Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

It's not an opinion. It was like that (Twitter), now it's not (X).

He's telling you your experience is outdated.


> It's not an opinion. It was like that (Twitter), now it's not (X).

????????????

> He's telling you your experience is outdated.

No, they said what I said was simply not true.

And my experience is from using the new stuff. There may be technical reasons why it wasn't sticky however in my experience it wasn't as sticky as it should be and I ended up on the crappy feed all the time.


That's false. Hurricanes are not getting bigger or more frequent due to climate change.

They aren't getting bigger or more frequent at all.

NOAA has stated this multiple times and you can read an article addressing it here:

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/beyond-data/can-...

It's well known that hurricanes go through multidecadal swings.

Why this keeps getting repeated when it's obviously false is beyond me.


Great article, scientifically written. I wish it was as confident as you are in your conclusion.

> No, we cannot confidently detect a trend today in observed Atlantic hurricane activity due to man-made (greenhouse gas-driven) climate change. Some human influence may be present

> The importance of this distinction between potential causes of AMV for future hurricane projections is clear: if strong man-made aerosol forcing and volcanic forcing were responsible for most of the “quiet period” of Atlantic major hurricane activity from the 1970s through the early 1990s, then a return to this more “quiet” regime in the coming decades may not occur. But if the “quiet period” of the 1970s through early 1990s (as well as the earlier quiet period of the early 20th Century) was caused mainly by internal climate variability, one would expect to return to relatively “quiet” conditions in the coming decades as the climate swings back and forth between more active and inactive Atlantic hurricane periods. This is an important research question that does not yet have a clear answer.

Meanwhile we continue to see stronger storms.

> Another hurricane metric, the fraction of rapidly intensifying Atlantic hurricanes, was reported to have increased since around 1980 (Bhatia et al. 2019), and they found that this change was highly unusual compared with simulated natural variability from a climate model, while being consistent in sign with the expected change from human-caused forcing. Even so, however, their confidence was limited by uncertainty in how well the single climate model used was representing real-world natural variability in the Atlantic region.

We do know for a fact that the ocean temperatures are rising. Also from your article,

> Global surface temperatures and tropical Atlantic sea surface temperatures have increased since 1900 (by around +1.3 ˚C [+2.3 ˚F] and +1.0 ˚C [+1.8 ˚F], respectively), unlike the reconstructed hurricane counts or U.S. landfalling hurricanes. Finally, a number of studies have found that several Atlantic hurricane metrics, including hurricane maximum intensities, hurricane numbers, major hurricane numbers, and Accumulated Cyclone Energy have all increased since around 1980.

But climate science is about studying a complex system, and finding direct causations is hard.

> However, in a 2019 tropical cyclone-climate change assessment, the majority of authors concluded that the recent hurricane activity increases mentioned above did not qualify as a detectable man-made influences (meaning clearly distinguishable from natural variability).

Another study linked recently from climate.gov (near the bottom) https://www.climate.gov/news-features/blogs/beyond-data/2024...

>[R]ecent studies in attribution science show that climate change is causing an increase in the frequency and/or severity of tropical storms, heavy rainfall, and extreme temperatures.

So at the end of the day, it's fine to say there is no smoking gun, but it is absolutely not 'obviously false'. I think your biases are showing.


Ofc they hint towards it, it's climate.gov. But the actual data shown, shows no increase at all.

You won't find a "smoking gun" because it's not happening.

Your biases are in-fact showing that you don't realize you went from claiming it was true to "well we have no smoking gun".


> The ball is in China’s court now, if they can provide a space where this class consciousness can continue to grow they’ll easily get equal/better

We can hope the CCP's consciousness grows and they shutdown their concentration camps, stop organ harvesting, and start having elections.

The ball is in their court.

We can talk TikTok being allowed after that.


Maybe every other country should ban American imports until we stop bankrolling Israel if that's your position.


Sure. Plenty of people to trade with who don't support terrorists like Hamas.


This is like saying that people who are against civilian casualties in the wars in iraq and Afghanistan are all pro 9/11 and love al-qaeda. How does the boot taste?


What's the implication? That we as a society and/or government have a more just consciousness?

There are certainly are issues in China but are these "popular headline" talking points worse than the suffering we have here? And that's even after assuming they are factual.

We sell prison labor for pennies. We allow individuals to create epidemics and slap them on the wrist. We allow the future of our next generations to be squandered for today's profits. We allow our government to be just as captive to the desires of private parties in a way that's effectually reduced elections to a non-choice.

I don't think anyone with a conscious can say we're any better and that's without taking into account our worst contributions of genocides/wars/instability to the global community.

But in the end w/e, you have your freedom tinted glasses on (it must be nice) and the average american is screwed on our current trajectory.


The difference between prison labor and Uyghur forced labor camps:

In the US those people lost their rights by committing criminal acts and were convicted by a jury of their peers.

In China, the Uyghurs were forced into camps because of their ethnicity.

No different than Nazi Germany. And yes those camps are real.

Btw the prison labor camp talking point is a common 50 cent army tactic. Not sure if you're doing it for free or...


Let me genuinely ask you something because you seem to be all over this thread with a strong different opinion, and I'm not so arrogant as to believe it's impossible that I'm wrong.

Do you really think, in real world terms, that China could not accomplish the types of infiltrations / surveillance it would deem strategically important without tiktok? Considering that they already compromise government systems on a regular basis (which I can provide links for if you're curious)

Do you genuinely think that corruption / lobbying has nothing to do with this ban? What is your primary concern that makes you in favor of this?

Do you look at things like facebook and instagram and either not see the blatant propaganda on there or not see a problem with it?

I'm just wondering if we are disagreeing on the facts or if we have fundamentally incompatable values, I want to understand.


Nice pivot. Don't want to talk about the Uyghur camps eh?

Respond to the prison labor vs concentration camps point, since you brought up prison labor in attempts to compare convicted criminals to an ethnic group being forced into labor.


I don't have a point, that wasn't me talking about it. The Uyghur camps are horrible, horrible things, and legalized slavery in the US is also horrible. I don't think they are equal at all but tbh I just don't know enough about the Uyghur situation to have an educated opinion on it generally or specifically in regards to the tiktok situation.

Although I do think there's some degree of equivalence specifically in regard to a specific ethnic group being forced into labor since you mentioned it, but I don't want to go on a tangent because that's not what I brought up and not what I was talking about.


> content access and moderation to meet local standards

what a nice way to say forcing a backdoor to identify, spy on, and oppress citizens.

but yeah I guess oppression of people is a "high bar" for foreign operators to meet.

backdoors are wrong here and are wrong there.


We can't have people doing things like searching for Tiananman Square or Mao Zedong or talking about how Taiwan and Hong Kong want complete independence from China.

I'm sure a big part of the cost is the additional infrastructure and manpower to implement all of China's censorship, tracking, etc.


Oh stop, it has nothing to do with xenophobia, the CCP has a terrible spying and human rights track record (organ harvesting, concentration camps, child labor, etc.).

Nothing to do with the Chinese people as a whole, and everything to do about their overlords.

Before you do some whataboutism, yes the US spies, even on it's own citizens. That is a separate issue we should make sure doesn't happen.

Two things can be bad and is not an excuse for more spying or letting foreign adversaries broadcast psyops.


What psyops are you talking about? Is it a bunch of US citizens talking about how they don't like the US bankrolling a genocide? Why is it more important to protect tiktok users from a threat no one can actually point to versus preserving a place a lot of people feel like is very important to their day to day lives? Why are these lawmakers prioritizing this over actual threats like school shootings? Honestly the general opinion is that this is extremely obviously not about national security for anybody I've talked to about this and I can't possibly disagree.


Yeah that's a good example.

Framing Gaza as the victims in this whole ordeal.

That's like the 3rd time you dropped Israel in this China topic.

Really trying to shoehorn that in eh?


Do you have an actual counter-argument to this or do you just like pointing out that you don't think Palestinians have a right to live? Just because we disagree doesn't mean that I'm only against human rights violations and war crimes because China said they were bad. Is that how you live your life? Being a good little boy or girl and doing what uncle sam tells you to? If no, why do you assume other people aren't capable of thinking for themselves?


You're terrible at this. Noone is defending the US, your whataboutism is just irrelevant.

I can be against Chinese spying and bad things the US does.

Israel is irrelevant in this thread...

Hopefully they aren't paying you the full 50c for these posts, get better.


You are arguing that my only reason for being against a genocide is either that I've been brainwashed or paid for. Get better at having basic human empathy. Israel is extremely relevant in this thread as pro-Palestinian sentiment is arguably the reason it's being banned.

You proved my point. You claim to be a free thinker and then try to dismiss what I'm saying by claiming I'm paid for without any substance.


US citizens elected representatives to make laws for them. Even more so, this is a bipartisan law.

Tiktok US users of voting age are already accounted for in that process, they don't get extra sway just because they use the app.


> US citizens elected representatives to make laws for them. Even more so, this is a bipartisan law.

A majority of American citizens want affordable healthcare, housing, and education, net neutrality, an arms embargo vs Israel, an end to illegal forever wars, stronger environmental protections, cleaner water, less fossil fuel use and an end to fracking, etc - and there's still bipartisan resistance in our politics and media against all of those.

Congress doesn't actually represent us, it represents capital. Been like that for a long time. https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746


I don't understand this. In my view most people don't want this otherwise they would have implemented a government where the majority is heard, but they didn't. And don't even seem to try.

Either it's a dictatorship or it's listening to the majority. There is nothing democratic about acting against the majority. Never was


> In my view most people don't want this

The polls on all the above are pretty clear. There's no need to rely on your own viewpoint.

> otherwise they would have implemented a government where the majority is heard, but they didn't.

May I suggest reading some Chomsky, or at least watching Manufacturing Consent.

> Either it's a dictatorship or it's listening to the majority.

It's a plutocracy, and this has never been more obvious.

> There is nothing democratic about acting against the majority.

Well, there you go. Do check out those polls.


Nevertheless, the voters made their choice and actively voted for these representatives.

If everyone is so outraged and there's so many TikTok users, they can rally and vote out the people who voted for this.

I for one support this ban fwiw. You'll find out a lot of people do too. So in this instance and quite a few others, my representative has voted in my favor.


Voting between 1 of 2 respectives every few years to represent all issues doesnt seem to represent how citizens feel about individual issues.


What would your system be?


Democratic


So mob rule? Doesn't work.


That’s not how voting works in practice. The people I vote for do not match my views on every single topic. Just enough (weighted) that they are the better choice.

It is possible that every single candidate on the ballot is in agreement on a topic that every single non-candidate voter has the opposite view on. That doesn’t mean nobody gets elected.


Really skipped over expanding on the CCP laws that Google chose not follow, didn't ya?


What's the relevance? Would you have been more satisfied if Google were forced to sell to Jack Ma instead?


Would you have been more satisfied if the US government forced a backdoor to TikTok? That's why Google pulled out of China.

The US is doing the opposite, it's removing TikTok because they probably spy / psyop for the CCP.

One country (China) was trying to force foreign companies to spy / psyop.

One country (US) is making sure a foreign adversary doesn't use it to spy / psyop.


> Would you have been more satisfied if the US government forced a backdoor to TikTok? That's why Google pulled out of China.

What a dope. Imagine being dumb enough to believe google pulled out to protect chinese people's privacy.

Google pulled out because the chinese government wanted to monitor it to make sure google wasn't acting as a state actor pushing propaganda to destabilize nations. Turns out the chinese were right and google was indeed a state actor. Their dirty little fingers were all over the color revolutions.

> One country (China) was trying to force foreign companies to spy / psyop.

But that's google's business model. Do you have two brain cells to rub together? Why would the chinese force google to do what it already was doing in china and everywhere in the world? And still does today?

> One country (US) is making sure a foreign adversary doesn't use it to spy / psyop.

That's what china was doing. Dummy. Literally, china created laws to stop google/facebook/etc from running psyops in china and that's why they chose to leave china.

You must be one of the morons that actually swallowed google's motto "Don't be evil" hook line and sinker.

How stupid do you have to be to think google left china because the chinese government forced them to spy on the chinese. When spying is google's bread and butter.


Yes, because it would at least show a modicum of honesty. Instead it's being done indirectly through putting a company in the hands of state-sanctioned owners. What difference does it make other than theater?


if they did that the US government would then be spying on US citizens by monitoring TikTok data.

how in the world would that show a modicum of honesty?


How so?

Decentralization can be hidden from the user, it's an implementation detail.

There's literally a popular decentralized social network.

It's less about the tech, and more about the execution.

Historically we can look at LimeWire or PopcornTime as an example.

Both decentralized, both popular due to the ease-of-use.


> There's literally a popular decentralized social network.

No there isn't. Not a single one.

There are a few federated social networks, which is a fancy way of saying that they are centralized networks that have (or can have, in principle) more than one "center".

In practice, the overwhelming majority of users of such networks gravitate towards one or a handful of large providers. And many of those providers actually refuse to federate with other providers unless they follow an ever-growing list of politically-charged rules. This is just centralization with extra steps.


bluesky has over 27 million users


Bluesky is federated, not decentralized.


not p2p, but federated: https://forgefed.org (ActivityPub extension)

I believe Gitea has support for it, not sure to what extent.


Forgejo (Gitea fork) has been working for multiple years to add support for this. It will still take a lot of effort to finish, I doubt we will see anything usable this year.

Originally the plan was to PR the federation support to Gitea as well. I'm not sure if this is still the case, considering the rising tensions between the two projects and the fact that Forgejo is now a hard fork.


Forgejo, a Gitea fork that I use, has support for it according to the page you linked. But the FAQ for Forgejo mentions it's on the roadmap so not sure how complete ActivityPub support is in Forgejo either.

https://forgejo.org/faq/#is-there-a-roadmap-for-forgejo

I only use my Forgejo instance for myself currently so I haven't looked at the ActivityPub features of it before.


If you're 5x more productive from AI, you can do 5x less effort if you feel your previous productivity was sufficient for the current pay.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: