Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

These are real recalls btw, for a safety feature that kills you. (airbag frag grenades)

I know some people have been conditioned that software rollbacks are recalls due to all the anti-Tesla articles.


Recalls are recalls because that's what the gov't is calling them, I do not understand this post at all.


What's not to understand? Physical recall. Killer airbag. Turn it in.

It simply means, your car will not roll this feature back itself because it's not a software recall. Go turn it in.

Turns out it's confusing to overload the term "recall", and downright dangerous when it comes to overloading safety terms.

We're always going on about how misleading AutoPilot is as a term to the hypothetically confused consumer. But overloading recall isn't confusing?

I cannot help that the government for some reason chose to overload this term.


>I cannot help that the government for some reason chose to overload this term.

Why would you need to help that? Is there some reason you have to not call it a recall?


Is there some reason you don't understand the negatives of an overloaded term?


I'm not sure what it has to do with you that you find the need to rectify it, even construing your assumptions as true (which I dispute).


And yet you're sure as to why you need to rectify my clarification?


I didn't correct you, I expressed why I found your post confusing.


It's a recall, just one that you don't need to go to a dealer for. I understand your point, but it is still a recall.


Yes, if you're used to "recalls" that happen automatically this is not one of those.


Recall is what the government called the autopilot thing, right? It's a legal term.


Yes I'm pointing out the difference that their legal term overlooks because it's overloaded.

Illegal alien is also a legal term that sometimes requires distinction.


You said anti-Tesla articles are conditioning people to think there were recalls. But there were in fact recalls, which Tesla responded to with OTA fixes.


I'm simply saying don't expect this to be rolled back in software.

It's a PHYSICAL recall. Normally the articles cover that important detail up, so all you see is recall.


Ironically, those are more likely to kill you, than these airbags.


Not really, Teslas are quite safe and don't have the killer Takata airbags like the many other car brands.

But yeah that facetiousness is why I said the statement above.

It's really easy to lookup Tesla safety ratings so I won't get dragged into what you're trying to do.



I stand corrected. Glad they stopped using them.


Tbh, 24 deaths in all the years since 2003 is a pretty tiny number considering just how many of these airbags were used.

I'm not saying it's a good thing, but it's also pretty low rate-wise.


Yes 24 people that had to die for no reason, but yeah it's low for the massive fuck up that this was.

I don't really know what the point of that statement is though. Reads like part of a Boeing spokesman's speech.


My point is that the person who made the statement "those are more likely to kill you than these airbags" wasn't really all that off the mark.

There's been more (~35) deaths due to Tesla issues (fires, self-driving, etc) in a few years than in the 2 decades this problem airbag has existed.


Are those 35 counting the people who were asleep, trying to kill themselves, etc?

Because if they are from the same news outlets as reports the other Tesla crashes, those are not always due to Tesla issues, and it always comes out they weren't because they have data on everything.

And other cars catch on fire in crashes and people burn to death in ICE cars. Fires are not exclusive to EVs. Shrapnel airbags on the other hand...

Plus I've seen at least 5+ videos where the safety features in a Tesla reacted faster than the driver and saved them, do we count that as a negative death?


>Plus I've seen at least 5+ videos where the safety features in a Tesla reacted faster than the driver and saved them, do we count that as a negative death?

Safety features that exist in other cars too? A base-model Corolla has pedestrian detection and collision avoidance in it as well.

And plenty of other manufacturers have similar systems.


I'm not talking about pedestrian detection, I'm talking about active avoidance of oncoming vehicles.

But if the positives of any safety system don't count, then the negatives don't count against Tesla.

Because all cars have safety systems that could kill or save you under that logic.


Most likely because it wasn't polished, so get it out now in a polished and limited state and now you have a fancy update to tout when it is done.


Is there a reason why Oct 7th (the massacre that started this escalation) was not discussed?

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1696896000&dateRange=custom&...


I haven't gone back to check this, but I assume users flagged the posts and moderators didn't turn off the flags.

We only turn off flags when it seems like there's some basis and at least some chance for a reflective, substantive discussion. That isn't possible in the immediate aftermath of a shocking event like the atrocities of Oct 7—the reactions are necessarily going to be reflexive rather than reflective; completely understandably so—but the odds of any thoughtful conversation in that state of shock are basically zero.

Not that this thread or the related ones have been anything close to what I would wish for on HN, in terms of thoughtful conversation, but unfortunately we don't have the ability to make that happen, and not discussing the topic at all seems out of the question as well, so here we are with no good position and no solution.


I understand, could you please check it and report what you find?

But as I understand you, it's left to the moderator's discretion to unflag topics.

Is there a checklist / criteria of judging whether the users can have a "reflective" or "reflexive" political discussion?

Would 9/11 not be covered because it would be too "reflexive"?

Why was this discussion of this "genocide" viewed as not too "reflexive"?

You have to see how it looks very one-sided. It would be nice for political discussion topic allowance details to be explained.

Currently it leaves a lot of assumptions as you point out.


Ok, I checked and the only moderator intervention I found was that we prevented flags from killing https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37800508. That's not the same thing as turning the flags off, but it prevented the story from being marked [flagged][dead] instead of [flagged].

> Would 9/11 not be covered because it would be too "reflexive"?

Probably? I'd prefer not to discuss counterfactuals because it's impossible to know.

I've explained at length on many occasions how we approach the question of which political topics to allow or turn off flags on - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

I know it's unsatisfying, but moderation of these things is never going to be (and certainly never going to feel) completely consistent. We try our best, but it's not possible, and especially not in hindsight, because moderation is guesswork.


>> We only turn off flags when it seems like there's some basis and at least some chance for a reflective, substantive discussion.

Mokay, but then can I grumble? I've posted several articles on the subject of the alleged genocide of the Palestinians by Israel's IDF, here on HN I mean, and they all got flagged and not unflagged. I took care to post opinions on both sides of the subject, e.g. this public statement by "over 800 scholars and practitioners of international law, conflict studies and genocide studies" warning of potential genocide [1], and this NYT article by historian of genocide Omer Bartov, saying that genocide is not in evidence ("yet") [2].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38036236

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38228704

Those are articles by scholars who discuss the subject in the most dispassionate manner imaginable (Bartov is particularly a pleasure to read for his level-headed and erudite analysis, although it's obvious he'll find it very hard to admit genocide by his country which he clearly loves) and I'm pretty sure that means they satisfy the "curious conversation" goal you, dang, hold sacred (and it's good that you do).

So what's up? I've been posting this stuff for months and now the subject has exploded in mainstream discourse with the ICJ case, which makes it even more emotionally charged than before. Wouldn't it have been better to get a chance to discuss this before it got to this point?

And while I appreciate there's not one side that HN favours, the ability to flag anything anyone dislikes shapes the discourse in the way vocal minorities prefer.

Sorry for grumbling. I hope you know I respect and admire the work you've done to keep HN on the straight and narrow.


Sorry again. This must be a hard day for the moderation team. My <3 <3 <3 to all of youse.

(My partner claims "<3" looks like I'm mooning you. I assure you that's not the intended meaning).


I'm afraid the answer is boringly straightforward: users flagged those articles, and either we didn't see them or we chose not to turn off the flags. Most likely we didn't see them.

The usual pattern is that flags come from a 'coalition' of users: some because they hold opposing views, while others just think the story doesn't belong on HN. Maybe they think it's off-topic or otherwise against the site guidelines, or they think the story has already been covered a lot recently, or who knows what.

I took a look at the flags on your two submissions. They followed this pattern. I saw one user whose flagging history looked primarily political, but only one—less than I expected to see. Among the others, here's a sample of other stories that at least one of those same users has flagged:

An Open Letter to the Next School Shooter - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31721682

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33732913

“How America took out the Nord Stream pipeline” - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34707305

Call Girl in Calangute Beach Escort Service And91-9319373153 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35927067

Humanity Just Witnessed Its First Space Battle - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38195174

Did Ancient Rome Have Windows? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38733970

Joe Biden Plans to Ban Logging in US Old-Growth Forests in 2025 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38779191

Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39147669

Gazan civilians have told Hamas was preventing them from leaving combat areas - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39160294

As you can see, there's a range of topics there (all the way to outright spam) and possible motives for flagging. The last one is interesting because unless I'm mistaken, it has opposite politics to the articles you posted. This is a sign of what I mean when I say that not all flaggers are politically motivated.

So that's the flagging side; now for the admin side:

First, we can't moderate anything we don't see and we don't come close to seeing everything. There's just too much. If there's an article you (or anyone) think particularly deserves consideration, I can always be reached at [email protected] and I'm happy to take a look.

When deciding whether to turn off flags, one thing we consider is whether a story is substantive enough to provide a foundation for a thoughtful discussion rather than a flamewar. (On a topic like the OP, the odds are sadly awful no matter what the article is, but it is still an important consideration.) I hear you that you think your posts met this condition—I haven't read them, but let's say that's correct. The thing is, it's not a required one. There are other concerns as well.

For example, we have to consider how much the topic has been covered recently, and how much coverage of it HN can 'take' without showing signs of breaking under the strain.

People have wildly diverging views about how much is too much. For some users with strong feelings on a topic, no coverage can ever be too much; any limitation at all must be proof that the mods are biased against it. For other users, any coverage is already too much and proves the mods are biased against them. So it goes.

It's trickiest when there's a major ongoing topic that goes on for months and generates a series of stories. We can't just say "no, HN covered that a couple months ago" if there has been a significant state change; but we also have to be careful not to let many follow-up articles onto the front page (e.g. articles that repeat what has already been discussed, perhaps adding some minor twist or opinion take, or media outlets circulating their own version of the same story), because they'll use up the community's 'attention budget' for that story, leaving nothing for later.

For example in 2013, the Snowden saga dominated HN's front page—there were so many follow-up articles that when something important did happen (e.g. when he finally left Hong Kong or whatever), it got drowned out, or bogged down in the "I'm so sick of all these posts" complaint that repetition inevitably generates on HN.

The principle we ended up settling on was the Significant New Information (SNI) one: does the new submission count as SNI in the sequence of threads that have already happened? SNI can mean some objective new development in the story; or it can mean something with enough of a diff from previous related submissions to count as a somewhat different topic.

There are other considerations too, for example about HN as a whole, which is a different scope than a particular topic. But this comment is already too long, so I'll skip those, and anyway I wouldn't be able to remember them all.

Putting all of the above together, your submissions got flagged by regular users for regular reasons, and we either didn't see them or decided not to turn off the flags, probably not because the articles weren't substantive enough, but rather because either (1) the topic had had a major thread recently; or (2) we didn't think they cleared the bar for SNI. I'm just speaking generally because I don't have any memory of those posts.

I'm afraid I've given a false impression that this is all somehow orderly or co-ordinated. It isn't. It's random and ad hoc, and various random factors (like whether we see something at all) are at least as significant as all this stuff. It's not a repeatable process. Moreover, we just make bad calls sometimes—especially in hindsight. Some of it is accidents of timing. People are far too quick to infer general patterns from specific data points they observe. That's true about everything on HN, but it gets more true as the emotions are more engaged.

I have one last thing to respond to in your comment:

> I've been posting this stuff for months and now the subject has exploded in mainstream discourse with the ICJ case, which makes it even more emotionally charged than before. Wouldn't it have been better to get a chance to discuss this before it got to this point?

I don't think that's right. It was just as emotionally charged before, and threads about those articles you posted would have ended up in the same place that this thread did, as did the earlier threads in this sequence. So no, I don't think it would have been better to discuss before it got to this point; I think it's the other way around—by waiting till this point, we at least had clear grounds for having a thread, since there's no question that this was SNI.


St. Spyridon and all the saints, dude, where do you find the energy to write that much and read everything everyone else writes? I guess you use writing as a form of thinking, of course, but in any case you must really care about HN.

I had a disagreement a while ago with a user here and they said something that irked me so I asked them "is that the internet that you want?". And they seem to be taken aback by that because obviously there was some kind of internet that they wanted and that included a frank, but productive, exchange of views, and they seemed to agree their style of commenting wasn't conducive to that. So the conversation went a lot better afterwards. I have convinced myself that you, too, want a certain kind of internet -one where "curious conversation" can be had- and you're doing what you can to make HN, at least, that kind of internet. And I think it's working: the amount of flames and slagging matches on HN is near-zero and you still get to hear different opinions on everything (in fact, a few too many of those but, eh).

Which is to say, I didn't grumble for the flags to imply your moderation is one-sided, just to be clear. I was a bit surprised that the flags stood for two reasons: one, because I assumed when something gets flagged, it is brought to the attention of the moderation team and that makes it less likely that it will stay flagged if the flags are one-sided; and two, the reason I pointed out above, the scholarly credentials of the authors of the articles I posted.

Well you've answered both of those I guess. In particular:

>> It's not a repeatable process.

I understand that, but I tend to forget it. My bad.

I accept also that the ICJ case is "SNI". But the articles I posted were among the first to raise the issue in a scholarly manner, so I thought they were salient.

Btw- Bartov's text was really top-notch (I kind of disagree with him, though I have to defer to his obvious expertise). It's a bit dated now that so much time has passed and he's updated his opinion a bit (still not genocide) but anyway, for anyone interested in this subject and having an urgent need for a voice of reason amid the madness, for now at least he will do.


I don't come close to reading everything, that's for sure. I took time to write the above because I know people are particularly sensitive on this question about this topic.

> the amount of flames and slagging matches on HN is near-zero

I wish. But I guess if anyone has this perception at all, that's a sign of something working.

> I assumed when something gets flagged, it is brought to the attention of the moderation team

That's mostly true, but not as true as it used to be. There are a lot of flagged stories. While at least one moderator does note them all, it has to be done quickly and it's easy to miss salient details.


>> I wish. But I guess if anyone has this perception at all, that's a sign of something working.

I meant the ones that escape the flagging to death. Those are relatively few, compared with my experience from other places on the 'net.


[flagged]


I was specifically asking about Oct 7th coverage and the coverage this event.

While I don't agree with your recount of history, it's off-topic to my question to @dang

In fact, the presence and tone of comments like yours vs the lacking and flagging of pro-Israel gets exactly to the root of my question.


Seems more like, we would like to increase investment on the condition that you use it more for X (???) and less for Y (people).

Oh and all you companies do this all at the same time so no one loses stock value, kthxbye.


No, it's a facetious response to those who want to experiment with billions of people's lives to replace capitalism which has brought so many people out of poverty and hunger with an unstated system that will most likely resemble communism which will again starve hundreds of millions as it has countless of times.

People can and do operate a commune within a capitalistic society. Go in with other people and buy some land to live off, make a contract to share all property. You can't do the inverse in a communistic society.

But no, we all have to do it or it won't work, because apparently it's only possible at scale and it can't be explained until then. Convenient.

So don't act like you can't go live life in a commune today, you can, just people don't, because capitalistic life is more comfortable.

They'd rather complain online about other people's lives, using their iPhone, drinking Starbucks, thinking about how know best for all more than the great minds that created the society they take for granted.


> those who want to experiment with billions of people's lives

Sorry, but you don't know that this is the method of anybody the response is targeted at. It's an ill-formed assumption, and many people are interested in counteracting the apparent and obvious detrimental aspects of capitalist society without violent revolution and totalitarian regimes.

> People can and do operate a commune within a capitalistic society.

Cool, good for them. Escapism isn't necessarily the goal, though. Obviously it depends on the person.

> You can't do the inverse in a communistic society.

Communism is the "free association of producers." If the producers wish to assign dictatorial control of their factory to one person and sell their labor to that person in exchange for a wage based on paper money, they are free to do so. But why would anybody willingly engage in this arrangement unless there is no alternative?

> They'd rather complain online about other people's lives, using their iPhone, drinking Starbucks, thinking about how know best for all

You have created a stereotype and are reinforcing it here. It's based in nothing.

> more than the great minds that created the society they take for granted.

Wait, capitalism was a constructed system? My impression is that it's a somewhat emergent system that started with feudalism and grew from there.


> Communism is the "free association of producers."

This sounds very hand-wavy. Why isn't capitalism this?


Capitalism is the free association of property owners.


I care about open source as a developer.

As a user I want the most polished program available and am not against using closed source if it meets my needs as is and I don't need to modify it beyond it's supported options.


none of these work in my area, mockingbirds confuse the hell out of it haha

they register through like 10-15 calls, a lot of birds not even from the region, they get around!


Homekit uses bluetooth mesh.

It's the main reason I chose it, no wifi for anything.


It uses Thread (mesh) or Bluetooth (but I believe direct to phone/hub, no mesh)


It connects to the hub but you have bluetooth repeaters to extend it.

True, devices don't directly connect to each other, so I guess not mesh.

But for all intents and purposes the bluetooth instead of wifi is all I care about, not how it's implemented, as long as it's reliable.


There's just little benefit in HTMX unless you have a live financial dashboard or something like that.

I find the opposite approach of local-first (database in the client).

It fits more solutions and solves many more things (free offline, syncing, undo support) and getting rid of caching, retries, and latency.

Of course the industry wants you to want more on the server though.

Same view applies to RSC (react server components).

Embrace CRDTs.


oh, i dunno, seems like the internet has been somewhat successful as a distributed system, but ymmv


centralizing would be using HTMX and authoritative servers.

local-first is more decentralized as your clients can sync directly with each other (or through a dumb proxy for NAT punching)

I see no need for servers to be anything but dumb proxies for clients. Not the opposite of making clients dumb terminals.


welp, when you are coordinating things it's often a tremendous simplification to have a centralized source of truth and then present representations of that truth in the form of hypermedia to hypermedia clients, using hypermedia as the engine of application state

of course, it's not right for everything and there are alternative approaches that work better or worse, depending on context, but i'd say it's hard to not call it a pretty successful approach to distributed systems


a centralized source of truth is a pretty successful approach to distributed systems?

seems more like a successful escape hatch. yes it's simpler, but it's antithetical to the goal.


well, i mean, the web is a distributed system of servers providing resource representations specified by universal resource locators

it seems to have been fairly successful to me

i think you are associating 'distributed' w/peer-to-peer models, whereas i'm using it in the broader sense of networked software that can interact (link) to one another

i have no beef w/ peer-to-peer and it would be interesting to think about how hypermedia could layer on top of that model, but i'm not an expert on that sort of stuff so I can't have particularly informed opinions on it


I saw the twitter post of what they're talking about.

It was just the way the car hit it I guess, CT was basically untouched, everyone was fine, but it was high enough speed to total the other car.

It's not really an indicator of anything, just an interesting happenstance.

CT didn't crumple because it wasn't hit where it needed to crumple.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: