Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

You can just buy hard drugs there instead, it's Oregon!

But you will have to go to a shady place since they only decriminalized them...

If it seems stupid it's because it is.


Behind the counter (BTC) is the specific term for these OTC medicines.


Is that "significant amount of people" based on something or just your own prejudices?

Personally most people I know who don't want the covid vax reached that conclusion after weighing the risk/benefit.

I'm also from an area where "Pray" would be a significant part of their life, but has nothing to do with their decision.


>Personally most people I know who don't want the covid vax reached that conclusion after weighing the risk/benefit

This has to be a class/geographic thing because all but one of the 2 dozen or so people I have met that told me they didnt get the covid vax(rural area, southern state), said they did so for reasons that revolved loosely around " i dont want the demon-crat drug changing my DNA and causing a WHO mass population culling". You could definitely claim that only those types of people are the ones being vocal about it, but the actual demographic breakdown of opinion on the covid vaccine....

https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://...

only 40% of Republicans view the covid vaccine as safe, as of sept. 23. last month. they STILL dont think its safe. compared to 80% for democrats, a lot of that likely to due any loading of the word "safe".


My anecdotes of people's reasons disagree with yours so I don't think they are very useful.

A political breakdown doesn't give you the insight of those people's individual reasoning.


That's why they qualified it.


No we punish the companies now, not the thieves, see Kia and Hyundai.


I think the point of the Kia and Hyundai cases is that customers had some expectation that the locks would actually provide a higher level of security than they actually did. Otherwise why even bother having locks? Saying that "stealing is illegal and we should pushing the thieves not the companies for failing to provide security" completely negates the point of having any security industry.

If you provide a product that is intended to offer a certain level of security you should get punished when your product fails in a spectacular manor.


Weird how the level of protection the Kia and Hyundai locks provide change depending on whether your local law enforcement agencies are effectively able to deter theft?


To some extent, but the TikTok craze was just crashing it, which happened to my parents. The car made it all of 30 ft and they hit a tree. Honestly not sure what local police can do to stop that.


Glass breaks very easily. Locks don’t matter.


You can start a car by breaking glass? That’s even more impressive than the hack in the article!


Is an ignition a lock? How about the wiring to the ignition…?

It would be one thing if Kia and Hyundai advertised “anti theft” via an immobilizer then didn’t actually put one in. They just left it out because the company is being cheap. The cars being sold with this vuln are cheap. You get what you pay for.


Models affected by this extend well into the 30k range. This is not just affecting the cheapest possible vehicle someone can buy and we're running into people not setting expectations accordingly. Equally cheap vehicles from other manufacturers are not nearly this easy to steal, particularly by completely inexperienced thieves.


Have you seen how to steal a Honda built between 1972 and 2000? You get a key from any other Honda, and jiggle it, and off you go.


Yes 30k is cheap when the Average cost of a new car is 48k.

https://www.moneygeek.com/insurance/auto/average-price-of-a-...

This is even worse when vehicles from both brands have absolutely terrible resale value and depreciation.


Cheaper than the mean perhaps, but again not bottom of the barrel for many of these models. However, even if you want to keep focusing on these being 'cheap' vehicles, it STILL stands out in the industry as highly unusual. Even back in 2015, 96% of vehicles from other manufacturers had these devices (https://www.iihs.org/media/0e14ba17-a3c2-4375-8e66-081df9101...). It's a pretty easy argument to make that consumers would not be looking specifically for a feature that is near universal elsewhere. It was an abnormality and Hyundai/Kia will, unsurprisingly, pay for it in the long run.


30k car is definitely not "cheap". That statistics is skewed by 1) high-end cars (Bill Gates walks into a bar, everybody's average income doubles) 2) the fact that people that can't afford expensive cars just buy used ones. That doesn't make the new ones less expensive in any way.


Stating "You get what you pay for" is a strange way to both blame the victims & attempt to absolve multi-billion dollar corporations for not including a standardized piece of security equipment, when you consider that every major manufacturer sells vehicles firmly in the same price bracket - up to half the price of your reported average (we love to forget about outliers, don't we) that have this equipment.

Pedantry about what security was advertised or not will not make a compelling case. What a strange thing to try to argue.


Nobody even knows what an immobilizer is or how it works. They put key in car and go. People don't even read the manuals that come with the car. Most people don't even read signs along the freeways while they're driving.

This kind of willful ignorance about cars goes so far that insurance companies willfully chose to insure these cars against theft, and claimed they had no idea that the cars didn't have immobilizers. And now they are suing the manufacturers. It's the insurance company's job to evaluate risk. All they had to do was read the fucking manual and if it didn't say something in there, ask.


It's not expensive enough to be worth leaving out in basically any car.

Basic security shouldn't be a premium feature.


> It's not expensive enough to be worth leaving out in basically any car.

> Basic security shouldn't be a premium feature.

That’s your opinion presented as a fact.


It is, which is pretty normal for opinion posts.

But your argument that this is okay is also an opinion.


I’m stating the manufacturer did not advertise this security feature, nor did any of the purchasers really care until their cars started getting stolen and used to cause mayhem.

You stated a basic security feature such as an immobilizer should be installed by default because it’s cheap.

Am I missing something?


The implication of "it would be one thing" and "you get what you pay for" is that this product offering is acceptable. Which is an opinion.

If there was no implication intended, then "it would be one thing if X" would be a tautology. Which wouldn't make sense as a post.

And then in contrast, my opinion is that this product offering is not acceptable.


It’s the law in most countries. It is a fact, averaged out globally.


Why not both? People shouldn’t steal cars and companies should probably be held accountable for gross negligence.


This is not a zero sum game.

You can punish both.

Especially considering immobilizers have been mandatory in the EU since the ‘90s and cost a manufacturer less than $1.

This is not some state of the art high tech high cost mitigation.


Well, then I suppose you could rightfully punish the manufacturers for cars sold in Europe that don't have them. But, you should probably not punish manufacturers for cars sold in the US that don't have them until you make it illegal to sell cars without them in the US...


There’s the concept of negligence.

If you distill it down, it essentially comes down to not doing things that no law explicitly requires (lest you end up with walls and walls of law books simply describing very specific matters), but can be reasonably expected of you to have done.

What’s reasonable depends from time period to time period and the norms that exist, nevertheless the concept exists.

A good example would be you owning a house with a balcony in an unincorporated area where no law exists that sets requirements on structural integrity of such things.

You’re aware that the balcony might be a bit iffy and it has been decades since last it was checked out by a professional.

You have guests over, you don’t bother telling anyone to stay away from the balcony. Some of your guests walk underneath the balcony, or worse, they go out onto the balcony to have a smoke.

The balcony collapses and your guests get injured or die.

You’re on the hook for negligence. Specifically negligence that resulted in tort in this case.

Hell, in some places, depending on the prosecutors in the area and the laws on the books, you might even be criminally liable for negligent homicide.

My comment on the EU and the regulations there isn’t to imply that the laws there apply to here in the US, rather it’s used (and could be used in real life) as a way to argue that the solution is inexpensive and not implementing it could be considered negligent because there is an easy solution available due to that regulation.


Sure, negligence is a very useful concept.

But what we're talking about here is that there are "bad guys" (tm) who stopped by your party and used a chain saw to cut the supports under the balcony, which would not otherwise have fallen down. But you could have prevented this if you had reinforced the supports with steel posts.

The Kias and Hyundais didn't steal themselves. Let's put the blame where it lies, on the f**ing criminals.


Are you really taking the side of the idiots who made a modern car you can Hotwire in 45s with no special tools? And then refused to issue a recall and fix the problem?


One if by land, two if by sea.

Either way, let's wait for the video, I don't believe Paul that the Brits are here.


Texas has the most installed wind power capacity of any US state.

Many days the grid runs 100% off of wind energy.


And on the days when there isn’t enough wind, ERCOT sends out mobile phone alerts threatening us with rolling blackouts if we don’t adjust our air conditioners.


Well of course! No one would be worried, if it was just one windmill!


Who do you think allows all those windmills in their pastures?

Never heard anyone complaining other than once about a company trying to not pay out for energy produced.


Nobody shows their true reality in public pictures anyway, it's all staged in some way.

For private pictures, it didn't change your reality, you can lie to yourself, but you've always been able to do that.


but when you take a picture that capture personal moment and some software without your consent alters it with some generative stuff, what would that lead to?

I disagree with lying to yourself. For people who are not mindful and aware, this is severely impact their perception.


> but when you take a picture that capture personal moment and some software without your consent alters it with some generative stuff, what would that lead to?

I mean, do you not look at the photo after you take it? Even if you don't, you were there and saw the original scene. If your memory fails you, it's on you. If you didn't take an accurate picture, it's on you. Check next time.

If anything meaningful is added, it'll be very noticeable, if it's not meaningful, then what does it matter?

Cameras already do a lot of corrections that don't represent reality.

Hell, our perceptions of colors is different than everyone else's.


> what ended up being implemented

He's the CEO, what's implemented is what he wants to do.

He did what he wanted, which was pitch, listen to feedback, and implement. Like a good CEO.


> listen to feedback, and implement.

The whole X debacle has proven once again that Elon will never give up on a bad idea that he has tied his ego to or that was shut down by people he dislikes.

These are exactly the kind of idea that he will jump at once the opportunity arises and the pesky naysayers aren't in the room; "why should we have to bother with any of this privacy or informed consent stuff" is where he's coming from.

That is his style of CEOing, for better or worse.


This event is literally about how he listened to his people.

> The whole X debacle has proven

I don't understand. What was the "debacle" and how did it "prove" your claim?


And then use it against the customers for malicious means. Like a good CEO.


Only until recently the Russians were our only ride to the ISS. The US didn't even have a shuttle program...

The US itself still doesn't have a working program, thankfully SpaceX can do it.

The Russians could probably go to the moon again, but there's no real point to.


1. The SpaceX Commercial Crew Program was intentionally the US's plan. That was the expectation of the program (Not that the Boeing side of it looks good to anybody) 2. Russia, just last month, flubbed a rover a couple feet deep into the surface of the moon...so, no if they wanted to, apparently they could not.


Russia has tried to go to the moon (Luna 25) like a month ago. It failed.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: