Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

Unfortunately?

Just above we can see a clear point that criminals will still have guns.

They won't turn them in. You'll only take away the ability of law-abiding citizens to defend themselves.

My wife carries a gun because she is smaller and weaker than most men, she needs it to protect herself.


But if they’re harder to get, fewer will have them. You can very much get an illegal firearm in Australia or the UK if you really want, but firearms crimes are significantly less because they’re not readily available.

I don’t think we (Canada or anybody) should necessarily ban guns, but I don’t think the US should have the 2nd amendment (as it’s now interpreted anyways) either.


Unfortunately because I wish there were no guns at all. But I’m a pragmatist. I know gun ownership will never go away in the U.S. so I own guns as well.


How would you prevent folks from machining, 3d printing, or casting their own? Firearm technology is centuries old.


Is this an anecdote of your experience or?

11 years does not seem like long enough time for a language to first start declining and then end as being the primary formal language.


It’s not “declining” but rather being actively replaced and rejected by the population. When your nation suffers brutal aggression perpetrated by the neighbor - it makes it no longer fashionable to speak the language of the aggressor. The fact that Russia also denies that Ukraine and Ukrainians are even a real nation and culture distinct from Russia fuels the sentiment too.


not anecdotal, I speak both languages. The trend now is to reject everything russian even though you do understand it, no way around this. And yes, the “kitchen language” for many ukrainians, especially east part, remained russian. However, on public or outside ppl try their best to speak Ukrainian. The younger generation will be more like the one in the baltic counties or Georgia. Understand russian but rather speak their native language.


anecdotal means your personal experience.


Based on the recent (September 2023) social study:

Which is your native language? 2012: 57% Ukrainian, 42% Russian; 2023: 82% Ukrainian, 16% Russian

Which language do you speak at home? 2023: 63% Ukrainian, 27% mixed, 7% Russian

Coincides with my andecotal experience. Source: https://ratinggroup.ua/en/research/ukraine/soc_olog_chne_dos...


Something about having your country invaded and missiles fired at your cities tends to change perceptions of the culture initiating said aggression.


But they do not make you forget a language is the point.


I thought we were talking about the 80% who "preferred" it as a language of business. Surely that... has dropped like a stone.

That and the way people respond to polls now is gonna change.

In any case I think going forward you'll see English's fortunes rise in Ukraine, and probably Polish as well.


The parent comment of this thread by @Waterluvian is whether they understand the Russian language.


Organically, no, 11 years is not long enough.

But you may recall that in 2014, a few political directives regarding culture and language use have been made by the Rada, and then a few political decisions were made in the Kremlin, and then everything turned to shit (To put it simply).

It's easy to do a lot in 11 years when you start banning foreign-language media, stop using a language for government services, stop teaching it, etc, etc.


February 2014 Moscow occupied Crimea. 12.04.2014 Moscow occupied Slovyansk.

Name "few political directives" in 2014 before Moscow invasion. Ukraine actions are direct response to Moscow aggression. People don't want to be occupied by Moscow like Donetsk, Luhansk. Life is awful there, million fled from occupation. That's why changes were supported by majority of Ukrainians.

Still occupants language was learned in schools, media could use it though eventually quotas set to use Ukrainian too. And officials continued using it.

Ukraine policies fought discrimination of Ukrainian in Ukraine. Discrimination that stems from centuries of occupation by Moscow. In 2016 state stated at least 60% TV should be on Ukrainian. Only in 2017 education in schools was switched from occupants language to Ukrainian. Since 2019 Ukrainian should be used in services unless requested otherwise by customer. People switch to Ukrainian voluntarily, state provides means.

Ukraine is a democratic state, check out Euromaidan. Stop pretending like changes is anything but result of Moscow agression.


"Name "few political directives" in 2014 before Moscow invasion."

"On February 23, 2014, the second day after the flight of Viktor Yanukovich, while in a parliamentary session, a deputy from the Batkivshchyna party, Vyacheslav Kyrylenko, moved to include in the agenda a bill to repeal the 2012 law "On the principles of the state language policy". <...> The bill would have made Ukrainian the sole state language at all levels. <...> However, the move to repeal the 2012 law "On the principles of the state language policy" provoked negative reactions in Crimea and in some regions of Southern and Eastern Ukraine. It became one of the topics of the protests against the new government approved by the parliament after the flight of Viktor Yanukovich." [0]

And more generally: Ukrainization Post-1991: Independent Ukraine. [1]

"check out Euromaidan."

“The mob, whatever it is, has no legitimacy before the sovereign people expressing themselves through its elected representatives.” [2]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_policy_in_Ukraine#Att...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainization#Post-1991:_indep...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/22/world/europe/macron-pensi...


There was a bit of a coup against one of the branches of government on Feb 2014, it's odd that it's missing from your timeline, given that it kind of precipitated everything else that followed.

But perhaps that's how you think democracies work - when you don't like the government, you bring your friends to wear funny hats and storm the capitol, and get a new one... Should Americans do that the next time an unpopular politician ends up heading the executive? It certainly speeds up the transfer of power, even if it drops the 'peaceful' aspect of it...


Euromaidan was response to violent dispersal of protesters. Government escalated, eventually killed hundred of citizens. Do you claim Americans would do nothing if killed in hundreds? No persecution, approved by "unpopular politician", passed laws on dictatorship (16.01.2014).

Moscow invaded Ukraine (Crimea) 20.02.2014. Yanukovych fled 21.02.2014. Occupation does not just "happen", it was staged. Ukrainians felt that as betrayal, seen as occupants population cheared in support. That hurts, breaks cultural ties. In a few months Moscow invaded east of Ukraine while spreading lies. Lies obvious for Ukraine citizens, believed by occupants population.


> Do you claim Americans would do nothing if killed in hundreds?

They'd blame the people who died. At least, that's how Kent State went down (And the students there weren't even trying to overthrow the government).

There's a process for peaceful transfer of power. Some countries have good processes for this, some have bad ones, some are in between. As far as I'm aware, though, no country has a process of 'Enough people storm the capitol' for determining when that happens.

When you don't follow the permitted process, this compromises a democracy's legitimacy. Now, obviously the coup was only carried out against the executive, not the legislature, so the resulting government was partially legitimate - at least, the legislature remained representative of the public (And the issue was resolved in the subsequent election).

But that aside, just because the coup only finished on the 21st, and the invasion happened on the 20th, doesn't mean that the weeks of the revolution leading up to it weren't intimately related to the start of the war.


Laws on dictatorship passed 16.01.2014, copied from Belarus, Russian Federation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-protest_laws_in_Ukraine

Peaceful transfer of power is not possible in Belarus or Russian Federation. Ukrainians have no guns, democracy is not stable, judiciary and special forces are not independent, media influenced by state and oligarchs. Euromaidan saved Ukraine from Belarus fate.

Moscow invasion staged not in preceding weeks but in years. Putin revealed intentions in 2007, occupied Georgia in 2008.


Still, that 80% hasn’t died off so those people still know the language


Yeah, that crazy heart attack gene ya'know.


to ensure or assure no foul play and to keep stats of what's killing us and sometimes try to mitigate those things.


Yeah and a thinly veiled one at that, reused the same phrase as the Died Suddenly documentary that covered the blood clot autopsies.

Lots of studies and news articles now coming out how common sudden death from cardio problems are, strange timing.


It's known that Covid infection can cause heart issues, and winter infections have been peaking recently.


the spike protein itself causes heart issues, present in both covid and the vaccines.


I'm immensely interested in people commenting how they are disinterested in X thing.

Please go on! I'd love to know the motivation of posting, it makes no sense to me.

Seems to be a self-fulfilled prophecy.


I guess I just wish the HN timeline wasn't so full of his garbage.


I use starlink, it works pretty well, as good as cable. Not garbage.

I've ridden in Teslas. Some likes, but holy shit that drivetrain. Not garbage.

You however, have been consuming garbage media. Hint: if every other day (ahem Gawker sites) there is an outrageous anti-Musk headline or "crazy thing Musk said" headline, your media source is total garbage.

Is he a "good guy"? No. Is he "the worse thing ever?" No. What does it matter what he says or does? Nothing. Yet he is living in seemingly millions of people's brains as the sum factor of dozens of PR and advertising campaigns, in addition to the general anti-intellectualism of America.

Anyway, Starlink is a transformative data provider service that blankets virtually the entire world in broadband class connectivity, including massive amounts of third world countries and other areas.

Calling it garbage is dumb.


Agree to disagree I guess. The fact that it's his project makes it uninteresting even if the tech would have been alright in the hands of someone less harmful.

If you aren't catching things like his signal boosting of literal nazis on Twitter, your media sources are garbage. (Also is Gawker even still a thing?)


on one hand

- Tesla kicked off one of the two pillars of dealing with climate change: EVs to eliminate as much carbon emissions from transportation as possible

on the other hand

- mean tweets

... yes there is a lot of hard work by other people involved in #1, but Musk's leadership was a major contributor. Let me ask you a question. Rank the most evil CEOs in the world. If you have musk over petroleum companies, mining executives, military contractors, gun manufacturers, internet companies hoovering your data for the government, financial wizards defrauding people for short term gain, etc, then I'm sorry, you don't know anything about the world. Oops, I forgot purdue pharma and other opioid producers, chemicals and industrialists that dump and poison the environment, surveillance and security companies enabling despots (and the US government), I mean, I could go on.


EVs don't "eliminate as much carbon emissions from transportation as possible".


I suppose I could engineer a worm that bricks as many connected ICE cars, and also a worm that brings the world supply chain and petroleum production pipeline to a halt, and bring civilization to an end.

So technically, you are correct.

When Tesla started, there was zero. ZERO. movement by the automotive and governmental powers towards decarbonization of transportation beyond hollow treaties, one of which had already been utterly ignored.

Let me emphasize: ZERO, or as close as practically imaginable to it. Ten years later, every company's CEO had a question in front of them 1) how are you going to transition to electric vehicles and stay viable. If they couldn't answer that (BMW in particular, who actually were minutely ahead of the curve but squandered it), they were fired.


Do you have a specific qualms with satellites providing internet to remote areas or EVs or space exploration or is it purely personal?

In other words, what makes it "garbage" to you?

If it's straight up due to Musk being involved, isn't that a negative outlook for the sake of being negative?

You could just view it as humans advancing and be happy about that.


I think I have been pretty clear? I don't care for Musk's projects.


You were clear on the opinion, not the reasoning.

I was just curious as to why you didn't care for the projects.


I don't really see an individual asshole's ownership of such a large part of the world's internet access as "humans advancing". Nor do I see his attempt at shifting the conversation away from actual solutions (e.g public transport, walkable cities, etc) over to "buy slightly more efficient and very expensive cars from him" as "humans advancing". His efforts to signal-boost the far right is certainly not "humans advancing".

This is just PR for one of his shitty projects. It has no place on HN.


that internet access didn't exist before this project.

it's not like he took over an existing share of the internet, he connected more people together that weren't previously.

btw you'll still need vehicles, whether you make your city/town walkable or not, stores need trucks, people have emergencies.

and it's up to your local government to handle public transportation properly, not Elon...


None of that has anything to do with what I wrote, cool.


Smart choice to deflect.

See you on the next Elon article you crave.


I mean there's not that much I can do when you just write unrelated stuff? "None of those people were connected to the Internet before" .. so therefore it's somehow good that those people's Internet access is controlled by one ass? "Businesses still need trucks" .. so therefore it's good to sell in slightly more efficient cars as the solution to the personal transport part of the climate crisis? Or to derail high speed rail projects with vapourware promises?

The things I wrote and the things you responded with aren't connected, so there's not much intelligent commentary to give.


Now you responded to each item, good. That's how a conversation works.

But going into each individual political talking point for the various subjects you brought up would be tiring.

I'm not going to dive into your misguided views when we can't even talk about the initial topic that giving internet to disconnected people is a good thing and not garbage.


Cool. Bye.


It is not HIS garbage. He is involved in numerous companies. Starlink is a product of SpaceX and that is full of thousands of great engineers. To be disinterested in SpaceX technology because of Musk is to be completely dismissive of the amazing accomplishments and effort of those thousands of great engineers. Would you like to have your work dismissed because the head of your company was a bizarre jerk? By any rational measure, SpaceX is NOT producing garbage tech.


Those thousands of great engineers at SpaceX decided to dedicate their lives to do Musk's bidding. Not my fault.


You'd find the support system for humans walking the same distance would take up more space than cars.

Strange to compare two completely different modes of transportation isolating one variable.


It would be more efficient to reconfigure our urban space to be more human scale. This required less distance in walking and less dependence on cars.


Cities/states can't even complete a public transportation project without embezzling the money. (see CHSR)

You also have the problem of stocking. You still need roads for trucks to supply stores.

Then there's the need of roads to connect cities and towns.

I can walk end to end in my town, but I still need to be able to drive to a specific spot incase of an emergency or logistical errand like moving or vacationing.

Even simple things like buying kitty litter would be a hassle without a car.

I'd go with a horse then if no car, which I occasionally see actually. Then a bike with a wagon or something. Slowly regressing in mobility, freedom, and tech.

The urban planning no cars thing really makes no sense once you realize your bubble is supported by the vast road network the US has.


You've never been stuck in traffic on a toll road?

And you do pay to use Freeway lanes, through vehicle registration fees and gas taxes.


Vehicle and gas taxes cost the same when driving on an empty road at 2am and a rush hour LA freeway.

They're completely irrelevant for this discussion.


well no, you burn more gas sitting in rush hour than driving on an empty road, thus you pay more taxes.

it was mainly a side point though that it's not free, every legal driver has prepaid via vehicle registration AND pays on usage basis via a gas tax.

my main refute was toll roads get just as congested.


OK, we have to take a step further into microeconomic theory.

For demand to match supply, it's not enough to charge any non zero price.

If cell phones cost nothing, they will always be sold out. If they cost $1, they will also always be sold out. This does not disprove microeconomic theory!

With some experimentation you can find the "equilibrium price", where supply meets demand, and you can always find a phone to buy.

For road pricing, it's true that the driver pays a bit extra for gas in rush hour traffic. But if it's just going from 1% to 2% of the equilibrium price, there will still be gridlock.

Toll roads are a better cause for you, but even if thery try to set equilibrium prices, that is pretty hard, since conditions vary every 10 minutes. If prices are set politically, it's bad for reelection to set the prices high enough.

If you do succeed in setting equilibrium road prices - and to be fair, I'm not aware of anywhere that has been done, which weakens my point - we would see freeways that today crawl at 15 mph go at full speed 65 mph traffic 24/7, which - and this is the huge payoff - means vastly more cars could travel on them, and they'd be much more useful than today.


This was my experience as well.

Down to the metal fabrication / woodworking being the most critical thinking I did in K-12 other than programming and reading on my own time


Is there a difference between being harassed with deepfakes vs fakes?

Photoshop has the power to cause distress too when used maliciously.

You go after the aggressors, not the tool used for aggression.


Ease of use and accessibility. Think of how we control access to guns even though a baseball bat could also be used to kill or maim someone.

I agree that we should legislate against the aggressors, that's why I'm pointing out the limitations of technical solutions like watermarks. We need extensions to things like revenge pornography laws, if we're talking about legislation, and I don't see any harm in outlawing services that automate the creation of deepfakes.

Of course the only "solution" is that we would universally behind to teach young boys that they are not entitled to women's bodies or their sexuality, but so many grown men apparently disagree that I can't see it happening quickly enough.


I'm one of the grown men who disagree. I don't think treating half the population as pre-criminals, when in reality it's an extremely tiny minority who act in this way, is a particularly good solution. If we were to apply this kind of "solution" to all undesirable behaviours exhibited by deviant minorities of both men and women I doubt there'd be any time for any actual K-12 formal education.

It's a nice applause line though.


So no to technical solutions, no to legislative solutions and no to education. What do you suggest?

Edit: you disagree that men aren't entitled to women's sexuality?

Edit: I mis-interpreted what was being disagree with.


I suggest we clearly specify the class of problem we're trying to solve and come up with a principled solution that would make sense when applied consistently and universally to all problems in that class. I prefer this over coming up with knee-jerk moral panic patches (e.g. "censor generative models so they can't generate this particular thing I find distasteful") or with overly abstract and tangential problem-solutions (e.g. "just teach men not to be big jerks").

I think the central issue here is: what restrictions, if any, should be placed around creating and distributing a likeness of another person? Are we just looking to prohibit pornographic likenesses, or do you think the restrictions should be broader? What's the threshold rule you would apply? Should these rules be medium-specific, or should we also prohibit people from, say, painting a likeness of another person without their consent?

I guess in a US context you'd also have to consider whether it's constitutional to restrict freedom of expression, even the distasteful ones, in this manner.

Edit: Just saw your edit suggesting that I think "men are entitled to women's bodies" (whatever that means). I think I'll end my participation here, not interested in having a bad faith discussion.


I'm not in the US but I understand that there are already laws which limit your expression, such as in cases of CSAM or revenge pornography, which night be the closest analogue.

Personally the limits are similar to that, as I'm personally most interested in fighting sexual harassment. The legislation against revenge pornography already faces and tackles issues of what constitutes pornography and when it becomes illegal to disseminate pornographic images of others, so it's not an intractable problem.

Indeed, we also have precedents for limiting the use of tools for certain purposes. Using deepfake technology to generate images akin to CSAM would already be illegal in the UK, but other broader and everyday examples exist like speed limits for cars.

Edit to respond to yours: I said above that we should teach boys they're not entitled to women's sexuality, but that many men disagree. You said you were one of them. I had meant the disagreement being on the entitlement, but I'm now considering that you took it to mean they disagreed with the education about entitlement. It was a misunderstanding, and I was responding in good faith. I didn't suggest anything about you, I asked if my interpretation of your response was correct.


Fair enough on your edit, I accept it was a misinterpretation and appreciate the clarification.

The precedents you raise are worth considering. They're related but not completely analogous to deepfake porn of real people in my view. CSAM is criminalised due to the direct harm its production inflicts on minors and the deep injury to society that follows. Deepfake CSAM, I presume, has more of an 'obscenity' rationale as there is no actual direct harm inflicted on minors in that case. I suppose you could have a similar obscenity rationale for criminalising deepfake porn but you would then have to accept that pornography in general should be outlawed. An obscenity rationale would also be more supportive of criminal sanctions, as acts of obscenity injure society in addition to individual subjects.

I think revenge pornography is the best analogy here. I assume the policy rationale / theory of harm for criminalising 'revenge porn' (i.e. distributing true intimate private images of another person) is one of two things: (1) violation of the subject's privacy or (2) infliction of psychological harm on the subject. If the policy rationale is (1) then I don't I don't think there's a sound analogy to deepfake porn - deepfakes are fictional and so do not violate the privacy of the subject.

If the rationale is (2), psychological harm, then I could see a similar policy rationale for legislating against deepfake porn. But if psychological harm is your policy rationale then wouldn't it make more sense to directly criminalise the infliction of psychological harm on others regardless of the method used? If we were regulating on a principled and universal basis we should pass a law that criminalises any act, publication or utterance that inflicts psychological harm on another person, rather than using the law to solve single instances of this class of offences. Although I'd strongly disagree with such a law due to the chilling effect it would have on all forms of speech, expression and public commentary I think there's at least a principled argument to be had.

But if you legislate on this principle then you have to grapple with the far reaching implications of such a law - if someone writes some smutty (but fictional) erotic story about me that I find psychologically distressing should they then be thrown in jail? What if they say hurtful things to me that I find psychologically harmful? What if they insult a religion or political candidate, party or ideology that I strongly identify with? We all inflict psychological harm on others from time to time - what should minimum harm threshold be?

Personally, I don't think the criminal law is the answer in either the deepfake or revenge porn cases if the rationale is 'psychological harm'. Although I'm not sure where I stand on the following, I think a civil tort for infliction of psychological harm would be the sanest option if we feel the need to regulate against infliction of psychological harm. It would be analogous to defamation and libel torts, but instead of having to prove economic harm the plaintiff would have to prove some minimum threshold level of psychological harm to become entitled to compensation from the defendant in proportion to the actual provable injury sustained.

My thoughts aside, what is your general theory of harm / principled policy rationale here and, on that basis, what do you think the state's response should be to regulate?


Presumably enforcement of existing laws.


Which laws do you mean and where do they apply?

This article talks a bit about the lack of legal power to fight against deepfakes: https://mcolaw.com/theres-not-much-we-can-legally-do-about-d...


Good information. Then the solution would be to improve harassment legislation rather than limiting the availability of tools. Just as assault is illegal but we don’t require all hammers to be made out of foam.


Indeed.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: