Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more lambda's commentslogin

Some people do abuse this to rip companies off, to varying degrees; I know some people who treat returns as free rentals, buying something, using it without ever intending to keep it, and then returning it. Some people go even further and steal things and then return them for cash.

But I guess that on the whole, the good customer experience for the honest customers outweighs the cost of fraud.


REI has a 100% satisfaction guaranteed. About a year or two ago I purchased a few different bicycle parts. I kept them without using them for a few months and decided I didn't really need them after all. Since they were a few hundred dollars worth of parts I didn't want to just keep them or get rid of them, I wanted to return them. Even though their policy is "satisfaction" guaranteed, I felt like I was abusing the good faith of the policy--knowing just how heavily discounted their garage sale items are.

What I ended up deciding to do was returning them but asking for an 80% refund. The guy behind the counter gave me a really weird look and told me he had to ask if that was even allowed. Luckily for me, it was. They refunded me 80% of the total amount and I called it fair.



EDIT: My apologies. It looks like I'll need to have a discussion with my friend about this.


> "If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this."

That is a poor assumption that is likely incorrect more often than not.

A Chinese restaurant that I go to occasionally has a bowl of mints by the register. I could take a handful of them, they would not stop me, but that would be a dick move. I could go hang out at library and pass the time by taking their books off the shelves and building castles with them on the desks, but that would be a dick move. I could go to the shoe store and try on every single pair of shoes that they have, leaving them all in a massive pile in the middle of the store, but that would be a dick move.

Generous customer-friendly policies like this can exist, for the benefit of the customer, because there is an understanding that most people will be respectful and not abuse the privilege. If everybody acted like your friend, then we would not be able to have nice things.


With policies like these, companies account for the % of times abuse is likely to happen. Retailers and manufacturers spend millions analyzing buying and returning patterns and factor that into prices.

So "abuse" over time could cause prices to increase by a small amount. However, not hassling people over things that rarely happen increases loyalty, which increases volume, which increases the discounts a retailer can get from a manufacturer...

The vast majority of people don't need to benchmark video cards or want to "rent" products - they buy things because they need them and that's why good customer service exists.


I would guess that the abuse has increased for Best Buy and Game Stop.

Game Stop now only offers returns for pre-owned games 7 days after instead of 14 days. My guess is too many people used this as a way to test games out or beat single player games for free.

Best Buy's return policy is down from 30 days to 14 and even on an exchange I needed a driver's license last week.


Retailers also plan on a base level of shoplifting and employee theft, referred to as "shrinkage". However that isn't an excuse for that sort of bad behavior.


> > "If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this." > That is a poor assumption that is likely incorrect more often than not.

As a concrete example, I worked someplace with a nice and consumer friendly return policy... no restock fees, no hassle.

But when a customer "bought" and then without fail returned something like 40 books, 1 at a time (without buying anything else), we did have a word with them. Depending on the books, that can adds up to several hundred dollars of overstock, eating up already crammed inventory space in high-rent storefronts. Plenty of seating for those who'd like to read books without buying that won't excite our inventory count ;)


Regarding returning things without a receipt:

Once upon a time, it used to be possible to get Bing points by playing a bunch of stupid games on Club Bing - you could accumulate at most 1000 per day, unless there was some sort of modifier (like "double ticket day") site-wide. The prizes available for these points were usually older Microsoft products like old games (9.99USD), kitchen appliances, hammocks, cheap headphones, etc. The biggest prizes were Zunes, Vista, Microsoft Office, and the XBox360 Arcade Edition. As I recall, the XBox required some crazy amount of points and thus wasn't worth it...and Vista and Office are hardly sexy items. You could win at most one of each prize per physical mailing address.

The games that you played to win points were flash games, so a bunch of bot writers automated this. They'd register multiple accounts and try to max out the number of points they could get per day. Since users had multiple accounts, people would maintain different amounts of points to save for the big ticket items. I believe that Office and Vista were in the 50,000 to 100,000 point range. (Side note: Microsoft was slow, but they DID actually deliver - I got a 360 controller for free!) There are forums dedicated to "opportunities" like these.

So, what do you do with a free copy of Vista Ultimate? Well, one day a user who had exhausted all of the other prizes tried going to Best Buy with his copy. He went to customer service, in-store, and said "Hey, my grandmother got me this for my birthday. I already have it. Is there any way you could possibly help me out?"

Can you guess what they did? They gave him $450 in Best Buy credit.

For awhile, the overarching Club Bing metagame was to simply farm Vista Ultimate, go to a different Best Buy, and "return" your copy. And, on top of that, someone discovered that Microsoft's shipping treated "123 N. Fake Street Apartment A" and "123 N. Fake Street Apartment Z" (and, for that matter, "123 N. Fake Street Apartment AAAA") as unique addresses - so it became possible to have multiple copies of Vista Ultimate shipped to your house. At one point there were so many Club Bing copies of Vista Ultimate floating around that you could go on forums and purchase it directly for $100 because botters had exhausted their local return options.


So those pitiful statistics on Vista usage were -- inflated?


It was still Vista, though.


I love that story.


If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.

Why would a company want you to do that?! The only reason some allow it is that it's very difficult to have a policy that allows honest customers to return items they don't like (for whatever reasons) while at the same time preventing this behavior.

You'll find that there are many companies who have stopped the practice of accepting returns for any reason, for the very reason you stated. If you were running a product company, would you enjoy and encourage the "free rental" behavior?


I remember swinging by Home Depot just before a big winter storm. One of the sales guys mentioned that they didn't have any generators in stock because people would buy them, leave them in the box, and return them if they didn't lose power during the storm. Presumably, they wouldn't return the generators if they were actually used due to a power outage. I seriously doubt that Home Depot wanted their customers to do that. Large companies do sometimes keep track of how many returns people rack up over time to identify bad actors (that's much harder with "no receipt" or "no questions asked" policies).

On the other hand, Kragen advertises that they have a loaner tool program. It's essentially a liberal return policy, as long as you don't break the tool while trying to repair your car. I have used that, when I had a functioning tool to return when I was done with the job.


My guess is that if 100 people bought generators with the intention of returning them if they didn't need them, that 100-x people actually return them, where x is probably around 10 or more... People are lazy, decide why not keep it, etc. Worse case senario you have a customer coming into your store twice.. Maybe on the return trip they buy stuff to repair damages from the storm.. If you have the inventory this isn't a big deal and probably ends up increasing revenue vs. not having them buy in the first place.


The generators have a lot more value to being in stock before or during the storm than after. When I bought mine, I had to drive two hours away to a Lowes, because they were out of stock in my county. If the local Home Depot had one, I would have just bought it there. The person buying and returning it is not only costing them a fraction of the cost (credit card fees each way); but also actual sales.

On the other hand, I think that in general, the relaxed Home Depot returns policy helps them. I often take advantage of the ability to buy multiple sizes of things, extras in case I mess something up, and then when I'm done with a project go back return the excess. If you use a credit card, that is even easier than keeping the receipts, they swipe the card, scan the stuff, and it goes back automatically. I find this easier, because I always have my card; and there is no need to have however many receipts that the items were originally bought with. And for very small stuff that I could conceivably use in the future, there is a decent chance I won't bother returning it anyway.


As a native Floridian, here is what I would do. Buy generator, take it to area that has lost power. Resell it for 2x price. Most people don't take care of there generator until they actually need it. It sits in the garage or basement, until the lubes dry it and the bearings seize.


Interestingly, Les Schwab (the dominant regional tire company here in the Pacific Northwest) advertises that if you buy snow chains and don't use them, you can return them at the end of snow season.

Of course, once you have the chains, no real point in bringing them back since you'll just need them next year.


> This isn't morally wrong. My friend, a graphics programmer, did this with videocards in order to test his graphics engine on various types of hardware configurations. If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.

No, that's immoral.


> This isn't morally wrong. My friend, a graphics programmer, did this with videocards in order to test his graphics engine on various types of hardware configurations. If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.

Morals have nothing to do with what others let you or don't let you do. If anything morals are about your sense of right and wrong in the absence of external pressures. It may be legal, but I don't think it's moral to abuse a system that's intended to help and protect honest customers. Even if you don't care about hurting the profits of a giant corporation, you're potentially hurting other consumers if the benefit is revoked because too many people are abusing it.


> This seems impossible. Returns require a receipt. I don't know what you're talking about.

1. Buy item #1, obtain receipt, take it home

2. Go back into store, find identical item #2, take it past checkout counter and up to return counter

3. "Return" item #2 using receipt for item #1

4. Profit

For big ticket items there's usually a unique serial the store will scan to prevent this sort of thing, but not always. Pretty deplorable.


In the OP situation this could play out like this:

1. Have a broken laptop (item #1)

2. Buy a new laptop (item #2)

3. Return item #1 with item #2's receipt

4. Have a working computer.

note: I'm not condoning this and it's unlikely to working in the OP's case because stores are usually smart enough to check serials on bigger ticket items.


Walmart has a very liberal return policy (accept anything) and the staff was somewhat aware this was going on. This is what my friend and former Walmart employee tald me years ago.


> If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.

This is the kind of behavior and attitude that ruin nice things for everyone.

My car can go 100 MPH in a residential neighborhood, did the manufacturer intend for it to be used like that just because it can?


"This seems impossible. Returns require a receipt. I don't know what you're talking about."

Depends on the store. When I used to be behind a returns desk we'd give store credit (on a gift card) if they didn't have a receipt.


I had accidentally bought two copies of the same book from Barnes and Noble. I didn't have the receipt anymore. At first they thought I wanted to return it for money and seemed hesitant but I just wanted to get the first book (I had two of the second). They were really helpful and exchanged it for the correct book.

I know it's not too relevant but I was so afraid of a no receipt, tough luck situation. I'm surprised they didn't think I just grabbed it off the shelf and went to the counter. It was just a $10 book and not a TV or anything but it left a good impression.


If you use a credit card, typically they often won't require a receipt. They can run the card and bring up the transaction.


  > The store then had the same graphics cards as before.
No, they started with new graphics cards, and were left with used graphics cards.

  > If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.
In that case, why didn't your friend simply ask the graphics card companies for some loaners?


You are wrong, using return policies to get test devices is morally wrong. Your friend is stealing the cost of discounting the returned item + the cost of processing the return.

Buying something that might work, trying it and returning it if it doesn't isn't morally wrong.

The difference is your friend is buying with no actual intent to keep and own.


>This seems impossible. Returns require a receipt. I don't know what you're talking about.

Ever try to do this? Plenty of times I've done this and sometimes you get store credit sometimes cash. Many stores have "customer friendly" return policies such as these. Walmart is a big one who will take any return. You need ID usually.

>The store then had the same graphics cards as before

No they don't, they now have used graphics cards, and they have the overhead of staffing the return counter if many people get this idea. Plus the contract (i will buy this item at this price from you) was entered into in bad faith.


If the companies didn't want you to do this, then they wouldn't let you do this.

They do not want you to do this. What your friend did is considered to be a form of return fraud and abuse. The industry term for it is 'wardrobing' or 'renting'.

It's a big enough problem that there is a company, http://www.theretailequation.com, that helps large firms blacklist people like your friend, though these defenses are fairly recent.

Returns require a receipt.

Not always.


Here's a study that shows that while low-carb diets achieved effects faster (involved more weight loss in the first 6 months), after a year the difference in weight was negligible. Low carb diets led to higher levels of LDL cholesterol, which is generally considered to be bad, though were also correlated with better levels of HDL cholesterol, which are considered to be good. http://www.ceb-institute.org/fileadmin/upload/refman/arch_in...

Here is a a long term study that shows that low carbohydrate, high protein diets were correlated with higher mortality rates. It's an observational, not a controlled study, so the usual caveats apply, but it's definitely some evidence that there's no automatic win for low-carb, high protein diets: http://folk.ntnu.no/lyngbakk/artikler/trichopoulou.pdf

I'm pretty sure I've seen another study that linked long-term use of low-carb, high protein diets with increased incidence of cancer, but I can't find that study at the moment.


Thanks for those links. Yes, I should have been more specific, the diet I was talking about is low carb high fat (LCHF), not low carb high protein. Increased protein intake can indeed be a problem and seems to be common with low carb eaters.

Edit: Let me also add that meat consumption seems to be mostly problematic with processed meat (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23497300)


Please don't promote "observational" studies. They are not worth the electrons it cost to display them on my screen let alone transmit them across the 'net.

You can find an 'observational' study to promote nearly any point of view. If it's not a properly controlled peer reviewed study it's not worth anyone's time except the shills who got paid to write it up by whatever corporate group commissioned it.


Wow, you definitely sound a bit too defensive. A bit like my sister, in fact. She also followed the ketogenic diet for four months and was very, very adamant about how it was healthy because she was finally losing weight. But then reality hit her hard. She had her blood samples taken before she started the diet and after the four month period. What the lab results showed clearly was dangerously elevated levels of LDL (from all the fried pig skins and bacon jerky she was munching on, no doubt). She finally realized that, despite what you read on the Internet, nothing beats the hard results you see on a lab report. She returned to a normal diet afterward.


Controlled studies about lifelong effects of fairly fundamental parts of your life such as diet are quite difficult to do, especially with large enough populations to be statistically significant and without being overly affected by their dropout rate.

Observational studies have significant problems, as I explicitly pointed out in my comment about the study. However, they have some advantages in that they are a lot easier to do for larger populations over a longer time period.

Both of these are valid scientific techniques, to inform us about what is most likely to be a healthy way to eat. There are, of course, other valid techniques, such as studying immediate metabolic effects of ingesting certain foods, and linking those to known risk factors for a variety of conditions. Science is not a single, infallible technique, it is a set of techniques which taken together are intended to give us the best approximation of the truth, though every method can fail in certain ways.

Diet is an especially difficult topic. Human bodies, human behavior, and differences between different people are quite complex. There are a lot of people who are afraid of diseases of affluence or degenerative diseases that you see coming up more often simply due to our longer lifespan. Lots of people are interested in solving these problems, and I think that a lot of people jump to over-simplifying conclusions on these topics. We've seen this played out in the past; a huge over-emphasis on low-fat diets, that seems to have left us unhealthier than ever. Warnings about dietary cholesterol, when it turns out that the cholesterol in our blood stream has very little correlation to cholesterol consumed.

Every time I hear about some new extreme diet that is supposed to work wonders, I get concerned. Low fat, low sodium, low carb, no carb, paleo, high protein, high fat, vegan, raw, gluten free, dairy free and so on. Most of these things seem to focus on some single source of evil, and claim to offer amazing benefits if you follow them. Most of those benefits don't actually play out; despite the huge push for low-fat diets over the 80s and 90s, obesity continued rising at an alarming rate. Despite the huge popularity of Atkins, "paleo", and other low carb diets over the past decade, it has continued to rise.

People keep searching for a silver bullet, and in diets, like much of life, there is no silver bullet. Eat less, exercise more, eat healthier foods like fruits, vegetables, nuts, and whole grains while reducing the amount of sugars and fats, avoiding too much processed food and so on is not some amazing new diet plan that you'll be able to sell some fancy book about, but it's pretty much the actual advice you need to follow if you want to stay healthier.

Anyhow, I see this over and over again, and then I hear from eager people who want to tell me that low-carb, no fasting, no gluten free, no lactose free diets will help them lose weight, prevent cancer, prevent heart disease, prevent Alzheimers, prevent autism or ADHD, do all of the above and more, and there's no risk, they're so healthy, why would anyone not do this? And then I read the literature, and I find that actually, this new diet has quicker effects in the first six months but is about as effective as the last fad diet was after a year, and actually it does have certain dangers, and so on.

Eat less, exercise more, keep it healthy. Beyond that, don't worry too much, and do everything in moderation. Take all dietary science with a grain of salt, since it's a tough field to study the real, long term effects of (20 year studies are considered to be long term studies, but that's only a fraction of a life, meaning that many real long term effects get very little study). Take industrial food with an even larger grain of salt, as it's more likely optimized for shelf life, profitability, or narrow nutrition claims to be able to put some particular label on it, rather than flavor and health. Don't drink soda; I don't care if it's regular or diet, or whether the sugar is corn syrup or cane sugar. Soda is always extra calories that you don't need, or extra sweetness sans calories that confuses your body. And don't drink venti mochafrappucaremelates, or whatever the hell they're called. Don't eat salty snacks on a regular basis, but don't be afraid to put a pinch of salt in your food to make it taste good. Don't have dessert with every meal, but don't be afraid to have a slice of cake at a birthday party.

Anyhow, rant over. I just get upset when I see people getting religious over some new diet fad, which in 10 years will be the diet that the people selling a new diet fad will be talking about in their "you've been lied to for all of these years. Learn how to really stay healthy and lean!"


I didn't really see anybody getting religious, but why is it you get so emotional about this?

> Eat less, exercise more

So eating above one's caloric requirement and a lack of energy are always problems of willpower?

> eat healthier foods

I think everybody can get behind this, it's like thinking of the children.

> fruits, vegetables, nuts, and whole grains while reducing the amount of sugars and fats, avoiding too much processed food

So grains healthy, fat bad? As you don't mention meat that's probably also bad? Well, it's the details that get interesting, what are healthy foods.


> I didn't really see anybody getting religious, but why is it you get so emotional about this?

It's just that there have been one too many threads of people promoting some particular fad diet idea (gluten is poison! sugar is poison! soylent is the food of the future!) and I'm getting kind of sick of them. I've been hearing these fad diet ideas for years, it's just different things which are claimed to be the poison or different combinations of things or combination of restrictions which are claimed to be the be-all cure.

This thread hasn't been particularly bad, though you were a bit overly pushy about ketogenic diets and dismissive of criticisms of them earlier: "I'm not aware of any scientic data that found adverse consequences. You get a lot of resistace from health professionals because for the last decades what you eat on a ketogenic diet has been blamed for heart diseases or high cholesterol, but there never was scientific evidence to back up those claims."

> So eating above one's caloric requirement and a lack of energy are always problems of willpower?

No, there is not always a problem of lack of willpower. Metabolism plays a role, though diet and behavior play a big role too. There are certain circumstances for which ketogenic diets are appropriate, just like there are certain circumstances for which gluten free diets are appropriate; likewise, just because they are appropriate and effective in certain cases doesn't mean they are appropriate or effective for every case.

I think that for a lot of people, however, the problem is willpower. There are a lot of people who just want an easy excuse or an easy answer, when there really is an easy answer that just takes a bit more willpower.

I do believe that the low-carb, paleo, ketogenic, and likewise diet fads have at least helped combat the harmful emphasis on low-fat above all else. I recall at the height of the low-fat craze finding lots of fat free and low-fat foods that were stuffed with tons of sugar to compensate.

> I think everybody can get behind this, it's like thinking of the children.

No, I don't think everyone can get behind it. There are a lot of people who take the "you can eat whatever you want as long as it's not carbs" idea and eat way too much bacon, pork rinds, and the like.

Fresh fruits and vegetables are healthy. Eating pork rinds instead of a banana because the banana is fairly carb rich and the pork rinds are not is not healthy.

> So grains healthy, fat bad? As you don't mention meat that's probably also bad? Well, it's the details that get interesting, what are healthy foods.

I don't think dividing it into "this entire category of food is healthy, this food is not" is a good way to approach your diet. So no, I'm not claiming "grains healthy, fat bad". Both grains and fats are good for you, in moderation. Likewise meat. All of these things can be bad for you when taken to excess; eating too much meat can give you cancer (and some meats are fattier, leading to the problems with too much fat), too much fat can raise your cholesterol leading to heart disease, too much grains (especially highly refined grains) can lead to spikes in blood glucose and harm your insulin response.

What I'm saying is favor fruits and vegetables over grains, favor whole grains over refined, treat meat as a supplement, flavoring, or occasional treat rather than the central part of every meal, favor unsaturated fats (generally vegetable oils and fish) over saturated fats (generally from other animal sources), and keep refined sugar consumption very low. If you need to lose weight, eat a little less, and try to fill up a little more on things without much caloric value like greens (but don't go spending all of your time eating salads, as they generally come with dressings that consist mostly of fat and sugar, defeating the whole point).

Personally, I follow this by eating meat (of any form, fish, poultry or red meat) only about 3 times a week. I never drink soda (can't stand the stuff now that I'm not used to it any more). I generally use unsalted nuts or fruit as a snack if I need something to tide me over between meals (but don't snack often). I usually buy whole grain bread. But I cook with butter plenty (as well as with olive oil, I love sauteing food in a combination of the two), I put cream in my coffee, I enjoy the occasional juicy steak, I eat a lot of cheese (my one main vice), and I have the occasional dessert.

Now, I don't claim that my diet would work for everyone. That's why I'm not out selling it; it's just what happens to work for me. But I do think that it's good to employ an approach of moderation and avoiding thinking about food in black and white terms, unless there's a very good reason why a food should be completely banned (like if you have celiac disease, a nut allergy, or a moral objection to consuming animals).


> too much fat can raise your cholesterol leading to heart disease

Actually, foods with a high glycmic load seem to be what's really bad for the heart http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19364995

> favor unsaturated fats (generally vegetable oils and fish) over saturated fats (generally from other animal sources)

Doubtful, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2010/01/13/ajcn.2009...

Polyunsaturated and monounsaturated oils have to be balanced. Too much omega-6 rich polyunsaturated vegetable oil like from soybean or corn may actually increase risk of heart diseases, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16387724, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21118617

> though you were a bit overly pushy about ketogenic diets and dismissive of criticisms of them earlier

Seriously, you keep calling LCHF keto a "fad diet" and accuse people who talk about it of "selling books", calling it the "be-all cure" or eating "way too much bacon, pork rinds, and the like". Your underlying tone is really ad hominem, you seem to think all ketoers are stupid, uneducated or in it for a quick buck.

Edit: Let me also add that keto is a proven treatment for diabetes, epilepsy and there is currently research into more therapeutic benefits: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1325029/, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2367001/, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3826507/


> Actually, foods with a high glycmic load seem to be what's really bad for the heart http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19364995

From the referenced study: "associations of harmful factors, including intake of trans–fatty acids and foods with a high glycemic index or load"

You seem to have missed the other half of that statement.

> Doubtful, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2010/01/13/ajcn.2009...

From the study you link to:

"Of note, in intervention trials that have shown protective effects of reducing saturated fat, ie, the Veteran Affairs (19), Oslo Diet Heart (20), and Finnish Mental Hospital (21) studies, the calculated P:S ratios ranged from 1.4 to 2.4—values that are much higher than the threshold of 0.49 above which CHD risk has been reported to be reduced (44). Relatively high P:S ratios (1.25–1.5) were also observed in the Anti-Coronary Club Study, an early trial that showed beneficial effects of a lower fat diet (30–32% of total energy) (45). The presumed beneficial effects of diets with reduced saturated fat on CVD risk may therefore be dependent on a significant increase in polyunsaturated fat in the diet. Existing epidemiologic studies and clinical trials support that substituting polyunsaturated fat for saturated fat is more beneficial for CHD risk than exchanging carbohydrates for saturated fat in the diet, as described further elsewhere (46)."

Exactly as I said, favoring unsaturated fat in diets over saturated fats seems to have benefits as far as cardiovascular disease, while replacing fats with carbohydrates leads to poor results.

> Polyunsaturated and monounsaturated oils have to be balanced. Too much omega-6 rich polyunsaturated vegetable oil like from soybean or corn may actually increase risk of heart diseases

Sure. I wasn't trying to lay out every possible dietary guideline, just a few rough ones. And I really mean them as rough, and meant to be broken. I don't believe that we know enough about dietary science at the time to make strong judgements; making drastic dietary changes on the basis of poorly understood science can be a bad idea.

One rough metric for whether a diet is good to eat is whether it a similar diet has been eaten over the past few hundred years by agricultural societies; that gives at least some evidence that it works over a large population for a long period of time. It's not perfect, and modern scientific understanding can help us understand and improve it, but it gives you a good baseline.

I don't really buy the paleo idea that we evolved for the hunter gatherer diet, and then evolution stopped; after all, Europeans evolved white skin as a result of agriculture, so I find it a lot more plausible that our digestive system has likewise adapted to agriculture, though it's too quick for it to have adapted to modern industrial agriculture and food processing.

Given that we've been eating butter, olive oil, and lard for centuries, while corn and soybean oil are inventions of modern agriculture, I tend to favor the former over the latter.

> Seriously, you keep calling LCHF keto a "fad diet" and accuse people who talk about it of "selling books", calling it the "be-all cure" or eating "way too much bacon, pork rinds, and the like". Your underlying tone is really ad hominem, you seem to think all ketoers are stupid, uneducated or in it for a quick buck.

I do think that there's a LCHF/keto fad. I've seen a lot of fad diets over the years, and it has all the trappings of one. I don't think that all ketoers are stupid, uneducated or in it for a quick buck, but I do think that lots of well meaning, smart people can get caught up in fad diets, just like the low-fat fad that was popular for so long (and still has plenty of vestiges in nutrition advice and policy today).

That doesn't mean that that there aren't valid uses for a keto diet. That has been demonstrated in a variety of studies, and a classic example is in epilepsy. What I don't think has been demonstrated is the long-term efficacy of keto diets over normal calorie restricted diets. Keto tends to get results quicker (at the expense of some unpleasant side effects) but the advantage tapers off after a year.

On the other hand, low-fat diets are useful for specific therapeutic purposes as well, such as people having gallbladder problems. We've all seen the damage that over-emphasis on low-fat diets for the general population has done. Look at all the trans-fats people have consumed while avoiding saturated fats; and all the sugars that have been substituted for fats in foods to try to make bland processed food taste better.

From the evidence I've seen, I think that low-carb is likely to be a bit safer than low-fat as it's easier to wind up consuming more calories in carbs when eliminating fat than vice versa, but I do worry that too many people deciding to jump on the low-carb high-fat or low-carb high-protein bandwagon may wind up doing themselves harm; possibly from causes that we already know, and possibly from things that we don't know.

By the way, I think you've mistaken what ad-hominem is. An ad-hominem attack is one in which you attack a person rather than their ideas. That's not really what I've done; I've just been fairly dismissive about the idea. Perhaps I've been unduly dismissive, but having recently been in a thread discussing gluten free diets, I'm feeling a bit uncharitable towards the tendency for people to latch onto a dietary idea that is a very effective treatment for a very specific problem, and decide that it's the solution for everybody and must be evangelized far and wide.


> From the referenced study: "associations of harmful factors, including intake of trans–fatty acids and foods with a high glycemic index or load" > You seem to have missed the other half of that statement.

What the actual frack? No, I can read, and we weren't talking about trans-fatty acids at all, how on earth could I have missed something we're not talking about? Or did I promote eating processed foods?

Anyway, this doesn't seem to lead anywhere, you have made up your mind.


Do you really think that tailored custom devices for spying on particular people of interests exceeds their constitutional grounds?

Would you object to the NSA or CIA planting bugs that record audio or video on targets of interest outside of the United States? Does that exceed their constitutional grounds? How about if they supplied these to law enforcement agencies which had valid search warrants?

I have plenty of concerns about the constitutionality of certain NSA programs (such as collecting metadata on everyone, regardless of prior suspicion or search warrant), and some of the techniques they use (tapping all of Google's fiber traffic between data centers, putting backdoors in international standards), and I find these revelations technically fascinating, but I don't find any fundamental constitutional issue with them using clever, advanced technology for spying on valid targets.


> Do you really think that tailored custom devices for spying on particular people of interests exceeds their constitutional grounds?

Do you really think that an agency that practices unconstitutional mass surveillance (or unconstitutional anything) would never use these recently revealed capabilities unconstitutionally?


No, but I don't think that the fact that they have such capabilities is, itself, evidence that they have used it unconstitutionally.

I think that it's important to distinguish between behavior that is bad (unconstitutional, illegal, or immoral) and behavior which is acceptable. Saying "It's really quite hard to stop admiring the technical lengths the NSA has gone to to exceed their constitutional bounds" implies that the USB cables equipped with radios are themselves unconstitutional, or must be used in ways that are unconstitutional, and that's not the case.

It's important when having these kinds of discussions to keep in mind the legitimate, legal, constitutional work the NSA does as well. Not everything they do is illegal or unconstitutional, and spreading the outrage from the bad work to the good helps no one at all.

Outrage at Dual EC DRBG is absolutely well founded. Outrage at mass metadata collection is absolutely well founded (though there is a bit more of a debate to be had there, because metadata is something that a third party must necessarily have in order to route your calls/packages/packets/emails properly, and so doesn't exactly fall under your personal effects that are fully protected by the fourth amendment; I believe that mass metadata collection is still immoral, but the constitutional argument is harder to make). Outrage at secret courts with no oversight, and national security letters that forbid even revealing details about exactly what and how much information the government has access is absolutely well founded.

But getting outraged because spies create spy gadgets is, well, kind of silly. Get outraged when they plant these gadgets on innocent targets, on political targets, on allies, on economic targets, sure. But there should be no reason to get outraged at their mere existence.


As far as I know, none of the NSA's practices have been ruled unconstitutional. At best, the courts have sent mixed signals, and the collection of metadata was explicitly decreed constitutional by a precious Supreme Court ruling.


Not exactly, you have to stretch pen register authority pretty far to extend it to the NSA's bulk programmatic uses.

http://www.lawfareblog.com/2013/11/problems-with-the-fiscs-n...


  The Winapi (aka Win32) is the only commonly used API that 
  regularly requires something other than UTF-8
Sadly, that's not really correct. Core Foundation and Cocoa on Mac OS X use UTF-16. Qt uses UTF-16. Java uses UTF-16. JavaScript uses UTF-16. Many of these APIs have easy methods for converting to and from other encodings, and offer a certain amount of abstraction over the underlying encoding, but it still shows through in that string length and character indexing work via UTF-16 code units, not Unicode code points.

  the Mac class NSString or the C# String class use UTF-16 
  internally, you don't normally need to care what they do 
  internally since any time you access the internal 
  characters, you specify the desired encoding.
While it's true that they do abstract over the encoding somewhat, and they offer conversions, the abstraction is fairly leaky, as string length and indexing all happen in terms of UTF-16 code units.

I'm a huge fan of UTF-8, and I agree that new APIs should generally favor it, but there is a lot of legacy code that has a lot of UTF-16 assumptions baked in that you can't really say that only the Winapi uses UTF-16.


There's a reason a ton of legacy code is UCS-2^/UTF-16 and not UTF-8.

The code is older than UTF-8.

Windows NT was first released in '93, UTF-8 didn't exist (much less have wide adoption) for most of it's development. Likewise, NeXTSTEP had an initial release in '89. Java and JavaScript (both '95) could have adopted UTF-8, but they're almost certainly running on an OS that expects UTF-16 soooo... yeah.

^UCS-2 was superceeded by UTF-16, so you'll find them used interchangeably a lot.


It doesn't matter when the projects started, it matters when they added Unicode support. Windows NT didn't support Unicode until 4.0, released in 1996. NeXTSTEP may have been released in '89, but Unicode itself wasn't finished until '91, it couldn't possibly have supported Unicode upon release. The original releases of NeXTSTEP just used C strings; it wasn't until OpenStep in 1994 that they introduced NSString based on UCS-2.

UTF-8 was publicly released in January 1993. So by the time these projects became Unicode enabled, UTF-8 had already existed for at least a year.

Java and JavaScript had no underlying platform constraints to choose UCS-2/UTF-16, since the underlying platforms didn't support Unicode during their development.

Qt 2.0 was the first release of Qt to introduce Unicode support in QString, and it was released in 1999.

No, the real problem was just the fundamental design mistake that the Unicode consortium made when first developing Unicode. They thought that 16 bits would be enough to fit all of the world's actively used writing systems, and the simplest way to support an extended character set would be to just switch the underlying character type from 8 bit integers to 16 bit integers. This was a mistake in many ways; 16 bits is not sufficient, especially when CJK is taken into account, and so they had to do a lot of unification that wasn't really appropriate and led to a lot of resistance to using Unicode from CJK users. Changing to 16 bit integers for the fundamental character type meant that every API had to be duplicated to provide a wide character version. Some APIs already had wide character support for legacy wide character sets, but differences in existing wide character support between NT (which used 16 bit wide characters) and many Unices (which used 32 bit wide characters) meant that writing portable code is quite difficult. Using 16 bit integers for an internal representation means that there's a native endianness, but once you need to interchange data endianness becomes a big issue. And so on.

UTF-8 was the solution to many of these problems, and it was introduced before Unicode support had become widespread, but the idea that 16 bit types should be used for Unicode had already permeated people's consciousness and likely early development efforts. It's too bad that more people didn't learn from Plan 9's experience switching to UTF-8, which happened all the way back in 1992 (they switched Plan 9 to UTF-8 before publicly announcing it, which acted as a very good proof of concept).


Technically, it's not that it can be passed through tools intended for ASCII only. It can be passed through tools which assume an ASCII compatible character set (character set for which ASCII is a subset), which are 8 bit clean, and which don't make incorrect assumptions about being able to truncate strings at arbitrary points and be left with two valid strings.

Which is actually generally true of any tools which had been internationalized with legacy, pre-Unicode character sets like the ISO 8859 series.


  This also shows a weakness in DNS. There is currently no 
  way to validate the DNS record you’re being served is what 
  the person hosting the website intended.
That's what DNSSEC is for, but it hasn't become pervasive enough yet to be able to depend on it.


Strangely enough, the largest deployment of DNSSEC-enabled, customer-facing, recursive/caching nameservers in the United States is... Comcast. That's right, the same Comcast that, back in 2009, hijacked NXDOMAIN responses by default and returned A records pointing to servers that served up advertisement-laden search pages over http.


I was also impressed to see that my Comcast connection uses IPv6. Turns out they have (or will have) one of the the largest IPv6 network in the world - http://gigaom.com/2013/11/27/comcast-xfinity-broadband-is-no...


Comcast's IPv6 network for content from Netflix or YouTube is actually better than using IPv4. A while back I set up an IPv6 only machine just to see the difference, and it is night and day.

That being said, their network still leaves something to be desired, the IPv6 routes taken to get to the same IPv6/IPv4 host can sometimes be circuitous and I have noticed that they have a higher latency too. So there are upsides and downsides, but I hope it can only get better with time!


Sadly DNSSEC kinda sucks. Here's some earlier discussion on HN, with a lot of links. (Namedrop: tptacek is against DNSSEC and talks about it in the link.)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5937004

TLDR: DNSSEC is kinda complex and hacko, doesn't protect you as much as you might think, and introduces a whole new PKI that you should probably trust even less than the current ones. But read the links above for the real story.

I'm using DNSCrypt right now, which (correct me if I'm wrong) protects against DNS interception by my ISP, and seems like a whole lot less trouble than DNSSEC.


DNScrypt only protects from your host to your nameserver. Your nameserver can still be poisoned as it queries other nameservers.

dnssec protects mostly from poisoning between nameservers. It does little to protect between a host and their namserver.

But in reality dnssec is not a solution, it's a problem. It will never be adopted in a meaningful way without major overhaul in spec.


"protects against DNS interception by my ISP"

Your ISP can still see the IP address of every web server that you connect to, and can still see the "Host" header that your browser sends in HTTP requests, and also in HTTPS requests (due to SNI) if you're using a reasonably modern OS/Browser combo.

All you've done is add an additional third party that can view and log what you're doing.


>All you've done is add an additional third party that can view and log what you're doing.

You forgot the part where it's protecting against trashy ISPs like the one in this article.


I did not forget that. The privacy lost is worse than the supposed "protection" gained by using DNSCrypt. "Trashy" ISPs can (and do) still intercept and modify the HTTP traffic even if they can't intercept and modify the DNS traffic.


Hmm. Most that I clicked on were freely available. The links go to Google Scholar searches, and most of those indicate that a PDF is available.


Huh? It's a list of best papers. What kind of summary can you give of hundreds of CS papers in different fields? "There sure is a lot of stuff you can do with computers!"

greenyoda already included the first few lines of the summary of institutions which contributed most to this list, which is about as close to a TL;DR as you can get for this link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6992714

But really, what were you expecting a TL;DR to be? There's no way you can summarize nearly two decades worth of computer science research in a single TL;DR.


cough Irony cough


Wooowee, did I ever strike a nerve :)


Too bad SIGGRAPH doesn't give such an award; I was curious to look at the top graphics papers.


Not top papers, but you can read many of the accepted papers by following the author links here: http://kesen.realtimerendering.com/sig2013.html


Thanks! I was interested in seeing the list of "best papers" just to see what the most interesting or innovative research over the years has been, but this is all good stuff too.


Looking at Google scholar results might be interesting:

http://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&vq=eng_computergra...


Yes, a provider can follow the DMCA safe harbor procedures to facilitate the filing of DMCA takedown notices, and comply with those promptly. The details are outlined here: http://www.chillingeffects.org/dmca512/faq.cgi

Basically, a provider needs to provide contact information for a designated agent for DMCA takedown notices. Had Luke done so, and complied with legal DMCA takedown requests (as well as counter-notifications), he could have continued operating his service; however, that may have become considerably more work than he wanted to put into running the service.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: