No. He's saying that the court would not use 18 USC 1030(a) to charge someone of a crime when they did something completely normal and innocuous but which was technically against the language in 18 USC 1030(a) because it was poorly drafted.
He's saying that the courts can make distinctions between what Congress intended (to make it illegal to bypass computer security systems without permission), and what the law might technically forbid but what is completely normal and innocuous to do (like browsing someone's website without their explicit permission).
If I discovered that someone hadn't locked a filing cabinet, and then I rifled through it, found a whole bunch of names and social security numbers, recorded all of them, and then went to talk to a news organization with this list without ever notifying the people whose filing cabinet I'd gone through, do you think that would be OK?
Because that's pretty much the equivalent of what happened here. You say "AT&T put this information on a public interface and relied on obscurity of serial numbers to protect it"; this phrasing puts the blame on AT&T. Yes, they should not have done that. But that's about equivalent to forgetting to lock a file cabinet; it's a mistake that someone made. Weev then took advantage of that mistake to violate the privacy of thousands of people, providing their personal information to a news organization.
Now, I don't necessarily think that they should have been convicted of everything they were convicted of. Unless there are facts that I haven't seen, they haven't come anywhere close to committing identity theft. But you do have to admit that Weev did not exactly handle this responsibly, and did invade people's privacy.
The metaphor doesn't really hold up; it's rather like you went to the administrative desk of AT&T 1000 times, asked the person behind the desk "Can I please have document 001?" and they simply handed it over without questions each of the 1000 times. That employee should have stopped handing over documents, but it didn't.
In my opinion the crime isn't in requesting or obtaining that information, it's in the way that he handled that information afterwards.
If he would have used it with the pure intention of showing that the system is insecure, he would have been right and nobody would have been able to blame him of improper conduct.
Instead he sold/handed over that information to Gawker, which is where he went wrong in my opinion, because he took another organisation's information and decided to put that information on the market against their will or consent.
Bingo. I think it was a dick move to go running to Gawker with it, rather than practicing responsible disclosure. But even then, I'm having a hard time with the idea of criminal charges for that; he didn't steal this data, AT&T happily handed it to him. He basically ran around saying "Haha, what a moron the guy at the administrative desk is, I just kept asking him for files and he just kept on handing them to me". And while that's distasteful, is it criminal?
Honestly, to me, it feels like he's being run down because someone got embarrassed, and he's being railroaded with archaic laws that can be applied in vague and nebulous ways to make just about anyone a criminal if it's useful.
No, that analogy suggests that there was someone actively paying attention, who should have noticed something awry, but was instead granting permission without thinking. In this case, they just left an unsecured program running; it was a passive mistake. Just like leaving a door unlocked and someone comes in and goes through your papers. The door being unlocked does not mean that someone gave permission for you to go through it.
> In my opinion the crime isn't in requesting or obtaining that information, it's in the way that he handled that information afterwards.
I think that the fact that he requested a hundred thousand records probably didn't work in his favor. If he had requested just a dozen or so, to confirm that the problem existed, it would have been one thing; once he hit thousands, it makes you wonder if he had ulterior motives. Past the first dozen or so, there was nothing left to prove about the security flaw.
> Instead he sold/handed over that information to Gawker, which is where he went wrong in my opinion, because he took another organisation's information and decided to put that information on the market against their will or consent.
Yes, this was the biggest mistake. And I don't remember the source, but I recall that someone mentioned that he had considered selling the information as well, before deciding to just give it to Gawker.
Of course, in some ways I don't blame him for not going to AT&T first; there have been researchers who have discovered flaws, and disclosed them to the company, only to have the company accuse them of criminal acts for having even tested for the flaw in the first place. That kind of behavior creates a catch-22, and a very chilling effect on security research.
You forgot to mention that this filing cabinet was not only unlocked but left unattended, near the road, day and night for months. Yes it had AT&T logo on it and opening and looking inside might be impolite. But a crime? Hardly.
Crime is leaving such a file cabinet in such manner, especially if it contains private data of your clients.
They redirect you to some ad (I'm not sure what, I have ad-block on so I don't see it, but I see the blank page). Then you can click through to the actual site. Presumably, that redirect is breaking for you for some reason. They may use a cookie to indicate what URL you are supposed to be redirected back to; do you have cookies disabled? Or you could just try clearing all of your cookies for that this site.
Thanks very much for the great answer. I didn't realize they redirected through an ad server, but that's exactly what the problem is. I'm not just using adblock and ghostly with cookies and javascript turned off, but I'm also using the ad-blocking hosts file.
There is a difference between "consent" and "putting up with because you want something else more."
I generally have a greater need to fly than to avoid being felt up. This does not mean I consent to being felt up. The fact that the Supreme Court mistakes this for consent bothers me greatly.
That's like saying I consent to have the sandwich you made but I don't consent to give you money for it, therefore you the sandwich shop owner are robbing me. You analyze the cost-benefit and consent to the whole package. You can't pick and choose.
No, nothing like that. I do not have a constitutionally protected right to eat a sandwich. I do have one to be free from unreasonable search and seizure.
Furthermore, with the sandwich, there are alternatives available to me. I can choose to go somewhere else that serves cheaper sandwiches, or make my own. There are some places that I just cannot get to without flying; and some for which getting there would take so long as to be completely impractical, thereby cutting me off from a large swath of possible activity if I do not "consent" to being touched in the nether bits.
Their argument is like saying that by walking into a fraternity, a woman consents to being groped. Hey, maybe they even put up a sign saying "we grope women who enter here." That argument does not make it consent.
Furthermore, you are not able to remove your consent once you reach the head of the line. At may airports, they subject only some passengers to having nude photos taken of them by x-ray (or groping if you don't consent to the backscatter). But at the point when you get to the head of the line and find out if you're lucky, you are not able to leave in order to avoid the search; they have arrested people for trying to do so.
There are certain ways to coerce people to create an illusion of consent; but that shouldn't be confused with actual consent.
And see, I find that to be a slimy, horrible way to get around these inconvenient "rights" that we have, by defining an entire class of activity, that is pretty much essential to be able to participate in the modern world, as a way of giving up your rights.
"Oh, sure, you may have a constitutionally protected right to free speech. But upon accepting employment or payment for anything, you waive that right." Hey, the government has the right to regulate interstate commerce, and has ruled that even commerce within a state counts because it impacts prices on an interstate level. So let's just do away with the whole bill of rights by saying "you give implied consent to no longer have these rights by engaging in commerce." Done and done.
Not in this case there isn't. You showing up at the airport and going through security is implied consent to the search, just like opening the door to them without explicitly denying consent is enough for police to legally enter your house.
If you watch the video, that's all that this is claimed to do. The headline it was posted under on is.gd and here on HN claim it's for clearing mines; but at 2:50 he says "My ideal scenario would be to provide it for local people as a tool to cheaply survey this danger in their own environment."
All this discussion is because of an over-enthusiastic headline, not what the tool is actually intended for.
I can't verify since I'm at work, but I'm pretty sure he talks about how a single roller can clear up to four mines. To me that implies this is meant as a tool for clearing the mines.
Protip: don't ever reply to ads that ask for a "ninja" or "rockstar." Look for the more boring sounding jobs; they will have fewer people competing for the job, so you can probably make relatively better rates.
Also, why do you only do remote work? Is there no one near you who needs a sysadmin? Could you travel? People value face-to-face interaction a lot more than online; if you only do remote work, then some guy in Bangalore can undercut your rates (hence the $20 an hour offers), and you're not really offering much over him.
And as the original article says, don't charge per hour. Charge per week, or per incident. And charge rates that make sense for that kind of time frame. Read the original article; it has good advice. Once you charge per week (or per incident, based on a standard weekly rate), you can start talking about "OK, you want to spend less, which things should I not do", not "Well, I think I'm worth $50 an hour, but since I need the money, I'll take the job for $20"
Yes, for systems administration it can work that way. Here where I work we don't really have any sysadmins (or everyone's a sysadmin, which is even worse). We have developers, and we have tech support who support customer systems, and we all kind of chip in on the system administration, but we don't have anyone who's job it is to maintain our own network. It finally got so bad that we've brought someone in to straighten it out. I don't know the details of how he's being paid, but I could easily imagine it as "it will cost $5000 for me to track down your problems, reconfigure your core router, set it up in a way that will be more maintainable in the future, and write the documentation for running that."
> Protip: don't ever reply to ads that ask for a "ninja" or "rockstar."
No, please do reply. Then go in wearing leather pants, with white powder on your upper lip and reeking of Jack Daniels. Use a pawn-shop electric guitar to smash the fuck out of their interview room. Then stab somebody with a katana on your way out.
It is much better if the price and terms are simply public up front. For instance, we were worrying about PyQt (GPL + commercial option) vs. PySide (LGPL) for a project, where PySide didn't support certain things that we needed. But then we realized that the PyQt commercial license comes with reasonable terms, and costs only £350, and it wasn't even worth the time worrying over it any more.
So yeah, "contact the authors" can be hard, but an up-front agreement and price can make it pretty easy.
How come this is so much faster than Google's own Street View interface? I feel like whether I use Flash or WebGL, Street View always feels a bit clunky and laggy, while here it's really instant.
I suppose one of the things that helps is that this doesn't do the "zoom" effect that looks ugly and slows you down navigating.
Self reply to mention that one reason it feels so "instant" is that in many cases, it has already auto-completed and started displaying your destination before you finish typing. For instance, I typed "golden gate bridge", and probably by the time I had typed "golden ga" it could start loading, and everything was loaded by the time I finished typing "bridge."
Also, what panoramic viewer is this? Is this something provided by Google, something off the shelf, or something custom written by them?
He's saying that the courts can make distinctions between what Congress intended (to make it illegal to bypass computer security systems without permission), and what the law might technically forbid but what is completely normal and innocuous to do (like browsing someone's website without their explicit permission).