Note that Evil Governments can much more easily flick the switch to cars than maintain roadblocks.
Take a look at Syria, or Egypt. Egypt actually did shut down the internet[1] during unrest. The Syrian government has tried to suppress an uprising, but has not been successful in doing so. It take a lot more resources to actually hold and maintain an effective roadblock than it does to just flick a switch. Imagine how much easier it would have been for them if they could just flick the switch and shut down all of the rebel's cars.
This is not some abstract hypothetical point, there are actually cases out there today with oppressive governments who would have incentive to use this technology nefariously.
But beyond that, there are more mundane concerns as well. After the subprime loan crisis, dealers started including remote disablers in cars, so they could remotely repo cars if the owners defaulted. However, a disgruntled former employee has used those disablers to disable hundreds of cars that had them[2].
Honestly, a good decision is a good decision, and I'm not going to worry too much about who in particular was able to argue it.
Had it been a small non-profit, or some bootstrapped startup, they may have been able to get cheap representation via the EFF or some other group that defends the public interest.
> Had it been a small non-profit, or some bootstrapped startup, they may have been able to get cheap representation via the EFF or some other group that defends the public interest.
And they very likely would have lost.
I think that cft is insinuating that the law is not the same for the wealthy and well-connected and the poor.
the law is not the same for the wealthy and well-connected and the poor
Precedent-setting may not be for the lone wolf without a nickel to his name, but it's rare in any ecosystem that the penniless loner can turn around as monstrous a ship as the US legal system.
I'm disappointed that they didn't mention that this is hooked to an online service until you get well into their FAQ:
Maintaining the integrity of your Coin’s data is
critical to your peace of mind. That’s why our servers,
mobile apps and the Coin itself use 128-bit or 256-bit
encryption for all storage and communication (http and
bluetooth). Additionally Coin can alert you in the
event that you leave it somewhere.
If this were purely a hardware device and software than ran on my phone, I might be interested. Adding in an online service appears to add more points of failure, and more opportunity for yet another third party to snoop on my behavior. It would be nice if they described in more detail why this online service was necessary, what data was stored there, and what privacy protections they provide.
Also disappointing that it doesn't support chip and pin. Whenever I travel to the UK, I find that people are increasingly surprised by cards that don't have a chip, and need to fumble around trying to remember how to use the card reader; it would be nice if this would be an opportunity for me to get a chip and pin compatible card out of my mag stripe card to avoid that problem (though on reflection, it's likely that a mag stripe doesn't contain sufficient information to make a valid chip and pin card).
$100 for something that lasts for two years and solves only a minor annoyance seems a bit steep. I'm sure that there will be plenty of people who will buy it, but I don't know if I would find it worth the cost beyond the novelty value.
The cloud part concerns me just from a functionality point of view. Does it require internet connectivity just for basic operation? It doesn't seem totally clear. I would certainly hope not.
I hate to sound incredibly cynical, but this sounds like a perfect example of Silicon Valley fluff that will never become mainstream. They aren't even the first SV company to be working on this product.
You picked a valid point of concern (if Coin requires connectivity for basic operation), assumed the negative, and then used that assumption to denounce the company as "Silicon Valley fluff that will never become mainstream". Stylised: if A then shit -> I think A -> hence shit.
Q. What if I lose my phone?
A. When you pair your Coin with your phone, it is associated with your account and not that specific phone/device. If you lose your phone, it is possible to pair your Coin with your new phone after installing the Coin mobile app and signing in.
I think the online service has the potential to be the most valuable part of this whole product. All your transactions, across multiple accounts, tracked in one place allowing breakdowns of your spending and clarity on our outgoings. I also see a big win here for Coin, think Mint but with an opportunity to also suggest better products & services to spend your money on (since they'll know almost everything you're buying) - a marketer's dream.
Marketers already have access to all your purchases.
Your bank statement has ads. Your credit card issuer sells your transactions to their partners. Retailers sell your data to data processing companies. The three big scoring companies have access to all your key financial information - and they sell it back to you (in the form of credit score monitoring services), and to marketers. DSPs allow marketers to bid on impressions at a very precise level, based on which sites you visited yesterday.
Marketer's dreams were already fulfilled years ago. They have a more data than most can handle.
Coin can become the credit card of credit cards. They could offer financing, revolving credit, analytics (like Mint), and tons of other financial products based on credit history. These are a lot more interesting - and profitable - than selling ads (or data) to marketers.
It's an obvious idea, but (apparently) nicely executed. It's a perfect acquisition target for Square. Or Visa/MC/Amex.
> I think the online service has the potential to be the most valuable part of this whole product.
This is assumed to be from the user's point of view (rather than from the point of view of the company -- generating revenue -- or from an interested 3rd party).
Then you end with this:
> a marketer's dream
So is Coin targeting marketers, and the users are the product to be sold like so many other start-ups to come out of the Valley?
I'm not sure Vimeo is really the right platform. Vimeo seems a lot more targeted towards the art of videography itself, so comments about technique and editing and so on are a lot more common, rather than the actual content of the video.
I would say that Java is a more common bytecode than ACPI. Sure, if you just consider desktop or laptops, ACPI will be more common, but feature phones all generally include a Java VM, and the baseband on smartphones generally do too. For that matter, SIM cards themselves include a Java Card interpreter, which interprets a stripped down version off JVM bytecode. Your phone may contain two or three different variants of JVM just to make a phone call.
Furthermore, exactly what you consider to be a bytecode vs a machine language can be a bit of an open question. After all, Intel CPUs don't actually execute the x86 instruction set directly, the execute microcode which translates the instruction set into the actual instructions that the CPU executes. So you could say that x86 is the ultimate bytecode. And hey, for a while Mac OS X had PowerPC emulation support, and before that System 7 has 68k emulation support. On the other hand, people have implemented Java in hardware, so today's bytecode may become tomorrow's machine language, and vice versa.
edit: Can whoever downvoted please provide an explanation? This comment is on topic and polite; if you disagree, please explain, as I would be interested to know why. If there's something that's incorrect, a correction would be appreciated.
I don't really care which bytecode is the "most popular". I just thought it would be cool to introduce people to some specified bytecode running inside subsystems that you probably didn't think anything about before.
Jasper that was a fabulous start to the morning. A morsel of hacker news on hacker news. Thanks.
Would be interested in your thoughts about code generation -
I'm writing a VM, playing with ideas. I have wondered at this as an approach to software development: whenever you have a significant task to do, first build a virtual machine. Then create bytecode to satisfy your application.
You can have a rich instruction set to meet your needs - writing performant or hardware-oriented features in C, but getting easy access to them through your upstream high-level language. Highly portable, no library dependencies.
I'm fine at hand-editing bytecode, but code generation from a high-level language is still a mystery to me. I want to find a notation that gives me enough power to deal with high-level concepts, but for which it is easy to write a compiler to bytecode.
Currently options in mind: scheme (lots of resources, but might be too complicated - can tail recursion be done simply? adequate GC?); forth; some subset of C; something fancy with ometa.
Or, could I just write scheme functions to output machine code, and build my application logic in macros that on top of that. This bypasses the need for a conventional compiler.
I like the idea of scheme functions to output machine code. If you know scheme, you're probably already familiar with this, but since you say code generation is a mystery, let me recommend SICP (http://mitpress.mit.edu/sicp/full-text/book/book.html).
I scratch around at SICP every few months, and generally get stuck because there's a lot of assumption of mathematics knowledge in there that I don't have. But I started to watch the MIT lectures just last weekend. I'll keep at it, sounds like I'm on the right track. Thanks :)
I don't really think it's that important either, and I thought it was an interesting article that described some bytecodes people might not be familiar with, but you had started your article with "What is the most commonly used bytecode language in the world?" and I was responding to that question.
I suspect that it's JVM, due to it's ubiquity in phones, and thought it might be worth pointing out since most people don't know that they have a JVM subset running on their SIM card. We really do have miniature bytecode interpreters running everywhere; and vulnerabilities can lead to security issues that allow your SIM card itself to be rooted[1]
It's fascinating to learn about all of the hidden bytecode implementations scattered about and a bit alarming that some are so complicated. As for most common, when counting up the tally for the JVM, you must include all Blu-ray players too. The interactive menus on a Blu-ray disc are implemented via a java program on the disc.
Why don't you just buy Ensure or Carnation Instant Breakfast? They already exist and are well known, that you can buy anywhere. Or make yourself a bowl of oatmeal. Or eat leftovers from the night before.
I think that the only reason that anyone's interested in Soylent is the current startup/crowdfunding bubble hype, not because it's actually anything particularly new. Soylent is to Ensure as Groupon is to coupons. Before the hype, on select groups (people who were too sick to eat, middle-aged housewives) would be into each of them, but once you add the startup/crowdfunding/Internet angle, all of a sudden a bunch of 20 somethings take a fascination in something that they otherwise would have sneered at.
Can you really compare products like Ensure or Carnation Instant Breakfast to Soylent? Pick up any of those products in a store and you'll see that half of the ingredients have nothing to do with nutritional value and are about making the product taste better. I'm holding a bottle of Nestle's "Boost" meal replacement drink right now and here are the main ingredients:
Just because something is "well known" doesn't make it better. Nestle is not a company with an outstanding global reputation and if given the choice between trusting them or a company like Soylent, I'm going to choose Soylent.
Like others here, I view Soylent as an interesting experiment. I enjoy a nice meal as much as the next person but I also appreciate the value of something fast, simple and nutritionally complete that can be used from time to time as supplementation when you don't feel the need to sit down for an actual meal.
I'm not sure flavorlessness will make Soylent more popular. Most people like to have at least some flavor.
My point is that there already are a lot of products out there that are "fast, simple, and nutritionally complete that can be used from time to time as supplementation when you don't feel the need to sit down for an actual meal," but I don't see everyone who's so excited about Soylent already using them on a regular basis. OK, perhaps you would prefer to have something without sugar in it (I'm not sure why you would object to the other ingredients, fats and salts are essential parts of your diet), but I would think that if Soylent were going to be as popular as people make it out to be, there would already be lots of people replacing meals with existing meal replacements. All Soylent offers over the others is that it's bland, as far as I can tell.
I'm not saying the existing, well known ones are better. Just that they haven't revolutionized food or replaced traditional meals on a large scale or anything.
There are plenty of people who do already replace occasional meals with these existing meal replacers, along with energy bars and the like. So, Soylent will be one more out of a large number of choices in this field, produced by people with no particular food industry experience, and more bland than the rest. Is that supposed to get me excited about "the future of food"?
I can imagine people who already do use existing meal replacers, but having some particular problem with them that Soylent solves, might go for this. And then there's the Silicon Valley hype bubble, where a bunch of people will buy it and drink it for lunch for a month or two before getting bored and excited by the next big new thing (Twitter to your shoes! Personal Instagram quadcopter follow bot! Distributed decentralized FarmVille/GTA hybrid!)
The reason I'm so baffled by this is that it's hard to imagine why so many people would get excited about yet another product in an already crowded marketplace that's fairly niche (well, fairly niche for people who use them as their primary nutrition; relatively large for people who use it to replace an occasional meal). I don't see anything revolutionary about Soylent; it's yet another meal replacer.
Ensure tastes like shit. If Soylent tastes reasonably OK, and has stronger guarantees that it can be a true meal replacement than supplements like Ensure, then sign me up.
I was replying to a comment that suggested he was interested in using it merely as a supplement (replacing only lunch). Ensure is perfectly capable of doing that. I'm not sure what "stronger guarantees" Soylent would have. Ensure has been used to replace meals for tons of sick people for 40 years; why do you think that a few computer geeks will be able to suddenly do better than 40 years of industrial research?
As far as the taste, it's too soon to tell. Indications are that it's pretty flavorless http://gawker.com/we-drank-soylent-the-weird-food-of-the-fut... (outside of joking reactions like "It was great and I love it. I don't want to eat anymore.") Given that they aren't particularly focusing on trying to make it taste good ("I'm not trying to make something delicious; there are already a lot of delicious things. It's all about efficiency, it's about cost and convenience."), I doubt it will wind up tasting much better than Ensure.
I just don't get all of the excitement over Soylent. It seems like a solution in search of a problem. It's pretty damn easy to get a healthy diet for cheap and extremely low effort, as long as you don't care about flavor and variety. Rice, beans, and grated cheese covers pretty much all of your nutritional needs (maybe toss in a multivitamin per day to be on the safe side), takes about 5 minutes of work and 15 minutes of waiting for it to simmer, you can prepare a week's worth in advance and reheat it over the course of the week, and it will cost you less than $5 per day in the US. How is Soylent supposed to be so much better than that that it will "disrupt the world food system"?
Given how much of a problem some people here seem to have with normal food (though it only seems to have happened after seeing the Soylent marketing materials, I didn't know anyone who complained about how much trouble eating was before the Soylent hype), it's hard to tell if you're being sarcastic or serious. I suppose I've just run up against the Silicon Valley Hype Machine version of Poe's Law.
Given how bad the hype has become (Soylent appears to me to be about as useful and likely to be successful as Pets.com), I think it's time to start shoring a bunch of Silicon Valley stock; we appear to have hit the next bubble. The problem is that outside of Twitter and Facebook, no one has really gone public recently, so it's a lot harder to actually short these silly companies.
I've been complaining about how much trouble eating was since I realized I was underweight maybe 6-7 years ago. I've narrowed it down to some kind of mental problem that makes me chew 3-5x longer than other people. I therefore get full 3-5x sooner and it's hard to eat enough calories.
I've tried supplements and eating very dense foods (lots of grease and carbs) with lukewarm results but if Soylent works as promised, it'll basically change my life.
That said, my comment was meant to be humourous and I totally understand how people who don't have problems with normal food might view Soylent. It's the ultimate first-world problem.
If you try Soylent, and dislike it, there are other products that are calorie dense that may help. (This is not medical advice, see a doctor, etc etc).
I know of Ensure Plus because I know lots of people with anorexia, and it's used during refeeding programs. (Sometimes as a drink, and sometimes through an NG tube).
OK, so it was a mix of sarcastic and serious. Good to know.
Sure, there may be some people in specialized circumstances that have problems with normal food, though there are a lot of options already (smoothies, existing meal replacements like Ensure, possibly even bodybuilding focused meal replacements as they tend to focus on being high-calorie, soups, etc). And yeah, Soylent does seem like the ultimate first-world-problem food.
Anyhow, good luck with trying to get more calories in your diet, and if Soylent helps you with that, all the better!
I'm commuting 2+ hours twice a week for school, and I don't have time to actually eat (real) food in between work and school. Having a decent meal replacement for that is helpful, so that I don't end up eating garbage.
I drank ensure pretty much every day for about 15 years due to health issues. Every flavor tasted terrible, and it was always presented as a supplement by my doctor. Maybe it's better now this was 10-15 years ago
Farting or burping is something that is involuntary, natural, and brief.
Smoking or vaporizing is something that people choose to do for extended periods of time, and doing so in an enclosed space, especially many people doing it at once, can fill air in that enclosed space with the byproducts, which may be harmful.
If people drank something that made them burp constantly, permeated the air with the smell of those burps, and that vapor was harmful, then absolutely that should not be allowed (beer does not quite count; you don't generally burp continuously while drinking it, though it may cause an occasional burp, and it doesn't cause a lingering, carcinogenic vapor to permeate the space).
Smokers huddling in the doorway means there's a nice big cloud of smoke that I need to walk through and breath in, which then gets blown into the bar as soon as I open the door. Even if smoking in completely unconfined spaces is harmless due to the smoke dissipating too quickly to be concentrated enough to cause harm, what winds up happening when you ban smoking indoors is that people just smoke huddled up in the doorway (especially if you live somewhere cold, where the smokers huddle in the door for a quick smoke, and then drop their butts all over the ground).
Setting aside the danger, it's quite obnoxious. It's a powerful, unpleasant odor to many people, and can trigger asthma attacks.
Smokers seem to believe that because they want to inhale something, everyone else around them must want to inhale it as well. Why do they think that?
Anyhow, if it is shown that there's no secondhand risk from e-cigs, and they turn out to be less obnoxious than regular cigarettes (I've never walked through a cloud of vapor from a bunch of people using e-cigs, so I can't say), then I would be happy to allow them. As long as they don't affect me, I welcome you putting whatever you want into your body. Heck, I'd welcome them if it meant not having the huddling smokers outside and pile of discarded butts on the ground. But if they are harmful, or if they do lead to obnoxious odors (and I find many perfumes offensive and wish those were banned too, so telling me that they are flavored or smell nice won't help), they should be treated similarly to any other form of smoking.
They release vapors that contain nicotine into the atmosphere. There has been comparatively little study on the dangers of second hand nicotine vapor vs. secondhand smoke, but I would be hesitant to assume that there is no danger.
I could also imagine that they could reduce the social pressure against smoking, as people would be seen happily puffing away on e-cigs which, from a distance, look an awful lot like regular cigarettes. Impressionable kids, people who have quit smoking but may be tempted to go back, etc. will now see smoking suddenly becoming socially acceptable again. Some people may see it and think that smoking is allowed wherever this is, and then light up a real cigarette.
There's a further sort of puritanical attitude that many people have towards smoking, I think due to the fact that it was so prevalent and so obnoxious for much of the 20th century. Much as some people have a puritanical attitude about drinking (and we still have ridiculous laws stemming from that), that attitude may persist about smoking even if e-cigs turn out to be much less obnoxious than cigarettes.
You have to remember, there are plenty of people who were non-smokers during the middle of the 20th century, when you couldn't go to a bar that wasn't saturated in smoke, where you had to breathe in secondhand smoke almost everywhere (even in the non-smoking section of restaurants, it would still waft over from the smoking section), where if you lent something to a smoker it would come back reeking of smoke. The idea of losing ground on the fight that was just recently won, of not allowing it in most indoor public places, makes non-smokers fairly anxious.
Now, if it can be demonstrated that secondhand vapor from e-cigs is perfectly safe, and that it doesn't permeate the air with the same foul smell, then maybe their introduction would be welcomed.
After all of the damage we've done over the years by rapidly accepting new technologies that wind up poisoning the air (see, for example, secondhand smoke, leaded gasoline, diacetyl, asbestos, the Great Smog of '52 and the continuing smog problems in Beijing today), we need to be less willing to simply assume that releasing something into the air we all breathe is perfectly safe, and instead only allow it once it has been demonstrated to be safe.
As far as I can tell, e-cigs only started becoming popular in the last few years. While I'm fine with people using them in their own homes or outdoors (since there's a certain level of concentration below which it's not worth worrying about anything), I'd be very skeptical of accepting them in establishments in which smoking is not allowed without further study.
I'm not saying anything about the safety of the vapor one way or the other. I've seen people cite studies saying it is safe, I've seen people cite studies saying they are not safe, I've seen even more people say that the whole deal has yet to be studied. I don't use the things, so frankly I can't be arsed to get to the bottom of it.
All I'm poking at are what I do perceive to be irrational arguments against them.
Arguments like:
> "Impressionable kids"
Ban real cigarettes in movies and outdoors then.
> "people who have quit smoking but may be tempted to go back"
No special considerations like this are afforded to recovering alcoholics.
> "The idea of losing ground on the fight that was just recently won, of not allowing it in most indoor public places, makes non-smokers fairly anxious."
Their anxiety is irrational, indoor smoking is not making a comeback. If second hand e-cig vapor is a concern, it is an independent concern.
I pretty much agree that those are fairly weak or irrational arguments. You do have to understand that psychology plays a large factor in the politics of this. If people want e-cigs to become socially acceptable in places that cigarettes currently are not, they probably shouldn't call them e-cigs and probably shouldn't style them to look like cigarettes. If they are marketed instead as vaporizers (or maybe something else, since "vaporizer" to me implies cannabis, and that's even less socially acceptable to some people than tobacco), in shapes that aren't reminiscent as cigarettes or cigars at all, they are a lot more likely to be accepted by people who have been trained over the years to cringe from anything smoking related.
However, before I'm willing to support e-cigs in indoor public places, I would like good evidence from independent third parties about the safety of secondhand e-cig vapor. The problem is that there's a catch-22; this kind of information is hard to obtain without them being popular enough and acceptable enough to reach the same numbers of people in indoor places at approximately the same concentration as smokers, and for long enough for long-term affects like cancer and heart disease to become distinguishable. I'm not really sure the best way to address that kind of problem; of safely studying something that has the potential to be harmful in the long term, but also has the potential to displace something even more harmful.
Wintel just refers to the instruction set, not the actual processor. The reason for using it in this case is that since ActiveX are compiled for x86, they won't run on other platforms that Windows runs on. In the past, Windows NT ran on PowerPC, Alpha, MIPS, and Itanium platforms; now Windows runs on ARM in the form of Windows Phone and Surface. So it's not just IE on Windows that is relevant for ActiveX, it's IE on Windows on x86. But that's a mouthful to say, so people abbreviate it to "Wintel".
Take a look at Syria, or Egypt. Egypt actually did shut down the internet[1] during unrest. The Syrian government has tried to suppress an uprising, but has not been successful in doing so. It take a lot more resources to actually hold and maintain an effective roadblock than it does to just flick a switch. Imagine how much easier it would have been for them if they could just flick the switch and shut down all of the rebel's cars.
This is not some abstract hypothetical point, there are actually cases out there today with oppressive governments who would have incentive to use this technology nefariously.
But beyond that, there are more mundane concerns as well. After the subprime loan crisis, dealers started including remote disablers in cars, so they could remotely repo cars if the owners defaulted. However, a disgruntled former employee has used those disablers to disable hundreds of cars that had them[2].
[1]: http://www.renesys.com/2011/01/egypt-leaves-the-internet/
[2]: http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/03/hacker-bricks-cars/