Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | simplechris's commentslogin

I am very interested in hearing about your experiences migrating to vespa. When it was opensourced we all thought it would be an absolute game-changer, but I see so few people building new products (or migrating existing products to) vespa.


You can contact me. I'm also planning to do a blog post comparing with Solr and Elasticsearch. I think that naturally it takes some time to adopt a solution like that. And the ecosystem it still at it infancy. But, randomly, a project using Vespa appeared in my GitHub timeline today (https://github.com/rdoume/News_API). So, the adoption is increasing.

For me Vespa is a absolute game-change, in features and as someone said here, ES looks like it intentionally complicated to maintain. With nodes randomly getting unhealthy. Vespa is like Redis to me. I completely forgot about maintaining it and works great.

It makes a world of difference in our product, and I take every opportunity to evangelize it.


That's interesting to hear. Would love to read about how Vespa compares to Solr and ES.

This may be of interest to you: https://sematext.com/opensee/report/project/trend?q=ElasticS...

Would you happen to know how Vespa compares to ES in terms of memory or CPU footprint? Have you done apples to apples comparison by any chance?


I do not have a completely fair comparison. But a migration from Elasticsearch 5 (2016) to the Vespa 7 (2019) we reduced half of our nodes, and cut in half the average response time. Another amazing feature during the migration, is that Vespa allows you to reduce or increase the number of nodes dynamically. And it take full care about the data distribution. In ES we (used to) had to follow the limits of the pre-configured number of shards/replicas during the Index creation.


I have been wondering why Vespa isn't getting much traction. Everyone still defaults to ES, even in new project.


It should be marketed better, I feel. Some SEO for "Solr/lucene vs X" queries might help. I have been spending the last 3-4 months studying open source and commercial search systems, but it's only in this thread that I discovered Vespa.


We do at Vimeo: I gave a talk this week at the NY Elasticsearch meetup about a new search product we built using ES. If you're interested you can access the recording of the livestream here: https://vimeo.com/348443979 The product in question is https://vimeo.com/stock


Vimeo HQ is just around the corner too


Fair points, but I think it's important to highlight the distinction between Elasticsearch BV, (the company - who will try to continue to offer commercial services and support to grow their business - fair enough) and the Elasticsearch project, which is the open source project.

As a company, Elasticsearch BV will reinvest back into the Elasticsearch project, which will increase the adoption and value of their commercial services. Both exist independently, but the success of either improves the other.


I've been really impressed with how easy it was to set up and instantly identify bottlenecks within our infrastructure. Sure, other plugins have offered similar statistics (and some with a nice UI too) but to provide all of this insight out-of-the-box and in a single tool is an amazing addition to Elasticsearch, and in my opinion will help boost even more widespread adoption.

If anyone is interested, I wrote about my initial reactions to Marvel here: http://chrissimpson.co.uk/elasticsearch-marvel-monitor-and-m...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: