Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

the "rednecks" are the ones fixing power lines for you.

your neck may not be red because you get to sit inside while they keep your power on for you.

meanwhile you sit inside writing your hateful, elitist, garbage.

the conspiracy theories related to event you linked are ridiculous.


> your neck may not be red because you get to sit inside while they keep your power on for you.

Before I got into IT I was working in construction for our local telco provider, believe me I have seen shit.


Yeah must be all of his companies have good employees and all his competitors companies have terrible employees.

Nothing to do with the CEO or the company culture. Sort of like Apple, Jobs was probably just annoying his engineers all the time and contributed nothing.

/s


That is exactly what is going on. Boeing doesn't have Gwenn Shotwell. She's the one making SpaceX operate.


and why dont they?


correct. because twitter 1.0 went down constantly.

and staff has been axed for awhile.

ddos happens, having a large staff isn't really relevant.


quality is relevant


elaborate.


Don't be making a mess in the HN echo chamber!


eh twitter 1.0 was 10+ years ago. twitter more recently had been extremely stable.

(source: was on the platform eng team for years)


Well they can do that with paper.

They should have the details of the law printed out in front of them.

Scrolling through on a phone seems very limited.

They can write down notes and they can reply to constituents after they vote.


Yeah! We used to write code on paper too! Software engnieers should only use paper too!

All computer programs should also be printed and reviewed using punch cards!

A literal computer with arguably more features than a modern desktop is too limited!

This is a totally sane take! I know I like writing things twice, or using a format without any ability to search through it.


They are not programming. It's a bill that can be printed off and already is. Just make copies.

They are not editing it, they are reviewing it and making notes.

Laptop use is...fine, but I don't believe for a second they are reviewing the entire bill on their phone.

You don't take tests on your phone, nor should you legislate on your phone.


Starlink is helping Ukraine, connects many remote populations, and provides emergency connectivity during natural disasters.

Tesla brought EVs to the mainstream.

How exactly are they a threat to the free world?



He’s done before, so we can definitely expect something like this.


Never happened, Starlink wasn't turned off anywhere, it was just bad media reporting and social media bias. He refused to turn on Starlink over Crimea on a last minute request from Ukraine. It'd have meant violating US sanctions on providing services to Russian controlled territory.


> never happened, Starlink wasn't turned off anywhere

Based on Musk’s comments, he just kneecapped them in favour of Moscow [1]. Negotiators are currently using Starlink as leverage to Molotov-Ribbentrop Ukraine’s mineral resources [2].

That said, Musk is a liar. So absent a statement from Kyiv absolving him (I honestly haven’t looked for this), the best we can say is we don’t know.

[1] https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1699917639043404146?s=46

[2] https://www.reuters.com/business/us-could-cut-ukraines-acces...



Musk's support of Trump looks increasingly like it will start WW3, with Trump personally threatening action against several current NATO allies.

Musk would be correct that private individuals should not have this much power, should not take decisions about what is and isn't legal — which makes it even more hypocritical for him to have had a fight with Brazil or the UK government or offer support for any political party in Germany, let alone to be wielding a chainsaw on-stage at CPAC, being the public face of DOGE, taking his kid into the Oval Office to have a chat with the press, etc.


keyword: could

but in this reality now they are helping and have been for awhile.

articles like those you have linked have always been appearing, but it only highlights how useful starlink has been.

what other company has helped provide internet to ukraine?


They already did cut it once around the Black Sea coast and prevented an attack on some Russian ships in the region. Something that USAID was investigating Starlink for (and I'm sure this next part is a total coincidence /s) and USAID was one of the first targets of the DOGE purges.


> they already did cut it once

They may have. Musk denies it. Kyiv doesn’t, to my knowledge, seem to have pressed it. Can’t quite say it’s not true. But can definitely say it’s not known.


[flagged]


It's a bit like if someone sells you one jet fighter (Starlink is a paid service).

Then, the manufacturer threatens you to disconnect the plane remotely if you don't agree to their absolutely unrelated wishes.

Would you still trust the plane manufacturer ?


I see you don't want to answer the question posed either.

Noone else has helped Ukraine in this regard.

Starlink donates connectivity all the time to many disasters, has anyone else?

I remember when many people on this site was saying starlink was going to be useless...

You have no right to be critical of how others help, if you aren't helping yourself.


> keyword: could

That’s the difference between a threat and an attack.


No, it's a difference between a hypothetical and reality.

The reality is they are currently helping, have been, and noone else has in that same regard.

-- edit --

Those articles linked below are about "talks" and proposals.

As of now, noone is deployed in Ukraine other than Starlink.

Those companies highlighted don't even have the capacity.

They are just blowing hot air for publicity. They aren't helping at all, they are just using the situation to advertise.

-- edit 2 --

I see, I must have missed that Eurosat was deployed in Ukraine. Albeit in a much more limited form than Starlink.

That's good at least one other company has helped.

However, you still have to credit SpaceX for enabling the ability to send the satellites up there in the first place :)

Sure you could subsidize the competitors, but they'll be sending a huge portion of that to Starlink anyway to launch them.


> reality is they are currently helping and noone else is in the same regard

Eutelsat’s OneWeb and Geo are currently providing services in Ukraine [1][2].

Their leadership, meanwhile, isn’t trying to undermine Kyiv at home and abroad.

> those articles linked below are about "talks" and proposals

Nope. The proposals are for expansion. Eutelsat currently provides service in Ukraine.

(Out of curiosity, where did you read that Starlink has a monopoly on satellite internet in Ukraine? Always helpful to keep track of bad sources.)

> those companies highlighted don't even have the capacity

Sure, Europe fucked up by relying on Musk. Now they have the opportunity to fix it. In the meantime, it’s insanity to divert any resources to Musk that could go to building a competitor, even if heavily subsidised. (U.S. ignoring WTO rules means dumping and state-support rules no longer apply.)

[1] https://www.ft.com/content/f4cc04f0-5ccf-44d8-b5c1-f3eebc9cd...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/technology/space/eutelsat-committed-...


In addition, the "help" from Elon Musk is mostly him agreeing to SELL the service and to have a free trial at the beginning of the war.

The majority of the Starlink terminals are now paid by the countries on public funds (USAID, and the EU countries).

It's not exactly cheap (4'500 USD/month at the beginning of the war, now 1'500 USD/month, for a total of 0.5B/year in revenue for SpaceX).


Any and all dependence on the US is now a liability to the remaining democracies.


> Starlink is helping Ukraine.

The company owned by the dude who wants immediate Ukraine surrender and threatens Ukraine armed forces with disconnecting them?

Oh so helpful.


You might remember the reason a bunch of this started is that Starlink would not help Ukraine unless Ukraine agreed not to hurt Russia too much.


> How exactly are they a threat to the free world?

First by playing 'free market' and getting bilions in incentives from taxpayer money. And then they will be a threat by the time Tesla will lock you into a subscription model and starlink sell your data to the government the first time it will feel threatened.

Socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor.


i say this as a tesla owner, knowing that getting rid of my tesla doesn't necessarily help anything..... and having bought my car despite Elon (certainly not because of him) a handful of years back.

Tesla's value gives Elon his money which also gives him his power. For obvious reasons Elon is VERY associated with Tesla. People are viewing purchasing a Tesla as giving Elon money, which isn't totally wrong but isn't as direct as people as saying either.

In the case of Tesla the threat is Elon himself and how he chooses to use his power. The cars (in my opinion) are not a threat IRT surveillance etc. I think its easy enough to cover the cameras etc. Of course I can be wrong, as I often am.

In the case of Starlink.... being able to use communication and internet access during an emergency to make money, or use it for influence is pretty powerful. particularly as the US govt (which Elon is a part of) pivots towards an alliance with Russia, starlink is a massive liability that Ukraine cannot count on AT ALL. Nothing is stopping Elon from pulling access to starlink at the behest of Putin. America is already pausing anti-russian activity IRT cyber attacks etc under the guise of "good faith during active negotiations". Why wouldn't starlink be next? Why can't starlink be used to suppress access to things. Remember the stories about ISPs injecting ads into content that they didn't own? Why can't starlink just start serving propaganda and misinformation instead of actual content?

These are a threat because they are not being used for the good of humanity and civilization. Elon has deluded himself into thinking that he knows what is best for the world and is using his power/money/influence/technology to assert those ideas and opinions onto the world.

Until we have literally any evidence to the contrary, Elon, Trump, and Putin can all be named interchangeably


> knowing that getting rid of my tesla doesn't necessarily help anything

Getting rid of your Tesla would, at least, eliminate a very sensitive flow of personal data about you to Tesla.


yeah, i suppose that I haven't personally considered it to be "very personal", but in today's world, I am evaluating stuff pretty frequently.


I think that moment-by-moment data about your location and travels, as well as the video streams, are intensely personal.


my phone is with me, netflix has streaming data... meta has my instagram data. the data is all over, and I'm confident that its for sale across the board


Starlink isn't helping helping Ukraine out of the goodness of Elon's heart; he's being paid millions of dollars to provide a service. It's just another business deal for him that he can spin into good publicity as well. His public comments have made it very clear that he doesn't care about the Ukrainian people. Given that he's co-leading an administration that is completely aligning itself with Putin I don't expect that to continue for much longer. As soon as the payments stop, and possibly even sooner, that service will be gone.


[flagged]


You are normally a quality poster. This kind of thing is beneath you.


About every 1 in 100 posts I just can't help myself.


From the circles I was in, everyone jumped from Skype / Mumble / Teamspeak because of D/DoS attacks after having their ip exposed.

It happened all the time because booters were so popular and widely available, costing about $5/mo via paypal.

People were willing to put up with more delay (over p2p) to prevent having to trust each person that joins the TS.

Skype transitioned away from p2p because mobile phones were not very powerful and they needed a lot of supernodes.

First desktop apps were the supernodes, then it turned into centralized servers entirely.


Mumble was never P2P.


would be nicer if there was a cheaper / simpler alternative (offline voice recognition, just timers and clock, possibly weather)

but it's nice to use your voice so you don't contaminate your phone. (preparing chicken and such)

the kitchen is pretty much the only use-case for voice assistants imo.


If all you really need is a timer, you can just use a digital watch.

I don't worry about getting mine dirty because I just wash the watch when I watch my hands.


the timer getting dirty is not the only issue.

you don't always have hands free to fiddle with a watch.

more often than not, both hands are doing something, and setting a timer is... timely.


You don't need both hands free to set a watch's timer.

You can still hold something in the hand that the watch is strapped to.


you need a few fingers free to touch the watch on your wrist.

sometimes you're putting something in the oven, sometimes you're mixing something (holding the bowl and whip)

tons of instances where two hands are in use and voice commands help.


This is nice as long as your data doesn't exceed allowed memory.


Right. But you can push it a bit further than that actually by explicitly unloading portions of the data to disk kinda like closing a file on a desktop app


Incredibly accurate. I hate eating and would eat one of those every morning for 2 years.

You shovel it down and go about your day.

Tastes and feels like you're eating mud, but who cares, only lasts a minute.


hmm, usually a la carte in the US means you can buy individual items vs a meal combo.

- adjective: (of a restaurant meal) having unlimited choices with a separate price for each item

- noun: a menu having individual dishes listed with separate prices

- adverb: by ordering items listed individually on a menu


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: