very much in demand on phones, even if it offered nothing more than a safe guest account.


With kid's corner feature in windows phone 8, you can have fine grain control over what the kids have access to.


The RPi has a serial port, though it takes a custom cable to hook it up. You can do basic I/O with that, and much more simply than a USB stack.


This is not a very favorable review. While it seems to be trying to spin in a positive direction, the fact that the first several paragraphs are about how Microsoft wanted to control the message, and not about how great a product this is, are not encouraging.

Then there's a lot of hemming an hawing over how there's no perfect solution, and it doesn't run Windows applications. This was not enough to convince me to read the rest of the review.


How can you attempt to summarize a review as "not very favorable" when you haven't been "convinced" to read the rest of it? At least read the closing paragraph if you're not going to bother spending more time: "If you're ok being an early adopter, and ok dealing with the fact that mobile devices are still being significantly revved every year, Surface is worth your consideration. If you've wanted a tablet that could really bridge the content consumption and productivity device, Surface is it."

If anything, this review seemed to lean positive. I wouldn't say it was gushing with love, but it's certainly left me with a solid impression of the hardware and a sense that the Surface won't be a complete flop.

The mix of damning judgement and deliberate ignorance here is amusing.


This one focuses on the hardware for the most part. Which I think is quite comparable to other options if not favorable. When it comes to Windows 8 though, its a personal taste. I love it even on my non-touch laptop and am looking forward to using it on a touch based laptop when I upgrade my current machine.


Translation... I already own an IPad (may be several of them), I am insecure to read about other options out there because their advantages may make my device look like lacking and hence I become a stupid consumer. For me to be considered a smart consumer, I should constantly remind the rest of the population how awesome my IPad is.


But more than that, there are laws, that were written perhaps in part due to pressures from these groups, but in part from all kinds of other pressures, which provide a lot of inertia for the way things are done.

Whenever there's some kind of education reform, it's usually to add stricter standards, because we're always falling behind in education and feel that stricter standards will help make sure that we don't. This means that textbooks need to meet stricter standards. Which mean that there needs to be some kind of review. Which means that someone needs to pay for that review. Which generally falls on the textbook publishers, or some overworked underpaid government committee. Which means that only a limited number of textbooks go through that review, locking out anything else which might be suitable but hasn't been reviewed to determine if it meets that standard.

The standards wind up changing every few years, so the textbooks need to be updated to match.


But in the case of Firefox, you are explicitly trying to do a web search. While in Unity, you are just running your local app launcher.

Confusing a private local search for your own files with an online search that sends information to a third party is is a fairly substantial privacy issue, and the fact that Canonical is just blowing it off (by saying "we already have root") is incredibly concerning about their judgement.


http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/9clji/where_did_m...

I should add that this is not direct pressure from their advertisers, but from their parent company, Condé Nast. I'm sure that Sears is and advertiser for at least some Condé Nast properties, so it's effectively the same, though with an extra level of indirection.


Some context would be useful here. The post was in relation to a URL exploit on a Sears site, and I can see the justification for a company taking issue with a partner of theirs posting how to exploit their site.

This isn't just "Advertiser gets a post banned they don't like", this is "Advertiser asks partner to pull down an exploit". Framing it as the former makes it sound like a capricious, moralizing decision.


What? Freedom of speech does not mean "I have to pay you for the kind of speech you create."

There is no hypocrisy in saying "I don't support what you are saying, but I defend your right to say it."

Now, sure the money they made clouds matters a bit, but that money was content-neutral. They neither encouraged nor discouraged any particular content.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: