Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | microdan's commentslogin

I think the complaints were more about how pg was originally saying that he intended to never support Unicode. That said, people should realize that UTF-8 encoding/decoding is the zeroth step to internationalization with Unicode.


pg didn't say that. people just made it up.


He did however say:

"It's not for everyone. In fact, Arc embodies just about every form of political incorrectness possible in a programming language. It doesn't have strong typing, or even type declarations; it uses overlays on hash tables instead of conventional objects; its macros are unhygienic; it doesn't distinguish between falsity and the empty list, or between form and content in web pages; it doesn't have modules or any predefined form of encapsulation except closures; it doesn't support any character sets except ascii. Such things may have their uses, but there's also a place for a language that skips them, just as there is a place in architecture for markers as well as laser printers." (http://arclanguage.com/)

I certainly interpreted this as ASCII-only (along with presentational markup) was an explicit design decision, and I don't think this is a far-fetched interpretation. Luckily PG has clarified (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=111189) that this is not really what he meant, and now everyone is happy and has regained trust in Arc!


What kind of site does it make YC if this is how to get karma?


there is a very different pattern of karma for comments in "big" threads.


On reflection: your reply is ♫♪♫ to my ears. I ♥ good points...

Edit: heh, "thanks grandma" has even more than that.

Edit: btw it's funny that i'm still being upmodded


so someone downmodded all of:

- a simple, popular comment

- a comment suggesting maybe the first one shouldn't have been upmodded so much

- a comment backing off

Why would you downmod all of them? If you like dislike the first comment, you should like the second, and vice versa. And if you're unhappy with me in general for the first two, you should like the third one.


1) How do you know the same person downmodded the three?

2) Simplest explanation for that case would be that he's downmodding the latter two as noise. You can agree to a comment and still believe it doesn't add anything to the topic in which it appears.


I downmodded because the discussion was getting too meta :P


all 3 downmods appeared between quick refreshes.


This reminds me of how "macros" work in Factor, in a way. You don't avoid manually creating the s-expression (though Scheme and Dylan have a nice mechanism for that), but there is a finer line between macros and regular functions. A macro is a function which takes a bunch of arguments and returns another function which takes no arguments and does the action of the macro. Basically, it's constant-folded at compiletime if possible. The runtime definition is memoized. For Factor's syntax, this kind of macro is practical for everything but new definition syntax and datastructure literals (neither of which this idea would work really well on, and which there is a different mechanism for). In general, a macro operates just like other words and can be quoted and executed like them.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: