Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

Yes, and talks between air traffic control and pilots are recorded.

Would you be okay with a recorder being beside your desk at all times? Catching every conversation, even personal ones?

Currently it's your choice to participate in sending memes over email. You also have the choice to walk over and have a private conversation.


Would this be any different from walking out of the cockpit to have a private conversation?


Pilot's shouldn't be encouraged to walk out of the cockpit mid flight, also after 9/11 all cockpit doors are locked during flight


I have a young family. My great grandmother was alive until about my highschool graduation.

People got married and had kids (age 15 for my grandma) early back in the day, not too odd.


I mean, there's no reason a Starship can't be turned into a space telescope, and it's pretty much an assembly line rocket.

Also no reason why it can't be an ISS, and no reason you couldn't link multiple together.

Pretty useful to have a reusable grain silo you can launch and land.


yay, compromises!

who needs to work offline anyway.


Oddly I haven't yet needed to work offline in my 12 year career as a software dev. But then again it's not common for internet to go away where I live.


Usually I only work on my laptop when I travel.

When I travel there's not always reliable internet.

Otherwise I use my PC at home.

A laptop that needs internet is not a great portable.


Indeed, the only time I'd use my laptop is because I'm offline or out and about. There's no need to use a laptop if I'm at home, since, like you, I have a desktop.


we're talking about "M3 laptop substitute"

if you actually need its performance, you'll have online access and most likely be stationary

ssh (more like remote desktop tho) solution just allows you to bring that power anywhere in your house, e.g. in bed


> if you actually need its performance, you'll have online access and most likely be stationary

So powerful laptops are always connected to the internet? What is that logic? I wish that to be true.

I don't think internet emits from my laptop when I'm in a remote area just because of it's specs.

If I'm using the laptop as a glorified monitor I'd just use a cheap chromebook or similar...

No I need a powerful laptop to replace my powerful desktop because I'm away from it and I can't guarantee that I can connect to it.


He never said he was offended by those things.

Just those things don't always need to be in all kid shows.

You can support those ideals and not want pandering in your show.

Crazy, I know.


Is it pandering? None of those things are rare, and I'd be surprised to find out any significant portion of the population wouldn't encounter them in their own school. It's literally just a representation of the real world.

I guess preparing children for the world that exists is "woke" or something.


Bluey prepares kids more for the real world more than the corporate HR messages the US shows have.

It's not about checking diversity boxes, it's about handling your emotions.

And yes, we're all tired of "woke" shit, that's not the real world, but it tries to parade as it is.


In my 8 year old's classroom there is:

A kid in a wheelchair. Another with mild autism. Another whose being raised by the grandparents because her mother is a drug addict. Another with pretty severe alopecia (this being her "best friend"). One of her other friends has been very sad because her aunt was killed in Israel.

This is all "real world". And it affects us despite it not happening to our family. At least not yet.


You teach morals to handle all situations.

You don't have to directly have brokenness, sex, rape, drugs, and murder in kids shows even if those things exist in the real world.


I find it easier to learn abstract things like morals when there are also examples presented along-side them. More so when those examples are practical and applicable to my life. I find this to be a common sentiment.

Are you really trying to say that showing brown people and kids with a single parent is equivalent to showing rape and drug use?

Perhaps you should pause and reflect on your own morals if you think these are equivalent.


First off, you brought up someone being killed as a real world struggle, so don't act like I pulled these real world events out of nowhere and tried to equate it to "brown people" (your words) alluding that I'm racist or something.

Second, my point was to show you that not everything in the real world needs to be depicted directly in kids shows. Not to make an equivalence of those listed things, but to test the consistency of the logic.

Learning morals you can learn how to handle those situations and ideals in the future without being introduced to inappropriate things too early in life.

Perhaps you shouldn't try to make an ad-hominem attack on my morals because you can't interpret it correctly. If you didn't understand, you could have asked for clarification.


I'd argue that encountering people that are slightly different than one's self is a normal daily reality for most people, and that using those people as characters in the protagonists' lives is just making the show relatable. I don't think it's a moral lesson any more than having parents who don't murder every episode is a moral lesson - sure it's an example of decent morals but it's not a lesson in morality.

That is to say, using same logic on "depicting brown people" and "depicting rape" is fundamentally flawed, it doesn't make sense to apply the same rules to "proximity to disabled people" and "murder" they aren't remotely in the same category. They are fundamentally different, and even if they were somehow similar enough to apply the same logic, they are not in any way similar in scope, its like claiming that showing a kid keeping a $100 bill they find on the street is somehow the same as showing a kid planning a multibillion dollar crypto heist... they involve different morals, different situations, and different consequences for every single person involved - that is they aren't the same.

Further, I never brought up someone being killed - that was a different person. You can tell because we have different usernames.


Any inclusion is pandering to some people.


Yes pandering is relative.

So the GP was happy with a show that was relevant to his family.

Yeah I think we're on the same page.


It's almost like people just want to be upset about how other people are living their lives for some reason.


Yup, just let people enjoy Bluey and live their own lives.

There's plenty of "woke" stuff to enjoy if you want to live life that way.


Oh, believe me, gay and trans furries love Bluey. It's pretty much our fav thing, it's so insanely popular with the LGBT+ crowd.


Ok? My Little Pony was in the same boat. Doesn't really change anything.


It's insanely popular and I certainly don't want to stop anyone from enjoying it :)

Was it pandering when My Little Pony had a lesbian couple?


Never watched it, my point was another group enjoying something doesn't really effect what another group gets out of it.

For me it depends on how it's presented. The characters shouldn't announce what they like to fuck. That's jarring, pandering, and very inappropriate.

No idea how it was portrayed so I can't say.


>The characters shouldn't announce what they like to fuck.

Has that happened in a kids show you've seen?


No. The shows I screen never say or portray anything sexual.

They will find out that out on their own, without the help of kid shows.

I have no idea what the character's sexual preferences are and I don't want to know.

Curiously, how was it presented that they were lesbian, and who was lesbian? One of the ponies? lol.


Wait, why did you bring up characters on children's show announcing their sexual proclivities then?

Are you just getting angry about a hypothetical? Help me understand where you're coming from please


I'm not angry? And I didn't bring it up, you brought up the lesbian in MLP.

How was it presented in the show?


Why did you bring up whether the characters want to fuck?


Because that's what your sexual preference essentially is.

Why is it relevant in a kid's show?


There's so much more to relationships and human connection and even romantic relationships than that.

Get your mind out of the gutter.


Connections can be made in kids show without referencing sexual preferences, that's my point.

I just fail to see why you need to make a pony a lesbian in a kids show.

Why bring that up at all?


> Why bring that up at all?

So that it reflects the real world, perhaps? Same reason shows have families with moms and dads in them.


Why bring up couples at all?

Are the heterosexual couples going to tell the kids about the sex they're having?


That's why I said it's how it depends how it's presented, and you never explained so I don't know if it was appropriate or not.

Many kids shows I enjoyed never had any couples or parents in them, which avoids that altogether.


That's really great, good talk, buddy.


You too, pal.

So is any exclusion.


Isn’t the point of kids media to help prepare them for the real world?


Not at all? How much "preparing for the real world" was there in Hanna Barbera cartoons, or GI Joe, Thundercats, Looney Toons, etc?

One could argue that cartoons of an era are descriptive of current culture, but to take them as prescriptive seems a terribly misguided idea.


Tip: you can use https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher to make it open the clock instead.

(just built a new PC and Windows 11 was quite awful w/ stock UX)


> His offer was immediately declined, and Sangster was ordered to return to his seat. Sangster says he immediately complied, but while waiting for departure, he decided to take the opportunity to write a complaint on the Delta app about the delay.

> The same flight attendant who had ordered him back to his seat noticed Sangster writing the complaint, and within minutes, a ground agent had boarded the plane and was telling Sangster to collect his belongings and get off.

I feel like there's more to this story than what the author suggests.

How does one "notice" another person on their phone writing a complaint?

It just looks like you're on the Delta app, which is normal on a flight.

And under that statement, the title is wrong, they weren't thrown off for offering to fix something, but for writing a complaint, which I don't believe.

Now if the person was vocal about their complaint as well, then I can see noticing...


100% agree. You don't get "thrown off" for offering to fix the WiFi. You usually get that treatment when you insist on fixing it, refuse to comply with the instructions from the FA and, perhaps in this case, refuse to stow your laptop after the FA tells you too, repeatedly.


After some number of paranoia pills one can imagine it from a perspective of a pilot as an early stage of attempt to hijack the plane.


The pilot likely heard "I think 24E is acting suspiciously, he tried to mess with the entertainment system, can we boot him?" and responded by saying "yeah go for it" before resuming checklists.


Speak for yourself, not everyone.

I actually like X, it's much more enjoyable than Twitter used to be.

Spaces are seamless, it's cool to drop into a random conversation with hundreds of thousands of listeners.

Community notes actually gives great context without parading as a de-facto fact checker ran by a couple of companies with their own biases.


Twitter’s “community notes” is one of two things: 1) if it is 100% community based, then exactly the same as most upvoted tweet reply; 2) if it is moderated additionally, then exactly the same as fact checker run by a company with its own bias.

Which one is it?


it's neither of those which leads to your own lack of knowledge of the system.

you can see the source code of the algorithm here: https://github.com/twitter/communitynotes

there's a number of factors that goes into the rankings, like taking into account which other community note users rated it helpful and how they rated previous notes.

also simple usage of community notes would have revealed it was at least more sophisticated than the prison of two ideas you presented.


> the prison of two ideas you presented.

No need to be so dramatic. Looks like it’s in fact 100% community based, just the community is separate (the ‘community notes community’). The higher barrier to entry, compared to Twitter’s mainstream audience, is its saving grace (at least for now, as more time passes this seems susceptible to good old astroturphing, gaming, and eventually good faith contributors rage-quitting).


I'd rather have a few more nuclear plants than vast arrays of panels scattered throughout land and sea.

It can't be great to cover so much of nature.


If you reject cheap renewable energy today because of some nuclear power pipe dream you're basically a lobbyist for fossil fuels, even if you don't know it.

Because there is absolutely no reason not to assume that those new nuclear power plants will once again take least 20 years to build (and will be 3 times over budget). That's quite a long time span that you need to fill with fossil fuels.


20 Year regulatory delays can easily be overcome with political will.

Political will requires a median IQ high enough to understand the tradeoffs and lack fear from decades pass, which I don't think is possible this century.


Most of that 20 years is construction time, not regulatory delays. For example, Finland's latest took 18 years to build after construction started. The regulatory delays were significant and on top of the 18 years.


Also a lobbyist for nuclear weapons and the military industrial complex.

The only reason countries want to maintain an industrial nuclear supply chain and skills base is because they are a nuclear power already (France, Russia, US, etc.) or because they are purchasing the option to become one in a hurry (Iran, Sweden, South Korea, etc.).

Governments don't firehose subsidies at a form of power that has an LCOE 5x the cost of its competitors and give it free catastrophe insurance on top for the hell of it.


>Also a lobbyist for nuclear weapons and the military industrial complex.

People will post stuff like this and then act surprised when others are put off.


> It can't be great to cover so much of nature.

You'd be surprised! Solar panels provide shade for local wildlife and improve crop/grazing yields due to the cover moderating the hot sun and providing spots for dew to form. As much as I love nuclear, we really should have started deploying it 10 years ago to make a difference. Solar is cheaper now and easier to deploy.


> Solar panels provide shade for local wildlife and improve crop/grazing yields

This dual-use of land for solar panels and agriculture is called "agrivoltaics".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrivoltaics


When solar panels cover canals -- there should be a name for that too.


Is solar plus equivalent battery storage cheaper? Genuinely curious how costs compare for 1TW nuclear to (1+X)TW solar + (1+Y)TWhr battery

where X and Y could be integers depending on location for 12 + hr demand.


The best moment to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best moment to plant a tree is now.


Sure.

Reality is that solar is being built at a much faster pace than predicted for much cheaper than predicted.

Nuclear. Crickets.

Also you are overplaying the amount of panels covering land and sea.


> Also you are overplaying the amount of panels covering land and sea.

Oh, what's the amount of land & sea needed to rely on solar then?

I also wonder (not asking) about the resources to make and replace each panel every 30 years vs the equivalent of making and maintaining nuclear plants.

> Reality is that solar is being built at a much faster pace than predicted

I see, so the Christmas wish is coming true!

Ideally, I'd like to see the NRC dial back it's strict regulations.

That's the main reason nuclear development is slow here.

Other countries build nuclear much cheaper and quicker, just as safe.

That's my Christmas wish.


There's a catch-22 in your wish. Nuclear is safe because of the regulations, and if you remove the regulations its not safe. The regulations make it expensive, but the lack of regulations is very likely to make it much much much much more expensive, very suddenly.


Other countries with safe nuclear have 4-5x faster regulatory oversight.


> Oh, what's the amount of land & sea needed to rely on solar then?

7.6% of Nevada

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%28US%20power%20consump...


1 TW needs an area of 173 x 173 Km = ~30.000 Km².

These are 0.02% of the earth landmass.

Values are like this, when calculating conservative: 1 KWp needs an area around 10m². For enough maintenance distance multiply by 3 = 30m².

  => 1 Megawatt = 3 * 10m² * 1000 = 30.000m².
  => 1 Gigawatt = 3 * 10m² * 1000 * 1000 = 30.000.000m².
  => 1 Terawatt = 3 * 10m² * 1000 * 1000 * 1000 = 30.000.000.000m².
Square root of 30.000.000.000m² = 173205m = 173Km. According to statista.com, the total earth landmass is 149.000.000 Km², so 30.000m² are 0.02% auf 149 million Km².


I got curious so I googled: https://blogs.ucl.ac.uk/energy/2015/05/21/fact-checking-elon...

Seems doable to be honest, even if you assume real-world inefficiencies and double or triple the area required. Especially when you fold it into existing infrastructure (eg solar panels on buildings).


Which other countries are building nuclear in a meaningful capacity?

We need a reactor going online each week to make a dent.

Not disagreeing that the regulations in the US are way too onerous for nuclear.


Your ignoring the externalities of solar and wind power. Ignoring externalities of fossil fuels is what got us here in the first place.

What happens if in 30 years we have to discuss nano PV particulates in blood and great PV patch in some ocean?


“Nano PV particulates” are mostly sand, and mostly harmless. All forms of electricity production have negative externalities, we want to minimize those so internalizing them is good policy. Goes for nuclear waste (dangerous, there’s no long-term plan) and PV waste (large amounts, maybe reusable, there’s no mid-term plan), as well as fossil fuel waste (all of the above).


And plastic is mostly oil. But that's not the whole picture is it?

PV aren't just sand, if they were my windows would be PV. Small impurities matter over long times and large quantities.

Also wrong on long term plan for nuclear. Long term plan is wait. Radioactivity reduces itself with time.


> Impurities matter

Yes, we need to recycle the materials. Landfill is not a viable solution for any waste, none of that is unique to solar power.

> Long term plan is wait

Waiting a lifetime is easy. Waiting hundreds of generations after we’re dead is not. Is that an argument against nuclear power? Not in my opinion. There’s still no finalized plan describing how waiting will work in practice though.


> Goes for nuclear waste (dangerous, there’s no long-term plan)

90% of nuclear waste is harmless within a year or two. The rest is so dense, that it fits a couple of trucks, and can be stored indefinitely long in a very small storage


Stored indefinitely until a curious explorer decides to investigate the unknown tomb of the gods of the third millennium, and… voila. I’m convinces we’ll solve storage by reusing the waste - but it’s not a solved problem by any stretch.


> Stored indefinitely until a curious explorer decides to investigate the unknown tomb of the gods of the third millennium, and… voila.

Voila what? If you're concerned about people degrading so far down that whatever we leave behind is "tombs of the third millenium", then storing a truckload of nuclear waste isn't really an issue.


Good thing nothing like that ever happens with nuclear.

("Externalities of wind power"? Oh.... is this bird strikes?)


If, as you say, you're reading up on the subject, side effects of wind power (and increased electric networks with solar, batteries, etc) are increased mining and concentrate processing of copper, nickel, lithium, etc.

Not being a scaremonger, these are just real costs that come along for the ride into a brave new future.

Spodumene processing in Malaysia from Australian concentrates (Mt. Weld, etc) to produce litium for batteries creates massive acid dams of wate and tonnes of radioactive waste.

Copper mining has always been problematic (albeit out of sight for many) and much more of that is called for.

Without being pro or anti any of the possible solutions for power generation we need moving forward, they all have toxic waste issues that bear looking into.


4 billion tonnes of coal mined per year.

2021 produced 50 thousand tons of pure lithium.

Coal gets used ONCE, lithium stores energy thousands of times before recycling to do it again.

This kind of context is important before whatabouting.


Coal has peaked, is on a plateau, and will decline and continue so, according to the IEA. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38652273

Lithium, Copper, Nickel, and a slew of other minerals and elements are on the increase and have some serious waste products.

The comparison here is to

> Good thing nothing like that ever happens with nuclear.

(with implied /s)

with the rational response that all resources come with a downside.

This kind of context is important before whatabouting.

You've whatabout'd by dragging in coal.


Lets try rephrasing it. Given that we need about 580m terajoules (source https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges/climate-change/ene...) what's the least worst way of achieving that?

Mixed, obviously, and different mixes in different parts of the world, but what should be our first-choice energy source? Assume fusion's off the table for now, lets stick with things that already exist.

My gut feeling is that wind, with its primarily local ecological impacts that are able to be minimised with careful placement and design, is a strong candidate for least-worst solution. The catastrophic failure mode of a wind farm does a lot less damage than the catastrohopic failure mode of a nuclear reactor, for a start. I do realise a lot of that wind power is probably going to end up in batteries (I'm hopeful for StEnSEA, but like fusion it's a bit Real Soon Now).


Regardless of our personal positions and feelings on nuclear it's going ahead and will persist as a global low continuous baseload provider; South Korea is building more, China is building more, both at home and globally.

In a very real sense to date the actual catastrophic failure modes of nuclear haven't been that bad on a realistic industrial scale.

Chernobyl persists as a bad place to dig into the soil if you're a Russian soldier commanded to do dumb things, as a large area nature reserve the case could be made that it has been a positive for non human animals.

The events at the Fukishima nuclear plant had few actual direct deaths, as an incident embedded within the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami that directly caused 19,759 deaths, 6,242 injured, and 2,553 people missing it would fade from sight were it not for the evacuations and containment costs.

The areas evacuated are already allowing returns to much of the region, the containment costs are the kinds of things that can be mitigated with engineering on future projects.

I'm no great fan of nuclear but pragmatically designs and safety have improved over the decades and actual deaths and casualties look small compared to deaths in conventional resource mining and industrial accidents such as the Bhopal disaster (500,000 people exposed to the highly toxic gas methyl isocyanate).

Sure, let's go with as much wind and solar as we can, let's have battery farms, green gas production, overnight thermal energy storage in sodium salts, etc.

But let us also pay attention to the costs of "green energy" - the ramp up to meet the current fossil fuel power creation levels will drastically ramp up toxic waste byproducts from nickel|copper mining, litium for batteries, rare eath processing, etc.

We are in a looming CO2 crisis that is worse for being kicked down the road since the 1970s when eraly action could have been taken.

Let's not blindly walk into another e-waste crisis by greenwashing away the real issues that come with new energy sources.


Also from IAE https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpLhuguXsA8YE8V?format=png&name=...

Coal might have peaked but it has an insanely long way down.

Mining waste problems need to be dealt with but they are localized and can be cleaned up afterwards.

Climate change is neither.


> Mining waste problems need to be dealt with but they are localized and can be cleaned up afterwards.

Right .. like recycling in the USofA - greenwashing.

Just be self aware about advocating to continuing to kick a can down the road and admit to yourself at least that you have no intention of being bothered by mining waste.

I'm glad to see the back of coal, but were it not for the associated C02 emmissions I would much prefer to live within 20 km of (say) the Muja coal | power site than (say) Lynas Malaysia, Kuantan.

Nickel | Copper mining in Sudbury and nearby generates more than 650 million tonnes of tailings every year from 200 operations along with about 10,000 abandoned mines that are "managed" by the Canadian government. "Managed" is essentially a euphermism for "not actively dealt with". Mine remediation has a long way to go in countries such as Canda and Australia and the majority of sites with problems are elsewhere and out of sight out of mind.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muja_Power_Station

https://aidwatch.org.au/stop-lynas/

"Can be cleaned up afterwards" is very different from "Will be cleaned up".

> Also from IAE https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpLhuguXsA8YE8V

Seriously? Not sure what point you're attempting to make with an graphic that lacks context and in any case supports my point that solar related waste will be rising seemingly "expontentially" along with solar.

If you're serious about understanding global energy and mineral resources I advise you to look at presentations that put total usage and transitions in the same picture - coal has a long way to fall to zero and solar has a long way to go to replace.

I'd also reiterate that I care about the issues here that come along with energy transitions - I'm not advocating for any one over another.


> ("Externalities of wind power"? Oh.... is this bird strikes?)

Noise is problematic for wildlife, and in some areas we tend to build wind power in previously quiet areas.


This is like the peak of bikeshedding.

Completely forgets the impact of climate change to the ecosystems.


No, climate change is a far bigger problem. No one argues otherwise. There’s a pervasive idea, though, that renewable electricity production is harmless so there’s no point focusing on and avoiding waste.

Adding to that, by acknowledging the harms of wind power we can locate it where it’s less harmful. Near cities or at sea, instead of destroying the few quiet places.


Yeah, I'm just reading up on the subject. Apparently a badly placed wind farm can have knock-on effects on the whole food web. We quickly reach a "never do anything" impasse though.


You are talking about mostly unknown maybe externalities.

I’m talking about the massive externality of climate change that is certain.

Waiting for nuclear to maybe get its shit together is not a gamble that we can take.

That said, I have nothing against nuclear. It’s just not happening unfortunately.


Sure, I never said give up on solar, PV, wind, etc. Give up on coal, oil and gas, but carefully consider your options to do so.

My point is even plastic packaging was invented to deal with problems of previous packing techniques namely glass, tin, paper, etc. Now we have a huge plastic environment issues.


You can meet the entire us demand for energy with solar panels covering just a tiny fraction of the land area: https://css.umich.edu/publications/factsheets/energy/photovo...


Nuclear can’t simply be built as cheaply and fast as solar.

https://www.iea.org/energy-system/electricity/nuclear-power# “ Nuclear energy, with around 413 gigawatts (GW) of capacity operating in 32 countries”

So the total global nuclear capacity ever built is now producing 413GW. Eerily the same as the solar capacity installed just last year.

Whoever is pushing for nuclear instead of solar in 2023 either doesn’t have the slightest idea about the current energy market or simply wants to help the fossil fuels to survive given how long would it take to build a nuclear power plant and at what cost.


> So the total global nuclear capacity ever built is now producing 413GW. Eerily the same as the solar capacity installed just last year.

Peak power isn’t the right measure of comparison here, I don’t think. Average power and guaranteed power on a 24- hour basis seems a more logical comparison.

“Can it run my heat pump at 5 in the morning on a cold winter day?” matters a lot to people.


Why not? You don’t need always peak power, in the night when there is no solar production the peak power consumption is much lower. And even accounting for average generation, using the capacity factor of 20% for solar and 90% for nuclear it means that you would need 4 years and half at current production level to deploy the entire average energy produced by all the nuclear power plants in the world. But given how the solar deployments are increasing YoY it will be probably closer to 2y 1/2 or 3y.


When comparing a plant that typically makes energy equivalent to its rated power 24 hours per day to one that typically makes energy equivalent to its rated power times 4-5 hours per day, comparing plants by their rated power is far from telling the most useful comparison.


> And even accounting for average generation, using the capacity factor of 20% for solar

The capacity factor of solar at night is exactly 0%.


> It can't be great to cover so much of nature.

You don't have to cover nature if you cover buildings.

Los Angeles, for example, could provide a very significant amount of it's electricity needs if it got a 5 mile radius of commercial buildings to all cover their roofs with solar panels.

Now, we can argue whether those buildings, themselves, are a good thing. But, given that they exist, we should cover them.


With the projected economics of renewables you’re fighting a losing battle: there will be shining seas of panels from coast to coast. With the way PV panel pricing is going, at some point doing anything else will basically amount to theft.


Nuclear as it is today is much more expensive than solar.


For each kWh delivered by the tech? Yes.

For 24x7 grid supply at .9999 reliability? I’m not nearly so sure; it might be, and if that were the case, it’s great news, because it makes that almost an inevitability.


And also for a new prototype reactor built every 10 years. If you build them in series like France did in the 70/80s or China now the cost would be greatly less.

Only billionaires could afford the cheap smartphone you have in your pocket if it wasn't manufactured at scale.


There are many TWs of capacity available from rooftops. They are already covered.


And intermittent electricity.


> If people spent time with meat animals, there would be a lot more vegetarians.

Having grown up on a ranch, yes I know cows are smart... chickens not so much. It does not change my views on eating beef at all.

Cows are treated very well in all the ranches I've been on. One because it makes them taste better, another because we about our livestock.

Your alternative is them not existing at all, they cannot survive in nature.

The cow does not know it's going to be slaughtered.

It lives a nice happy life roaming the fields, on the last few days it goes to processing to eat a massive last great meal.

It's the nicest form of us being eating our prey.


Every time there's an article posted somewhere stating the obvious (as the original post does), there's always someone in the comments referring to non-humans as if they are objects, insisting that of course it is okay to breed various animals into existence to exploit someone for life and then hang them by a hook when they're no longer useful, and slit their throats or shoot them or to dismember them alive (as is documented).

"Of course cows are treated well!", nevermind their children being taken away from them and slaughtered in childhood—love for your children must just be a human thing. Nevermind that the majority of cows, hundreds of millions of them, exist in factory farms. No, you should continue to eat flesh because "we treat them well in ranches".

Incredibly depraved behaviour that history will not look kindly upon. It should, and does, make anyone with a conscience nauseous and sick.


My feeling is not that killing is morally justified by their lack of intelligence, but that there is no purely ethical choice in food besides starving to death. Even veganism necessitates environmental destruction, exploited labor, and other externalities under industrial farming. Anyone that’s harvested a grain field knows that a vegetarian diet is not free from costing animal lives just because it doesn’t include animal protein.

I give my animals the best life and the best death that I can. I hugely value getting significant calories from the sun to my mouth, without environmental destruction /global shipping/slavery/preservatives/etc.


That there are deaths during crop harvesting does not mean that one should then feed those crops to other animals and then kill them for flesh too—instead of growing and eating something human edible. The vast majority of animals killed for their flesh are fed grains and various other harvested crops.

I of course don't know what you specifically are doing—but if it somehow does result in lesser suffering, it is remotely not the norm.


Your original point was that breeding animals and shooting them was incredibly depraved behavior that should make anyone with a conscience sick.

I don’t agree- I think there are ways that raising animals for meat can be an ethical choice. I offered up my own experience of living closely with my animals, relating to them with respect while still using them for meat and fiber.

We are in agreement on the horrors of modern industrial farming. I’m not making any kind of argument in support of factory farming, because I DO find it morally abhorrent.

I hoped by sharing my own experience with my animals, I could add some nuance to the conversation. I now see that that’s unlikely.


Overall getting protein from meat is something like 10x less efficient resource-wise so if you pull back and look at the numbers, it's better to eat plants. One can think of meat eaters as greedily using 10x what they need in a world where resources are scarce.


Note that this is only true for modern agricultural practices. The norm for much of human history was to graze cows and sheep on grass, which humans can't consume at all, and which has evolved in concert with grazing animals. Pigs would often be fed on leftovers and also plenty of non-edible foodstuffs. Chicken were more of an exception, but then again their eggs were eaten much more often than sacrificing the chicken itself.

There is nothing preventing us from going back to more traditional agricultural practices in this area, just as we need to do for most crop harvests to avoid depleting the soils everywhere. Of course, this will require meat to become more expensive, seasonal, and a less common food overall. But there is no reason a 0-emission world would require the whole humam population to be vegan.


>grass, which humans can't consume at all

wheat, rice, maize (corn), barley and millet are all grasses


Neither wheat, rice, maize, barley, nor millet grow on mountain pastures where many sheep and cows are traditionally grazed. In addition, humans can only process the seeds of those plants, while grazing animals can eat the entirety of the plant (and in fact typically don't digest the seeds, instead spreading them in their feces).


most humans do not live on mountains. most livestock are not grazed on mountains. those who do eat goat. even if that were true, out of the many cultivars available, there will be some hardy enough for mountain growth. additionally, neither of your statements refute the fact that cereals and grains are grasses


This is still the norm. They graze in pastures or free range (small and large ranches) even in places like Nevada and Arizona.

They are then shipped to the large processing cages you see several days before and are fed large sums of grain.


That's just not true, at scale. I did some googling and all signs point to single percentage points of beef being handled that way. That's US beef, you think the last 20 years of Argentinian beef has coexisted with the Amazon?


> One can think of meat eaters as greedily using 10x what they need in a world where resources are scarce.

Go ahead and try to replace the protein that meat gives. Cows feed so many people.

So, sure let's replace that ranchland with farmland, what's so hard about that?

That huge amount of natural grassland the cows usually roam on is going to need to be tilled, planted, and fertilized (synthetic via oil or animal based).

You're going to need a lot of water and a lot of fertilizer and resources (labor, machinery, etc.)

Man those cows in Arizona and Nevada really put up with some harsh conditions.

Looks like we need like... a lot water, and a lot more fertilizer...

You know what is scarce, fresh water! California knows this.


Protein from beef is the least efficient way (2%) to farm protein. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/protein-efficiency-of-mea... (last chart).

It’s trivial to get protein from plants which are far more efficient source to farm.


Water isn't really that scarce in California, we just give it all to almond farmers who export it to China.


Adding just so it’s explicit: modern factory farming is morally abhorrent. Yes, the abuses are well-documented and disgusting, and there is no argument in my mind that can ever justify that level of treatment for any conscious being.


If cows were raised like they were throughout history - free range instead of in factory farms, and calves sharing closeness and the milk - would you have the same objection to them being slaughtered at some point later without much suffering?


Perhaps such a system did exist somewhere in some bygone era—maybe in ancient India where milk was common but where cows or calves were never intentionally killed, and skin and carrion was sometimes taken from the corpse. I think most people would consider that non-objectionable—as did most ancient Jains, Buddhist, and Hindus, who believed in ahimsa.

But such a system does not, and probably can not, exist at any significant scale in the modern era. And while instant death is sometimes preferable to a "natural death"—I doubt those interested in "harvesting" the corpse would ever have any incentive to care about whether the death was "without much suffering".


> I doubt those interested in "harvesting" the corpse would ever have any incentive to care about whether the death was "without much suffering".

I am. I work really hard to make sure my animals have the best death I can possibly give them. There’s horrific things happening in industrial meat production, no argument. That doesn’t mean that everyone who raises meat animals is uncaring.


No it does exist, today.

A large portion of cows do roam free in pastures in the US.

They are only processed several days before where they are fed a large sum of grain in those crowded cages you see.


> Incredibly depraved behaviour that history will not look kindly upon. It should, and does, make anyone with a conscience nauseous and sick.

Are you also upset by lions, hyenas, etc eating animals alive and often targeting calves since they are easier to catch?


I raise my own animals and eat them, and was also a vegetarian for a big chunk of my life. I have friends visit who have never been around livestock, never thought too hard about where their meat comes from, and don’t understand how I can kill animals that I also give scritches to and let nap in my lap.

For me, midwifing and raising and caring for animals so they have good lives and quick deaths is the better choice. For many people, the weight of the death is too much. That’s why I say there would be more vegetarians, not because I think vegetarianism is morally superior (or inferior!).


>For me, midwifing and raising and caring for animals so they have good lives and quick deaths is the better choice

Than not eating them at all?


I do need to eat food, and all food comes from somewhere.


Not all food comes from killed animals, though


You are totally correct.

I can choose to get my protein all kinds of ways, including from tofu made in a factory, out of soy grown on another continent, on ground that used to be rainforest and fertilized with nitrogen produced at the cost of huge carbon emissions, then shipped across an ocean. I can also choose to get it from an animal I helped birth, that eats blackberry bushes and grass in my pasture with their family until they’re grown, then gets led to some food on the ground and doesn’t even know what hit them.

I can choose either, and I’m not going to argue on the internet that one is inherently morally superior to the other. ALL of the things we consume come with costs. Just because they’re hidden in the end product doesn’t make them nonexistent.

I also know enough vegans and was a staunch enough vegetarian to know that neither of us is likely to change our minds or even really absorb new information here.


> including from tofu made in a factory, out of soy grown on another continent, on ground that used to be rainforest and fertilized with nitrogen produced at the cost of huge carbon emissions, then shipped across an ocean

or from tofu made from organic, local soy. Why would you want it to come from another country and produced in horrible ways? Of course one can do anything badly, so let's focus on realistic, proper ways to do things.

Unlike raising one's own animals in awesome conditions, which is very costly and basically requires to be a full time job so which most people can't realistically do, I can just drop by the organic shop nearby and buy my organic, local tofu easily enough. Which I do.

Around 80% of the soy is produced to feed animals so that argument does not even work. If you eat meat, you are probably actually doing both at the same time and probably indirectly consume a lot more soy than a vegetarian. I see that you actually raise your own animals in other comments, so maybe not you, and congrats, but your situation does not generalize well.


>or from tofu made from organic, local soy. Why would you want it to come from another country and produced in horrible ways

It's a strawman


[edit: oh, you meant the parent comment is a strawman?]

Why? The parent comment says that you can choose to eat "proteins" in any way possible, from eating horrible soy to eating meat from animals raised in awesome conditions.

I argue that this is not really a useful statement (I want to say, it actually feels misleading and dishonest and that's why I reacted. OP writes about changing one's mind and absorbing new information, a prerequisite of this is to be honest with oneself - the thing that most vegetarian people, who weren't born like this, have already done because they had to to change their minds).

I do want to eat properly and that's what we are discussing. I point out that while the average person can realistically buy local, organic soy easily, one can't do so for meat from properly raised animals.

Of course I can choose to eat horrible soy (I guess? Not sure where I would find tofu made from it actually), like I can choose to eat horrible meat. But if we are to do things the proper way, neither of these options are good. Though eating horrible meat (which includes the horrible soy!) is the realistic option for meat because that's what scales.

(where "horrible meat" means "meat from animals who suffered")

The horrible soy is not even worth mentioning because it harms the pro-meat argument. Like, why even mention the horrible soy to the vegetarians? It's laughable.


Yep, your edit is correct. HN prevented me from replying quickly - sorry.


Okay :-)

No problem. (small tip to use wisely in such a situation: you can click on the timestamp of the comment to reply anyway)

And sorry for having misread you at first. I suspect some of the downvotes you took might have come from people who misread you as well.


Most soy grown is to be fed to animals so we can kill them and eat them. If we ate the soy (and other grains) directly, we wouldn’t need to grow anywhere near as much and destroy as much land as we currently do (+ the land required to raise the animals).


The search for convincing pro-animal-ag arguments continues.


Sounds like you are justifying cannibalism


> Cows are treated very well in all the ranches I've been on.

Unfortunately the entire premise of your argument is based on a personal anecdote that's a gross generalization of vast number of cattle farms.


Let's be fair and acknowledge the difference between a small local farm and the larger "industrial"-like ones. I grew up in a farm, I know others too, people are kind to their animals.

Of course, the larger ones don't care. The same happens even when producing vegetables, no regards to nature in those cases either.


Chickens are very affectionate though. They love to be patted, will run through the field with you, and sit down when they want you to take them to the coop to be locked in for the night (there's many foxes and marters where we live, and no matter how much you try, eventually your free range chickens will be taken by them).


> Your alternative is them not existing at all, they cannot survive in nature.

That's flat out false - there are many examples of free range beef, the entire clean skin northern australian market for one.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBpOiEfYk6A

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8B-zWxDJOZU


> Cows are treated very well in all the ranches I've been on.

The ones with horrible practices do not allow visitors or even cameras. While it is possible to source all your meat from happy places, statistically almost nobody does.


> statistically almost nobody does

Do you have the source of the statistic of everyone eating beef from horrible places?


> We estimate that 99% of US farmed animals are living in factory farms at present. By species, we estimate that 70.4% of cows, 98.3% of pigs, 99.8% of turkeys, 98.2% of chickens raised for eggs, and over 99.9% of chickens raised for meat are living in factory farms.

https://www.sentienceinstitute.org/us-factory-farming-estima...


>Cows are treated very well in all the ranches I've been on.

Unfortunately, that's the minority of cattle and AFAIK it's not really possible to replace all current meat production with the kind of treatment you're talking about, even if everyone was willing to stomach a big price increase.


> Your alternative is them not existing at all, they cannot survive in nature.

What’s wrong with not existing at all vs being exploited and eventually killed before your natural life is over? Statistically speaking, if you’re a cow or other animal we exploit, your chances are far greater to be born and exist in a factory farm. Is it really a life worth living at all?


Yes, life is precious.

Consciousness is even more precious.

The smarter the lifeform, the more precious it's life.

This is the main idea that drives vegetarian and veganism is it not?

To exist is the greatest gift of all. You're experiencing it right now.

It would be a sad day to see such a smart, useful, beautiful creature be extinct from this Earth such as the cow.


Happy lives… that’s not the case for most meat you buy in the $1 bonus packs in the supermarket. Those animals get tortured every day of their short and miserable lives. You have seen different but stimulating meat consumption while those factories exist is wrong imho as that will only grow as a result. But it is not fixable because there is no space to grow meat for all humans this way in a free range way, so better stop eating it at all (until it comes from labs or space or whatever).

So visit one of the horror pig farms and see how the bacon tastes after that I would say. In my view only actual psychopaths can eat it after seeing that.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: