Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

Are you on an usecured wifi network or something?

Because I see no such background. I feel like maybe you are being MITMed.


My connection is as secure as T-Mobile makes their "4G Mobile Hotspot."

The fact that an acquaintance in England (I'm in Hawaii) also saw the x-rated background leads me to believe that something else is going on with this page.


I find that very hard to believe. When I bike, I really don't eat that much more than when I don't. Yeah, my appetite increases a little, but I can usually supplement my diet with some pretty cheap calories, or a lot of time just finishing more of what's put in front of me. American portions are fairly large, I usually have a calorie surplus.

And even when I do buy more, a few dollars a day isn't all that much. Now, gas for my commute also wouldn't cost much; at 10 miles a day, that's less than $2 a day. But gas isn't the only cost of owning a car. There's the price of the car itself, and depreciation, maintenance, insurance, taxes, parking. Heck, at my last job, it would have cost $200 a month just for parking alone. My bike has maybe had $1000 put into it for original cost, accessories, maintenance over the past 5 years I've had it, and I've had to put none of those other costs in.


You'd have to bike at a resting heartrate to come anywhere close to not needing any more food.


That's assuming you don't normally eat more calories than you need. Probably an incorrect assumption for most people.


Boston, MA (Full time or single-project contract starting immediately)

EditShare http://www.editshare.com/

We are a small but rapidly growing company selling integrated hardware and software solutions for a professional digital video editing workflow. We have always been privately owned, never taken funding from anyone outside the company; you will be working directly with the CEO and co-owner, who built the company from a single machine at a trade show.

We are looking for a full-stack JavaScript developer, with experience in Node.js, Backbone.js, Socket.IO, and HTML5 video (or some suitable subset, or equivalent experience with similar frameworks). We are creating a web-based interface for a video asset management system, which will allow searching and playing video and adding metadata.

We are ready to hire immediately; we had the previous developer on this project leave unexpectedly, and have an urgent deadline approaching, so we are ready to give a job offer on Monday if you're good. Code samples are strongly recommended when applying.

http://ephemera.continuation.org/FullStackWebDeveloper.pdf

In addition, we are always looking for good engineers for our other products. We maintain our own Linux distribution (we are in the process of moving from an RPM based distro to an Ubuntu derivative) which forms the basis for our platform, and write management software in Python using Twisted, work on a variety of open source packages in C, and have application software written in C++. We strongly support open source software, funding and working closely with several projects, as well as having released Lightworks (http://lwks.com/), a professional non-linear video editor, for free (as in beer at the moment, though we plan to release the source code once we've finished the Linux and Mac ports and removed the proprietary codecs that we've licensed from third parties). So if you have experience in digital video, distributed systems, storage, backup, Linux packaging, Python, C, or C++, we would also love to hear from you.

Email resume and code samples (cover letter optional, but at least mention which position you are interested in) to: work(at)editshare.com


Of course someone would do that; even with DRM, people have done that. What content is available on Netflix that is not available on The Pirate Bay?

DRM has completely failed at preventing people from pirating content; and yet, companies selling content seem to be doing plenty well at it. Why do we keep insisting that DRM is necessary or else people will pirate all of the content, and thus making our software and standards more complex, more flaky, and work against the interests of users, when the existence of piracy is obviously not destroying the content providers now?

You know what's preventing them from making more money? The fact that because of complex licensing schemes, DRM, and the like, I can't be guaranteed that if I buy content I can play it on the devices that I choose to use. If I pirate a video, I can play it anywhere. Content producers are shooting themselves in the foot because of their fear of piracy; piracy works better than buying the content directly, and will continue to do so as long as they insist on DRM.


I think the issue that's concerning is that this increases the necessity to obtain a patent on any novel idea, lest someone else copy your idea, patent it, and then sue you for implementing your own idea. This means that now, every time you come up with some new idea, you need to spend all the time, money, and effort to patent it (and hope, in the process, that you don't come across an existing patent for that idea, since now your infringement of that patent will be willful with treble damages).

Especially in the software field, this causes all kinds of problems. As many people have pointed out, if you were to try and patent software that you create, you would have to file a patent for every few lines of code you write. With first-to-invent, I would expect (though I'm not a lawyer, and haven't studied this in depth, so I could very well be wrong) that you would be able to simply not bother patenting it, and then if sued, file a patent and use the first to invent rule to get your patent to override theirs.


It does not mean that. The filer has to prove they invented the idea, which they can't do if you've published it prior to their filing.

If you weren't going to publish or file a patent, nothing changes for you at all; you're exactly as exposed to patent litigation as you were prior to the change, because your inaction was no more effective at blunting bad patents under "first to invent". If you invent something and keep it a secret, other people have always been able to patent the same idea, because the law does not require people to read your mind.

Again, I think the issue is that the "move" from "inventing" to "filing" conveys a kind of paperwork urgency that just isn't there.


"If you invent something and keep it a secret, other people have always been able to patent the same idea, because the law does not require people to read your mind."

This is not right. Prior to AIA it was possible to invalidate a patent by showing secret invention by another inventor prior to the patent invention date, among other things.

See also: Metallizing Eng. v. Kenyon (secret commercial use by party) or Eggbert v. Lippman (secret use in public) or Gore v. Garlock (Secret use by third party).

In fact, there is a bunch of "secret prior art" that AIA eliminates.


Whoah. How did that work?

Also: from having been through the patent process a bunch of times: does this make it "harder" to obtain a patent by eliminating the ability to sell the invention under NDA before filing? I remember this being part of the M.O. of building, selling, and then patenting technology at companies I've worked at.


There were a variety of forms of secret art (in the sense that the inventor could not possibly have known about them when they filed for the patent), they were only brought up in re-exams or trials, of course.

There are also some sad cases where out-of-order patent processing caused later filed patents issued more than a year before earlier filed pending app. You don't get interference proceedings if the later-filed patent issued more than a year before your pending app. You just get a huge mess instead ;)

To answer the other question, since AIA makes secret commercialization not prior art, I expect more people will sell stuff under NDA[1]. Hopefully, more people will publish too.

[1] The statute itself is a bit ambiguous, but the PTO's new guidelines say "The legislative history of the AIA indicates that the inclusion of this clause in AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) should be viewed as indicating that AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) does not cover non-public uses or nonpublic offers for sale "


Your analysis seems not quite right. Metallizing, for example, is a public use case in the sense that the legislative history uses the term even though the public could not have understood how to make the invention from the public use. I think the legislative history here is meant to say that the clause is meant to have the same scope as the old 102(b) bars except for territoriality. There's stil the new clause though...


Yes, i agree with your viewpoint of what Metallizing is about, though Metallizing is still generally considered a secret prior art case, in the way "secret prior art" is used: Things the inventor could not have possibly known about at the time of filing, even if they had attempted to know everything.

In that sense, it is in fact, a secret use, even though the holding was that it was a public use :)


The unstated assumption here is that the patent office actually does the work to see whether anything related was published prior to granting the patent.


It does not mean that. The filer has to prove they invented the idea, which they can't do if you've published it prior to their filing.

But wouldn't that be exactly "first to invent" rather than "first to file"?


It's patents, so the terminology has to be confusing!

The "First to" is speaking about what happens in an interference proceeding between two patent applicants. What counts as prior art is largely unchanged— it's arguably even strengthened a bit (as a dishonest player could previously get away with more backdating of his lab notebooks).

Third party— that is, not derived from the applicant's work— public practice (which is pretty broad, including publication and use in a product available to the public) is an absolute bar to patentablity. After one year the "not derived" part goes away and even the applicants own publication (and work derived from it) constitute prior art. (this was all also the case before, though the details a somewhat subtly different)

To quote the statute:

(a) NOVELTY; PRIOR ART.—A person shall be entitled to a patent unless—

(1) the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention; or

[...]

(b) EXCEPTIONS.—

(1) DISCLOSURES MADE 1 YEAR OR LESS BEFORE THE EFFECTIVE FILING DATE OF THE CLAIMED INVENTION.—A disclosure made 1 year or less before the effective filing date of a claimed invention shall not be prior art to the claimed invention under subsection (a)(1) if—

(A) the disclosure was made by the inventor or joint inventor or by another who obtained the subject matter disclosed directly or indirectly from the inventor or a joint inventor; or

(B) the subject matter disclosed had, before such disclosure, been publicly disclosed by the inventor or a joint inventor or another who obtained the subject matter disclosed directly or indirectly from the inventor or a joint inventor.


Multiple people can independently invent the same thing, either over time or all at the same time. Whichever one files first, wins.


One of my concerns is that it gives the upper hand to large organization with the resources (including perhaps labor costs fixed to a certain degree by virtue of staff attorneys; also, filing fees) to file early and often.

Further entrenchment of IP as the purview of those who can afford it.

I'm glad to be proven wrong -- I'm not well-informed on this. But I fear it, both from my own limited thought exercise, and out of concern for the types of legal changes that are able to make it through the Federal process, these days, generally speaking.


First-to-invent also gave the upper hand to large organizations that had the manpower/resources to document every step of their invention process.

In all honesty, it's more of a wash.


Crashes the whole phone if I run it under Firefox on Android. I should probably report that, any crashing bug is a potential security vulnerability.


Sorry about that. I wrote the web code quite sloppily, and it was my first time. I just wanted to port my native C++/OpenGL code to the web.


Not your fault. If it crashes the whole phone, that's a bug in Firefox and/or Android. A Web app should never be able to crash the browser, and the browser shouldn't be able to crash the phone.


Actually, for a while, IE was the best browser available. It was lighter weight, faster than Netscape, and had better web standards support. Mozilla, with its new Gecko engine, took a long time to mature, and was still fairly slow and bloated until Firefox (née Phoenix) came around. Remember, IE was where several features that now form the basis of the modern web came from. Heard of something called XMLHttpRequest? That came from IE.


Yes, insurance is a bad idea for anything that you can afford to replace if you lose it.

If, however, losing that item would lead to your financial ruin (such as losing your home and everything in it), then the insurance is worthwhile. It's how you avoid "gamblers ruin". Yes, on average it's a net negative expected value, otherwise the insurance companies wouldn't offer it; but it prevents you from losing the bulk of your wealth in the event of disaster, and being unable to recover from said disaster.

It even says so at your link: if you can't afford to replace something, and must have it, then insurance makes sense.

So, it's worthwhile buying insurance for those things that you just can't replace: your house, your body. Things that are more replaceable? I have enough money saved up to by a new car if need be. If my car is stolen or totalled, I can replace it out of pocket; so I need only the bare minimum liability insurance, not accident insurance for my car.


> It even says so at your link: if you can't afford to replace something, and must have it, then insurance makes sense.

Yes, absolutely, if you cannot afford to lose the insured item, then you really should get insurance. But that leads to the insurance paradox: people who buy insurance tend to be people who cannot afford to lose their possessions because they buy insurance instead of becoming investors.


I don't think it's interesting in a "hey look, you can find porn on Google." It's interesting in that it's a bug that produces results for imposible queries, but for some reason seems to mostly turn up porn results. Is that just a statistical sampling; so much of Google's index is porn, that a random bug which picks up impossible results, that thus don't go through its safe search feature, is predominantly porn? Or is the bug somehow linked to the safe search feature, accidentally turning the blacklist into a whitelist?


So, Byrne used two examples; one about Rosa Parks, and one about Daniel Ellsberg. But he misses a few key points about both of them.

One is that Daniel Ellsberg did do his work surreptitiously. He didn't just openly take the documents, and accept being arrested while doing so. He took them secretly, then tried several different ways of publicizing them while insulating himself legally, including seeing if he could get a senator to enter them into the minutes, since you can't be prosecuted for official business on the senate floor. And when they were eventually released, he went into hiding for a while, before eventually deciding to turn himself in. And he did not, in the end, have to serve any time, as his case was thrown out due to many illegal actions taken by the government, including burgling Ellsberg's psychiatrists office, trying to bribe the judge, and illegally wiretapping Ellsberg.

However, nowadays the case is quite different. In the "post-9/11 world", there are many easier ways for the government to surreptitiously gather evidence. In fact, the government today has shown a willingness to pass laws granting retroactive immunity for illegal wiretapping. It's got to be a lot easier to feel despondent about your chances in a court case in todays world, especially with a prosecutor who has built his career on harsh prosecution of electronic crime.

And Rosa Parks is a completely different story than Ellsberg or Swartz. She was facing a $10 fine and $4 in court costs, not years in jail, hundreds of thousands to millions in fines, fees, and court costs, a felony conviction. While what she did is definitely laudable, it's a lot easier to accept the possibility of losing your case when the stakes are that much lower.

And Bradley Manning? He did something not too dissimilar to Ellsberg. But while Ellsberg got off free of charges, Brad Manning has been imprisoned for years without trial, including months of solitary confinement, and even a period of suicide watch in which he was not allowed clothes or a pillow at night.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: