Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | leothelocust's commentslogin

> Either way... Holy shit is that github thread full of negativity and entitlement!

Negativity - rightfully so imo.

Entitlement - many people have contributed to the docker project. It's open source. Entitlement comes with the territory.

It's the hateful and cruel comments that bother me. State your opinion of the move to a loginwall, don't hate the ppl who did it.


> but it's just not that major an issue.

Maybe not to you.


> In Docker's defense they don't really barrage you with marketing.

Although they may not barrage you now, there is no telling what the future holds with stunts like this.


> Although they may not barrage you now, there is no telling what the future holds with stunts like this.

I think the future is pretty predictable.

In the off chance they just wake up and start slamming you with unsolicited marketing then you can click unsubscribe in the footer of their email and you'll never see another email from Docker again.

But really, I don't think Docker is foolish enough to do that. They've spent a lot of years building up their brand and business, and aren't reckless enough to put all of that at risk by relentlessly emailing their users with marketing agendas (if that's what they wanted to do they could have been doing that for years).

Docker already knows that almost everyone uses the free community edition anyways, so they really have nothing to sell to us anyways, except for maybe Docker Hub private repo access. Anyone who already downloads Docker already knows the benefits of using Docker, so they don't need to sell us on Docker as a technology. What are they going to market to us?

Lastly, let's not forget that the Docker for Windows / Mac clients have allowed you to login to the Docker Hub for a long time now and nothing bad has came from that (unexpected marketing attempts).


> In the off chance they just wake up and start slamming you with unsolicited marketing then you can click unsubscribe in the footer of their email and you'll never see another email from Docker again.

No, you see tons of email from everyone Docker sold your "Guaranteed Live And Active" email address to, once it verified liveness and activity by you clicking the "Unsubscribe" link at the bottom of the email. And that's assuming Docker doesn't just keep spamming you, secure in the knowledge you're reading their earnest missives and care enough to respond to them personally and by hand.

> But really, I don't think Docker is foolish enough to do that. They've spent a lot of years building up their brand and business, and aren't reckless enough to put all of that at risk by relentlessly emailing their users with marketing agendas (if that's what they wanted to do they could have been doing that for years).

If they're suddenly in a different financial position, or change leadership, or for any of a number of different reasons, they could indeed go off a cliff like that.


Fully agree. You can cause parsing issues, but you can also... not.

If you are creating a JSON response from your own API, you control the JSON output.

Unless you are crafting JSON from scratch I doubt anyone runs into the issues mentioned in the OP.


Only if they make less than a certain amount.


I get the feeling a company like this would only make this kind of leap because they have the data to show it will pay off. I.e. they can formulate algorithms to make the best purchases and the most profit. I foresee big gains from this


It’s rarely a good idea to compete against your customers


In this case it seems the customers are unlikely to revolt. Most won't even notice, right?


Great point. For now, it is limited to AZ and NV and for wholesale purchases only. But it seems like a conflict of interest that's hard to prove isn't being abused.


Isn't Amazon's marketplace similar in that regard? They compete with other sellers using Amazon's platform all the time.

Ethically, it seems a bit fuzzy for me given that one of Zillow's big features is there zEstimate. How can they demonstrably prove they aren't tweaking that somehow for their own gain?


I'd argue that Amazon's customers are the buyers of the products, not the sellers using Amazon's platform.


I'd argue that Amazon has many different groups of customers.


Why? BlackRock offers solutions to other asset management firms to make investment decisions. They use the same solution in their asset management division.


Isn't there a firewall between the units?


Zillow has captured the user base so effectively that the customers will have no choice but to continue paying.

See also: Amazon


Every big company does this in some way. The only smart move in business is to be where the money is.


A testable prediction at least.

I wouldn't be surprised if they make a bunch of money and then make a big mistake and lose a much bigger bunch of money.


This was my thinking as well, they can decide what they want to buy based on their data on prior listings and closing prices. It is an interesting advantage.


But how is this scalable? You need manual labor. This is a bigger headache than hiring agents as full time employees like Redfin.


Exactly, which is why I will live forever...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: