I can see the worry with vaccination, as it directly affects everyone, but does everyone necessarily have to agree on the other two issues?
Is it a real issue if someone is doing really good things for society, being an excellent person, but happens to disagree with you about evolution or climate change?
Science is getting to be its own fundamental religion for many IMHO, who prescribe 'science' as the answer to everything, and treat scientific papers as the bible (They also cherry pick the scientific papers they like, and ignore the ones they don't, just like religious folks do).
Also, the link you cite for climate change is 404, but I would expect the only real bone of contention is whether any change in the climate is caused by humans or not. Are there really people who deny the climate is changing?
You're being a little dramatic. "People who do not believe in evolution are holding back progress" ... Honestly... The cool thing about science is that whether you think gravity is real or not you will still fall. Progress will always be made in due time..
I present to you Texas science textbooks and their treatment of the theory of evolution. Or shall we teach our future engineers that Pi is exactly 3 too? Ignorant people with influence is a terrible thing.
Large scale evolution denialism in the western world is pretty much exclusive to the U.S.
There are, of course, various smaller groups of believers and faith-based private schools that espouse creationism, but it is certainly not very prevalent.
It's extremely hard for me to imagine how my quality of life would improve if my neighbor started believing in evolution. Perhaps you can provide an example?
Its about an educated and critical thinking public. A public that approaches everything with a critical eye is less susceptible to political pandering and more accepting of good science and evidence/data based laws. The average person doesn't know how to interpret a bar graph and has no clue what a good source of data looks like. Agreeing on a specific point, such as evolution, is just a symptom of the larger problem.
Sure: People who don't believe in evolution can taint those around them especially the young, which could cause those to not pursue scientific careers, setting back further progress in those fields and pushing forward the next discoveries in fields like cancer, life-lengthening, and other diseases. These "potential setbacks of breakthroughs" hurts society's quality of life.
You would be less likely to get an antibiotic-resistant infection in the future, because an understanding of evolution is necessary to understand how massive application of antibiotics can lead to more resistant bacteria in the future.
You would be more likely to survive a pandemic in the future because there would be more public support for research into how diseases evolve.
There would be less racial strife because more people would understand that the differences we see in people lie on a continuous genetic spectrum, not broken up in distinct "races."
I don't think excessive antibiotic use is exclusive to those who don't believe in evolution, but thanks for at least providing a few concrete examples instead of more hand hand waving.
You're probably going to die from cancer or heart disease.
Even if you just look at environmental factors, we're more likely to die either from the bee population dying due to pesticides, or because of the massive increase in routine use of antibiotics in meat production. Neither of which really get much media attention, maybe because they're both issues caused by science, and people like cheap food.
But at the end of the day we're going to die from overcrowding . The population has doubled in the last 30 years. (Hence why science has to make horrible dangerous food to feed them all).
Whether your fellow man believes in global warming is pretty irrelevant, and whether he believes in evolution is even less relevant to anything that matters. You're certainly not going to die from global warming!
Your comment is the sort of "scientific fundamentalism" I was talking about.
> because of the massive increase in routine use of antibiotics in meat production
Which is dangerous because it leads bacteria to evolve away from the antibiotics, becoming harder to stop in humans. Antibiotic resistance is one of the issues hurt by the poor understanding of evolution.
Anyway, the general problem is that people don't have an understanding of science in general necessary to understand issues on which the government must make public policy. It's like trying to drive a car somewhere without knowing how to read street signs or a map.
First world countries are not overcrowded. Scientific progress (increase food production, improved medicine and care) is the reason you will probably live 30 years longer than if you were born 2 centuries ago.
Those stats are faulty - the infant mortality rate 2 centuries ago was massive, which dragged the life expectancy down massively. Also, I don't think extending our life past 80 or so is a good idea.
Quality of life is far more important than quantity. Define "overcrowded"... First world countries are more crowded than they were 30 years ago, and (IMHO) the quality of life has gone down.
And as for your "increase food production"... We're force feeding chickens to be morbidly obese, pumping them full of anti-biotics so they don't get ill from living in squalid conditions. We're killing off the bee population with pesticides everywhere. These things are not good, and will only get worse as there are more people to feed.
The fact that you were born today means that you will be shielded, either fully or partially, from many of the factors that made the average lifespan 30 years shorter 2 centuries ago, infant mortality included. The lack of these factors would then lead to you "probably" having a 30 year longer lifespan ("probably" in the statistical sense).
You could argue that a more robust statistic like a median would provide a better representation of the expected lifespan less drastically affected by outliers, but calling the 30 year difference in average lifespan "meaningless" is disingenuous at best and could represent a fundamental denial of basic empirical evidence at worst (the latter of which seems more likely to me judging from some of your other replies so far on this subject).
People living in cities are healthier and less obese than their counterparts living in the suburbs, rural areas, and small towns.
The best way to improve your life is to look to science. Please stop spreading ignorance around. You're actively working to hold society's progress back.
Some might argue that one should avoid appeals to nature [0] (not to mention sweeping generalizations), and rather look to what can be demonstrated to be effective.
Global warming is another issue that affects everyone, so it does matter in the way you described.
>Science is getting to be its own fundamental religion for many IMHO, who prescribe 'science' as the answer to everything
If "not believing in evolution or global warming" isn't a real issue for society, I don't understand how "believing too much in science" can be a real issue. Senators and other powerful politicians deny global warming and evolution to demonstrably negative effects. I haven't seen any evidence that the /r/atheism-style fundamentalism is having any effect on the world besides being pompous and annoying.
I'm also assuming that you're criticizing the vagueness of giving 'science' as an answer to big problems as some internet atheists might be wont to do. Otherwise I'm not sure what you're criticizing.
Although it's only one case, here's an NPR interview (http://www.npr.org/2015/03/10/392142452/florida-gov-scott-de...) discussing the governor of Florida's policy to avoid the term 'climate change'. Not sure if denying usage of the term is equivalent to denying its existence, but hopefully it's something.
denying any truth is a flaw in thinking. it matters less materially than vaccination in that I don't have to worry about the spread of a disease which may infect me or my children.
just because someones beliefs don't directly cause me harm, doesn't imply that those believes are immune from criticism. especially on correctness grounds.
You do realise there's a good reason it's cheaper don't you.
How many accidents have you been in which required claiming against their insurance (or lack of it). What about unvetted drivers who might rape you?
After airBnB, and Uber, surely the next area ripe for "disruption" / completely ignoring the laws and regulation, is banking. Just offer higher savings rates than any bank, but ignore all that irritating regulation the big banks are subject to!
You realize Uber does background checks, right? I could link you stories of rapist taxi drivers (Yknow, those traditional and regulated ones that you're implying are so much safer)...
In a way, services like AirBnB and Uber remind us of how very rarely things actually go wrong. In a way, they act as correction to the usual scaremongering we get through most mass-media: "you can ride in uninsured cabs with complete strangers and sleep in unregulated and potentially dangerous flats, and you'll likely be fine anyway".
This said, good on the German government for forcing the company to actually respect their laws. Being a trendy net-based startup is not a license to flaunt all rules, especially consistent rules that exist for very good reason.
One thing most commentators cannot seem to grasp: the German government hasn't applied for the injunction, and it isn't running the taxi service.
Government regulates private companies running the service. And those private companies are standing up to a shitty company that openly says that they won't comply with laws or verdicts, because they are the future. Or something like that.
Insurance isn't there because you have a good chance of having something bad happen to you. It's there because bad things happen predictably and often, and victims of those would have serious problems for the rest of their lives if not for insurance.
It's all about who you know. That's all that matters in the startup world.
How is texting a pizza order to Magic, who then text it to a pizza company (Introducing a middle man) making the world a better place?
It's so well suited to startup founders though - Hey I'm way too busy and important to do menial things, I need a personal assistant on my phone that can do things for me while I'm saving the world by making some crappy website, which will never make any money, but will get bought for billions by some bigger fool because we know people who know people.
Magic sounds like it's right out of "Silicon Valley" (The TV Show).
I'd be surprised if anyone remembers Magic in a years time. Either that or it'll get bought by Amazon for $20bn. Or maybe both...
> It's all about who you know. That's all that matters in the startup world.
Exactly. If they were't connected to YC or someone else that could grease the wheels they would have their merchant account and CC acceptance terminated in the first 72 hours for the obvious and flagrant violations outlined in the Wired article, and quietly fade into the ether.
Is the cynicism truly necessary? I can practically taste the bile dripping off your comment.
Every minute that someone's spending on some random, menial task is a minute that someone isn't getting something else more productive done. Maybe the world isn't getting saved, but I find it hard to call a service that gives people more time in their day anything but "making the world a better place".
Yes, but with scale, they'll get better at it. They might even be able to automate large portions of it.
Also, it's a person spending their minutes on it, who might not have a better job available to them at the time.
Don't get mad because someone is willing to OFFER money for a service that YOU would find demeaning to provide. Just don't take that job. Problem solved. Sheesh.
Is you argument really that if there is something that "has been a thing for a LONG TIME" that it isn't problematic and that we shouldn't be concerned about avoiding it?
I'm seeking to improve the argument. Pretending that THIS is something new is a bad argument. If you want to assail the general category of what you consider to be demeaning jobs, then go for it.
No, you're doing far more than seeking to improve somebody else's argument. You're making your own argument, while pretending not to. This is clearly an argument: "Just don't take that job. Problem solved. Sheesh."
It's not even a very good argument, in that you're just demonstrating the willful ignorance the previous poster was pointing out.
Hilarious. I think it's good for an economy to offer jobs, even ones you find demeaning. People are free to not take those jobs. If enough people don't take that job, then they'll have to either offer more money for the job, or they'll have to find a new way to do the job. I believe in markets. I believe in minimum wages as well, but those are not mutually exclusive concepts.
You dismiss this entire line of reasoning as "willful ignorance," rather than ACTUALLY RESPONDING TO IT AND TELLING ME WHY YOU DISAGREE.
Sorry, but that's just arrogant and rude.
I had a completely different problem with kefka, which was that they said "Great idea." As though this concept of turkification were something new. It's not something new. Therefore, objecting to THIS idea on the basis of it "being a new idea" is a bad argument. If you want to reject the entire category of turk jobs, that's ANOTHER DISCUSSION.
It is not my job to solve your ignorance here, but suffice to say that I don't think the markets-solve-everything hypothesis stands up when you look at historical problems with labor issues over, say, the last century. Markets are fine tools when we set out to solve a particular problem, but they have been poor masters.
Markets (and capitalism) are great tools. They should not be seen as the end-all-be-all. Same with socialism, communism, as well as other socioeconomic -isms.
The failing of the markets is the lack of empathy for the fellow human. We know from the way the US looks how capitalism fails. Poor people are disempowered and marginalized from the system, because little money = little power over self. There is also a downward push to bring everyone into poverty.
The current gig economy and using mTurk are both ways to make previous corporate internalites to the public as externalities, whilst privatizing profit. Along with that, they also rely on having none of the protections of an employee, yet with all the requirements of one. It conveniently gets rid of the reforms we fought for in the '30s.
Are there solutions to the marginalization of the workforce, along with poverty working class? Yes.
1. Minimum income. Everybody gets it, regardless of a means test. This could be built up by the local level or state, where fees and fines and such could start the basis of a minimum income, even if it's $20/mo. Start small, look big.
2. Change laws to encourage worker cooperatives. Worker cooperatives, like Mondragon, have shown that they care for the fellow worker, because they all own the company as well as manage the company. It would also fit inside our current idea of ownership and contracts. The goal here is to enable political decisions to make company creation in this route easier. Thus the 3'rd...
3. Change unemployment law that allows you and 9 of your unemployed friends who want to start a cooperative to cash out of rest of unemployment to start a business: a worker cooperative. This has been a law in Italy since '85, and is greatly successful. And given how small businesses are celebrated, this should be a great law to pass regardless party.
I actually said explicitly that I believe in minimum wage. That already puts me well out of free-market fundamentalism.
If you've read some of my comments on HN, you'll see that I'm also in favor of regulation.
I happen to also believe that a Basic Living Standard is necessary.
I wish we had single-payer health care.
And I'm all for free, socialized education. (With BLS [stipend] on top of it.)
So, no, I'd say I fall WELL outside of the free-market fundamentalism you're referring to.
So, when you call me willfully ignorant, it's pretty damned offensive.
I happen to think data entry is demeaning. Some people enjoy it. I think busing tables is demeaning. Some people enjoy it. I have a friend who loves moving boxes in a factory, because he has free time to think about his poetry. I would never want to sell tooth paste to a super-market chain. Some people like to deal cards at casinos. Some like to sell pull-tabs. Some are waiters and airline stewards. Some people clean bedpans. Some clean houses after grisly murders.
Some people LOVE being a concierge. Well, this is a digital concierge service. And just because you and bendoernberg think it's menial and degrading, doesn't mean IT SHOULD BE ILLEGAL TO OFFER THAT JOB. Or, that we as a culture should be embarrassed that job exists.
If a person hates their job, I want to give them every chance to get out of that job. Every chance. But you're angry the job exists... regardless of whether someone WANTS to do it, for the pay they receive?
> we are not acting with sufficient empathy toward the people who are doing the work
I can't imagine why you think that of me. My grandpa worked four jobs at a time, sometime - because he grew up during the Great Depression, and if you can get work, you work. He set bowling pins. He delivered milk. He drove a school bus. He laid brick. All kinds of crap. Meanwhile, I TYPE in an air-conditioned building, and they pay me VASTLY more than he ever earned. It's ridiculous. And my peers are upset because the product owner violated the spirit of Agile when he made them change priorities mid-sprint (because we were shipping defective product). WHAT? GET OVER YOURSELF!
I want affordable housing. I want upward mobility. I want meritocracy and elbow grease. I want a safety net, and government-supplied-bootstraps. I want people to be able to declare bankruptcy, unlike today. I want an immigration system that's less like the mythical Labyrinth, and has empathy for immigrants.
So, are you really "solving my ignorance," or are you reading WAY TOO MUCH into one line of thought - and then running with it, half-cocked, and totally arrogant?
I'm not commenting on your entire history as person, let alone going back generations. My comments are about what you wrote here, in the things I responded to. You might be Mother Teresa, but "Just don't take that job. Problem solved," demonstrates willful ignorance. And then "Sheesh" implies people are stupid for even asking, encouraging willful ignorance generally. If that's in conflict with what you believe, well, maybe you should try writing something different next time.
Drama? You called me "willfully ignorant." That's an insult.
I'll note you haven't actually engaged me in conversation here, AT ALL.
All you've done is name-called, and then criticized me.
Can't you see how the combination of a secure net, PLUS a free market where you are free to not take a job, results in people having jobs that they want?
As in, "Problem solved."
The problem is not that there are jobs that you find degrading - the problem is there's no safety net, so people HAVE TO TAKE THOSE JOBS.
Or do you want ignore the actual topic, and just poke me with a stick, some more?
No, I said a comment was an example of the willful ignorance the previous poster was pointing out. You may or may not be personally ignorant; I couldn't know. But that comment ignored the actual reality. The reality here that people are not always free to not take jobs. It is something the HN glibertarian contingent continually ignores, which is precisely the point
bendoernberg when you jumped in. The problem is not solved until it is actually solved, not just because it might be solved in some imaginary world you are partial to.
Engagement in conversation is not something you are entitled to. It is earned. You seem to think you're entitled to make facile comments and then not have those comments challenged. And when they are, you turn it into personal drama apparently so that you don't have to face dealing with what you've actually said. I have no idea why you think that makes you an appealing person to have a conversation with.
> And when they are, you turn it into personal drama apparently so that you don't have to face dealing with what you've actually said.
That was me explaining the background behind my reasoning. Including personal anecdotes. Personal anecdotes are emotional, and you call it drama instead.
You still haven't engaged the topic, other than to say that my proposed solution is "some imaginary world."
Yes, PROPOSED solutions are "imaginary worlds" until you act on them. That's how that works.
I get that you didn't like my first comment, and I agree I didn't explain my entire world-view well in 140 characters.
When I tried to go deeper into my world-view, I was met with nothing but insults and meta-discussion. I'm not interested in either.
If my wife, desperate to calm our crying daughter, texts Magic that she needs Similac Advance, a gallon of purified water, and a CLEANED set of Tommee Tippee bottles at 3 AM, and Magic is able to fulfill that need in short order... that's a MASSIVE win for everyone.
Honestly, if you had to get those three things at 3 AM, how much time and effort would it take you? Add a screaming child to the equation.
Anything that makes it easier for a consumer to get what they need, when they need it, if they are willing to pay the price, makes the world a better place. Especially if there's competition for that service.
Have you actually used Magic? I'm a reporter for a new startup Tech.pro and am writing a story about Magic. Looking for users. Please let me know! Thanks!
You would seriously trust some random person to clean baby bottles for you? Seriously? What the hell.
If I had to get those things at 3AM - I don't know where you live, but for me (Out in the country), it's a 10 minute journey to a 24 hour supermarket, then 10 minutes back. The child would likely nap in the car.
> How is texting a pizza order to Magic, who then text it to a pizza company (Introducing a middle man) making the world a better place?
In the old days we used to call this a personal assistant. Now an Uber for personal assistants is something that would be really useful because I sure as hell don't have the money or the need for a full time assistant.
Although I have considered hiring somebody on a retainer basis to just be available for a few hours of menial tasks a few times a week or month.
I spent the weekend with a bunch of venture partners at a firm's off site and Magic came up a few times in conversation: not ''is it a killer idea?'' (of course, if it works) but ''can it scale?''.
Some business models simply don't scale until some amorphous inflection point in tech/attitudes/etc hits, no matter how much we want them to.
There's a healthy argument to make for raising and burning a bunch of money to aggregate users together in anticipation of the market shortly hitting that scaling inflection point, but it's still a big gamble (albeit one I think Magic and a handful of competitors will all take).
And then ultimately if it can scale, I think Amex and Visa/MC buy up competitors and make it a loss leader/free service attached to their card services.
I predict a lot of new SMS services headed our way. e.g. If I'm EXP on American Airlines, why don't they have a concierge # for me to text with? Why doesn't Seamless have a # for food delivery? etc.
The term "SMS Services" reminds me of the archaic term "CD-ROM Industry", which was so popular before that "industry" was blindsided by the Internet. Fetishizing the medium itself, without taking a step back and asking "what's the actual product, and the best way to deliver it?" Why SMS and not Siri?
I don't think there will be "a lot of new SMS services headed our way." The real value to the user for Magic is that you can use it for everything. Pizza one day, flight reservations the next. You don't need to google multiple numbers for things.
And if there were multiple SMS services for pizza ordering or flight reservations or whatever, then Magic would just subcontract out to those smaller services, and people would still just use Magic.
Magic isn't going to exist in a year, so that's a non-premise.
They're going to drown and the temporary hype will go away (needed to support the volume, which will fall out from under their service just about the time they're trying to raise serious capital), long before they can scale up and deliver on the premise.
Someone else will make a lot of money off of a service like this, but it is not going to be Magic.
Keep in mind that sometimes the less you do, the better you do it. "Doing everything" sounds great but often just means the execution of various "things" suffers. Whereas Seamless for example just focuses on food and can no doubt provide better service there.
Magic is chatroulette. A bizarre, temporary amusement. It acquires your curiosity, it gets media buzz because of the premise (which can't be delivered on), but the foundation under it and the 'company' behind it is sand.
To pull off Magic, realistically, will require extraordinary resources and execution. Magic will flame out long before they can manage to acquire such.
A company like Amazon however, might just attempt a variation of it. For Amazon it can be another AWS service: ordering things as a web service. Amazon sources contractor labor, said labor gets reviewed / rated. It's a form of mechanical turk.
So how are you saving the world or does it bother you that other people are trying to make a difference? This tone towards startups and founders, I get it, but in the anonymous internet I have to wonder, who are these people and what are they doing that they think gives them a superior moral position. Or is it just that the other person has supposedly taken a superior moral position so you can argue however you want?
I'm not the one claiming to be saving the world. A lot of startups do seem to genuinely believe that what they are working on will save humanity (Or they'll sell the crappy website for billions and spend the money solving world hunger or something).
You should watch "Sillicon Valley" if you haven't already. I'm pretty sure they took a lot of it straight from YCombinator. And it's hilarious. "Magic" would fit right in on there, as it's comedy gold.
It's the little things. It allows you to focus on whatever you think is more important, while someone specialized in the task can do it maybe more efficiently than you can.
It's the good ol' fashioned trade of money for time, and trading is what makes an economy work.
Call your pizza company and see how much effort it takes you to order a pizza to your house. They don't know your card number, your address, etc.
Compare with magic: "I want a large pepperoni pizza". Confirm the price, you're done. About 20 seconds of time involved.
Assuming your time is worth, I don't know, $20/hour or more, this seems to be worth the money directly--not even accounting for less cognitive load, loss of focus, daily happiness, whatever.
The pizza company sucks at taking your pizza order. Magic doesn't suck at it.
In my city, restaurants are typically very loud and staffed by someone who does not speak any of the languages that I do. There are ~ ten million people in my city with this problem, so Magic/Seamless/whatever is valuable because it prevents me from shouting, straining to hear, and repeating myself four times, only to find later that the order is wrong because I have no meaningful checksum to insure correctness.
I find it a little odd that the canonical use case for Magic in these examples seems to be ordering your favorite dish to your home. I would agree with you, the complexity/cognitive load of this is low and with e.g. Seamless you get more control over the order and timeframe for little to no extra overhead.
But I could see a huge value in having someone make these decisions for you when it's something that's far outside of your normal routine. The last time I went skiing for example, we landed in the small ski town at night and needed to get dinner, we ended up calling around to 4 different places and making a bunch of arbitrary decisions and still had no idea if the food would even be good. Someone else (or eventually software) could have done that just as effectively and it would have saved us a lot of stress, in that scenario it really would feel like magic.
No, but I understand that there's plenty of people who do.
FWIW it's more like 5-10 minutes every time I've ever ordered pizza (admittedly not often, I'm sure my pizza skills could improve, if I worked on them. I don't want to.)
Magic doesn't magically know your address/payment, of course, but it remembers it in the future. For every service, including new ones. I'm sure you actually knew that already. Point is it's one-time, ever.
My Domino's Pizza online account remembers both my address and my last/favorite orders. (I could even let it remember my card number, but I don't.) Ordering pizza consists of visiting the website, selecting "Yep, that same thing again", and following through the order process.
Granted, Magic has that for all transactions, but pizza can already be pretty convenient.
I'm not wholeheartedly disagreeing, but there's so much more to consider:
1) You're not at home.
2) You don't always order Dominos.
3) You don't even know what's available for delivery (I'm in a less urban area than most--Pizza Hut just started delivering in the last 12 months, and doesn't deliver to the whole city)
Essentially, when things get complex, Magic's cognitive load hardly changes at all. If it's a matter of routine (same pizza, same company, same house), your way is probably worth saving the money they charge.
Anyway, my pizza place has none of that. Including "online account," my pizza guy would have a good laugh at that.
>The pizza company sucks at taking your pizza order. Magic doesn't suck at it.
My regular pizza company is completely painless to order from, both on the phone or online. They know my address, don't need my credit card number because I pay via credit card at the door, and they even have my order history. This is 2015. Maybe you need a new pizza company?
FWIW my very favorite pizza company is a local place in my city that doesn't deliver. It probably goes without saying they also don't have a website, any way to store card data, etc. His register is a cashbox.
I have every expectation that Magic would handle that order for me, though. Probably slowly, if the article is any indication, but I'm assuming they'll get better.
I wasn't really talking about my local shop, though, so point taken. It'd be pretty enjoyable to get "hey mr. mod!" and I say "hey, give me what i got last time, please." and hang up.
I don't want to bother with paying at the door, but I'd tough it out, I guess.
If the Pizza company is doing it right, they do have my address and payment info just from the number that pops up on callerID.
There is some pain points (god I hate myself right now) that magic could solve, but ordering food isn't one of them.
Grubhub or seamless is just easier. It takes longer to tell someone your order correctly that to just to it yourself.
I also do wonder if a pay per use secretary will actually work. My secretary knows me so she can better make choices. Someone with just a chat log has a harder go of it.
I imagine I am not alone in wanting a pretty specific pizza order (the restaurant, the toppings, the crust, etc.), which greatly diminishes the value proposition of saving time.
"Okay, google. Send a text message to magic I'd like a hand-tossed pizza, supreme but without olives, with butter and marinara sauce on the side, and a 2 liter of coke."
I mean, you're going to have to tell someone the specifics of your order. It's all the rest of the details where you're saving time.
What it demonstrates to me is that online pizza ordering systems are too difficult to use. I know what I want and don't want to be asked a million questions or fill out endless forms. Magic might not be a good service, but lessons can be learned from it.
Hey lots of people use administrative assistants, for good reason. Days have 24 hours; somebody else to help you save minutes or hours has good marginal value. Doesn't matter what they're doing, just so you don't have to do it.
The JVM as a plugin is almost dead on desktop already, due to very bad past malware vector experiences.
Anyway, plugins are dead code walking, not only because of security worries, but because "mobile" in full trumps desktop, and the de-facto "no plugins on mobile" OS-set standard.
Plugins alas are still "facultative not obligate" on the desktop, so browsers support them. Even on desktop, their days are numbered (see Chrome killing NPAPI plugin support; see also Shumway).
The JVM isn't going to be integrated directly (i.e., not as a plugin) into browsers, either.
For all its virtues on the server side, and I'm thinking of multiple JVMs here going back to the CLDC VM that Macromedia tried to license from Sun for Flash (rejected: they did Tamarin instead), "the" JVM is nowhere near a clean fit on the client side.
This leaves the already-obligate-not-facultative JS VMs, which are evolving fairly rapidly due to browser competition, serving both hand-coded and compile-to-JS workloads.
All as predicted! I think Dave Herman first spoke about this at Web Rebels in 2012, and a bunch of us have laid bets well before then, including on HN. Yeah, I've been hard on PNaCl as a would-be better plugin for safe native code, not due to the tech itself as because of the opportunity cost.
Now that it's 2015, everyone seems to be on convergent paths toward some kind of LLVM-compiled, cross-browser, safe-native intermediate code that's evolved from JS (starting from asm.js, but not restricted to the current subset, e.g., shared memory threads could be added only to the intermediate code and its runtime).
Such a "WebAsm" or js.bin format would then co-evolve with JS until source code download goes away -- if JS source download ever does (I'm skeptical, but given enough time, it could happen).
Lots of risk still, but this remains by far the shortest-distance evolutionary path from where we are.
The JVM is indeed great in many ways. The main issues with it today, I would say, are
* Patent and copyright issues - the lawsuit with Google is still going on, last I heard.
* There used to be serious technical issues with startup speed. People saw websites with Java applets and saw how slow they were to load. If that hasn't been fixed, it's a serious problem, as websites do need to load fast, unlike typical Java applications.
edit:
* A big use case is compiled C++ code. I am aware of lots of languages compiling to the JVM, but I actually don't think I heard of C and C++. Is there such an option? If such an option doesn't exist, or exists but runs more slowly than asm.js currently does (which is pretty close to native already), it would be a problem.
Could Java applets modify the DOM? Were they nicely integrated with the Browser interface? Did they come bundled within the browser for easier installation and upgrades by their users?
Sure there's some parallels, but don't pretend industry ditched Java applets due to ignorance. Javascript in the browser, for 99% of web applications, provides a much better user experience. The developer experience we could argue here, but I'd say nowadays developing client side JS (or TypeScript, CoffeeScript, Haxe etc.) isn't that bad. The tooling is great and there's if anything, too many frameworks to choose from (competition is good!).
The same arguments apply for Flash, really. Flash integrated slightly better with browsers at the expense of being a resource hog.
As for why not the Java VM, my guess is that the browsers are staggeringly enormous piles of C++ code and trying to integrate a Java VM into it would probably be insanely difficult, and anything other than pure 100% integration, too slow to use. It is probably literally easier to continue with the already-integrated JS VM and improve it up to JVM-esque quality than to try to graft the JVM into the browsers that exist today.
Or somebody would have already have tried since nothing would have prevented JS from already running on the JVM, if that were feasible; asm.js is actually independent of this question when it comes down to it.
The JVM does not run in the browser. Its windows can run physically "in" the browser window, inasmuch as it would appear that the Java app was "in" the browser, but the Java app itself was a "plugin", and was a separate OS process. That's not the right kind of "in".
The JVM has never run in the same process as the browser, to the best of my knowledge, with the exception of the ill-fated "HotJava" browser: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HotJava which ran Java applets "in" the browser by virtue of being written in Java, instead of C++. At the time this was too sluggish for general use, though.
So allow me to repeat myself: We can't run the JVM in the browser right now. The impedance mismatch between the JVM and the C++ world are just too great to have sufficient performance right now. All the current browsers are enormous piles of C++ code. There is no way to "just" integrate a JVM directly into them, and no bridge between the two is going to have enough performance for the demands we're putting on browsers. It doesn't matter how awesome Java may or may not be when the browsers aren't in Java. It's not an option today, short of replicating Sun's feat and rewriting your own browser in Java. But the only thing stopping you from doing that is the sheer size of the task, rather than any technical problem. (But make no mistake, it is an enormous undertaking now to write an engine capable of replacing any of the existing ones for even a single well-chosen use case.)
> You know tons of language already compile and run on the JVM, right?
Yes. So?
> And you know the JVM ran in the browser almost 20 years ago,
And it did such a good job that everyone has been prefering java applets to html/js/flash for those 20 years.
Oh, actually, they didn't. In fact, with few exceptions, they have been rejected by users for most of those 20 years. The implementation was horrible. I don't know if it's better today - maybe it is for some Windows browsers. But no browser on my Mac or Linux supports it without an external install -- and last time I actually used it (~2 years ago), it still took forever to start applets.
It might have worked if the execution was acceptable; it's not impossible - flash had reasonable execution which lead to widespread adoption that is still nontrivial despite a big part of the web - that of mobile - made it unusable. And yet, 18 years later (I'm up-to-date as of 2 years ago), Java applets are still a mess.
So, the bottom line is: who cares the JVM ran in the browser?
The applet user experience is horrible, you're right. It's pathetic that this hasn't been fixed.
Instead, we're developing apps on a platform intended for delivering documents, and targeting code to a "bytecode" (asm.js) built on a half-baked language originally intended for doing form validation, pop-up ads, and animating dancing bears.
Java and the JVM form a 3/4 baked language environment originally designed to run on washing machines, freezers and TV-top sets - that after 20 years can't even get applets and GUI properly.
See how easy it is?
Yes, I completely dislike JavaScript. I also completely dislike Java. But both are here to stay, regardless of their (lack of) merits compared to some ideals. Java missed the browser bus because it was horrible, and JavaScript drives the bus now because it was there.
Hah. I totally agree. I personally dislike both Java and Javascript, also. Javascript was born brain damaged. Java had a chance, but it jumped the shark sometime in the early 2000's when J2EE took off.
There is a tendency for history to repeat itself in programming, since, as Alan Kay put it, programming is "not quite a field" as it lacks a proper sense of its own history. So going by this, I predict that VM vulnerabilities are going to creep into the JS ecosystem, put there in the name of optimization, much like the "Use After Free" vulnerabilities in the JVM for Android.
We're reinventing the wheel because the Java plugin didn't reach critical mass. There's never been a time that you could require Java in a web app and expect a trouble free experience for your users.
Perhaps the browser/OS vendors and Oracle could have worked together to make this happen, but they didn't, and the world moved on.
We have separate events for women in chess tournaments as well. Could it possibly gasp be that womens brains are different to mens? Or is that utterly too horrifying to some to comprehend...
Even scrolling seems sort of "off" and choppy, at least on Safari (both OS X and iOS). It looks pretty I guess, but how the hell did they manage to mess up scrolling?
But other forms of gambling are not? The bookies? The slot machines in the pub? Online poker?
I don't see why the lottery (which is the only gambling that has any measurable positive impact on society) deserves to be singled out. Or is it that the positive impact that makes it a tax, instead of just a way of [company k] making profits.
While I don't buy, I think if someone does so with disposable income, I don't see a problem. Honestly I could even see some people might even enjoy the process of buying a lottery ticket so they might actually be getting a value back for every ticket.
> You can't spend the time dreaming you'll win it, if you don't buy a ticket.
I think this statement is more key to a lot of things than people realize. You can never be lucky if you don't take chances. People often like to defend gambles they take in life by using expected returns/risks as a premise that they are making an "informed risk". At the end of the day, however, buying stocks, creating a business, starting a new job, etc, are all gambles.
Is it a real issue if someone is doing really good things for society, being an excellent person, but happens to disagree with you about evolution or climate change?
Science is getting to be its own fundamental religion for many IMHO, who prescribe 'science' as the answer to everything, and treat scientific papers as the bible (They also cherry pick the scientific papers they like, and ignore the ones they don't, just like religious folks do).
Also, the link you cite for climate change is 404, but I would expect the only real bone of contention is whether any change in the climate is caused by humans or not. Are there really people who deny the climate is changing?