Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | thankthunk's commentslogin

Retirement? The guy visited china and met with the leader of china to calm relations after trump got elected.

http://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy-defence/article/205...

A german born professor with a thick accent to National Security Advisor and then Secretary of State overnight ( the third most powerful position in government )? How does that happen?

The guy is a war criminal but the media is in love with him.


> Do not write scripts with bash.

It's a bit too late for that. Bash is pretty much the de facto default shell for linux. Telling people not to use bash scripts is like telling web devs not to use javascript or OS devs not to use C.

It may change in the future, but bash is so entrenched, it's going to take an extraordinary use case for people to move from bash.


Bash is nowhere close for being de facto default shell for Linux. This is a bad analogy. In this case it is more like telling people that want to code Javascript to only write it in React. You got to go from something generic to something specific. Scripts written with bash will often rely on bash-specifics and can therefore only be interpreted by bash. There are entire projects dedicated to stop this plague. If you want to write portable shell scripts, use dash.

https://linux.die.net/man/1/checkbashisms https://mywiki.wooledge.org/Bashism https://wiki.ubuntu.com/DashAsBinSh https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/bashism


> Bash is nowhere close for being de facto default shell for Linux.

Oh, yes it is. Every important distribution uses bash as the default.


Ubuntu has dash as /bin/sh.


But bash as the login shell.


Login shell means your interactive shell. It does not necessarily mean that that shell should be used for scripting.


> It may change in the future, but bash is so entrenched, it's going to take an extraordinary use case for people to move from bash.

You don't know your history. Exactly such a move has already happened once, a decade ago. And it was a success.

* https://lists.debian.org/debian-release/2007/07/msg00027.htm...

* http://initscripts-ng.alioth.debian.org/soc2006-bootsystem/b...

* https://wiki.debian.org/BootProcessSpeedup#Using_a_faster_sy...


bash is completely out of date on macOS (GPL2 vs. GPL3), and not shipped on any *BSD AFAICT.

Some Linux distro don't ship it either (void, alpine IIRC).

And, most of the time, bash is used because people don't know any better, see e.g. https://github.com/OpenRA/OpenRA/pull/8405/files


> bash is completely out of date on macOS

I love finding and removing all the GNU/Linux-ism in my bash code when I move it from a dev host to my personal laptop. macOS coreutils don't have GNU longopts, surprise!


In case you didn't know: if you really need some GNU tool, you can do `brew install coreutils` (assuming you use Homebrew).

The installed binaries will have their names prefixed with `g`; e.g. `gdate` instead of `date`.

If something you want isn't part of coreutils, you can often install it directly; e.g. `brew install gawk` or the weirdly-named `brew install gnu-sed` (which names its installed binary `gsed`... go figure.)


I know this; but can I teach every potential user of my scripts this same fact through documentation I have to maintain? What if: I write the code so that documenting it is easier?


Quite some people use Zsh interactively.


>Telling people not to use bash scripts is like telling web devs not to use javascript or OS devs not to use C.

Wow, this comparison is totally whack. Javascript and C are both standardized and the former is the only option when using a web browser.

It's never too late. We managed to get people off of ANSI C and there's a similar amount of difference between ANSI* C and C89 as there is between bash and sh.

* correction: pre-ANSI


[flagged]


>Javascript isn't the only option. It is the most popular by far and hence the "de facto" language of the web. And javascript certainly isn't "standardized" in the sense you are writing. Do you know anything about web development, browser implementation of javascript and javascript itself? Javascript is no more "standardized" than SQL is standardized. Every RDBMs implements their own flavor of SQL just like browsers do with javascript.

This is nonsense. I am very familiar with web browsers. Javascript is standardized as ECMAScript:

https://www.ecma-international.org/publications/standards/Ec...

The "standard library" browsers implement is also standardized:

https://www.w3.org/standards/

You're off your rocker.

>Did I say it was too late? Of course I didn't. Maybe if you took a step back from your fanboyism and read...

Here is a direct quote from your comment:

>It's a bit too late for that. Bash is pretty much the de facto default shell for linux.

>ANSI C and C89 are the same thing. ANSI C is just another name for C89... Sigh...

Derp, I meant K&R C or pre-ANSI C. My mistake.


> This is nonsense [...] You're off your rocker.

Come on Drew, you know better than to do this here, regardless of how wrong someone is. If senior users set this kind of example how can we tell new ones not to?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


You're right, I'm sorry.


> Come on Drew, you know better than to do this here, regardless of how wrong someone is.

But I wasn't wrong. I was right. But you wouldn't know that because your a gender studies major and not a CS major.

> If senior users set this kind of example how can we tell new ones not to?

And yet no flagging and no ban. How hypocritical of you. The guy instigated it and yet you banned the victim rather than the victimizer. Also senior? I've been using hacker news since the very beginning. Long before trash like you arrived daniel.


"Regardless of how wrong someone is" does not imply that anyone was wrong. It just says that even if they're wrong, other users must remain civil. That's why we use that wording.


[flagged]


We've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. Would you please not create accounts to do that with?

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


A quick question. How proud are your parents that you moderate comments on a silly forum? Do they brag about your "career" during family gatherings on thanksgiving? Do you ever wake up and realize that you moderate comments for a living and get depressed/suicidal? Can you think of a more worthless existence that moderating comments? I commend you for not jumping in front of a train or jumping off a bridge. It takes real fortitude for someone so useless to keep going.


Of course. Especially when proprietary software/intellectual property is involved.

I don't know of any tech shop that makes the source code available to the QA. QA is normally a "black box" operation. It exists to test/use the software as your client/user would. So QA just tests the software/app and then signs off on it or if there is an error, they update the bug tracker and assign it to the relevant dev.


> Of course. Especially when proprietary > software/intellectual property is involved.

I'm not sure how this is relevant. Surely, the more qualified someone is in software engineering, the more likely they will be able to make nefarious use of the stolen code.

> I don't know of any tech shop that makes > the source code available to the QA.

Sure, that's fair.

My point wasn't about QA specifically, but about GP's point about not letting someone who has (only) completed a couple of Udemy courses touch the code. That doesn't seem warranted, and I've personally seen people who have never written production code review someone else's code and find where it didn't match their idea of what it should do.

I wish it were more common, but it requires both motivation (on the part of domain experts / non-SWEs) and trust (on the part of the tech folks).


> I'm not sure how this is relevant.

It's relevant because you want to limit the number of people who have access to your proprietary software. It's pretty straightforward.

> the more likely they will be able to make nefarious use of the stolen code.

The point is to limit the "surface area". There is absolutely no reason for QA to have access to the source code. Giving them access is simply opening up another security vulnerability. It's not even using the code for nefarious purposes. People can sell the code for money.

> and I've personally seen people who have never written production code review someone else's code and find where it didn't match their idea of what it should do.

What? That makes absolutely no sense. Are you talking about tech leads or managers? Who reviews code who has never written code? That's like saying someone who never learned chinese critiquing chinese literature. Makes absolutely no sense.

> I wish it were more common, but it requires both motivation (on the part of domain experts / non-SWEs) and trust (on the part of the tech folks).

It makes no sense to do so. Especially in terms of security. Especially when proprietary software is involved.


I accept your points about limiting the surface area, but it applies more to tech companies than it does to other types of companies. For many (maybe most?) companies, their proprietary code is barely useful enough for its intended purpose within the context of that company's operations, and would be less than useful to a competitor.

"Who reviews code who has never written code?"

I'm not talking about reviewing code as in 'code review', but reading code to understand what it's doing.

And I didn't talk about anyone who has 'never written code', but someone who has never written production code. The article also wasn't talking about people who have never written code; if you do a Udemy coding course, you'll write at least some code.

I worked at a place a few years ago that had some popular consumer tech products. I was using one of them, and experienced what I thought was a strange error message. I was able to search the code base for the error message, and read the ~20 lines of code before it, to understand how it was triggered. I was then able to file a very specific bug about what I thought was wrong with the logic. I didn't need to be a SWE, tech lead or engineer manager to do that. I didn't learn to code using Udemy courses, but someone who did could have done the same thing in the same situation.


> I feel like the decline of traditional television is behind a lot of the push to destroy net neutrality.

It's the decline of TV, news and traditional media in general. Look at what the news industry has been able to do against social media/tech companies. Brow beat them into serving as spammers for their own news content so that news companies can make more money. The same thing is happening with TV. Youtube is now spamming traditional tv content at the expense of regular youtube content. I used to get variety of recommendations from programming to sports to "trending comedy". Now I get recommendations for things I've never watched on youtube - John Oliver, Late Night Shows, Saturday Night Live, CNN, etc.

They couldn't compete in the new internet/social media environment, so traditional media is forcing the environment to change for them. It's been working for them in the short term, but will it work in the long term? I hope not, but who knows.

The changes have been incremental, but people truly don't understand how much google search, youtube, reddit, facebook, etc has changed in the last 4 years.

The internet/social media has gone from local/non-traditional media content to predominantly corporate content. And it's a trend that's going to accelerate as tech/social media is pushed to favor corporate content over ordinary user content.


> I am inherently suspicious of these types of nanny-tech initiatives.

As you should be. It just gives google more excuse to monitor you. They have justification for monitoring you more closely. To "help" you.

It's so funny to me how the HN crowd who attacked google,facebook, etc relentlessly for monitoring their users are now demanding google,facebook,etc monitor their users even more to manipulate their behavior.

What happened to individual responsibility? And why the focus solely on social media? Should ISPs do the same thing? What about 24/7 stores? What about TV? What about news organizations? Should we only allow news organizations to print on odd numbered days to help news junkies?

I know most of the anti-social media rhetoric is just paid propaganda funded by the elites who want control over social media. But I just don't understand the supposedly "independent minded free thinking" liberals on hacker news advocating for nanny-state and nanny-corporations.

Is this hacker news or geriatric news. It seems like most posters on here are bitter 50+ year olds who rail against technology. There is something so eerie and strange about the HN crowd lately. Is it that most HN are just old now?

I would never expected this type of thinking from developers, let alone "hackers" on "hacker" news.


> the economist publishes articles of extraordinary quality

No they don't. They offer fluff. This article is just fluff and years old news. Maybe because I work in the tech industry, but this article didn't offer anything of value. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that $100 billion dollar fund dedicated to tech investing ( especially in developing nations ) is going to have an impact.


the paper has been in circulation for close to a 175 years and is ranked as the most trusted journalistic publication ( https://www.rjionline.org/reporthtml.html ) - do yourself a favor, get the print edition convince yourself. I've been a reader for years and highly recommend it.


> the paper has been in circulation for close to a 175 years

The NY Post has been in circulation for over 200 years. Not sure what your point is.

> is ranked as the most trusted journalistic publication

That isn't a good thing. Think about it.

> do yourself a favor, get the print edition convince yourself. I've been a reader for years and highly recommend it.

Does it seem like I've never read the economist to you? It's information pollution. You are dumber and more misinformed for having read it. The economist along with every other media publication should come with a warning like cigarettes.


> Frankly that's luck. No doubt he is smart and has smart people working for him but that's pure luck.

All investment is "luck" if you put it that way.

> All but one gone and that tiny $20 mil investment saves it all.

That investment didn't save it all. Softbank was a multibillion dollar company before and after their investment in alibaba. With or without alibaba, they would still be around.

Not sure where you are getting the idea that alibaba saved softbank. Softbank's Alibaba stake makes softbank very valuable, but it would be around without alibaba.


>>Not sure where you are getting the idea that alibaba saved softbank. Softbank's Alibaba stake makes softbank very valuable, but it would be around without alibaba.

Without Alibaba they would have lost, say, 100% of their investment in the 90's. Makes a great "trust us with $100 Billion, we have a great record" pitch.

Also, "still being around" and worth a lot of money and still being trusted with investment money are two very different things.


Because the guy was justifying taking and keeping the DNA material for perpetuity with his anecdote.

It's the quintessential example of authoritarianism defense. One instance of good justifies authoritarianism and violation of individual liberties and freedom.


> I was told that I could not opt out and that the sample becomes the property of the State and there is nothing I could do about it.

That is so disgusting. For all the talk about individuality and liberalism, it's amazing how liberal societies are so authoritarian and controlling.

If you don't own your DNA, then what do you own? But I guess big brother knows what's best for us.


DNA is a pretty hard thing to keep private. I wouldn’t think of it as one of the last things you lose right before liberty.


Well, when you don't own the majority of the fruits of your own labor, then I'd say your "DNA" is a drop in the bucket in comparison. But yeah, precisely how you feel is how Libertarians and other actual free-minded individuals feel about concepts such as taxation.

Personally, I don't see DNA as that intrinsic or important as others do. It's just a piece of information about the composition of my body. Sure, if they could completely clone my brain and the essence of what I am, then I could get behind something like this. But as is, I'd just be peeved that someone gets to "use" my DNA. Same way I get peeved that Google/Facebook "use" my browsing habits to train their ML algorithms.


I’m most worried that in the future our DNA could be used by health insurers the way financial institutions use credit scores. Those with genetic predisposition to expensive conditions might never be insureable.


That would be society doing that, not just insurance companies.

Just like before the ACA it was society at large that didn't worry too much about people being dropped from insurance. Sure, people moralize about how awful it is, but then they take the policy with the lower rate instead of the better underwriting.


[flagged]


> In the Netherlands, gym membership require drug tests

Ehh, that's bull. It doesn't.

(source: Dutch, with gym membership)


Does it maybe require accepting that random or targeted drug tests can be carried out and you have no right to refuse? Source this is the case in several countries.


I've never heard of this happening in The Netherlands. I googled around on the Dutch 'net, but nothing came up.

Also, there is no legal basis for subjecting employees or applicants to drug tests. So it does not happen here.

I'd be interested to know which countries you are referring to.


Denmark and Norway. I think that it's the law in both of those not just gym policy/terms and conditions.


Why do/should they care if people in the gym are on drugs or not?

I understand you can be fired from the job because of them (due to negative affect they might have on your work), and when participating in competitive sports, but rejecting someone to the gym for the sole reason of them being on drugs seems in-line to refusing them serving in a supermarket for the same reason.


NB I don't necessarily agree with it.

This is legislation not gym terms and conditions. It is about public policy towards steroids. I.e. one mentally unstable person did something criminal whilst using steroids and then there was a moral panic.


Another Dutchman here: never heard of drug tests. Not work, not for gym memberships. Obviously.

The only drug tests i've ever heard about are for pro sports leagues.


> and many rental properties require, either formally or informally, occupants to be of Dutch nationality.

I asked around my expat friends here in The Netherlands, and they could not confirm this.


> corporate, neoliberal, infantile fascism

Not so infantile anymore.

> "pussification" ... "SJW"

Please keep this words limited to 4chan.


> Both nationalism nor patriotism barely make sense any more. Time are changing.

People said the same thing in the late and early 20th century before ww1 and ww2. They were wrong.

> If you read it, you will realize that all of civilization is fundamentally based on global markets and the global shipping of crude oil and other resources.

Modern nations are dependent on oil for sure. That's what ww1 and ww2 was fought over.

> In the long run, all countries have to work together or modern society will fail.

That's fundamentally not true. Certain nations, like the US, don't have to work with anyone. We are one of the few nations who have enough resources ( including oil ) to keep our civilization running. If you expand the US to include the anglo-nations ( Canada, Australia, etc ), then we are more than able to keep our society running without the rest of the world.

> In a nutshell, we live in an essentially transnational society and this cannot change unless you're willing to give up almost all of modern technology.

What? Maybe if you are denmark or iceland, but that doesn't hold true for the US.

Also, your entire argument is about international trade, not transnationalism. You need nations to have international trade.

And as I said, your argument isn't new. It's been long debunked. The same argument was made in the midst of pax britannica before ww1 and ww2. People argued that nations were too dependent on each other for wars to break out. Hell, people argued that germany would never attack the soviet union since most of germany's oil/resources came from the soviet union.

The current international system will continue as long as nations deem it beneficial to themselves. If it ceases to be, then it will end.

There is nothing inherently good or bad about any system. And I highly doubt china, russia and much of the world will adhere to the US/European led international system for much longer.

Pax americana will come to an end like all "pax" in the past. Instead of clinging to silly utopian transnationalism, we should be preparing ourselves for a multipolar nationalistic world.

The post ww2 era is an anomaly in human history where one nation ruled the world. The only comparable situation in human history was the mongol empire where mongol's established direct or indirect control over pretty much all of eurasia. That system crumbled also.


>Modern nations are dependent on oil for sure. That's what ww1 and ww2 was fought over.

This is simply, objectively, not true.

>Certain nations, like the US, don't have to work with anyone. We are one of the few nations who have enough resources ( including oil ) to keep our civilization running.

Doesn't the US import almost double what it exports (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=727&t=6)? Also, why has the US worked so hard in the past 70 years to maintain influence across the world, warring and pillaging and murdering, and trading and bribing as well? Doesn't their standard of living rest on the global state of affairs they strive to maintain (or further exploit)?

>The post ww2 era is an anomaly in human history where one nation ruled the world.

In terms of technology, the last 100 years have been more transformative than the 10,000 before. It's silly to compare this to the mongol empire.


> Doesn't the US import almost double what it exports

Yes, though that's due to legal restrictions on domestic drilling, not some sort of physical necessity.

> Also, why has the US worked so hard in the past 70 years to maintain influence across the world, warring and pillaging and murdering, and trading and bribing as well? Doesn't their standard of living rest on the global state of affairs they strive to maintain (or further exploit)?

There are multiple schools of thought and multiple eras of the US. What should be US involvement in UN, Syria, Iraq, Vietnam, Cuba, etc.

I don't think that really disproves the point.


>Pax americana will come to an end like all "pax" in the past. Instead of clinging to silly utopian transnationalism, we should be preparing ourselves for a multipolar nationalistic world.

What if most hegemonic powers in a "pax" period tend toward your pragmatic attitude and as a result create a societal gestalt which becomes a self fufilling prophecy of paralyzed stagnation? Why should we assume that just because a "silly utopian transnationalism" hasn't happened yet it can't possibly happen at all? The technology available to a hegemon in the 21st century is unlike anything a previous hegemon has ever known. Betting the future will follow the patterns of the past is a safe bet until it isn't.


> And as I said, your argument isn't new. It's been long debunked. The same argument was made in the midst of pax britannica before ww1 and ww2. People argued that nations were too dependent on each other for wars to break out. Hell, people argued that germany would never attack the soviet union since most of germany's oil/resources came from the soviet union.

Bingo. Nation states drove society, and they'll continue to drive society.


Very well said. Along the same line of thinking, I'd like to point out a few things from the article that were a bit of a revelation for me:

"As the nearest existing equivalent I have chosen the word ‘nationalism’, but it will be seen in a moment that I am not using it in quite the ordinary sense, if only because the emotion I am speaking about does not always attach itself to what is called a nation — that is, a single race or a geographical area."

"By ‘nationalism’ I mean first of all the habit of assuming that human beings can be classified like insects and that whole blocks of millions or tens of millions of people can be confidently labelled ‘good’ or ‘bad’(1)."

"But secondly — and this is much more important — I mean the habit of identifying oneself with a single nation or other unit, placing it beyond good and evil and recognising no other duty than that of advancing its interests."

"Patriotism is of its nature defensive, both militarily and culturally. Nationalism, on the other hand, is inseparable from the desire for power. The abiding purpose of every nationalist is to secure more power and more prestige, not for himself but for the nation or other unit in which he has chosen to sink his own individuality."

Now, maybe this is somewhat skewed by when it was written, but based on my interpretation of modern people's usage of the word nationalism, it seems completely consistent with current times.....so my question is basically: why is race (and force/violence) considered inseparable from nationalism? Or even more precisely, why is it seemingly only people who live in extremely ethnically diverse societies who think this way (go watch some "man on the street" interview videos on YouTube and you'll see that Modern Western Progressive values that only originated in the last 20 years aren't shared universally across the planet)?

Let's check the dictionary:

Nationalism:

1. spirit or aspirations common to the whole of a nation.

2. devotion and loyalty to one's own country; patriotism.

3. excessive patriotism; chauvinism.

4. the desire for national advancement or political independence.

5. the policy or doctrine of asserting the interests of one's own nation viewed as separate from the interests of other nations or the common interests of all nations.

6. an idiom or trait peculiar to a nation.

7. a movement, as in the arts, based upon the folk idioms, history, aspirations, etc., of a nation.

The only definition even remotely close to race/racism is #3, yet do a google search for "nationalism" in the news and on forums (including this one, and in this very thread) and I bet you'll discover that in the vast majority of cases you'll find it being used in a way that's synonymous with racism.

I will often ask people I see doing this why they do it, what their exact meaning is, but no one will ever answer. In my opinion, these types of people are, ironically, similarly as evil as racists, in that they hate a group of people based on falsehoods or false stereotypes.

I'd love to know if anyone can think of a good explanation for this phenomenon. And considering how widespread it is, "people are dumb, get over it" seems like a completely disingenuous copout, equivalent to a racist-apologist.


>The only definition even remotely close to race/racism is #3, yet do a google search for "nationalism" in the news and on forums (including this one, and in this very thread) and I bet you'll discover that in the vast majority of cases you'll find it being used in a way that's synonymous with racism.

That's because, US and a few other multi-ethnic nations aside, most nation states are either somewhat ethnically consistent, or have one dominant ethnic majority -- and thus nationalism there is also related to ethnicity (and/or race).

Race is also not always seen as meaning whole classes of people (like black, white, asian, latin, etc) but can seen as defined for historically and genetically similar lineage too, so, e.g. Norwegians could be seen as different to Swedish in racial terms (and often such arguments invoke such terms).


Sure, but this doesn't address the phenomenon of why actual (dictionary) nationalism has become synonymous with racism/Nazism. If anything, and I don't mean this disrespectfully, your difficulty in seeing how Western multicultural societies are different in this respect (the assumption that nothing but extreme malice can possibly be behind nationalism) demonstrates my point. Unless I've misinterpreted you, which is very easy (and common) to do in these types of conversations.


>Sure, but this doesn't address the phenomenon of why actual (dictionary) nationalism has become synonymous with racism/Nazism.

Because it was an extreme example, and those tend to dominate further discussion.

Plus nationalism (even in the legit patriotism version) has fallen out of favor in the age of globalism, so everyone who wants to follow the cultural party line feels free to compare it to Nazism.

>If anything, and I don't mean this disrespectfully, your difficulty in seeing how Western multicultural societies are different in this respect (the assumption that nothing but extreme malice can possibly be behind nationalism) demonstrates my point.

Well, for what is worth, I'm not an American, and not exactly westerner either.


> Because it was an extreme example, and those tend to dominate further discussion.

I'm sorry, I'm not understanding your line of thinking. What is an extreme example? And this explains what (I'm referring to "because....")?

> Plus nationalism (even in the legit patriotism version) has fallen out of favor in the age of globalism, so everyone who wants to follow the cultural party line feels free to compare it to Nazism.

No disagreement here, but if this is the case, are people simply unable to see this in themselves? Do they intuitively (as seems to be the case) know not to reply to any questions that might broach that particular possibility?


>I'm sorry, I'm not understanding your line of thinking. What is an extreme example? And this explains what (I'm referring to "because....")?

Sorry, can you state your original question more clearly? It seems obvious to me which is the extreme example I was referring to, and how it answers your question -- besides, I even quoted the part I was replying to.

You asked about how "the phenomenon of why actual (dictionary) nationalism has become synonymous with racism/Nazism" could be addressed.

My answer is that the reason actual (dictionary) nationalism has become synonymous with racism/Nazism is because Nazism was an extreme example of nationalism, and people tend to use extreme examples when discussing a phenomenon.

Plus, racism/Nazism have very ugly connotations, so it makes sense to associate nationalism with those phenomena, in an era when nationalism is in disfavor in favor of globalization.

>No disagreement here, but if this is the case, are people simply unable to see this in themselves? Do they intuitively (as seems to be the case) know not to reply to any questions that might broach that particular possibility?

Yes.


> My answer is that the reason actual (dictionary) nationalism has become synonymous with racism/Nazism is because Nazism was an extreme example of nationalism, and people tend to use extreme examples when discussing a phenomenon.

I mean, this is certainly plausible, but I don't think it's that simple. There are all sorts of examples of degrees of one thing or another, yet is there any other example where a major portion of the public suddenly lost all perspective to the degree that they believe things that are literally incorrect (and mock those who are not)? It's not just that people are exaggerating things, the fundamental beliefs are such that it is considered not possible for a nationalist to not be a racist, if not worse. Rarely are such outrageous and objectively false claims challenged, and frequently any challenge is downvoted to net negative.


>It's not just that people are exaggerating things, the fundamental beliefs are such that it is considered not possible for a nationalist to not be a racist, if not worse. Rarely are such outrageous and objectively false claims challenged, and frequently any challenge is downvoted to net negative.

It's not like the general public (or even more media / public figures for that matter) are well rooted in the history of ideas, or care to examine most the conventional understanding of ideas of their time.

Once a thing falls out of favor (like nationalism has) it gets reduced to some caricature very quickly and can be associated (falsely) with all kinds of prejudices.

Consider the case of the hippy and the underground movements, how they were all the rage in the 60s and 70s and utterly mocked (and misunderstood) from the 80s onwards.


Again, I don't completely disagree, and thank you for actually being willing to have a reasonable discussion. But it's not like I'm springing this question on people in an off-road or inappropriate way. Nationalism is literally the topic of conversation, and many people have expressed disagreement with downvotes if not slurs.

And this isn't a rare occurrence, it is fundamental ideology, apparently not up for discussion or negotiation. People who fundamentally disagree, which wouldn't be you, will not enter a discussion. Ironically, it is the same unthinking behavior that those they hate so much are known for. I'd call it extreme, but it isn't, it has absolutely taken over the mainstream psyche.

When people refuse to think any more, I think some concern and discussion is appropriate.


That's all academic. Current nationalists base their 'nation' on skin color and religion: white and Christian (though the religious aspect is sometimes less emphasized), like ISIS'/Daesh's nationalism based on Islam. You can read people advocating it in HN, just like you can read many attempts to whitewash it.

The endlessly repeated lesson of history is that if human rights are not universal, if you accept the nationalist argument that 'people on my side have rights and those on the other don't', then it ends up justifying denying rights to any person or group, and the brutality that follows. That's why the foundation of the United States is universal human rights, 'all men are created equal and endowed ... with inalienable rights'. We've had enough slavery, segregation, Holocausts, Tutsi massacres, Milosovic's, ISIS's, oppression of women, Nazis, etc, etc. to know how it turns out; we don't need to try again and hope it's different this time.

In contrast, universal human rights as the basis of the post-WWII order has provided the greatest expansion of freedom and prosperity in human history, with no comparison. Why would anyone want to give that up? Why are we looking for ways to divide people and to justify and whitewash hate?

What is the basis of nationalism? That a human being's rights and my regard from them depend on an imaginary line on the earth? One step this way, I love them; one step the other way, I oppose them? It's absurd.

Finally, nationalism is an obsession of a small group imposed on others. The nationalists say all white Christian people are part of their nation, but a most of those people don't see it that way. Certain nationalists claim me as part of their 'nation', but I abhor and oppose them and certainly am not a member. Nationalists are a small group of people who, just like the tyrants and evil people before them, simply try to impose their will on others. I believe the others should live free.


> That's all academic. Current nationalists base their 'nation' on skin color and religion: white and Christian (though the religious aspect is sometimes less emphasized), like ISIS'/Daesh's nationalism based on Islam. You can read people advocating it in HN, just like you can read many attempts to whitewash it.

That's somewhat true only in a very narrow world of USA and ISIS. In most of the world, nationalism is based on very different terms.

> One step this way, I love them; one step the other way, I oppose them? It's absurd.

Nah. Nationalism doesn't mean opposing anybody. It's belonging to community and working for it's greater good.

> Finally, nationalism is an obsession of a small group imposed on others.

Most people don't care about any political, societal or any other philosophical discourses. They just follow few people who are interested in that kind of stuff. As far as I looked all revolutions were imposed by a small group of concerned citizens on the rest of the community. I'm yet to find an exception where majority people truly believed in the original idea from day 1. They just followed people who seemed worthy.


[flagged]


Sure, let's discuss specific political movements. For example spring of nations in mid-19th century Europe or fall-of-iron-curtain movements of late 1980s/early 1990s in, again, Europe.

In both cases they effectively ended oppression and brutality. In most cases, it was direct result of ethnic hatred towards those people who called themselves nationalists.

Humans naturally gravitate towards tribalism. We're simply not capable to feel connected to every human on planet earth. Nationalism is probably one of the better and more sustainable forms of tribalism. Definitely better than highly polarised or multi-cultural (which is totally different from multi-ethnic or multi-racial) societies.

Most of what you listed if chauvinism, not nationalism. On the other hand, I don't see anything wrong if society wants to stay (not become) homogenous. It's easier to come to social contract that way. Which is the most important for healthy society.


> Humans naturally gravitate towards tribalism. We're simply not capable to feel connected to every human on planet earth.

Human have lots of bad instincts - violence, war, hatred, greed, etc etc - but history shows beyond a doubt that we overcome them and it works astoundingly well. But we've overcome those things and built democracies, liberty, a world where violence and war is at historic laws, lifespans are probably double what they were for most of history, women are in the workforce, we walk on the moon, human rights and prosperity have expanded by orders of magnitude. All of that came from the embrace of universal rights and liberty.

> We're simply not capable ...

In fact, we certainly are!

The question is, why would anyone want to take away all that success and ruin it?


> but history shows beyond a doubt that we overcome them and it works astoundingly well

Yes, yes, end of history and all that jazz. Yet greed is at all time high. We had a couple attempts at that in 20th century and it didn't went well at all. Hatred and violence are still strong. I'm

A lot of things you listed were done in societies that didn't fully embrace liberty/democracy/universal rights. USSR or commie China or Japan or Singapore. Western civilisation that did fully embrace them built their prosperity without any of those things and now just run on their former glory.

Walking on the moon was possible specifically because of war effort.

> > We're simply not capable ... > In fact, we certainly are!

Dunbar number. Anything above that needs a super simple approach to keep people together. Greece crises was a fantastic example. Lots of people were against bail out. Meanwhile they were pissed others don't want to help them too. If fellow europeans don't feel strong connection, I doubt they'd truly feel it for culturally much more different people on the other side of the globe.

> The question is, why would anyone want to take away all that success and ruin it?

What success? The success to not be able to keep population at replacement levels? Rampant mental illnesses? All that while democracy support is at 50 years low, liberty is in danger and people are too afraid of violence and war to solve any problem?

Oh and it's been a while since we were on the moon and it doesn't look like it's happening any time soon...


What information source are you using for the above claims?


> That's all academic. Current nationalists base their 'nation' on skin color and religion

They do?

> You can read people advocating it in HN, just like you can read many attempts to whitewash it.

> if you accept the nationalist argument that 'people on my side have rights and those on the other don't'

> We've had enough slavery, segregation, Holocausts, Tutsi massacres, Milosovic's, ISIS's, oppression of women, Nazis, etc, etc. to know how it turns out; we don't need to try again and hope it's different this time.

(I might as well excerpt your entire post, it is the perfect embodiment of my confusion on this topic. As are the rising downvotes, arguably proving my point and censoring my voice, as I will now have to leave this tab open and wait to post my sincere rebuttal later. Freedom of speech is a great principle until it disagrees with your ideas I guess.)

I gave you a definition of nationalism from the dictionary, I will ask you once again: what definition are you using for the word nationalism?

Going further, what is the origin of the various extreme beliefs & hatred you hold? Where did you learn these ideas?


There's no basis offered for any of the parent. Some things are obviously false:

> oil ... That's what ww1 and ww2 was fought over.

> Certain nations, like the US, don't have to work with anyone

> expand the US to include the anglo-nations ( Canada, Australia, etc )

etc.

These are arguments of white christian nationalists, who, as Orwell pointed out about nationalists in general, have no interest in reality, only justifying their hateful cause. They ignore the incredible, outrageous evil of Nazism, the universality and priority of human rights and freedom, basic economic reality, and the predictable destruction that comes with nationalism.

The American-led world order since WWII has led to an expansion of freedom and prosperity orders of magnitude beyond anything else in human history. It also embodies a just and fair way of managing international affairs, through law and democracy rather than the undemocratic system of the strong forcing the weak (it has a long a way to go, but it has come a very long way since WWII). A person must really embrace hate in order to give that up for nationalism, racism, and the destruction that inevitably follows, a return to pre-WWII or even pre-WWI. I suspect many of the white christian nationalists take that peace and prosperity for granted; they don't realize it was constructed by the survivors of WWII, who knew far more of nationalism and the world without a rules-driven world order.


>The American-led world order since WWII has led to an expansion of freedom and prosperity [...] It also embodies a just and fair way of managing international affairs, through law and democracy rather than the undemocratic system of the strong forcing the weak.

Wow... The people in Guatemala [1], Iran [2], Chile [3], Timor [4], and dozens other places will disagree with you. The will of the people stamped down by the boot of American might and imperialism, for the benefit of themselves: for the maintenance of their supreme place in the world on the back of neocolonialist exploitation of weaker countries. Is this not the picture of "undemocratic system of the strong forcing the weak"? Let's not forget the odious bootlicking of Saudi princes, for instance, and their positively medieval rule, for their economic favour.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._intervention_in_Chile#The...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Timor_genocide


> The people in Guatemala [1], Iran [2], Chile [3], Timor [4], and dozens other places ...

Agreed, and I considered whether to include that part of the story. On one hand, every HN comment can be criticized for leaving out details - we always can write more; these aren't dissertations or books, and each comment needs to draw the line somewhere. On the other, I probably should have mentioned that side of it.

But with that issue in mind, I was careful to write something that didn't contradict the parent's point. I said the expansion of freedom and prosperity have been unprecedented, which is true. It should be even more, including for the people of the places mentioned above, but it still has been unprecedented. I also wrote that the international order "embodies a just and fair way of managing international affairs, through law and democracy"; I was careful not to say it implemented those things are actually is democratic; it's not nearly that. But the UN, alongside the leading country actively promoting democracy and liberty is a huge step forward compared to human history, as are other international organizations and structures. There is a very long way to do, and every person that has suffered in those places and does suffer today deserves justice; we have a lot of work to do.


Wow, do I need to proofread ... yikes. Sorry to any readers.


The incidents you cite are indeed deeply regrettable and even shameful. But quaere whether you're overweighting them.


They're more than incidents, they're the intentional modus operandi of the USA.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: