Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

Man the critics here about deadlines is astounding.

I wonder how many deadlines that people miss here, and that's usually just pure software, no materials.


Vendors missing deadlines on contracts is a valid reason for contracts being terminated, renewals being cancelled, and even litigation over breach of contract or even misrepresentation (depending on how angry the customer is).

There's a reason why PepsiCo partners are moving to Daimler now.


The argument that it's just "missing deadlines" which as true as it is, is also a strawman.

Musk hasn't just "missed deadlines". He's outright lied.

For example, in 2016 he claimed Tesla already had self driving capabilities it hasn't shown today, 8 years later.

He lied about bulletproof windows on the CyberTruck. His own demo disproved this.

He lied about the solar roofs. The entire demo was false and staged and the tiles on the roofs were not solar tiles as the demo strongly implied. And testimony showed that he personally knew that it was a lie.

Musk doesn't just miss deadlines. He blatantly lies. And that raises the legitimate concern that a lot of "missed deadlines" weren't just deadlines that were missed, but deadlines that were never feasible and he just lied about.


I do think it's amusing what the other guy says. Forums like this will be full of "Why software estimates are so hard and we shouldn't be forced to stick to deadlines" and the explanation will be "because each React form is like brand new R&D - more akin to Marie Curie's discoveries than a surgeon's work" and then suddenly a brand new kind of vehicle that has never been mass produced before has to hit deadlines or it's sign of obvious incompetence.

That contrast is definitely striking.


I think this is a pretty clear misrepresentation. The entire point of those forum posts is that software engineers are angry at managers promising timelines that aren't connected to reality: they want the unpredictability of the task to be transparent. That is actually entirely consistent, and arguably the exact same frustration, that they have with Musk -- a manager-type promising outrageous deadlines, repeatedly, with apparently zero ability to learn from past misses. The anger is with continuing to promise these outrageous deadlines, and furthermore the frustration of being called out if you are skeptical of them, not with the fact that he misses them. It's a one-to-one, 100%, absolutely identical complaint.


Software estimates also need to be hit, but Sales, Product, and Engineering leadership will fight to prevent the brunt of that from hitting ICs, but at some point if a large contract does churn, plenty of IC engineers will have their head on the chopping board.

I've been on both sides so I get it, and the only solution is to have blunt and honest communication from all sides - Field Facing teams need to not overcommit, and Internal teams actually need to execute and COMMUNICATE why they cannot.

As an employee, we are all working to make the company more money. That's the only goal.


Production of EVs is hard. There's a reason why Ford lost 1.3B in the first quarter of 2024 ($3B in 2023) on EVs and is slowing production.

Overall Tesla is producing more EVs than any American company by far.

Yes, meeting the semi production goal would have been nice, but I'd rather consumer car production be prioritized.


That doesn't absolve them of the fact that they underdelivered on a 8-9 figure deal by 66% over 7 years.

The fact that PepsiCo leaked this to Reuters itself means they are on the warpath right now (eg. probably trying to strong-arm a significant refund and cost reduction, or setting up the paper trail needed to begin litigation over breach of contract).


> doesn't absolve them of the fact that they underdelivered on a 8-9 figure deal by 66% over 7 years

I mean, it almost might. The problem isn't the underdelivery. It's Musk's loss of credibility. When he says it's about battery production, it might be about battery production, or it might be that he randomly changed the design at the last minute.


That's a good point, but leaking this tidbit to Reuters seems like a nuclear option (like Tesla's customer retention program failed and PepsiCo is trying to break out of the contract now).

Like I've had customers pissed off about missed deadlines, but they didn't leak or churn because we tried to keep them happy.


As is usually the case with these things, I think the key to reading them is buried at the end of the article:

> PepsiCo investor Green Century Capital Management has reservations about the company's time table for rolling out the Semis. > > "The fact they're running behind schedule is concerning," said Andrea Ranger, a shareholder advocate at Green Century. The investment firm has followed PepsiCo's use of electric vehicles and is pushing the company to consider its impacts on biodiversity at its annual meeting in May.

Green Century (as its name implies) has a "three-pronged approach combines a fossil fuel free sustainable investing strategy with award-winning shareholder advocacy and support of environmental nonprofits to deliver impact in a way other mutual fund families can't" (quote is from their homepage). My guess is that Green Century are the ones feeling the heat here -- they need to have their fund's emmission figures come out right yesterday, and Pepsi can't make them right unless they get their EV fleet, whether via Tesla or someone else.

If you read between the lines, you'll notice that no one at PepsiCo says anything bad about Tesla per se, only that they're committed to deploying more EVs and a bunch of other green systems. The rest of the article is other supply & logistics companies pointing out that they're having good results with trucks from other manufacturers and/or that they're also unhappy with Tesla's timeline, then someone from GC saying they don't think Tesla can hit their schedule. With the review coming up in May ("the investment firm has followed PepsiCo's use of electric vehicles and is pushing the company to consider its impacts on biodiversity at its annual meeting in May.") this is probably GC trying to convince Pepsi to stop waiting for the bloody Teslas and just get whatever EVs will get their fleet going this year.


But their consumer sales have collapsed, the market has more competitors than ever, and the second hand market is flooded with cheap model 3's.


Isn't that a good thing that the market is flooded with cheap model 3's?

That's the goal isn't it? Cheaper EVs for everyone to replace ICE cars?

I keep hearing about competitors, but I never see any of their EVs, new or used. I see Teslas everywhere.

And cheap model 3's may "hurt" Tesla, but it hurts every other EV maker too. Good for the consumer though.


> I keep hearing about competitors, but I never see any of their EVs, new or used. I see Teslas everywhere.

Around these parts, we see a lot of non-Tesla electrics. Many of them are not obvious at all, until you realize that an SUV has a Clean Pass sticker, and no tailpipes.

But there are also many 3s and Ys. I think, for a time, Tesla was the biggest-selling brand in the US.


Was that accounting for rental deals?


Probably. I just read it, somewhere. Didn't really give it much thought.


There are plenty of other cars, but most of them look a lot like normal cars so maybe you don't notice them.

Statistics for the EU, EV sales in January 2024: https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-i...


You can thank tariffs on China for that. In China, Tesla is beat out by higher quality, cheaper competition.


Yes Chinese EVs are Tesla's only real competitor, I don't dispute that.

But what's the excuse for the other American EV companies?


Ford lost money because they went all in too fast for how late they were to the game.

And frankly it seems to be greed. They have proven hybrid and PHEV tech yet deny the US market the hybrid ranger, 'because US buyers can get the maverick'.

Except... they don't make enough of those either.


If you have been in this space you know that nearly every software project is late, reduced, different and the customer never cancels.


TFA quotes a logistics company employee who placed a deposit 7 years ago and still has not received a single semi.

I’ve been late on deadlines before, but not 7 years late.


The deposit is generally not on the deadline of delivery, otherwise you would have no need for the deposit.

And again, you're not dealing with global mass production of materials, or are you?


But seven years, though... Ouch.


"He just missed a deadline, like you and me".

Tesla promised 100 trucks in 2017.

Seven years late, they're only at one-third of that.

Mind you, no surprises here.

FSD, this year, 2016. FSD, this year, 2017. FSD, this year, 2018. Every year. Here we are, still.


> I wonder how many deadlines that people miss here, and that's usually just pure software

That's not the flex you think it is. Software is pretty unique in delivering products that the companies don't want to stand behind--think of every software license that basically says "if this software doesn't work, it's YOUR FAULT".

In most industries, missing deadlines is generally grounds for your customers to get very cross with you, especially when your customers are businesses and not consumers.


You, know, you're right. We should all over promise and under deliver. It works for Elmo. Until it doesn't...


It's been a couple years since I watched Sesame Street but when did Elmo over promise and underdeliver?


Elmo is Elon musk


> Man the critics here about deadlines is astounding. > I wonder how many deadlines that people miss here, and that's usually just pure software, no materials.

Look... I'm an investor in the Tesla IPO ($4k -> $200k+). I own a Tesla vehicle.

Current Elon has run off the deep end into conspiracy theories and utter nonsense. Buying Twitter because he was butt-hurt over some of his tweets being punished is just asinine. It is also a massive distraction on something utterly trivial.

There was absolutely a massive whisper campaign to say that EVs would never work. Elon did a lot of great things in the beginning. Some of those things include making lofty promises even though delivering on those promises took a lot longer than he thought. The most important thing in the beginning was proving EVs could work to the early adopters, ensuring Tesla could survive long enough to reach volume ramp-up. Volume means parts suppliers start returning your calls and economies of scale improve everything. Doing things differently got them noticed. Making cars fun was a brilliant marketing strategy... does anyone really need the Toy Box stuff Teslas can do? No... but it makes a lot of people (me included) smile. (My kids think Emissions mode is hilarious on our drive to school drop-off and now consider all other cars to be inferior because those cars can't make fart sounds. That's mind share you can't fucking buy even with unlimited money.)

Passing into the volume phase has killed a lot of companies. There are many more opportunities for things to go wrong and mistakes cost you a lot more. Your company also transitions from "we need exposure at any cost" to "we are a brand leader who has set expectations".

During this critical time Elon has failed to change his messaging. He is still in "we need exposure" mode, making outlandish promises and starting too many projects at once. In the end it is all a self-own. There was no need to get into semi-trucks. They have enough trouble scaling up Model Y and even shipping the Cyber Truck. They still haven't really delivered on FSD, despite charging for it and continuously increasing the price. It was 100% unnecessary. Focus on execution, leave the semi-truck idea for a few years down the road. You have enough irons in the fire. Your #1 focus should be a Model Y refresh since it is by far your top seller and is what is generating all that cash making Tesla an ongoing concern.

tl;dr: Tesla is no longer in survival mode but it is in a critical phase of its growth. Elon should have stopped making outlandish promises some time ago and focused on execution. His thin-skin about Twitter, resulting in trying to get a board seat, on a whim turning into buying the company has been a massive distraction that hurts Tesla at a time when it needs strong leadership and the traditional automakers are still fumbling on EVs.


You don't always die instantly when you're shot, especially in quick drive-bys.

A quicker response could mean the difference between someone surviving and someone bleeding out.


That article is extremely biased.

Basically it's accusing Meta of should have knowing that their algorithm and their user generated stickers was spreading this content.

Yes in an ideal world they should catch any campaign of this sort, but global moderation is difficult and they offer no proof that Meta knew about this.

It's disingenuous to say that Meta agitated this event. Those specific users of Meta agitated it and Meta did not catch it.


> Yes in an ideal world they should catch any campaign of this sort, but global moderation is difficult

It really isn't, it just is expensive to do it. They could just hire people to do that. Thats the accusation. Of course they don't catch it if they don't try.

Meta (or TikTok or Twitter or any other social media company/product) can't both algorithmically create specific types of discourse (because higher engagement means more ad views) and deny responsiblity for the side effects of said discourse.


Devices are installed where shootings are frequently reported by civilians.

The shootings are usually gang related, not at the police, so I don't see how your theory of heightened policing causes a loop.

The best way to protect the innocent civilians in the area is to increase surveillance and police presence.

Removing police presence is a disservice to the people who are victims of the gang violence in the area. Those people are the ones who call the police and want them there.

Only if you remove the police in areas do you get a feedback loop (no protection, so you join a gang for protection, which leads to more gang violence)


Doesn't the police frequently bring in people for drug related things, even if the reason they were present was fun violence related?


fun violence related?

gangs make money by selling drugs. they use that money to buy guns.

they then have turf wars over where they can sell drugs.

that leads to shootings which strike innocent civilians.

what do you suggest the police do? allow those gangs to sell the drugs and kill each other and other innocent bystanders?

also this thread is about whether they should monitor shootings...


Gun violence! Apologize for the typo, I spotted it after edit window ended.

I am not proposing to do anything. I just described a possible mechanism for how additional policing can lead to additional incarceration, aside from homicide and attempted murders.


I believe in praise for any company that finds a way to profit and do the right thing.

If they don't profit, then they don't have resources to do those things in addition to not being able to provide a livelihood for their workers.


That's completely false, but I wouldn't put any stock in anything that comes out of Texas Monthly, it's usually just race-bait...

The word "cowboy" originates from the Spanish term "vaquero" which refers to an individual who manages cattle while mounted on horseback.

The Spanish word "vaquero" is derived from "vaca" meaning "cow" which comes from the Latin word "vacca".

The term "cowboy" was first used in print by Jonathan Swift in 1725 and was used in the British Isles from 1820 to 1850 to describe young boys who tended the family or community cows.

Before "cowboy" the English word "cowherd" was used to describe a cattle herder, often referring to a pre-adolescent or early adolescent boy who usually worked on foot. This term is very old in the English language, originating prior to the year 1000.

The term "cowboy" was in use by 1849, although it was not used in all locations. The men who drove cattle for a living in the southwest were usually called cowhands, drovers, or stockmen.

Variations on the word appeared later, such as "cowhand" in about 1852 and "cowpoke" in 1881, originally restricted to individuals who prodded cattle with long poles to load them onto railroad cars for shipping.

To this day, cowhand and ranchhand are mainly used in America. The term cowboy is now generally used in the rodeo and a catch-all term.


Can you please not post in the flamewar style to HN? You did a ton of it in this thread and it's the opposite of what we're trying for here.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting, we'd appreciate it.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40084620.


What's the link between vaquero and cowboy? I get that they both derive from the name of the same animal but is there actually a lineal relationship between them? And why would a Spanish source word cancel out or disprove any later racial associations of the word?

Regarding the other terms that were in use: Cowhand, ranchhand, drovers, stockmen etc etc. - does the use of these terms disprove the racialised aspects of cowboy or the story of how the word became popularised? I would think cowboy could have still been popularised in the slavery context despite not having been coined especially for it.


The original claim also only referred to the usage of the term in Fort Bend County and the surrounding area


Well, the term "buckaroo" is believed to be an anglicized version of "vaquero" showing phonological characteristics compatible with its Spanish origin. The word "buckaroo" first appeared in American English in 1827. It's still used to refer to a certain style of cowboys and horsemanship, particularly in the Great Basin region of the United States, which retains characteristics of the traditional vaquero.

But to your criticism, the transition from "vaquero" to "cowboy" just reflects the influence of Spanish culture on American ranching practices.

Vaqueros and cowboys worked side by side so it seems to be a natural transition between the two and has much more support historically and linguistically than the complete lack of evidence provided by the article.

Words don't appear out of nowhere, they naturally evolve and generally are based on imported words and root words, and it makes sense that Spain, the ones who created this practice and imported these cows and horses were the root of the evolution, beginning from the latin root word "vacca".


I think both origins are probably correct at the same time, as you well know, Texas is a big place, and communications/movements of people were very slow until the 20th Century.

Black cowboy culture is kinda lost from the popular narrative - and cowboy culture was anglicized to an extent that the Mexican origins were also buried - similarly both mexican and black folks experienced similar kinds of racism depending on which part of the state they were in.


So what is the lineage from "buckaroo" to "cowboy"?


In side by side duolingo usage and then somewhat interchangeably .. so no real "from" -> "to" was outlined.

FWiW, though, The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension (1984) predates Space Cowboys (2000) by a good 0x10000 years; this ties in Hollywood, westerns, two chronological points and binary.


I don't think there is a lineage it's believed to be the literal anglicized version of vaquero. It was another branching of the word vaquero.

The term cowboy seems to have occurred naturally as a less literal transition of the word vaquero.

I am not a linguistics expert though, there may be someone else that has more details on the transition.

I will also accept a fortification of the article's attempt at explaining the origin, but I don't see any evidence or attempt at providing any.

Also as I noted in earlier comments the word "cowboy" was being used in print in 1725 by that time and used heavily in the British Isles in the mid 1800s


Certainly the onus to prove their claims lies with the authors of the article but the claim that they are engaging in "race baiting" is also very serious and as yet unsubstantiated.

Many words that were in print in the 18th Century have since been used in different contexts and taken on new associations.


I cannot provide a criticism against their theory of origin as they did not provide any evidence.

Judging from the theme and tones of their articles and their lack of evidence in their claims it is of my opinion they are race-baiting.

That is a subjective view so feel free to interpret their motives as you wish, I will interpret them how I view them based on my evaluations.


That's totally fine if you believe that. I only took issue when I saw you in 3 different parts of the thread saying the authors should be ignored because the publication engages in "race baiting."


I am not ignoring it nor did I say to ignore it. I simply dispute what they said.

If anything I want people to read it and see how trash it is.

Just don't be caught off guard if you use a "fact" of theirs and get embarrassed for being wrong.


“Race baiting” is a fairly incendiary way of putting it. The way I would put it would be to say that there’s a contemporary fixation on race that gets naively projected into other times and places in ways that are anachronistic and miss a lot of nuances. There’s also a tendency to overcorrect for past instances of this.

The thing is, you can motivate almost any oversimplified narrative with mutually exclusive rationales. Maybe you claim that all cowboys were white because you’re racist and you don’t think black people had the heroic qualities necessary for herding cattle. Or you could claim that all cowboys were white because the evil white man didn’t allow blacks to settle the frontier. I actually think this story is more on the side of nuance: it turns out some West Texas cowboys were black, some were white, and people on the frontier didn’t have the same obsession with maintaining racial systems of social hierarchy the way people did in the Deep South. Some of them would still be racist but a black man could handle those differences the same way men in that culture handled many of their differences, with his fists. And when this particular black cowboy did that, it worked out fine.

The odd claim about the etymology of the word “cowboy” does sort of hint and edge towards a completely different totalizing mythology of “actually, all cowboys were black”, but this also smells like bullshit to me. There were almost certainly more black cowboys than you’d assume based on watching old westerns, but they weren’t all black and none of the people in that place and time comfortably fit into any side of any contemporary culture war anyway. They were different people with ideas and motivations of their own, not just symbols in your contemporary culture war.


Will you also accept that a word might have several roots? I mean, it's a simple word. It could have been created several times in different places. Also not an etymology expert but such things must have happened, more than twice.


Sure, if you provide valid historical and linguistic evidence.


> used in the British Isles from 1820 to 1850 to describe young boys who tended the family or community cows

This sounds like exactly the kind of definition that would get appropriated to belittle slaves. See also simply, “boy.”


That's your own prejudice coming out. The word boy may have a negative connotation in some usages, but in this case it's referring to literal boys.

The term was used for family and community farms, not for large ranches / plantations.

The fathers and sons would tend to a small head of cattle used to feed their family and the community. They did not and could not afford to own slaves.

Plus the term was used well after Britain outlawed slavery.


I think the point being made is that it seems plausible that a term used in Britain to refer to literal boys was repurposed later in a different context to be a demeaning way to refer to an adult man working with cattle in the US.


It might be plausible if any evidence was presented, otherwise it's very loose speculation.

Many of the cowhands working side by side vaqueros were literal boys (15-17) and very young men.

In Texas it's very common to call a young man a boy.

Currently it's a baseless accusation that it was a derogatory term, even moreso that it's racial.

It's never been mentioned as such until now, well past the high days of cowboys.


"put any stock in anything that comes out of Texas Monthly, it's usually just race-bait" citation?


[0] “I made it up.”


[flagged]


If you don't have real examples then I will take it that you are just creating a problem where none exists.

Who is "they"? It looks like the origin is coming from a quote by Larry Callies who runs the Black Cowboy Museum. Is everything quoted correct? I don't know but it read as a fun story that may be some mix of truth / story and probably heavily location specific. I am not sure sure that would classify as "race-baiting".

There are articles of slavery and race in TM but I would not classify it as more than 25% maybe?


I just gave an example of them making up an origin of the term "cowboy" being related to slavery with no supporting evidence.


Who is them? It’s a quote from a man who runs a museum? Did he make it up? Is it from passing down of verbal knowledge? Seems like if I was writing an article, going to the museum of black cowboys could have some interesting information. Just because his information is different from your “linguistic” history does not mean it’s race baiting trash.



>I wouldn't put any stock in anything that comes out of Texas Monthly, it's usually just race-bait...

I've been reading TM since the 1970's. Anyone who characterizes their reporting as race-baiting is playing to an agenda. They have always reported on stories, events, personalities, etc that have a connection to Texas with no regard for who they might offend in the process. They roast politicians from the left and right and offer the most unvarnished accounts of events in the state. They are about as middle-ground as you'll find anywhere. I don't always agree with things they write but they do honest reporting.

With that said, I agree with you about the origins of the term "cowboy" and how it has never been associated with nor has it ever been explained historically as a term first applied to black slaves in Texas who found themselves tending cattle. That is as I have been known to say periodically, bullshit of the purest kind.

It is quite true that black men in the southern slave states were denigrated by referring to them as "boys" regardless of their ages but it is not accurate historically for anyone to connect "cow" and "boy" as in the article in such a way that would imply the that the term "cowboy" was first used in that county to describe slaves who tended cattle. Those black slaves who helped tend the cattle learned that trade from Mexican vaqueros (Spanish for "herder of cattle") employed to tend cattle or from the white owners of those cattle.

I found one article that makes a similar claim to the one made in the article - that black cowhands were referred to as "cowboys" and white cowhands were referred to as "cowmen". [0] There is no merit to this claim. The author's byline implies to me, a bit of bias on the subject and cements in my own mind a perception of this claim as bullshit.

[0] https://medium.com/@ronaustin/the-true-origin-of-the-histori...

In fact if you have ever read a biography of someone who actually was a black cowboy, born as a slave, who later rode the cattle drives you would find that the term was applied equally to all who shared that dust regardless of race. [1] This is Nat Love's biography. He was a notable black cowboy whose exploits became the basis for the Deadwood Dick stories in the late 19th century.

One passage describes his own experiences riding the range with other cowboys: -

Love recalled the camaraderie of cowboys with admiration. “A braver, truer set of men never lived than these wild sons of the plains whose home was in the saddle and their couch, mother earth, with the sky for a covering,” he wrote. “They were always ready to share their blanket and their last ration with a less fortunate fellow companion and always assisted each other in the many trying situations that were continually coming up in a cowboy's life.”

[1] https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/21634

To me the thing that makes it so unlikely that "cowboy" was a derogatory term invented locally and used to describe black cowhands is the fact that during and after the Civil War in the heyday of cattle drives and up until today the term "cowboy" was applied to those men who drove the herds to the rails to feed the eastern appetite for steak. By all accounts 25% of the cowboys were black, 30% were hispanic, and 45% were white. If the white men were so racist that they used that term to insult the black men they rode with and shared trail dust with, then why did they accept the term when it was used contemporaneously by others to describe themselves? Why did it historically become okay for a white guy to be called a cowboy? As they say down around where I'm from here in Texas - "sumpum ain't raht" or "that dog won't hunt".

With all that said, I agree with you that the term cowboy was already in use in one form or another to apply to men and boys who worked cattle in Texas and did not carry any racial connotations related to the 'boy' ending. That's bullshit.

In Texas, by the time Anglos settled Ft Bend County and started plantations with their imported slaves providing most of the labor, there was already a culture of cattle working from horseback with roots in the original Spanish settlers in the 17th century and the Spanish term vaquero became anglicized to cowboy as white settlers moved in during the early 19th century.


[flagged]


Texas monthly is fairly left in a Texas context. But I don’t make the connection that any of the articles are race bait.


Yeah and the Patriot Act was about patriotism.


The people who work at them do.


I wonder why they wouldn't give a last name... Half the "news" articles nowadays are "sources familiar with the matter".

Now that Boeing is in the hot seat we want to identify journalist sources?

And I don't think there's a rule that we can only talk about things that have been fully investigated.

It's on ongoing current event and a development in it. It can be talked about if people want to talk about it and can do it civilly.


What I'm realizing now is that I needed to do some educating as part of that comment - I'm surprised that so many people are interpreting those statements from the family as evidence of suicidal feelings, ideation, and planning.


Maybe this one will stick this time. I see people are flagging it heavily.

I vouched it, because it's a worthy discussion to have, and it should stay up so people can see it.

The other two were knocked off the top 20+ pages within a few minutes, you'd only notice it if you got lucky.

@dang, can we have an intervention here? Maybe merge the two other dupes together and allow the discussion to be had? People clearly want to talk about it.


What are you talking about? The big one from earlier isn't flagged? This is a [dupe].

People saw it. People talked about it. And are still.

Direct to the discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39712618


I was talking about page rank, it disappeared from the first 20+ pages of HN.

If you didn't see it within the 20 minutes it was there, you would never find it unless you had that handy direct link of yours.

And this one is currently flagged. It was flagged when I vouched for it (that's how I was able to vouch for it)


https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39712618 was on HN's front page for 4 hours, to judge by our logs.


I don’t understand why anyone would flag it. Yea it’s definitely worth having and worse case scenario it’s proven to be a suicide. But on the off chance it wasn’t it deserves to be looked into and companies shouldn’t be allowed to silence these things


I flagged this one because I'm not sure what kind of meaningful discussion we're supposed to have about it, nor do I currently see one occurring here. It is not even remotely on-topic for this site:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon.

This is not evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. This is rank hearsay, and it doesn't belong here.


> I don’t understand why anyone would flag it.

The mans family said he had PTSD and Anxiety. The gun he killed himself with was his own gun. Considering those factors and occam's razor it feels disrespectful to have this sort of speculative conversation. If this were his wife, kids, mother I would be inclined to say news worthy, but random friend as the only person who heard this story feels a whole lot like someone looking for their own 15 minutes of fame.

Note: I did not flag it and have a comment on one of the other threads...


That's an opinion you can have, but people deserve to find it, read it, and also read others and to offer counterpoints to your POV.


Your first two sentences are compelling facts. Where did you learn about them?


>I don’t understand why anyone would flag it.

I do, I didn't, but I understand why it happens. my HN account is 14 years old, I read comments frequently, comment rarely, upvote occasionally, and flag very very rarely.

I don't downvote because can't, I don't have enough karma yet. so, even if people who can't yet downvote don't know the full effects of flagging it's _literally_ their only option to indicate their belief something doesn't belong on the front page.


You can't downvote submissions regardless of karma.


right, I could've been clearer.

there's an implicit analogue between comments and submissions. i suspect low karma users use the only tools at their disposal for both


I'm in the thinking certain entities have a farm of "users" with 500+ karma that can mass user-flag articles they don't want to be talked about.

But who would do something like that and have the resources to do that? (<-- that applies to TFA and the meta situation)


I wouldn't assume this site to somehow be immune to paid shills and bots.


Flagging is used in a bizarre way on HN that is more akin to censorship. This should only be flagged if it was found that this article was fraudulent and incorrect and he didn’t say that in my opinion. Everything else should be handled by upvotes and downvotes.

I found this info interesting in a Reddit aviation thread. It helps with the tinfoil hat feelings.

>He was not testifying against Boeing for anything to do with their planes. He already did that and has been public about it since 2019. This deposition was for the appeal for his own civil defamation case against Boeing, which he orginially lost. So Boeing was not threatened by his testimony in anyway. Even if they lost the case or settled, it would be a drop in the bucket compared to the harm he has already caused them and other legal issues they are already having...


According to dang: “The purpose of flagging is to indicate that a story does not belong on HN.” [0] It’s valid to think that a topic that is essentially just gossip and speculation does not belong on HN. See also the “Off-Topic” section in the guidelines [1].

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12173836

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


That makes sense, thank you. I can imagine that a more substantive piece would not be flagged.


A sibling comment convinced me, this was probably flagged correctly. Not that the title statement is not important, but that this piece specifically is an especially shallow article and not up to standards.


To the best of my knowledge, his civil case revolves around his claim that Boeing retaliated against him for his whistleblowing. "Company that cut corners on safety found to have retaliated against whistleblower" certainly seems like it would have a pretty significant impact on PR and stock price.


>This should only be flagged if it was found that this article was fraudulent and incorrect and he didn’t say that in my opinion.

Okay then it should be flagged by your reasoning, did you read the article? Because there's no proof in it that he ever said it. A woman who refused to identify herself past a first name claims he said it.


Submissions cannot be downvoted. They can only be upvoted or flagged. Flagging is the tool we have for off-topic submissions.

Comments can be upvoted, downvoted, or flagged. There, voting may be used to express agreement and disagreement, but flagging should only be used for comments that violate the site's guidelines.


Okay I'm not interested in participating in this community anymore. It's an incredibly stupid way to handle anything and reeks of censorship and mob rule by a few that hit the flag button every time a story disturbs their world view.


Rank speculation about newsworthy deaths never go well on HN and historically have caused more pain for family and friends, and contributed to large amounts of misinformation being spread. I'm speaking specifically of Bob Lee, and also Tony Hsieh.

You say "Maybe this one will stick this time" but the main posting about this received over 360 comments, which is a lot for HN. It's not like the whole thing has just been nuked with no chance for productive discussion. But I'm not seeing much productive discussion. I don't mind these being de-ranked for now.

If it turns out to be an eBay stalking scandal type story, then we'll have a lot to talk about.

If it turns out that even being a successful whistleblowing can lead to life experience so awful that you want to kill yourself halfway through the depositions, then maybe we can talk about what can we as a society can provide whistleblowers to help them navigate these incredibly difficult times (financially, emotionally, socially, and spiritually).


While it did receive 360 comments, you cannot find it on any of the pages, going back 20+ pages.

While you can find many much much older articles that are far more dead just a couple pages back.

You wouldn't get the news at all about this tidbit of information if you didn't check HN in the right few minutes.

I for one get a lot of my news from HN, as it's a news aggregator and a lot of other mediums are more censored.

People are clearly interested in talking about it and have opinions about it and find it newsworthy given the TIMING and possible MOTIVE.

YOU even had an OPINION you inserted in, but you don't feel others should be able to see this or put their POV or COUNTERPOINTS in?


Just an FYI, there are some guidelines and a FAQ linked at the bottom of this page. A useful one:

> Please don't use uppercase for emphasis. If you want to emphasize a word or phrase, put *asterisks* around it and it will get italicized.

In other words, don't SHOUT EVERYTHING. Just like when speaking with people in person, shouting is generally a rude thing to do. If you want to emphasize something, just use asterisks around it: *emphasize* becomes emphasize (double up the *'s like ** or use \* if you want to include an asterisk literally).


The reason we're talking about this is because the Emmy award-winning network executive/producer/writer/reporter Anne Emerson made it her biggest story on ABC4 today[0]. The YouTube video has almost a million views, which is a lot more than these HN threads will have. It's the top post on r/interestingasfuck today[1], tied for 2nd most popular this week. It's referenced in the top post of r/wallstreetbets today[2] (bullet point #2).

I inserted nuanced opinion to help steer discussion away from emotional knee-jerk responses with no substance, to something a bit more productive. I haven't seen a lot of that in these threads, so I'm happy they're getting de-ranked. I don't think it's fair to characterize me the way you are.

0: https://abcnews4.com/news/local/if-anything-happens-its-not-...

1: https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/top/?t=day

2: https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/top/?t=day


Probably a dupe because I can't find this submission or the one you linked on any page of HN now.

edit: just found this one on page 6 now.

edit2: both are completely gone now off any page.

edit3: now it's claimed as a [dupe] and the active discussion is dead.

Wow.


Well, enough people found it to get >330 comments, which is a lot.


It's strange neither are on the first 20 pages of HN.

Many older Boeing articles with less points and less comments are on the first 10 pages.

It dropped to page 8 within seconds, I haven't seen that before.


IIRC, the algorithm on HN deliberately punishes submissions which have more comments than upvotes. It uses this as a flamebait-detector.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: