Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more phpnode's commentslogin

no, it's because he accused the owner of an anti bullying charity of being a paedophile - maybe not a great source but - http://www.dailydot.com/news/hunter-moore-revenge-porn-defam...


For values of "anti bullying charity" equal to "company making money from online extortion", but yeah. (Their website Cheaterville has ads for services offering to remove "slanderous" and "defamatory" content from Cheaterville for the fee of $500 per entry. They handle all their advertising inhouse, so at the very least they're entirely aware of where their advertising income's coming from. In fact, at one point those were the only external ads on the entire network of sites and there was no information on how to advertise with them, so they'd obviously cut some kind of private deal with the companies offering these services.)


one issue I've found with this approach is that clients are now incentivized to use those hours each month regardless of whether they really need them. Inevitably this results in a whole host of disparate small tweaks and changes, which are a pain to deal with.


It is possible that, if you sell something to someone, they will ask to take delivery of it.

Giving them days of availability rather than hours minimizes the disruption. It also gives you a built-in mechanism for teaching your clients to batch their requests for optimal service.


with class or out of fear because of the insane bullying that went on in https://github.com/joyent/libuv/pull/1015 ?


Probably both.

I foresee both sincere and satirical efforts of such extremist "gender neutral" feminist edits to increase in the coming months after the libuv incident.


The Featured Article


What role did tptacek have in "RSA gate"? I think you've misunderstood what he was saying


I think Pavel is providing the financial backing for Telegram, rather than being an employee -http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Durov


Ah, the Telegram HN account just said he "proposed the contest", so I assumed employee. If he is the financier, then it is not surprising that he doesn't understand why his crypto contest is a bad idea.


right and it also explains why the Telegram guys went ahead with his suggestion, because they're presumably keen to keep their main financial backer happy.

I don't think there's any attempt to sell snakeoil here, this is a case of a road to hell being paved with good intentions. To people not well versed in cryptography the things Pavel is saying and the approach Telegram is taking all seem completely reasonable, and the people who do do crypto and are responding might as well be talking a different language. To them the flaws and red flags are so obvious that their responses are incredulous, which has led to the vitriolic back and forth we've seen - neither side can comprehend the other's position. This is Dunning-Kruger[0].

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect


With all due respect, nothing can be "obvious" unless it is proven. You cannot take something for granted just because a respected cryptographer says that. Not after we learned that NSA pushes backdoors using respected firms and people in the crypto-community.


By this reasoning you should presumably agree that the onus is on Telegram to prove the security of their system, not on the rest of the cryptography community to prove that it is insecure. Telegram have completely failed to do this. Even if Telegram had a formal proof of their system (and implementation), would you be in a position to read and understand that proof? I suspect not. Like me, you'd have to trust a group of respected cryptographers to do that job for you, so I don't really know what you're trying to say here. Just because one or two respected cryptographers appear to have become NSA tools, does not mean everyone has.

Also note that it's not a case of one random crypto guy saying that Telegram's approach is flawed, but a case of virtually the entire crypto community saying that the approach is flawed. Does this not ring alarm bells for you? How can you judge that the Telegram guys know their stuff and aren't leading you down the garden path or are themselves deluded?

With your backing, there is a real chance for Telegram to bring secure communications to the masses. This is indisputably a noble goal, but the areas that Telegram should be innovating in are in UI and features - not cryptography. There is no such thing as mostly correct, 'good enough' cryptography, either the system is secure, or it's insecure - there is basically no middle ground. If you fail, it's a bit more serious than your typical software bug - innocent people can literally die - the very people that need this the most are the most at risk. These are the reasons Telegram have been met with such a frosty reception here. Because they come across as arrogant in an area where arrogance is the absolute least desirable trait.


sorry quarterto, this is actually The Fourth Law of Hacker News - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4722251


Which by some fluke is exactly twice as old as my law!


I'm not a perl coder, but the library support does seem pretty fantastic - http://www.cpan.org/


I would say "pretty fantastic" is an understatement...CPAN is the gold standard of library support


Maybe, for the modules that build and actually have useful documentation. That seemed to me to be depressingly uncommon.


What platform are you on? I can't remember the last time I tried to install a module on a modern Linux distribution and had problems with it. Docs might be weaker than I'd like in some cases, mostly because of not enough examples (the curse of most documentation, IMHO).

I don't develop on Windows or Mac, since I work on server-side software, so I might just be blissfully ignorant of a serious problem.


Linux. I think the most recent example (by which I mean about two years ago; I don't use Perl much) was trying to get the XML Signature modules to build. I gave up in the end.

The documentation for those was poor. I remember the documentation for Moose being poor, as well as the documentation for Catalyst being especially bad.


My experience is that the Perl community documents better than any other scripting language community. Most everything is perldoc (which gets installed as man pages when install a cpan package) with clear examples right up front where you can see them.

And that's not even talking about the built-in documentation. Even in 1994-5 when I first learned Perl, I learned it completely from the Perl man pages and not from a book. The man pages are comprehensive, easy to read, and organized well for reference.

Ruby, Python, PHP and Node really need to get their act together and follow Perl's lead in this area.



> Thanks to PG's rankban (I say things he dislikes, so my comments get a personal penalty in placement) this comment will probably be in the middle-bottom (if not absolute bottom) of the page no matter how much you upvote it.

do you have any evidence for this? because your whole post sounds a little paranoid - not just the last paragraph. In fact a lot of your recent posts seem to have taken this kind of tone. I don't mention this out of spite, but out of concern. I hope you're ok.


do you have any evidence for this?

Yes. I didn't talk about it until I confirmed it. Someone who knows a lot of people in the YC-sphere also confirmed.

Karma scores of others' posts don't appear here, but they are available (on old posts) using https://www.hnsearch.com/ .

If you look at your placement of an old post (> 3 months) and find yourself at/near the bottom but have the highest-rated comment, then you're on rankban (rankban seems to apply to threads that originated before it was applied).

You can also check for slowban empirically by comparing latency while logged in to what you get in Incognito mode.


It is a pretty serious accusation. I wish you'd prepare a pdf or something where ou state your case. Most people don't have time to dig into that themselves.


It's a huge accusation. Not one I'd make lightly.

At first I was furious about it, that I'd wasted so much time into comments that would almost always float to the bottom (when I used to have a ~50% top comment rate, that went to zero). Now I'm more flattered by it: it means that PG is trying to censor what I say-- that my comments are important enough to merit a personal rankban.

I also have good reasons to believe that PG is making the decision because he's been pressured by others in the VC world. I don't know that they specifically mentioned me (or even know who I am, for that matter) but he's definitely been told to "do something" about the formerly prominent anti-VC posts that tend to do well here (excluding rankban).


I notice that you avoided the implicit question in the above post: can you provide proof of your accusation?


if your customers are governments, I think your prices are missing one or more 0s


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: