Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

So next time Russia should buy ads for the candidate they want to lose.

1. Buy ads for opposition.

2. Opposition reports invalid figures not accounting for russian ads

3. People accuse opposition of being helped by russia and misreporting funds.

4. Opposition wins, recount stays the same, courts annul it because russia.

Am I missing something here?


You are missing two things.

First, the elections will be rerun. If people think the annulment was unfair, the opposition candidate may get even more votes due to organic publicity.

Second, you can't just buy ads. You must also find someone with wide enough circulation willing to show the ads. And that someone may be liable for the consequences.


No those two things are clear to me.

First, yes they will be re-ran, and it's doubtful the winning candidate will even get to run. Also, where does it end, do we keep re-running it until we get the right candidate? What if it was the candidate you voted for, how would you feel?

Second, yes apparently you can, it happened. If the whole country was able to be swayed by TikTok ads but apparently no politicians noticed then they aren't very good at politicking or governing. If they noticed an issue they should have dealt with TikTok earlier.

So far TikTok hasn't been held liable, only the voters who choose to vote for this candidate.


Right now, TikTok is under EU level investigation, which will take much longer than a few days. If found guilty, it can face a fine up to 6% of worldwide revenues.


Yes, as I said, as of right now they have not been held liable, only the voters have been punished by having their votes revoked.

The voters were apparently too stupid and got tricked by scary russian ads, so we must re-do the elections until they come to their senses and pick the correct candidate.

It's TikTok's fault for letting Russian ads in, so we'll take some of their money and we'll also stay in power. Win-win for the establishment.

It couldn't possibly be that the voters knew exactly what they were voting for... They're too gullible, that's it.


The point is that in the future, TikTok / Google / whatever will have to be more careful with political ads, because they can be bad for business.

Whatever your opinion on the candidates is, it's a fact that many people didn't consider the election results legitimate. In a situation like that, it's impossible to make them legitimate by any administrative action. Courts can make the results legal, but legitimacy is something people decide on their own. If legitimacy is considered important, the only way to regain it is to run new elections. It may take a long time and many attempts, and it may not work at all. But you can't have legitimate elections if the losers don't accept that the elections were fair and they lost.


> it's a fact that many people didn't consider the election results legitimate

it's a fact that more people considered it legitimate, otherwise the candidate in question wouldn't have won the election.

let me ask you this about your "fact" how "many people" didn't consider it legitimate? should be easy to answer since it's a fact.


Legitimacy is not determined by majority vote. It's determined by the people who don't like the results for whatever reason. If the vast majority of them accept that the elections were legitimate, they were legitimate. If a substantial minority of them don't accept the results, the legitimacy is questionable at best, and the country is in a lot of trouble.


> Legitimacy is not determined by majority vote.

> If the vast majority of them accept that the elections were legitimate, they were legitimate.

???

> determined by the people who don't like the results

So I guess I have to ask, which people and how are you determining majority legitimacy if not by vote?


Legitimacy is fundamentally about trust. Trust that the elections were fair, even if you don't like the outcome.

If your candidate won, your opinion on the legitimacy doesn't matter much. If your candidate lost, your opinion matters more. If you think that the elections were legitimate, your opinion doesn't matter much. If you think they were not legitimate, your opinion matters more.

It doesn't really matter if the elections were fair. If the losers don't trust the system, the elections were not legitimate.

A society can handle a small number of people who question its legitimacy. Maybe 5%, maybe 10%, maybe even 20%, depending on the overall level of trust. If too many people don't trust the system, the society doesn't really work anymore. Laws, constitutions, and other institutions are only as strong as people's faith in them.


> One could say that it's the intent which varies between a heart transplant and an Azrec blood sacrifice.

Heart transplants are from consenting donors that have recently diseased, not living victims murdered solely for their organs. Blood sacrifices do not involve taking the heart and saving a live either. So no intent is not the variance there.


That sounds as much "intent" as what I replied to.

Which is why I gave that exact example.


Your guardians consented to the shots because your brain wasn't developed enough to make your decision.

For mosquitoes, nature doesn't require consent, but humans are put on another standard.

Or do you think that because nature does something, humans are free to do it to themselves, like murder?

A wild bear will kill you, so therefore a human can kill another human right?


Yes, the child is unable to give consent in that scenario, so we have an alternative, because the benefit is worth it. (We could wait until people are adults before subjecting them to any vaccinations, but that would cost a lot of lives.)

It's possible an intervention like this one could also save a lot of lives, and therefore might also warrant an exception from individual consent. (Or not; it would depend on the specific expected benefits and risks.)


They're not putting shots into the mosquitos. They're modifying the parasite the mosquito injects that lives in your liver.

When you were 7, did you yearn for modified parasites?


To be honest yes, lots of super hero stories about them. Though to be fair they're called symbiotes when they're helpful.


My (just turned) 8 year old wants a box he can put any two animals in to breed them to make a hybrid.

His example was a cat and a slug. He would absolutely love modified parasites.


It seems to me the people here think it's a good idea because they know they won't be dropped on them, they'll be dropped in other countries.

The countries they live in are malaria free because they eradicated the disease-carrying mosquitos and developed their healthcare system.

Developing the healthcare system of a country helps with more diseases and keeps consent. It also doesn't open you up for a potential biological weapon if some entity decided to misuse it (Russia, CIA, etc.)


Not for that much longer. I believe that our Southern States are starting to see malaria mosquitoes (again -they used to be here, before).

There's a few types of malaria, not all are deadly, but none are fun.

But in the Climate Change Sweepstakes, Malaria has the winning ticket...


Yes, Florida for instance recently had their first documented cases of malaria in decades - immediately following the launch of a GMO mosquito manufacturing and distribution lab.

Not to worry: the scientists at lab promised the two events were totally unrelated.


Do you have a source or specific links to learn more about that lab?


How is it great? It's the equivalent of someone coming up to you with a needle full of something and stabbing you with it (that they already stabbed other people with) without your consent.

I just don't see how injecting people with genetically modified parasites without their consent is "great".


The entire problem is that we can't stop someone (namely Mr. Mosquito) from coming up to us with a needle full of something and stabbing us with it (that they already stabbed other people with) without our consent.

I'd much prefer we got rid of Mr. Mosquito, but if we won't (or can't) we can at least make sure that what's in that jerk's needle stops killing people every day.


That'd be Ms./Mrs. Mosquito.

from https://www.cdc.gov/mosquitoes/about/about-mosquito-bites.ht...

    - Female mosquitoes bite people and animals to get a blood meal.
    - Most female mosquitoes cannot produce eggs without a blood meal.
    - Male mosquitoes do not bite people and animals.


We can get rid of disease-carrying mosquitos, many countries do it.

You can modify them to not reproduce if you're modifying them already for this instance.

If it's a matter of "won't" then we should ask "why not", instead of allowing someone to do this.


> We can get rid of mosquitos, many countries do it.

Curious to know where I can find no mosquitoes, other than Iceland and Antarctica.


Maybe not mosquitos, but the US maintains a screwworm wall that keeps them from eating anyone anything north of Panama.


Thailand and many asian countries have eradicated the troubling mosquitos (not entirely but with great success, especially in urban areas)

The US has also had great success in their eradication and mitigation programs.


They're more likely to give you dengue than malaria, but one thing Thailand has definitely not eradicated is the likelihood of getting bitten by mosquitos with great regularity...


Yes and you still get bit in the US but malaria is a thing of the past.

The point is not to get rid of all mosquitos, just the disease-carrying ones.


Aren't all mosquitos that bite humans potentially the disease-carrying ones? In the US we've just been fairly lucky but it's not as if mosquitos carrying West Nile/Zika/Chikungunya/Eastern Equine Encephalitis aren't infecting Americans


you think there's ... less risk with genetically modifying a species to die out?


Yes, we've been doing it for awhile in the US.

Thailand has also done it with great success.


You hold a very simplistic and naive view.


The person he's replying to has a simplistic view, his view is "injecting parasites into people without their permision bad" a very fine view to have. However we're discussing a situation where these parasites are infact symbiotes, were alternatives are more deaths.

We're also not doing it from a position of "mosquitos couldn't be used to spread human selectable things to kill humans before and now people suddenly can spread genetically modified killer parasites".

The one thing this research does is add the ability to spread immunity to malaria through mosquito population it doesn't change anything else about what could be spread by mosquitos before. People have been using animals to spread disease as a weapon of war since medieval times this is not a new vector that will suddenly be exploited.

This can only be a good thing unless you view the vaccines as a danger worse than the disease (which with such a widespread and deadly disease would be rather unlikely in any objective sense) or to be simplistic you believe in the inalienable right to be a vector to spread diseases to those around you.


You're welcome to contribute anything to the conversation besides blindly throwing out insults with no explanation.


The same thing ordinary mosquitoes do already?


Yeah and some animals kill humans, does that mean it's okay to kill humans too?

Right now you can consent to get a malaria vaccine, no covert parasite needed.

If the counter that it is for poorer populations, I'd still say you may want to ask them if they want to be injected with a genetically modified parasite. If one single person doesn't want to be in the area, you shouldn't do it. Would you support them dropping these in your neighborhood?


I don't live in malaria country, but yes, absolutely. While we are at it, something just like this for Lyme disease and TBE would be the icing on the cake.


Alright, now go ask all of your neighbors if they want a genetically modified parasite injected into them. If everyone is okay with it, then proceed.


I already have to breathe in pollutants released into my neighbourhood by other people without my consent. I have to deal with the aggregated effects of bad economic decisions made by others. Getting infected with a malaria vaccine instead of actual malaria via a mosquito bite without my consent would be the most benign of this type of problem.

Oh, and this already happens with the attenuated polio vaccine. People can catch the vaccine from those who have been immunised, in a similar way to how they could catch the virus. Delivering the vaccine the same way the pathogen spreads also allows people to opt out by following the same techniques they would to avoid the actual disease. You can use mosquito nets, mosquito sprays, etc., to help avoid both malaria and the mosquito-delivered vaccine.


People are already infecting other people without my consent. How do you think I got COVID, the flu, etc.?


Seems like you just described mandatory vaccination. Which is indeed great in case of many vaccines.


Just like a mosquito does?


Have you heard about the old style glass injectors?


Yeah let's not do this. I'd rather we eradicate the mosquitos themselves.

What could go wrong with nonconsensual, covert, forced mass injections.

Today it's used for malaria, tomorrow?

When releasing these mosquitos, will they be getting consent of everyone in the area?


The "today x tomorrow y" argument doesn't work, as the villains of tomorrow don't care about any success of x.

For all x and y.


Developing X allows villians to use X to do Y.


The villains can develop x and y all by themselves.


Do regular mosquitos ask for consent before biting you?


Do you think it's okay to kill a human because other animals kill humans?

Just because nature does something, doesn't mean it's okay to allow humans to do it.


This is not a regular mosquito anymore.

Imagine the following: we found the part of the brain that's making you love everything done by the authority. We developed a genetic vaccine against it and we are deploying it via mosquitos.

You wouldn't say the same thing.


>I'd rather we eradicate the mosquitos themselves.

And you know the extent of this on the whole eco-system?


Do you know the extent of injecting modified parasites on the human population?

And yes, many places have eradicated mosquitos with no shift in the ecosystem.

It's pretty much the one creature that all animals would love to have eradicated or at the very least mitigated.


> And yes, many places have eradicated mosquitos with no shift in the ecosystem.

I read that the tropical rain forests are unlivable by humans because of mosquitos and that limits the amount of deforestation that occurs.

Whether that's really true or worthwhile I'll leave it to others to argue over.


I mean, Indonesia has 280 million people living in a tropical rainforest climate ... that's 80% of the US population, on a a bunch of tropical islands.

Deforestation is an issue, as those 280 million people do need to be fed. Mosquitoes don't really get in the way of deforestation. Insect repellents and pesticides do work. And when an area is deforested and either converted to urban or agricultural land, mosquitoes don't really linger in that area anymore.


Mosquitos are a food source for some reptiles, fish, birds, and other insects and male mosquitos also serve as pollinators, of which many a species are already in danger.


When people talk about mosquito eradication programs, they're talking about subspecies that suck blood and carry the major diseases like malaria. Not all mosquitos.


That line of reasoning neglects the fact that there is very little control in such systems that differentiate between the subspecies.

CRISPR for example has been hailed as surgical tool for slicing DNA, and works well in controlled environments because we set up methodology and environment to guarantee it.

This has lead many outside the related fields to believe that the tool alone has more control than it does. In reality, any changes with these tools must be formally verified through plasmid sequencing. This is Plasmidsaurus business model, and they are quite good at it.

Even afterwards though, outside very specific conditions (which are often involved in keeping it cold and below certain safety thresholds), unstable changes can occur, the effects of which we will never know beforehand. A shift by 1 base (3 bases per codon) may alter an entire sequence, but the molecular machinery would continue running until it is stopped.

It may result in death of the mosquito, and/or provide material (shedding/ingestion) that may be taken in by other unrelated species with unknown consequence.

Who is to say what impacts that might have, and with each additional node (mosquito), the chance of such outcomes increase greatly. To my knowledge, there have been very few studies that cover the topic of genomic stability with regards to CRISPR and its related tools. This is an area with extremely low visibility to potential consequences.

The very last outcome we want is for animals to attain a defiant pupil, along the plot line of Zoo.


Not really true.

Mosquitos are an important part of the ecosystem, they (especially their larva) are important food sources for other creatures.

However, most species of mosquitoes do not bite humans and not all of those are capable of spreading disease. What you are probably referencing is experiments in extermining specific disease carrying species. I don't think those studies have claimed "no shift in the ecosystem."


I mean, the paper's been published. The cat's out of the bag. If a sufficiently motivated villain wants to use this technology for villainy, they can now.


It's not really complex, GP is correct.

High energy prices cause high transportation and manufacturing costs which causes everything else to rise.

But the main cause of inflation is printing of money, especially when you introduce such a large amount in such a short time.

People used to know that, they either pretend it's not true now or they're ignorant.

And yes the "bad faith" parrot line is really annoying and doesn't contribute to the conversation. It's what people say when they don't have a rebuttal.


> It's what people say when they don't have a rebuttal

Only I have a rebuttal, and came with receipts from Eurostat. So what exactly are you trying to argue?

> But the main cause of inflation is printing of money, especially when you introduce such a large amount in such a short time.

The original premise (which is still in bad faith, however much you dislike that part) was that money printing was the main cause. And this is fundamentally and provably wrong (check my comment upthread, Eurostat inflation per sector with the timeline). Inflation was kickstarted by energy inflation which coincides with the Russian invasion.

Did money printing contribute? Of course. Did Russia's invasion of Ukraine and all the issues it brought in energy prices and food prices? Of course. Did the Houthis contribute with their attacks disturbing supply chains? Probably. Did Covid contribute with all the supply chain issues it caused? Of course.

Trying to pin it solely or mostly on one single reason, especially when it is a global phenomenon that many countries suffered from regardless of their exact specifics (e.g. Sweden's monetary policy was not the same as the EUs nor Canada's, yet they all suffered from serious inflation) is arguing in bad faith. It's so trivially provably wrong, it's not even funny entertaining people who are wrong.


tldr: stress


When I was teaching my wife how to play shooters I had to study how I was using my left hand on the keyboard.

I noticed that the WASD placement excluded the middle finger. Once you lift it up and keep it hovering, the pinky hitting A, the ring hitting W and S and the index hitting D, it's very easy to dance them.

I find the middle finger much less responsive than other fingers due to tendon connections (it is much stronger though as another user noted for bowling)

I am left handed but I do use the PC like a "normal" person. She is right handed and she played noticeably better once doing this.

The other major thing was to avoid cross talk between hands. Full aiming related things on the right, full movement related things on the left. (grenades, aimed abilities, etc. on mouse keys)

Related note: in paintball, you feather the trigger with the index and middle finger as they are the fastest. The pinky is also fast but the ring is so slow that doesn't work. Middle and ring is slow for the same reason.

TLDR: ring is your muscle finger, other fingers are more agile.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: