Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nancybelowzero's commentslogin

Maybe you can just put a towel over the jar for those guys. like a bird cage


>critically important aspect of life

Nothing says "life" like being dead.


I meant "life" in the big picture, not on the individual level.


I had this idea when I was 7. I would spend all day outside and get tons of mosquito bites, but also sometimes I would go to the doctor to get shots. They seemed to me to be not entirely different things, so I would wonder why they couldn't just put the shots into mosquitos, since they didn't hurt as much.

And it turns out, you can!


[flagged]


At 7, I don't believe I consented to the mosquitos or the shots.


> At 7, I don't believe I consented to the mosquitos or the shots

You also didn't consent to your mother's prenatal behaviour, neonatal nutrition, to going to school or having to clean up your room. Children are sapient. But it gets ridiculous when we extend the individual rights adults enjoy to them.


Your guardians consented to the shots because your brain wasn't developed enough to make your decision.

For mosquitoes, nature doesn't require consent, but humans are put on another standard.

Or do you think that because nature does something, humans are free to do it to themselves, like murder?

A wild bear will kill you, so therefore a human can kill another human right?


Yes, the child is unable to give consent in that scenario, so we have an alternative, because the benefit is worth it. (We could wait until people are adults before subjecting them to any vaccinations, but that would cost a lot of lives.)

It's possible an intervention like this one could also save a lot of lives, and therefore might also warrant an exception from individual consent. (Or not; it would depend on the specific expected benefits and risks.)


[flagged]


They did- people bitten by a mosquito do receive some amount of blood from previous individuals.


It's only a mystery if you choose to remain ignorant of it. We are having a discussion on the largest information-sharing system in the history of our species: not all information is available online, but a lot is!


My god what a simple take. Information Superhighway saves the day, yes. The future is now, information at our fingertips lest you choose to remain ignorant.

I'd love to have the innocence that you have. A world where nobody has any ulterior motives.


I'm not sure why this seems to be a needlessly negative reply to a fairly benign comment. Yeah, of course a child is unaware of those, it's just a fun observation by the commenter, you don't have to read so much into it.


They're not putting shots into the mosquitos. They're modifying the parasite the mosquito injects that lives in your liver.

When you were 7, did you yearn for modified parasites?


To be honest yes, lots of super hero stories about them. Though to be fair they're called symbiotes when they're helpful.


My (just turned) 8 year old wants a box he can put any two animals in to breed them to make a hybrid.

His example was a cat and a slug. He would absolutely love modified parasites.


The same thing ordinary mosquitoes do already?


Yeah and some animals kill humans, does that mean it's okay to kill humans too?

Right now you can consent to get a malaria vaccine, no covert parasite needed.

If the counter that it is for poorer populations, I'd still say you may want to ask them if they want to be injected with a genetically modified parasite. If one single person doesn't want to be in the area, you shouldn't do it. Would you support them dropping these in your neighborhood?


I don't live in malaria country, but yes, absolutely. While we are at it, something just like this for Lyme disease and TBE would be the icing on the cake.


Alright, now go ask all of your neighbors if they want a genetically modified parasite injected into them. If everyone is okay with it, then proceed.


I already have to breathe in pollutants released into my neighbourhood by other people without my consent. I have to deal with the aggregated effects of bad economic decisions made by others. Getting infected with a malaria vaccine instead of actual malaria via a mosquito bite without my consent would be the most benign of this type of problem.

Oh, and this already happens with the attenuated polio vaccine. People can catch the vaccine from those who have been immunised, in a similar way to how they could catch the virus. Delivering the vaccine the same way the pathogen spreads also allows people to opt out by following the same techniques they would to avoid the actual disease. You can use mosquito nets, mosquito sprays, etc., to help avoid both malaria and the mosquito-delivered vaccine.


Why is the baby in the header image wearing earrings? Doesn't eat piercing present a risk of infection?


What do you mean "no one is stopping"? The "ones stopping" are lobbiests and their associated bribes.


They can try to influence, but they are not successful all the time. I would bet the American public does not have the stomach for government spending on risky trials that more often than not fail to result in a medicine.

I don’t think any government in the world does.


Yandex.com?


Why would two shots be any more suspect than the 158 other supplements and medicines she has taken?


Dig a large pit, then drive the train into it. Post the results to YouTube.


Somebody call that Sir Monster fella all the kids are so into


I wonder how the stats stack up between damage from all the worlds nuclear accidents, and damage from the sun ($ spent to restore degradation of materials from UV, skin cancer, etc.) Bit moot since the sun can't be switched off.


UV is definitely higher -- there are about 300K new skin cancer cases per year world wide and about 60K deaths per year from it. Most (although not all) of these are due to UV exposure. That being said, before you blame the sun itself, a lot of this is due to ozone depletion (which is still a thing even though sometimes people make it sound like the problem is solved just because the ozone hole is shrinking)

https://www.wcrf.org/cancer-trends/skin-cancer-statistics/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozone_depletion


Don't forget to account for the approximately 100% of the global food supply which needs sunlight to grow.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: