Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

metal spatulas scrape. there's non-stick dishes to worry about.

and I thought of the sunny episode when I read your comment.

"just in case is as good a reason as any to believe in something", whether it's monkey paws, throwing salt over your shoulder, knocking on wood, etc.


At the very least, there’s about a 100% chance of microplastics getting into your food when using these things under heat. You can argue about the risks all day, but I imagine most people would want to avoid this bioaccumulation if possible.


This is my take as well. Can I avoid microplastics? No. Can I make simple household decisions that minimize my intake? Yes. Stainless pots and pans, stainless or wooden tools, stainless silverware, ceramic plates and bowls.

Yes, it takes slightly longer to clean some stuff up, but at least I'm not eating as much plastic/PTFE.


headless browsers won't work by default for cloudflare captchas.

open source stealth plugins don't really work now either.

you have to use real browser fingerprints.


Yucca Mountain.


That’s off the table currently


Because of politics and nothing else.

That's the only issue with nuclear, politics.


But politics are real, and thus are it's consequences.


It sure does have consequences.

Easy to split the atom, not so easy to vote (correctly) apparently.

I guess we'll keep shipping it around and storing it onsite, even though a massive facility is already built to house all of it.

Maybe one day people will realize the establishment you keep voting in doesn't want cheap and unlimited energy.

Until then, let's keep talking in circles about it.


Elaborate.

China and Russia use them quite effectively.

You dock them right on the shore and it powers an entire remote village / small city.

As another user pointed out, they've also been used by the US military for many decades to power carriers and subs without incident.



Military reactors do not have to be economical in any sense. They are not candidates for civilian power.


Added C02 from boats may have an effect. And people may know not to touch it, and you may not, but that doesn't mean other's don't.

The best way not to effect nature is to not interact with it.

Obviously that's not 100% possible nor pleasurable, but for more sensitive systems, it's more necessary.


Electric drones could suffice if you still want people to be able to view it up close.

There's plenty of nature reserves that have tourism limitations for the very reason that high traffic has negative effects.

The best thing for the reefs in Thailand was Covid (ie, the absence of people)


This is a valid concern as Thailand barrier reefs made great recovering during the covid period (hinting that tourism could have had major effects)


> It may be possible that this recent spike in growth indicates that there is a strong recovery, but looking at the data it also seems inarguable the ecosystem has become highly unstable as well over the past 20 years

Could you expand on how the recent explosive growth is unstable and fits with the predictions that the coral is dying?

And GPs post was evidence based, your interpretations were not, they were subjective and a bit handwaving, which is why I would like clarfication on your above view.


Explosive growth is generally speaking not stable. I will defer to the dictionary definition of stable. I'm just using words how they are defined.

From an ecosystem perspective, simple "coral coverage" is not a good enough metric to indicate that the coral reef is healthy. We also need to understand the biodiversity, is one coral taking over because it is better adapted and creating a monoculture? It's not clear. I made a point to not jump to conclusions, simply stating that explosive growth does not indicate a healthy ecosystem.


Thank you for the clarification. Some may interpret "not stable" meaning that it could be detrimental to it's life, not just the textbook velocity definition.

Could you answer the second part of my question:

> "How does explosive growth fit with the predictions that the coral is dying?"

To your statement:

> "We also need to understand the biodiversity, is one coral taking over because it is better adapted and creating a monoculture"

I'd say that we should not assume one way or another. It very may well be, or not. That data is probably out there and I'd be interested to know the answer. If the answer is yes, it's very healthy.

I'd also like to know what species these scientists are breeding. If it's only a select few species, is that healthier than the species that have adapted naturally and are growing fine?


Explosive growth does not happen in a vacuum. Sometimes it's due to a pre-existing boom and bust cycle (eg lynx and hares, rabbits and wolves, etc). Sometimes it's due to the elimination of key species or ecological instability (eg hares in australia with no predators, boom of sea urchins in california, cuttlefish booming due to overfishing), or maybe it's something completely different altogether.

Given that there is no history of a pre-existing boom and bust cycle in the data, I think we can rule that out. So clearly something is happening that wasn't happening before. The question you want answered is one-dimensional and ill-posed in this situation to allow you to better understand the dynamics at work.


The GBR is not that old, and it experienced a major boom during it's creation, obviously.

We really don't have enough data to rule anything out as we weren't tracking it that long relatively to say for sure. We also don't know all the variables.


They tried the "but what about biodiversity" argument back in 2020 when the regrowth started.

It is automatically true that in an ecosystem that experiences a population decline, when the population starts growing again the subtypes that grow fastest will become more common than those which grow slower, and thus there will be a temporary decline in biodiversity. That doesn't indicate a problem of any kind. It's just the natural state of affairs.


Yes I am. That's how it happens and how it should happen.

Coral systems live, spread, and die. That's what they do.

These processes happen over thousands of years.


Then the consequence will be vastly reduced fish populations for thousands of years, which may affect human populations.


Or the fish will continue to live in the reef skeletons and move on to healthier reef systems.


I think that is very, very unlikely.


Based on what expertise?


I think the collective expertise of marine biologists all across the globe. But I also think a high school education about evolution would be sufficient to establish that things really do go extinct, and our natural history is not one of perfectly balanced exchanges compensating every loss.


that's not at all a relevant response to the discussion.

but to play that game, you also learn about adaptation in high school


I'm sure you think you can play that game, but that's precisely the problem.

The fundamental confusion here is the notion that, absent one's own personal expert credentials, we have no access to any expertise or authority of any kind that can be brought to bear on this question (funny that that requirement applies only one way).

The vital role of coral in supporting marine ecosystems is a general and well understood phenomenon. So much so that our ordinary access to expertise through science communication in the media, our summary of this understanding as reflected in high school education, and, if needed, in major reports from NGOs is sufficient to address the question and indeed is central to the purpose of those respective institutions. Those are access to pertinent expertise for this kind of question.

I promise you, that this consensus has not overlooked the possibility of everything being made right by adaptations later on as you seem to be implying, and I promise that no version of explanations of evolutionary adaptation has ever taught that adaptation guarantees, as a cosmic law, compensation for the destruction of ecosystems. The same resources noted above are sufficient to dismiss this as an ordinary biology 101 confusion.


https://scripps.ucsd.edu/news/central-pacific-coral-reef-sho...

I think you need to be more careful about what your unqualified promises are.


What expertise do I need? Lots of coral is dying. It isn't right next to healthy coral. How do you think the fish are going to migrate? And those other coral reefs aren't empty.

As for the effect of coral bleaching on fish, you can google it and I've definitely read about it before, seen ecologists talk about it, etc. The expectation is that it will reduce the number of fish significantly.


You need a lot more expertise than just uneducated guesses before you say something is "very very unlikely."

https://scripps.ucsd.edu/news/central-pacific-coral-reef-sho...


Unfortunately, there is no law of the universe that says that change will only occur at a survivable rate. Thousands of species are already going extinct every year, and we're still burning just as many fossil fuels as what got us into this mess. We don't have thousands of years to wait for animals to adapt, we have mere decades.


Correct, there's no law of the universe that says change will occur a survivable rate. Species have been going extinct long before humans. We should help those species who environments we damage and we should mitigate or nullify the damage in the first place, but we should not play God.


That struck me as mostly reasonable until the 'playing god' bit which upended everything. For one, that term almost never means the same thing to any two people. For another, from the context up to this point you seem to have unrealistic assumptions that this is all part of a broader cosmic give and take that balances itself, or stands over us as an indecipherable mystery.

I think that temptation to stand in awe before a cosmic mystery is a common one and, in many cases a laudable one. In this case, that temptation is getting in the way of some very-knowable facts which are spelling out doom. "Not playing god" in this context seems to amount to standing by as an extinction event unfolds, and I don't think the desire to get lost in existential ditherings is an acceptable reason to stand by and let that happen.


We are playing God now by artificially and dramatically altering Earth’s set point.


How much are we altering it over coming out of the last ice age and the natural effects of volcanos and vents?

That is still unknown and constantly shifting in predictions.

Yes we should minimize our effects on the environment as much as possible, and we are doing a lot better in that goal, but we still need to live.

I wouldn't say living our lives is playing God.


Living life as a highly technologically advanced species that uses systems to dominate the plant for resource extraction to the detriment of countless other species with the awareness to know better is playing god, albeit rather poorly. .


> How much are we altering it over coming out of the last ice age and the natural CO2 effects of volcanos? That is still unknown and constantly shifting in predictions.

No, it's not an unknown. Please stop with this cowardly delusion. Human activity is changing the Earth's climate at unbelievable rates compared to the historical norm. XKCD for scale: https://xkcd.com/1732/


It would be nice if people responded to you instead of downvoting silently. Thank you for the information.

It's also worth noting the Great Barrier Reef is fairly new (6-8k years old). It came to be from the sea rise of the Last Glacial Maximum 20k years ago.


Information is fine, overconfident denialist commentary earns a downvote. When you see a comment to the effect of "The self-proclaimed experts are wrong! I know the truth," you should heavily discount the conclusions it draws.

Just because the mechanism of resurgence is unknown does not mean that all previous science on the topic is invalidated.

It can simultaneously be true that ocean warming is devastating the Great Barrier Reef corals and that the GBR has the ability to rebound on its own. Here's a question the parent comment didn't address: Are we seeing the same species in this resurgence that we saw before mass bleaching, or is biodiversity reduced?


Your last sentence would have been a fine reply to the GP without any meta level commenting.

And GP's main point was that the data from the experts monitoring the reef did not line up with the climate change predictions of the reef.

He didn't say HE knew the truth, he's saying the truth from scientific reports are not matching the predictions.

If anything, he's pointing out the real "experts" data. The opposite of what you are accusing him of.


> Your last sentence would have been a fine reply to the GP without any meta level commenting.

I get that but I stand by all of it though.

> data from the experts monitoring the reef did not line up with the climate change predictions of the reef.

That's normal.

> He didn't say HE knew the truth,

Well, that was a paraphrase of the unwarranted confidence in each of these statements, which I find extremely dubious:

> This fact is already a major problem for the claim that corals are hurt by global warming - if it were true, there should have been declines in this period

It's easy to imagine that warming would not have any effect up until reaching a certain tipping point, so this is overstated as evidence-against.

> This time series is incompatible with the idea of a link between CO2 and coral health.

Basically a restatement of the above. They're not incompatible.

> Whatever caused this set of changes is unlikely to be human driven

"Unlikely" is also an overstatement. These data can cast doubt but aren't strong enough to say that anthropogenic causes are unlikely, given how likely it frankly is due to the scale of changes in the ocean.

> But we can safely say that corals are already heat tolerant.

No, we can't say this. Some corals are heat-tolerant.

> they have existed throughout history in which natural climate change has created vastly greater differences than seen in the last 100 years.

This is... borderline misinformation. It ignores the rate of change, which is just not really a credible way to discuss climate change. Also, specifically, which changes has coral survived? I don't actually know how old coral is or which mass extinctions it has survived which is actually pretty important for making a comparison.

Etc. Not really worth going over every point, you get the idea.


> Just because the mechanism of resurgence is unknown does not mean that all previous science on the topic is invalidated.

This is really the core of the problem. It's why the downvoters are wrong and why it's worth debating the topic here, because it's really a much wider problem than corals or climate.

What government employees have done so far wasn't actually science and they aren't really experts. It was presented to the public as science, it was funded from science budgets, it has the superficial look of science, but it wasn't science. It was merely data collection, followed by wild theorizing based on nothing, followed by political lobbying. It wasn't even extrapolation, as there was no trend to extrapolate!

That isn't how the scientific method is supposed to work. Scientists are supposed to form a hypothesis, gather data that could falsify the hypothesis, publish it, then let others replicate it and so on, until we are certain enough we understand the underlying system to proclaim it a theory. Then you can go to politicians and demand money or changes to laws.

The complete lack of scientific method here is why reef ... people ... I don't want to give them the title of "scientist" ... have managed to not only seriously embarrass themselves but undermine confidence in all ecology and climatology. They had no basis on which to claim that CO2 induced warming was killing corals. The data simply did not fit that hypothesis at any point. Yet by tying their field to climate change they unlocked media interest and a much greater flow of money. They took the easy, tempting path instead of the right path and it is not only completely legitimate but a moral imperative to point out their dishonesty. Their own colleagues and institutional supervisors aren't doing it, so other people have to. If nobody does then this is how science dies, people! When anyone can call themselves a scientist despite not doing science, then eventually the whole concept of science itself will be seen as a discredited joke. That's how dark ages happen. Everyone should be calling out those who claim high confidence in their predictions whilst not having done the work to deserve that confidence.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: