Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

Some dairies do that, by including a $1 deposit on bottles. At $1, it's actually worth your while to collect and return the bottles to the store where you got them (likely when you go shopping for your next bottle of milk).


Norway has a bottle tax ranging from 0.5 to 2.5 NOK I think (been a while since I lived in Norway; 2.5NOK is roughly 43 cents), and a recycling rate for glass bottles of something like 99%.

The key, in addition to the bottle tax, is automated bottle collection machines in pretty much all grocery stores that'll issue receipts to be used to offset against purchases at the till. It's so convenient most people return them, and the bottle tax ensures most of those that gets thrown away gets picked up by kids or poorer people for the money.

Most undamaged glass bottles would be returned to bottlers by volume rather than origin, for washing and reuse, apart from Coke bottles for obvious reasons.

Though these days most of the bottles are still plastic, but are still largely recycled - even if the energy savings isn't all that huge, it still saves a lot of landfill space.


In Germany shopw have to charge you 25 eurocent when you buy a plastic bottle which they will return when you bring the bottle back.

No such thing exists for glass bottles but they do get recycled. There are even separate recycle bins for white, brown and green glass. Yes, germans take trash separation seriously (on a related note, people in Japan too).


I think you’re missing the point. It’s ‘reusing’ versus ’recycling’. When you throw bottles in a recycling bin, you can’t reuse them because they’re broken. It then takes a lot of energy to turn them into new bottles. It’s a lot better to keep the bottles intact, clean them, and fill them again. That’s what a few countries have chosen to do. The way it’s done in Germany is unfortunately a lot more common.


Actually, Germany does both. The 25ct thing is a more recent development.


These things certainly do exist.

Everything that you buy per crate is usually returned as a a crate with empty bottles again. Case in point: beer bottles.

Depending on brewery and type of bottle, I used to get beer that had the name of another beer printed on the (non-removable) snap-lock cap[1]. The same goes for a variety of other glass bottles. They are simply washed out (usually chemically), refilled, a new printed label is put on, a cap put on, done.

[1]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%BCgelverschluss


You're right, I have no idea how I forgot about this. Shame on me.


The charge on reusable glass bottles is 7ct in Germany for most bottles. No charge for one-way glass bottles which get recycled.


Denmark has these machines also, but I believe the vast majority of the bottles are now crushed anyway, rather than reused. The traditional standard bottles, mostly nowadays used by lower-end beer and soda manufacturers, are reused (you can tell by the scuffing around the middle of the bottle on reused bottles). They're made of thicker glass and are in a standardized shape. But most beer comes in bottles with thinner glass and unstandardized shape. I believe that started due to the EU ruling that Denmark's requirement for standardized bottles was de-facto a trade barrier, since it made it difficult for non-Danish beer manufacturers to export to the Danish market.


I knew this was working in Norway when the morning after some festival I saw young people use a small boat to gather all the bottles and cans in the nearby lake :)


In my town you can arbitrage them by buying quarts of yogurt at the farmers' market where the deposit is $1.25, and returning the bottles to the grocery store, that carries the same brand of yogurt in the same bottles, where they pay $1.50 for returns.


Reminds me how food stamps can be used to buy soda. Some people who had more than they needed would buy soda, pour it out, and return the bottle just for the deposit.

They fixed that by making the deposit not payable by the food stamp.


You know, people did manage to navigate before the advent of GPS based navigation systems. They looked at a map, planned out their route, watched for the appropriate streets, and if they got lost, stopped and looked at the map again.

If you have the offline map, you can still do this even if you can't use the GPS navigation feature.


No kidding. Thanks for sarcastically pointing out the obvious.

I can make coffee by pounding my own grinds and boiling water over a campfire. But if I wake up expecting to turn the coffee maker on and can't, it can throw off my day. Further Google Maps is a terrible, terrible way to handle navigate on a smartphone, especially in a dense urban area with layers of highways.


Apologies for the sarcasm. I was merely trying to point out that navigation may not be worth the ridiculous roaming charges, and instead just using it as a static map is possible.


> Canon, if you're a pro photographer. I assume Nikon has a similar support system for professionals. It's pretty amazing. Test/Evaluation loans on $15k lenses for weeks, emergency equipment loaners, dedicated support at major events (Superbowl, etc.).

Yes, but I believe you may need to be in a special "pro photographers club" that each of these manufacturers offer to get this kind of service. They don't do it for the average consumer.


Indeed:

http://www.cps.usa.canon.com/about_cps/about.shtml

Summary: you only get loaners and and such once you've purchased "20 CPS points" worth of stuff, which seems to roughly amount to $12-15K worth of gear.


It's a lot less than 12-15k for the Gold tier; more like a couple $1-2k bodies and $3k of lenses (which could be used), which is pretty standard for even the lowest end professional. The $100/yr membership at that tier is more of an issue.

For the top tier, it's probably $10-20k of gear, and $500/yr.


I guess Tesla buyers cannot be considered "average consumers" either :)


> If you want protection from injury on your bicycle, you are better off with a motorcycle helmet than a bicycle helmet, end of story.

Remember that protection is a balancing act. You are reducing the already low chance of catastrophic injury. However, in exchange for that, you are increasing your weight, drag, reducing your ventilation, giving yourself helmet hair, increasing the sweat your head is bathed in at the end of the ride, etc. Tossing a motorcycle helmet in may reduce your risk of injury even further, but remember, catastrophic crashes are relatively rare, they can kill you in many other ways than simple head injury, and a motorcycle helmet is way too heavy, hot, and unventilated for riding a bike, as well as restricting your vision and hearing and thus probably making it more likely for you to be involved in a crash. I would be very surprised if motorcycle helmets actually made you safer once you took all of this, as well as the effect of suppressing your desire to ride due to the discomfort and inconvenience (thus losing the benefits of the exercise it provides), into account.


> most programmers want C

Hmm. I've always thought that most programmers want languages that offer more abstraction than C. C is probably about the opposite of what you want, since it's a fairly low level language targeting a fairly different model of computation than an FPGA. What you want is higher-level tools that are designed and built around this much more parallel model, not something that allows you to compile C to an FPGA.

In fact, I think that there would be a lot more interest in creating better languages and tools for FPGAs, if there were actually open documentation on the low levels of how to program FPGAs, so people could actually write their own tools targeting them. But most vendors seem to just provide their own Verilog compilers with onerous licensing restrictions, and there's little portability between hardware, so there's nothing really good to target.


AFAIK C is by far the most prevalent language for embedded systems, which are typically the applications FPGA's are also used for.


The last time I looked into FPGA programming (probably back when I was in college), the cheap eval hardware cost at least a few hundred dollars a board, if not a few thousand. For something that would just be a toy to play around with, it was too much to justify spending money on.

On top of that, the tooling is all proprietary, clunky, with obnoxious licensing. If you notice, that eval board you pointed to comes with "ISE® WebPACK® software with device locked SDK and ChipScope™ Pro licenses". I'm just not interested at all in any "device-locked SDKs".

And finally, there's a bootstrapping problem. FPGAs aren't really a mass-market platform, because no one has them (unless they're developing custom hardware).

If there are now $90 eval boards, that solves part of the problem. Another big step would be building a reasonable toolchain around it that does not consist of big clunky proprietary tools with onerous licensing.

And finally, someone will need to start shipping FPGAs with a standardized interface on commodity hardware. If I can depend on their being an FPGA in a phone, in a workstation, or in COTS server hardware, there are lot more possible applications. As it is, you already have to be building your own hardware before an FPGA is something you would want to target at all. The vast majority of programmers write code to run on COTS hardware (servers, desktops, mobile), not custom hardware.


And finally, someone will need to start shipping FPGAs with a standardized interface on commodity hardware.

If Apple included an FPGA in their machines with some cool sounding marketing name like Particle Accelerator™ it would probably catch on.

The last time I looked into FPGA programming (probably back when I was in college), the cheap eval hardware cost at least a few hundred dollars a board, if not a few thousand.

Not sure when you were in college, but we used FPGAs in my upper level computer engineering courses, circa 2006, and the Xilinx dev boards we used were about $120.


> Another big step would be building a reasonable toolchain around it that does not consist of big clunky proprietary tools with onerous licensing.

While I think a toolchain other than Xilinx or Altera is out of the question due to technical complexity, Quartus Web Edition is free and supports the low-cost Cyclone devices including the ones with ARM cores (SoC): (pdf) http://www.altera.com/literature/po/ss_quartussevswe.pdf. I imagine Xilinx has something similar.

> And finally, there's a bootstrapping problem. FPGAs aren't really a mass-market platform, because no one has them (unless they're developing custom hardware).

Yes, that's the chicken/egg problem that both Xilinx and Altera are addressing by putting ARM cores on their devices that run just fine without any FPGA configuration at all. It's an appeal to software developers while pitching the FPGA hardware as a super-special add-on feature really cool to have for ... something.

Altera has just started shipping the first SoC devices I think, about 6 months or so behind Xilinx. Now we'll see if the strategy works...


The problem with eval boards is the tendency to explode price upward by sticking peripherals on the board. Sure, a 10/100 ethernet intf sounds cool and it'll only add $5... times 50 other devices and next thing you know you have one of those cool, but expensive Digilent boards that has more I/O options than you could ever use, but costs $200.

If you just want a nearly bare FPGA google for "micronova fpga mercury" and for $60 you get a DIP-64 circuit board with quite a few I/O and that's about it. No on board graphic LCD. No on board VGA output jack and D/A interface. Think, the basic stamp from 20 years ago, now a FPGA dev tool. I have one sitting on my desk waiting to fool around with it (I have a lot on my desk...)

Also all the software is free now. Maybe limited such that you need a license to synthesize for a $2000 chip, which doesn't matter. Pretty much if your average garage hacker can afford the dev board, the limits on the software don't matter. Closed source, but available for linux and windows and free.


Papilio one and papilio pro are both under $100

Vendor - https://www.sparkfun.com/products/11158

OEM - http://papilio.cc/


You can have a small FPGA test board here http://be.eurocircuits.com/shop/offtheshelf/product.aspx?&an... for 60€. The tutorials (non-free) can be found there http://www.elektor.com/magazines/2012/december/taming-the-be...


That only addresses the one point (expense of the test boards), which as I pointed out, is the one major problem that has been solved (I consider a $90 dev board reasonably affordable for tinkering, so a $70 dev board is better, but not by much).

It doesn't seem to solve the other two problems, though I suspect that solving the second (lack of open tools) would go a long way towards solving the third as well (ubiquity of hardware available to target).


The proprietary software is always going to be there (unfortunately).

The precise hardware layout of an FPFA is important for performance and a trade secret. Proprietary software algorithms can squeeze more out of the fixed hardware.


If proprietary software is why I'm not buying an FPGA (and if there are a lot of people like me) there will be much more to be made opening things up than keeping things closed. Not saying that this is the case, just that it could be, so "always" might be an overstatement.


I hope you're right, I work at Red Hat after all.

However I still don't think it's likely. The trouble is this is all tied to the hardware. FPGAs are integrated circuits with a complexity and development cost close to that of CPUs. (The fact that you can only use about 4% of the density of the FPGA is beside the point here). Because of this huge barrier to entry -- building your own fab -- we don't have fully open source x86-compatible high end processors, and we don't have open FPGAs either.

As long as the hardware is closed, the software for doing FPGA design is also going to be closed, for the reasons I outlined in my comment above.


Yeah, it's more hope than expectation; it just seems unlikely not absurd though.


If you're interested in a non-proprietary toolflow, you can try taking a look at VPR (http://www.eecg.toronto.edu/vpr/). It's an academic place and route tool out of the University of Toronto. You may still need to use some parts of the proprietary toolflow. I've never used it to actually run on an FPGA, but it's a popular tool for academic research in FPGA design and EDA algorithms.



> a local sheriff trying to find a missing child

As worthy as these cases might be... this is not a national security issue. This kind of case should never use any law regarding national security. This is a regular police investigation, and as such, should require a regular old subpoena or warrant.


They did not say that those requests use national security laws. They are just giving us the total number of accounts they have released information on regardless of what law was used to compel release.


Ah, you're right, now that I read it closer, that is the case. Thanks for the clarification.


But, the part you quoted said "legal and necessary". They were trying to convince Congress of both, because both are necessary for the surveillance to be acceptable.

They weren't saying that they were trying to convince Congress that it was "legal or necessary", which is what you seem to be complaining about.


Necessity plays a large role in determining whether something is legal.

Many court opinions about a law or government action hinge on whether there is a compelling state interest in the result. When balancing what a government does against rights defined by the bill of rights, you need to show that there is a good reason for the government to do what it's doing beyond simply denying the people their guaranteed rights.

For example, you may have laws about having a parade without a permit. Now, if you took an extreme view on the first amendment, you might say this abridged the rights of the people to peaceably assemble and speak their mind. However, there is a compelling state interest in controlling access to the roads that are shared by everyone; if anyone could parade at any time, it would screw up traffic. So governments are allowed to require a parade permit, as long as the requirements for obtaining one are content-neutral and don't single out any particular groups.

Likewise, whether the spying is legal does depend on whether it's necessary. The fourth amendment clearly says "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures..." Whether the search is reasonable plays a large role in whether it's legal. Thus, necessity is important, as well as being legal in the sense of having followed the letter of the law (gone through the appropriate warrant process, as outlined by the various laws and regulations that control it).


Yes, but it has an exception for treason and felonies, and disclosing classified information may count as at least a felony, if not treason.


> Yes, but it has an exception for treason and felonies

There are two separate parts:

1. While they are attending a session they can't be arrested, and

2. They can't be held accountable in any other forum based on the content of any speech or debate in either House.

The exception for for treason, felonies, and "breach of peace" applies to the first; the second, is an absolute, unqualified immunity, and, as applied by the Supreme Court, applies to all "legislative acts", which includes quite a bit that is not physically on the floor during a general session of the House.


As numerous commentators have pointed out, treason is a ridiculously high standard that has rarely been met. It has been misapplied so often by politicians using hyperbole that most people don't understand the meaning anymore.

It requires not just "aid and comfort" to the enemy, but also "adherence to the enemy" actively waging war against the United States, according to Supreme Court precedent. You cannot accidentally commit treason.


It's quite explicitly a felony; it's questionable whether it's treason but similar things have been treated as such in the past.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: