Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

What if the criminals aren't long gone and the gunfire persisted long enough to kill more innocent bystanders?

What if the arrival of the police or the sound of sirens dispelled the gunfire early enough to save those bystanders?

What if that body they find isn't quite dead, but bleeding out and they are able to save them?


Right? I’m at a loss as to how someone could think an unhurried response to gunfire is appropriate.


Topics about law enforcement get very irrational here.

To the point where suggesting officers should respond incase someone is bleeding out get downvoted.

I guess the compassionate thing is to wait for the body on Monday because "what's the point"


What are you referencing? Everywhere it's installed officers find usefulness in triangulating where shots are popped off.

The alternative is an extensive investigation which is difficult to determine the location, if not impossible.

I don't mind these shot spotters being installed vs CCTVs as the microphones are really just tuned for gunshots and can only serve one purpose (in the current form)


It was widely reported a few years ago that the tech was pretty useless for triangulation amongst a bunch of other worrying behavior by the company and police themselves: https://www.techdirt.com/2021/08/26/chicago-pd-oversight-say...


Yeah, I'd be very surprised to see triangulation work well. When you walk around neighborhoods where all the buildings are four to six stories tall, you can be totally deceived about what direction sounds are coming from, because there are so many sonic reflections.

If you built towers for microphone above the cityscape you could get an accurate triangulation, but obviously nobody's doing that.


We have a neighbouring ground-floor apartment with a hot tub outside and when people are out the back there it sounds like they are chatting right outside a second floor window of our house. It's pretty spooky!


Hot tub acoustics are wild. When my family is using ours and I'm not, I can hear every single word from... inside the house! At least our neighborhood is getting entertained!


The walking around is the problem. If you put enough microphones in fixed locations and do enough calibration, you can control for the reflection. DSP deconvolution was already good, combining that approach with large training datasets would let you get arbitrarily accurate if money and time were no object. In practice vendors and police accept low levels of accuracy as long as the outcome is slightly better than interpreting/triangulating 911 calls.


You only have two ears, very close together. Would it be confusing if you had 20 ears spread out all over the neighborhood?


Yes, because the signal will be equally confusing.

A sensor 4 blocks away will often record a much louder sound than one half a block away, because of buildings that are variously absorbing or reflecting sound.

That makes triangulation utterly useless.

You can localize to maybe a 20 square block area, but that's not a whole lot for cops to go on.


Loudness isn't too important - timing is. Even with the 4-block-away mic being on a direct line of sight, and the half-block-away mic being around a corner, the half-block-away mic will perceive the event .5s or more before the 4-block away mic does.


You're wrong about this. I have no particular love for shotspotter but I do have many years of pro experience as an audio engineer and understand FFTs inside out. Pathological reflections (where the echo is louder than the direct sound) exist of course, but they're rare; and when you're recording from fixed locations you can just map those problems out, because buildings don't move around much. You can always triangulate; you have to add more sensors and compute, but both of those are relatively cheap.


Interesting.

Mind if I ask how a sound recorded by two different sensors can be identified as the same original sound if the loudness is different? Unless the frequency of loud sounds is less than the time taken by the sounds to reach the sensors, wouldn’t it be hard to pick up two sounds spread apart by say a second but know that they are the same sound?

For example, if I’m on the phone with a friend during a thunderstorm and we are on opposite sides of the city, will we hear and be able to identify the same thunderclap?

Does sound have usable distinguishing features other than just loudness?


Sounds have pretty characteristic shapes, in both waveform (amplitude/time) and frequency spectra/time. So much so that when I'm doing an editing job and I know the source material well, I can often do tidy-up edits for 30 seconds' worth of audio by eye and be confident it will play back correctly. So you can do a lot of preliminary filtering by looking out for the distinctive shapes of percussive noises, as opposed to other loud things like vehicle horns, motors, or music.

Back in the shotspotter example, your microphones are in fixed positions, so you can figure out in advance what the echoes are going to be for any given originating sound, and do a reasonable job of triangulation with 3 sensors. You also have some other givens, eg it's reasonable to assume that the location of any actual gunshot is 1-2 meters above ground level; this means you'll be slightly wrong about rooftop snipers/shootouts but those are vanishingly rare compared to street shootings. I don't think anyone claims the product to be reliable for detecting shootings in building interiors, where you'd be competing with televisions and other false positives.

As I mentioned earlier, a product like this can get away with a relatively low success rate, as long as it's slightly better than the information that comes in from 911 calls and the rate of false positives if either tolerably low or negligently unaccounted for.


> Does sound have usable distinguishing features other than just loudness?

Than raw, peak amplitude? yes.

Frequency and amplitude variation over time will be roughly consistent in a linear system (i.e. the sound will get louder and quieter over time). If you have a stable, well-qualified listening system (such as, for example, a set of fixed recording locations in an environment that is acoustically static), you can build a map of how sound sources map to each recorder, and use principles of directed arrays to get very accurate location projections.

To use your example, yes it would be difficult for you and a single friend to confirm that you heard the same sound, but you could come up with a probability that if you heard a sound with the same characteristics with a certain time difference and loudness difference, it is likely to have been from a certain location. If, however, you have 4 friends, it gets much less likely that all 4 heard a different sounds calibrated exactly to seem like they came from a specific source when the data is combined.


That article is quite a mess isn't it? Seems they found more of a problem with the Chicago PD than ShotSpotter.

> If this result is attributable in part to missing or nonmatched records of investigatory stops that did take place as a direct consequence of a ShotSpotter alert, CPD’s record-keeping practices are obstructing a meaningful analysis of the effectiveness of the technology.

Should have been the end of the article right there, but techdirt decided to write one anyway.

And false positives really aren't that big a deal anyway. You get false police reports, at least with the sensors you can recalibrate and adjust.


"The study, which reviewed ShotSpotter deployments for roughly 21 months (from July 1, 2019, through April 14, 2021) using data obtained from the City of Chicago, found that 89% of ShotSpotter’s reports led police to find no gun-related crime and 86% turned up no crime at all, amounting to about 40,000 dead-end ShotSpotter deployments."

If only we took companies out to defend their product at face value we could waste even more time and resources!


Yes and then they go to say there's missing data for them to attribute investigations to ShotSpotter due to CPD’s lack of record keeping.

So much so that it's "obstructing a meaningful analysis of the effectiveness of the technology". Their words, not mine.


That would undermine the original point you made, though:

> Everywhere it's installed officers find usefulness in triangulating where shots are popped off.

At best, cops are going on 'feels' here because, presumably, the data aren't sufficient to provide a solid basis for analysis. Or the police are withholding data that proves the system works well, which prima facie seems unlikely.


I've only heard anecdotes of cops saying it worked well, and it does seem like a good investment and an achievable goal.

I don't know what the real numbers are, but from that article it seems noone does...

A proper reporting of numbers would be nice.


You wouldn't want to waste officers time responding to those calls, but sending an automated surveillance camera is a different use of resources. Most surveillance cameras spend 99.99+% of their time watching no crime happening.

I would rather the cameras go to the gunshot noises than stay bolted to a pole outside my house, which is where they are now.


Those systems wouldn't be that automated, you'd need a whole fleet of techs and others to maintain them. And why to chase the 10% change the alert is anything at all. To me it sounds like the tech improvement needed in this situation is being applied in the wrong place.


Yes, and they have those systems (fixed cameras, shotspotter, and drones) now that they maintain. We're just talking about using them together.

Also, a faster response could result in a better rate of finding crime. "89% of ShotSpotter’s reports led police to find no gun-related crime" does not equal "89% of reports weren't gunshots". It could be that police show up too late.


> Yes, and they have those systems (fixed cameras, shotspotter, and drones) now that they maintain. We're just talking about using them together.

In a sort of magical way where there is a drone that can easily be dispatched from within it's range that has the intelligence to not only navigate to the scene through a complex city environment but also find and gather evidence. I bet any current drone deployment is likely to be slower than dispatching people patrolling and there will be far fewer of them than regular cops. It's basically fantasy when the Shot Spotter stuff doesn't even seem to work.


Statements like "shotspotter doesn't work" are reductive. Let's be specific about what it does and doesn't do. Some departments have found the data to not be actionable using current response methods. However, the systems are good at detecting gunshot like noises. This data is much more actionable for placing a camera than how cameras are placed today, which is "this intersection is near where crime happened last year, let's bolt a camera to the pole"

Drone navigation has been progressing quite a lot over the past decade, and law enforcement in some places is already using them in an automated way, as the article mentions. Also, the suggestion above was forward looking, it wasn't suggesting that the NYPD should glue these systems together today.


> Let's be specific about what it does and doesn't do

It doesn't tell a gunshot from a dumpster lid slamming shut.

It does produce almost entirely false positives.

It doesn't identify the location of a gunshot to any useful level of precision.

I suppose if you want to start a police state, and make every fourth resident a cop, you might be able to mitigate the 90% false-positive rate, and the horrible location-identification rate, but at that point, do you even need shot-spotter?


Those are exactly some of the things that augmenting the data with video would help to address, which was the point of the above suggestion.

Right now, police have data about where loud sounds generally come from, and video from fixed poles where crime happened in previous years. Both of these aren't great data points on their own.

The intersection of that data: [Video around locations where loud noises just happened] is probably much better than disjointed data points of [video of where crime happened in previous years] and [general locations of where loud sounds are happening].


It is when it comes to nuclear regulation.

The NRC effectively makes nuclear impossible in the US.


Commercial nuclear should be very hard, almost impossible. This seems to be the correct conclusion after all the accidents and the reasons for them - incompetent, self-serving management pushing dangerous commands on the personnel (Chernobyl,Three Mile Island) or normalizing bad architecture and security plans (Fukushima). Better expensive energy than another major nuclear accident.

Nuclear energy can be done safely as long as it is run by competent nuclear energy physicists/technicians with real authority, so they can and will shut down stupid ideas such as operating outside parameters because economy/boss said so. This seems to rule out commercial organizations. NRC is more benevolent than that, maybe they should actually be even tougher.

We should allow only competent states to build and operate nuclear plants, so science and rules take precedence to money and boss boot-licking.

This may push nuclear energy into unprofitable territory, depending on the market conditions, infrastructure, water and people resources. Which is fine by me - nuclear energy in some areas is so important for grid stability we should have it even if it is unprofitable.


Nuclear is by far the safest form of energy and is developed safely in many countries without the strict overregulation that the US has.

Pointing to extreme events with outdated designs has nothing to do with this.


Extreme events and subsequent changes are why it can be the "safest form of energy". After Chernobyl and Fukushima, regulation did change in those countries as well.


There must be a name for the fallacy when one is focused on avoiding a single risk while completely ignoring much larger and closer dangers.

Nuclear energy has a minuscule list of total casualties throughout history. Casualties per megawatt produced? It's practically zero. At the same time burning hydrocarbons kills every single day through pollution. It kills millions yearly. Burning coal even spews radioactive ash into the air!

And above all, climate change is looming as a civilization-ending danger, closer and closer.

So which one should we regulate more?!


The black swan big disasters have to be taken seriously too.

A nuclear accident creates a big and costly disaster suddenly. People don't like sudden big problems but can live with continuously growing ones.

Burning hydrocarbons is much more acceptable in that regard. CO2/dust pollution is accepted by society, because it is continuous and dilutes well. Killing millions is socially acceptable when it happens randomly all over the planet. Radioactive pollution due to coal burning is/should be negligible, most is(should be) filtered out in the smokestack scrubbers.

I don't like fossil power plants, but they are much easier to build and more acceptable to people than nuclear ones. That's why regulation and security have to be high with nuclear, to make it acceptable to most of society.

> civilization-ending danger

I don't think climate change is a civilization-ending danger in the coming decades. It already creates political problems, migration. If we keep pumping CO2 then maybe in hundred years.


> The black swan big disasters

We had 2 huge ones. They resulted in a few thousand deaths and some uninhabitable land. Nothing compared to pollution damage.

> accepted by society [...] socially acceptable

I'd rather decide based on reason. And I doubt many people find millions of deaths due to pollution every year acceptable. They just don't know they had a choice. Choice stolen from them by rabid anti-nuclear fear mongering.

> I don't think climate change is a civilization-ending danger

Yet you think a few black swan nuclear disasters are? Can I borrow your crystal ball? You are pretty sure about the future but most experts I read disagree: nuclear experts consider it extremely safe while climate experts warn of dire futures.


I did not say black swan nuclear disasters are a civilization-ending danger. I said people are afraid of them much more than of climate change.

Nuclear experts consider it safe because of existing regulations and because it is hard for sketchy company to launch a new plant.


> I did not say black swan nuclear disasters are a civilization-ending danger. I said people are afraid of them much more than of climate change.

That may be, but you're coming off as mongering the same irrational fear.


That is surprising view to me. I tried to explain why naive anti-regulation talk is not helpful for getting more nuclear energy. The way to have more nuclear energy is to embrace and strengthen the state interest in nuclear.


When discussing nuclear vs coal, it's always funny to point out that coal power plants produce several times as much radiation as nuclear power plants.


Coal plants emit more radionuclides into atmosphere, but nuclear plants produce more radionuclides overall (burnt fuel). This coal nuclear pollution is however still very small to the point of irrelevance, the real pollution problem is with CO2, dust and mining coal.


>Nuclear is by far the safest form of energy

By the same logic, maximum security prisons have the safest interns. ;-)


So you prefer other people's children to do your construction, got it.

That's fine.. I guess, but the world needs construction workers, including in America.

If my son wanted to build nuclear reactors I'd be A-Okay with that.


Not the parent commenter, but I read their comment perhaps more charitably as describing a general societal attitude rather than their personal beliefs that they would instill on their children.

No idea if I’m correct, but it’s maybe worth offering them the benefit of the doubt here.


I don't have and have never wanted children, so you are correct that it is not my personal belief. Yes, it's a question of the social status afforded to certain professions. The ones that actually build and maintain a functioning society seem low on that hierarchy. I'm willing to bet that the lawyers litigating whether or not a nuclear power plant will be built have have a higher income than the people who build it.

This is my perception as someone from the working class who doesn't get one of those big FAANG salaries; they don't check that when you sign up here.


The general societal attitude is what influences their personal belief, and vice versa at scale.

But their point remains the same, "let someone else do it" (the quiet part: "it's below us").

It's a very negative and elitist attitude that's prevalent in bubbles where people don't have to work normal jobs.


> If my son wanted to build nuclear reactors I'd be A-Okay with that.

No no no no, we are talking about hard labor. I think OP is merely saying that there are jobs that no one wants to do, but they need to be done. So while everyone wish someone becomes the janitor, no one wants their own kid to become one (or whatever job you deem is less "respected").

This is not to say that I don't respect janitors, it is that I WISH i feel respect for them, but for whatever reason (nurture or nature) I simply don't feel respect for them and I constantly fight against this intuition.


Oh I'd prefer a lot of things that are never going to happen. It's more a question of social status - what pays more, construction worker, or lawyer who argues for/against construction?


What was your point in asking this "question of social status"?

Nothing in this thread points to lack of workers, but to over regulation.

On a personal note, I'd prefer many less lawyers, especially the ones who argue against the one energy source that works.

I'd prefer many more trade workers, much less in academics.

I'd prefer people to not view jobs as a social status and appreciate the contributions people give to society.

A plumber can make quite a bit of money, work up to their own business, not have to deal with huge amounts of debt, and actually provides needed services for society.


https://www.ziprecruiter.com/Salaries/Plumber-Salary-per-Mon...

A basketball player can make quite a bit of money playing basketball if they're exceptional. Looks like the national average for a plumber is about $60K/year. Most people on this forum would scoff at that if someone offered them that. It's actually about as much as my uncle, a heavy diesel mechanic, made before his untimely death. It's about what my father made when he retired.

Why don't we build? Why don't we do anything; because it's more profitable not to I'm sure.


60k/yr can support a family in a lot of areas. Most people in my area make around that.

SWE is a bubble and can't really be applied to the rest of the workforce. A SWE would scoff at any other job because of this.

We do have builders, there is overregulation that stops us from building.

It's not the lack of workers.


My brother was a contractor too and could barely make it on that with no kids. He fairly recently became an engineer (not the software kind) and was stunned to learn that he could take days off and still get paid. He was also quite happy to have health insurance. There may not be a lack of workers, but there's one less who will ever go back because of the nature of the job.


>Nothing in this thread points to lack of workers, but to over regulation.

The thread points at inflation and interest rates and general cost overruns. I don't see the overregulation. As others have said, you can run your non nuclear powerplants until they fall apart. That isn't possible with nuclear power.


Then a jury ruled in Musk's favor, right?

https://www.cnn.com/2023/02/03/cars/musk-tesla-tweet-lawsuit...

The end result is left out every time the "court finds" articles are linked. The jury found the opposite, which is what actually matters.


The jury finding was that he was not personally liable for investor losses, not that his tweet was in fact accurate.

The facts are not in dispute here. He tweeted "funding secured" and funding was not secured. He announced intentions to take it private at a given price, which did not happen.

He misrepresented the financial state of his company.


Musk was railroaded by the judge and the Saudis on that one.

Luckily the jury had sense that the tweet was harmless in the end.

The judge ignored his stake in SpaceX he could have leveraged and mainly the Saudi Arabia firm that he was in talks with in taking Tesla private would not testify and then said the exact opposite:

https://www.theverge.com/2022/4/25/23040961/elon-musk-saudi-...

https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/1/23/musk-on-trial-sa...

So in the end it's do you believe Elon or the Saudis?

The judge sided with the Saudis.


Well, a jury also ruled that his pedo comments were totally okay, so I don't know if I'd use that as a metric for what constitutes truth.


Well, courts have also persecuted and jailed innocent people so if you don't trust what a jury of your peers say you should also have a hard time trusting what a "court finds".

Do you agree with that logic or do you trust the courts over your peers?

(ie. what "metric" would you use "for what constitutes truth"?)



Timely! Now do the courts (or have those been perfect over the decades?)

Under that logic, maybe Musk is just another African American being persecuted by the US government.


Jury is mob-based justice. If mobs likes you, then you are basically immune to consequences as illustrated by the link above.


You ignored my statements. Evaluate the courts.

We're all waiting on the edge of our seats to know what your ideal judicial system is.

Btw you've never had jury duty? Did you vote in a mob form? I sure hope not. I haven't.


Anything else than jury mob rule is better judical system.


You still didn't answer the questions.

No jury I've been on has functioned that way. Have you acted that way?

If you don't support a system of a jury of your peers determining your guilt, what do you support?


> Jury is mob-based justice

Have you served on an American jury?


You missed his point. He's saying not picking up a mob pitchfork and challenging irrational statements does not mean you are white-knighting.

He's not saying "look over at that other CEO".

Even still, it's not whataboutism to put things in perspective as you may see that you're blowing one thing out of proportion due to bias if those same values are being violated by another entity but you are okay with it because of the entity itself.

It's always a good exercise to check for contradictions in your values.


Digital colonialism... you can't be serious? You really think giving villages or tribes with limited or no internet service is a bad thing?

There were quite a few tribes given Starlink to fix their school computers so their children could get a proper education.

You shoved in a lot of other nonsense in there too, but I'd thought I'd call out the most ridiculous first.

> Starlink was intentionally curtailed during the Ukraine war in order to provide tactical advantage to Russian forces

Starlink was given to Ukraine for humanitarian reasons. Ukraine wanted to use it for drone strikes and wanted the area expanded. Musk did not want Starlink used offensively.

You seem to support the US government being able to tell private citizens what they have to do or who they have to kill with the technology they create?

Ukraine is not even a NATO ally and we are not in war with Russia.


I certainly wouldn't argue that providing internet to anyone is a bad thing, and I'd love to see as much of the world as possible have access.

However, I do think it's a little comical that in doing so he is enabling the spread of the "woke mind virus" to new regions and people. So, it's conceivable that he will eventually think it was a bad thing.


No reason to believe the influence won't be in reverse though.


Let's say I build airplanes.

Let's also say I think communism is a mind-virus (I do).

I can still build airplanes knowing that communist leaders use them to spread their mind-virus.

That's because in my view, the benefit of connecting non-ideological people far outweighs the negatives of what the communist leaders spout off.

(ie, you're not only spreading that mind virus, but all thoughts, including the ones that CHALLENGE the mind virus. The biggest threat to an ideology is DISSENT)


> Digital colonialism... you can't be serious? You really think giving villages or tribes with limited or no internet service is a bad thing?

Prior to the 20th century, my hazy memory says more like ~17th, the Emperor of China or his emissaries would give lavish gifts to other nations. It worked like a "soft colonialism". Later they would expect favourable deals, trades, taxes, military support and so on. [0]

Facebook gives you free tools to contact your friends and influences, but in return they build models of you so that commercial bodies and political parties can tailor their messaging to include just the right keywords to make you look twice at their ads.

Churches have always come with offerings of peace and generosity to the poor and otherwise disadvantaged, and yet somehow the Catholic Church now has an untouchable principality and 10s or 100s of millions of people follow what they say.

> There were quite a few tribes given Starlink to fix their school computers so their children could get a proper education.

> You shoved in a lot of other nonsense in there too, but I'd thought I'd call out the most ridiculous first.

The benefits are real. But history tells us repeatedly to be suspicious of rich powerful entities offering free or cheap QoL boosts to the needy. It's really the easiest play in empire building because it's almost irresistible. Real, honest solutions to the problems of the disadvantaged group would involve actual risk to the powerful and be based education, patent access, loans with flexible terms, culture exchanges. Gifting just sets up dependencies and obligations.

[0] source https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06r84qy but it might have been a different episode


i mean, its sort of offtopic since many American readers here might not know about it, but the free internet scheme in India was sort of a dismal failure

their effort was called: "internet.org" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet.org#Net_neutrality_cr...

it basically just dumped unmoderated facebook on most of India.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/10/25/facebook-india-hat...


> Bankman-Fried was the second biggest Democratic-leaning megadonor this election cycle, according to OpenSecrets data. Only about $235,000 of his total political giving went toward Republican candidates.

https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2022/11/megadonor-no-more-s...


Only about $235,000 of his total political giving went toward Republican candidates.

This is false.

At trial, the prosecutors introduced evidence that more than $10 million went to Republican candidates, including the GOP Senate Minority Leader. Another $50+ million went to dark money organizations favoring Republican policies. All told, SBF and FTX (at SBF's direction) made over $100+ million in political donations, spread evenly between the two parties.

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/10/20/sam-bankman-fried-ftx-allies...


I posted what is known from Open Secrets.

We will find out at the end of the trial what is ruled as valid evidence or not.

(your source does not link "The documents" they reference so noone can verify)


???

A jury does not generally review each piece of evidence to determine whether the evidence is "valid" or not.

This evidence was already introduced at trial (in support of the conspiracy charges, since the campaign financing charge was dropped back in August). This means that the judge already reviewed it and deemed it to be valid, admissible evidence. (That happens before a trial, not after it, though in some cases may happen during a trial with the jury excused from the courtroom.)

It's weird to blindly believe OpenSecrets, which also does not link to supporting documents, while disbelieving widely-reported news reporting that has been covered for the past year...without any refutation by the Republican beneficiaries of SBF's donations.


https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/13Wq2kPw3C4X_50Tqc8H9...

Open Secrets' data is just processed FEC data, you don't have to "believe" Open Secrets, you can verify the numbers yourself:

https://www.fec.gov/introduction-campaign-finance/data-tutor...

My point was we don't have the data you are referencing to verify it the same way.

Or do you??? (a CNBC article w/ no reference does not count)


SBF was giving to the dems, his Co-CEO of FTX, Ryan Salame was giving to the republicans.

> FTX-linked donations last election cycle favored Democrats, with at least $44.6 million going to liberal candidates, causes and PACs, and at least $23.9 million going to Republicans. [1]

You know who isn't going to be going to prison forever? Ryan Salame. He's looking at giving up his Porche, and ten years maximum, probably less, given that he's co-operating.

[1] https://rollcall.com/2023/02/23/ftx-leaders-political-donati....


Sure, but the question was about which party SBF donated to. This thread and the article is about SBF.

Though I do think Ryan Salame mainly donated to non-partisan crypto PACs, but quite a bit did go to Rs, including $400k to his girlfriend.

But yeah, the plea deals are ridiculously lax, but SBF will just get pardoned by a outgoing D president like they did Susan Rosenberg, so he's good too.


Is there any other type of development where you have to inform the US gov about it when you start developing it?

The EO says you must inform the gov when you start the training the AI if it's a risk to public health, etc.

How would one determine if it's a risk? Who determines the risk (I assume the government).

So effectively that means the gov determines what is right/wrong, true/false. Not good.


My friend, it is quite literally the goverment's job to decide what is right or wrong through drafting and enacting laws.

I am not stating that having to inform the government when you're training models is right. It's an asinine way of thinking by people who have no idea what they're talking about and are severely out of touch. The laws they've enacted were based on fear, often propagated by OpenAI themselves. It is still their job to do that though.


> My friend, it is quite literally the goverment's job to decide what is right or wrong through drafting and enacting laws.

It is not their job to say what is true or false. That's propaganda. They also do not have the right to enforce what you train your AI to say.

Would love to see the SC challenge this EO. It violates the 1A.


Nuclear weapons are a tool to keep peace via MAD (mutual assured destruction)

It's most likely the main reason there's no direct world wars between super powers.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: