Not everyone is a frontend web developer, or any sort of frontent developer. I develop software to manage network attached storage, making my resolution pretty much irrelevant for testing my software. In fact, for the small amount of UI work that I do, I run it in a VM at 1024x768; the tiny resolution on this thing means that that would take up pretty much my whole display.
Furthermore, I like to be able to see my code and and the final product at the same time. In fact, I prefer to be able to have several columns of code, a terminal, a web browser, and my VM that I'm deploying my work to all visible at once. The more I can see, the better. I usually work with 3 1920x1080 monitors plus my laptop display, but sometimes need to use my laptop when I'm not at my desk. Being able to fit multiple columns of code and/or terminals on my screen at once is important to me.
Heck, these days, phones are coming with greater resolutions than that; you can't even fit your phone emulator on that display without scaling, if you develop mobile software. The Nexus 10 has 2560x1600 display on a 10 inch screen; why does a $400 tablet have such a better screen (its smaller dimension has more pixels than the XPS 13's larger!) than a $1500 laptop?
Aside from the poor resolution I also don't understand the price. I purchased a gaming laptop (ASUS G75VW) w/ 16GB of RAM, a 256GB SSD, 750GB HDD, GTX 660m & 3610QM, which runs 1920x1080 for under $1400. This dell laptop has the specifications of my $400 Chromebook. It seems like it has been massively overpriced because it's one of the few machines that runs linux out of the box.
This seems to be completely against the spirit of the Humble Bundles. They are normally creative games from independent publishers, available cross platform and DRM free. These are some generic mass-market games from a failing major publisher, available only on Windows, and delivered via Steam rather than DRM-free.
The excessive numbers of "Humble X Bundles" that have been coming out recently have been kind of killing my interest in them. When it was an occasional thing with some really good games in the bundle, and I was able to support cross-platform DRM-free game development, I would buy pretty much every one, even if I didn't play many of the games. Now that they've diluted the brand so much, I'm a lot less likely to look when they announce a new bundle.
Of course it’s a typical Humble Bundle. There were goddamn Android bundles in the past. No one complained. But now suddenly everyone. I do not get it.
The point of Humble Bundles is to make a bunch of cool games available for however much money you want to pay. Sometimes those games are cross-plattform, sometimes not. That’s it.
The Android bundles were just bundles that included Android versions of the games. They were still cross-platform and DRM-free (you can use their app, or download the .apk and put it on your device any way you choose)
The thing is, people have certain expectations of a Humble Bundle now; that's what it means to have a strong brand.
It's fine that they are doing new things -- I don't mind the Amnesia Fortnight stuff at all, in part because it's a pretty cool concept, but probably also because they're not calling it a Humble Bundle.
It's not just this one that I mind. The "Humble Android Bundle", "Humble Ebook Bundle", and so on are also diluting the brand.
But this one goes against some of the basic tenets of the Humble Bundle series; namely, the DRM-free, cross-platform nature. One of the reasons I support them is that I support choice. I want to have choice in what platform I run. I want to have choice in what machines I run my games on. DRM and single-platform games mean that I don't have that choice.
All I'm saying is that in the past, I've bought Humble Bundles and never even played a single game, just because I supported the idea so much. Now they've violated some of their core principles; they are still "pay what you want" and allow supporting charities, but they are selling games that I am morally opposed to. I'm better off just giving my money to the charities directly.
It's a cliche thing to say, but hey, you don't have to participate.
If you truly support Humble Bundle and what they do, then you would support them in this endeavor as well -- you are giving them some tip as well (and charities if that's your thing). Does anyone really think that since they are doing this with THQ they are going to simply stop supporting the indie community?
THQ made some bad decisions, and they are desperate. This is a pretty clever move for them, and one can only hope a kick in the butt to pay more attention to what gamers are looking for.
Yeah if this THQ bundle earns them a lot of money, maybe they do not need to work their ass off to promote indie titles from now on, and simply rely on big AAA titles sales once and then. Of course it would be stupid for them to do so (killing their brand) but it seems that they would be well off financially.
> People tend to avoid effort, and if you can make pirating content more difficult than obtaining it legitimately, most people will obtain it legitimately.
The problem with DRM is that with information, it doesn't matter if it's more difficult for any given user to pirate. It only takes one person to make a copy of it without DRM, and they can then share it, and now nothing can stop anyone from viewing it. At least, that's the case without horribly repressive measures that don't allow anyone to view their own media.
All the DRM does is make legitimate use harder. If you want to find a free copy, you can; but if you're a legitimate user, and want to make a backup of your DVD? Nope, sorry, people aren't allowed to sell tools to help you do that. Want to capture a few seconds to comment on? Nope, sorry, people can't legitimately distribute tools that allow that. Want to skip the stupid previews? Nope sorry, also illegal.
The problem with DRM is that if it doesn't work perfectly, all of the bad things that it's trying to prevent can still happen, and in the meantime, tons of legitimate uses are banned, and we start to produce technology that is oppressive and works against the interests of its users.
When funding something, you should consider its likelihood of succeeding and its value to you.
If its value is around the price you're funding it at or slightly higher, then you should only fund things which have a high chance of success; from a proven team, that has shipped plenty of products before. For instance, a band that you like that's released several albums and is raising money for a new one, a studio that is developing a new game based on an existing engine, and so on.
If it's a riskier campaign, like development of a new hardware product from a new company that has never shipped anything before, or an artist's first album, or some amazing new game with an amazing new engine that has all kinds of really neat features, with a game designer you like but a rookie team, then you should only fund it if it has significantly more value to you than what you are funding. Maybe you just think it's such a good idea, that even trying and failing and learning from that is worth the money you spend. Or maybe you think that it is a game worth $200; it's such a perfect game for you, that you would be willing to shell out $200 for it, or the equivalent, fund 10 such games for $20 and get one working game out of it. Or maybe you're just a big fan of the person you are funding, and don't mind giving them $20 even if you think they might not complete the project.
So yes, you should be aware of the risks when funding something; that's why it's funding, and not buying a completed product. You should decide if what you're going to get is worth the risk. Far too many people seem to see Kickstarter as a pre-order system, where the product is basically ready but they want funding to determine how large to make the first batch and fund just the final manufacture. Maybe people think that because it does act that way for some products; but you really should not expect it to work that way for all products.
If Kickstarter limited themselves to the pre-order model, that would vastly limit the kinds of things it would be good for. You seem to want only pre-orders, not to fund development, so maybe that would work for you. But some people want to be able to fund riskier, more wild ideas, and accept that risk. I think that they should be able to; the only trick is that there seems to be a good deal of confusion on the part of funders as to which projects are which type; people don't seem to be very good at judging the risks involved when funding a project.
The reason I use the lemon market analogy is that it is not always clear to the buyer what the level of risk is. Sure there are certain signals which indicate lower risk but I don't think there is yet enough data on completed projects to confirm this absolutely.
Some buyers are also savvier than others, for example is it riskier to fund an indie platformer or an arduino replacement? A HN reader might be able to guess but the general consumer might well have no idea.
There are also other factors, like might this fail because there isn't enough funding? or might this fail because it is just an outright scam?
So basically what we have is information asymmetry which will lead a lot of people to assume some mean level of risk in funding a project so the required value payoff will be higher than something bought off the shelf, what the "value coffecient" will be will take time to discover though.
The point is valid though that for example a game which I would love but would never be funded by a game studio might be worth $200 for me.
This is the problem. If people are thinking of themselves as consumers, rather than investors, then yes, you have a problem. This is why Kickstarter changed their rules on physical products, to not allow people to buy multiple quantities of something, in order to discourage people from treating it like a pre-order system.
Yeah, there's a certain amount of information asymmetry. I'm not sure you can ever do away with that, without killing the idea of crowdfunding entirely. If you require legal filings and financial disclosures and the like, all of a sudden you can't do it for small projects, you need to hire lawyers and accountants and things like that.
The best way to solve this is to convince people only to crowdfund people that they really trust. Don't look at an idea and say "hey, that's cool, I'll buy one of those." Look at the creator and say "this person can deliver, I'll give them some money to do so."
Huh? He was advocating for finding a principle and taking it to the extreme. He wasn't discouraging it.
Yes, he said that sometimes it won't work; but the whole point of the article is that you can discover and learn new things when you try taking one principle to its logical conclusion.
Where did you get the idea that he was arguing against that?
Yes, he said to try new principles, he also said not to expect them to really work, which undercuts the motivation for finding really difficult to discern principles.
> he also said not to expect them to really work, which undercuts the motivation for finding really difficult to discern principles.
That would be an argument against science, which labors under the same constraint (i.e. with rare exception, things don't work), but as it turns out it really isn't an argument against science at all, because the rare "thing that works" tends to change the world.
> Great science is done by people who are more like Newton and Tesla, not people like you and Edison.
Apart from the fact the "great science" isn't the topic of discussion, on the contrary: in terms of maximum effect on the human race, the "greatest" science is the man of the street who can't be bamboozled by an idea that has no supporting evidence.
"in terms of maximum effect on the human race, the "greatest" science is the man of the street who can't be bamboozled by an idea that has no supporting evidence."
That's a rather grandiose claim. Where's your supporting evidence?
Modern times is my evidence. The reason the Church didn't burn Galileo at the stake in 1633, as they did Bruno in 1600, is, not because they didn't want to, but because public awareness of science, of the value of comparing ideas to reality, had changed enough in that interval to make it a practical impossibility. And that was just 33 years.
The single most important manifestation of science is the general increase in everyday scientific reasoning, not the specialized form of science practiced by professionals, as important as the latter surely is.
Professional, high-level science gives us vaccines and modern medicine, certainly very valuable. Everyday science gives us the notion that an unfamiliar idea or claim must be accompanied by evidence. The second trumps the first.
Sure, the mob refraining from killing and attacking scientists is good. But the credit still goes to Galileo for his insight, not the common man for refraining from abusing Galileo.
IOW, who you have decided to credit is morally perverse.
> Sure, the mob refraining from killing and attacking scientists is good.
What? Are your reading what I'm posting? There was no mob, there was an all-powerful Church. It was the Church, not the public, who objected to what Galileo had to say and who put him on trial.
> But the credit still goes to Galileo for his insight, not the common man ...
You completely missed the point of this history lesson. The reason Galileo didn't share Bruno's fate wasn't Galileo, it was the common man. Times and perceptions had changed. Galileo and the common man both benefited. Everyone moved ahead except the Church.
The Church wasn't reluctant to burn Galileo at the stake because of his discoveries. Quite the contrary -- he was prosecuted for precisely those insights and the degree to which they contradicted Church dogma. But they could only go so far, because of public relations and changing times.
> IOW, who you have decided to credit is morally perverse.
Since I did no such thing, I don't have to defend it.
It's clear from what you're posting that you have no clue about this historical period, so ...
You were the one who made a wildly unsubstantiated claim that the common man's attitude about science has more effect on the human race than the insights of actual scientists. None of what you've said since then has justified this wild claim of yours and you can't because it's just patently absurd.
What's clear is that you haven't actually provided enough evidence to support your claim, that your original attack on me is pure hypocrisy, and that you now wish to cover your tracks by pretending that I just don't understand you.
> You were the one who made a wildly unsubstantiated claim that the common man's attitude about science has more effect on the human race than the insights of actual scientists.
"Wildly unsubstantiated"? Do you go outdoors much? It is a fact on the ground -- a dramatic reduction in religious persecution, indeed of religion altogether, a decline in the acceptance of superstitious beliefs, an increase in intellectual freedom demanded by the common man, and a thousand other examples. And the assumption that an idea with no supporting evidence is assumed to be false, by itself the most important evidence for public acceptance of the scientific outlook.
The true revolution in science is not the existence of scientific specialists (as important as that is), it is the fact that the public is willing to pay for the science, because they know it works, both as public policy and as an intellectual model for everyman.
Science is not about "actual scientists" as you put it. Science is about reality testing instead of blind belief. That's what distinguishes modern times from 500 years ago, a time when superstition ruled. Science cannot survive without public support, and public support requires public comprehension. The existence of working scientists is an effect, not a cause.
Look, I'm not going to bring you up to date on the last 500 years of human history, you're responsible for your own ignorance. Solve the problem st its source -- start now:
Look, I get it. If you don't know why you believe it, it's a "fact on the ground." If you don't know why I believe it, then I have a burden of substantiating it for you.
I know it went over your head, but the dispute here isn't about the basic facts of history, it's about your grandiose misinterpretation of those facts and your inability to distinguish a "fact" from an extremely broad generalization.
You do notice that all of the countries listed as "Very High Proficiency" are Scandinavian or Dutch, just like he said, right? And many of the continental European countries, like France, Italy, and Spain are listed at only "Moderate Proficiency."
While you don't need perfect language skills to understand technical concepts, not being at full proficiency can be a barrier. I know that when I help people out on StackOverflow, one of the main barriers to answering some people's questions is that they can't formulate it in English in a way that I can understand. Proficiency is a two-way thing; besides being able to read English, you need to be able to speak and write it well to fully interact with the technical community.
This article would have been a lot better with examples of where that complexity is (particular functions, where the complexity score comes from, etc), and what suggested refactorings help to reduce that complexity. That would make it possible to judge if this is a reasonable metric, or if this is just some overly-strict tool that dings perfectly reasonable code, which some frameworks happen to trigger more than others.
Furthermore, I like to be able to see my code and and the final product at the same time. In fact, I prefer to be able to have several columns of code, a terminal, a web browser, and my VM that I'm deploying my work to all visible at once. The more I can see, the better. I usually work with 3 1920x1080 monitors plus my laptop display, but sometimes need to use my laptop when I'm not at my desk. Being able to fit multiple columns of code and/or terminals on my screen at once is important to me.
Heck, these days, phones are coming with greater resolutions than that; you can't even fit your phone emulator on that display without scaling, if you develop mobile software. The Nexus 10 has 2560x1600 display on a 10 inch screen; why does a $400 tablet have such a better screen (its smaller dimension has more pixels than the XPS 13's larger!) than a $1500 laptop?