Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more theultdev's commentslogin

You don't see how gate-keeping who can create software is authoritarian?

The distinction between creating virtual software and physical structures is fairly obvious.

Of course physical engineers that create buildings and roads need to be regulated for safety.

And there are restrictions already for certain software industries, such as healthcare.

Many other forms of software do not have the same hazards so no license should be needed, as it would be prone for abuse.


I agree creating software in general shouldn't be gatekept, but requiring that app developers who process PII have more to show than vibe-coding experience would probably be beneficial.

I don't think anyone is proposing that Flappy Bird or Python scripts on Github should be outlawed. Just like you can still build a robot at home but not a bridge in the town center.


OP didn't qualify the statement "This is exactly why I think software engineering should require a licensing requirement".

No mention of PII or any specifics.

SWE already has regulations. I see no need for a license requirement...

Concerning PII, it's kind of hypocritical for the gov to regulate when the NSA was proven to be collecting data on everyone against their will or knowledge.


I’m happy to discuss specifics, so long as they don’t start with the premise “regulation is authoritarianism” and also are in good faith. Kids don’t have to have an engineering license to build a bridge out of popsicle sticks, I doubt you think that someone saying “building a bridge should require a civil engineering license” should apply to that. I’m not unreasonable. I just think there has been entirely too much demonstrated harm to start with the premise of “anyone can build any software they want at any time, with zero liability”.

These students may be liable for things after the fact, but that is hardly any consolation to the people that may have had their intimate personal data leaked. Even if they are successfully sued by everybody on the site, how much money could they possibly squeeze out of a bunch of college students? I don’t know how you can prevent this without some up front thing, such as a license, rather than making them liable after the fact.


You and many others (reading through the comments) are pretending that an information leak is on the same scale and severity as major safety concerns people may have about the safety of physical structure. It is obviously asinine comparison and why you will always get such push-back and people instinctively know they fundamentally different.

You also haven't thought about how many unintended consequences it will have. It will affect things like open source, hiring and how it will affect smaller niche cultures that rely on pseudo-anonymity or just want to do fun things.

Just off the top of my head:

Am I going to need a license to build a EDuke32 package for AUR?

Am I going to need a license to add a plugin to a piece of software?

Will I need a license to stick a gist on github?

Many people that currently make the laws in industry (just look at the UK online safety act) don't understand/won't care about any of the nuance.

>I just think there has been entirely too much demonstrated harm to start with the premise of “anyone can build any software they want at any time, with zero liability”.

Actually it is the opposite. I and many others could argue that it has improved the world immensely. I can talk to people that share my interests from all around the globe, I have the ability to work internationally and never leave my home. I've just recently I've taught myself how to fix many of my own vehicle problems at home using Youtube and do some basic maintenance around the house.

I can get any niche product delivered to my door in a matter of days. All of these are massively positives that have benefited the world immeasurably.

> These students may be liable for things after the fact, but that is hardly any consolation to the people that may have had their intimate personal data leaked. Even if they are successfully sued by everybody on the site, how much money could they possibly squeeze out of a bunch of college students? I don’t know how you can prevent this without some up front thing, such as a license, rather than making them liable after the fact.

A license will guarantee nothing. You should assume that anything you put online can be leaked. I can control the amount of information I put on most sites by either giving them false information or being pseudo-anonymous / anonymous.

However regulation in my country is going to force photo ID for platforms such as Discord (and many others) under the guise of age checks. This will mean that I have to give a third party my ID which has all my data or not use the service. This will tie my identity on Discord (which is pseudo-anonymous) to my Discord account.

So licensing/regulation actually guarantees more data leaks. Because I can't vet the company that deals with the ID check, not can I easily circumvent information gathering. Sure I will probably be able to defeat most of this with a VPN. But it is more of a PITA.


This was beautifully constructed, and I wish you got a reply.

I appreciate the effort.


Thanks. I think it is very easy for people to focus on a lot of the negatives about the tech over the last 25 years and demand regulation, without recognising the huge amount of innovation that took place because people were allowed to try things.


You aren't thinking through the broader implications.

Will I need a license if Flappy Bird has a online function for uploading high scores to a leader table stored online somewhere?

Will I need a license to put a PR on Github?


I believe they're comparing the tensile strength of the fibers of the tooth.

Though the pop article is light on details.


Found the Texas Monthly reader.


Please don't do this here.


Someone doxxing you and pressuring your employee to fire you because you said something they don't agree with politically is the same as you insulting your coworkers in your eyes?

You don't see any discrepancy between those two scenarios?

And you don't see anything wrong with the former scenario?


Not the op, but no - I don't see anything wrong with the scenario: the employer is making the call, and if they find the speech of the employee doesn't fit with their worldview they have all the rights to fire them.

Practical example: the employer is an LGBTQ+ friendly establishment, the employee is on social media saying that LGBTQ+ people are all deviants and will all burn in hell for their sins. I think the employer should have the freedom to fire the person, right?

Forcing the employer to keep the employee is the equivalent of compelled speech.

Edit: fixed - no joke - pronouns


They didn't say it was the same. You're arguing with what you imagined they said.


They presented a strawman. I'm unravelling it.

I want to know where their values are and if they contradict.

I'm re-presenting the original scenario being discussed and the scenario they introduced.

Comparing the two while also redirecting back to the original moral dilemma.


You're just abstracting it and trying to draw concrete conclusions form abstract cases. Of course it depends on what someone says; to ignore this is asinine.


Unraveling it by creating your own?

Maybe we can have a strawman party after.


[flagged]


Right into the ad hominem, fantastic debate tactic. Very dialectic of you.

The irony of saying "maybe you'll figure out how to have a real debate." after a string of personal attacks is *chef's kiss*.

>yet you complain when you get a meta level comment about your behavior.

I'm not complaining. And you're not giving me a "meta level comment about my behavior". You're just attempting to insult me.


they agreed it was an error, to send him to that particular prison, not out of the country in general.

he is an illegal and his deportation defense in 2019 was he feared for his life from a "rival gang" indicating he was in the MS-13 gang that the feds and judge found him to be part of.

he's not just some "father", as the left leaning news likes to portray. he participated in human trafficking and himself admitted he was a gang member.

it seemed that the left did not care about vetting when gang members were coming into the country.

...but now they're being deported, it seems vetting is crucial (which is being done, but you're not always privy to (or aware of) the information)

and "anonymous snitch" is quite derogatory. you do know how evil MS-13 is right? listen to yourself.

they chop people up without blinking an eye. the fact someone risked their life to "snitch" saved so many people. this isn't playground shit.


He's not illegal, he had protected status.

What precisely changed between the granting of that protected status and his arrest that warranted the change of status?


It's borderline insane to call Newsweek "left leaning".

'His attorneys claimed, and ICE later confirmed, that the only verification came from a form filled out by the Prince George County Police Department, which based his membership on the fact that "he was wearing a Chicago Bulls hat and a hoodie; and that a confidential informant advised that he was an active member of MS-13 with the Westerns clique" – a group based out of Long Island, New York.'

The state has confirmed to the press that it doesn't have any evidence of the claims you're making.

MS-13 is less evil than the Biden and current Trump administrations, who are guilty of genocide. I think you're part of an attempt to distract from that and other crimes, as well as the ongoing turmoil in the financial system.


I don't think you need to trust what "conservatives claim" when you see the test scores and literacy rates.

American public schooling is and has been broken for awhile.


Pretty much any teacher will tell you it's because parents aren't involved and treat school like daycare. When Mom and dad come home and veg out on their phones and TV after work, the kids learn that as well. The ones that succeed have parents that are involved with their schooling which is less and less likely these days. Teachers are quitting left and right because of it.


Of course they would say that.

Blaming the parents and kids is just a scapegoat.

But yes, the kids that succeed are the ones that the parents are involved, because the teachers are useless.

The quality of teachers has gone way down, especially since federal student loans.

Anyone can become a teacher, it's a default path, and it shows.


You're part of the problem and know nothing of the shift that these teachers have seen over the last 30 years.


I've experienced terrible teachers (especially math teachers) and had to teach myself.

I've seen good schools crumble due to terrible policies and teachers.

You're enabling the problem by apologizing for these poor performing teachers.

Literally all of 8th grade was learning how to count to 10 in other languages and some stupid cross-stitching art. In Math!!!

Luckily I learned through programming on my own time, but once you're behind from one shitty math teacher, it's hard to catch up.


[flagged]


A nice excuse to give up. Bye.

Next time, try to bolster your point instead of ad-hominem attacks.


Lol kids are in school 30+ hours a week. When you look at the basic curricula they have to learn it is 99% on the school if it cannot be taught in that time frame, even if the kid is going home to a 4 hour shift in the slave labor camps and only ghouls for parents.


There are many reasonable criticisms of modern public schooling, but the claim that's it's completely broken (and needs burnt to the ground, as many conservatives will claim) is hyperbole and unhelpful to making actual productive change.

And the notion that private schooling (in general) is better is hard to believe. When we looked at private schools for our son, test scores and college admittance were only marginally higher and much of the gap was simple selection bias (private schools are not legally required to take all students, so don't deal with disabled, disadvantaged, or otherwise non-exceptional students). The only time private was substantially better was hyper-elite, hyper-expensive schools (Sidwell Friends, DC vs Paul VI, Fairfax vs the publics in FCPS).


I did checked them. And while it is not perfect, it is not a massive horrible disaster conservatives like to make it. It is just not unfixably broken as it is called. Compared to Europe, it does fine, being above average or around there depending on the test.

Also, America do tend to be country of extremes, so it has some very good public schools and some bad ones. Bad ones being in poor place. And it just so happen that the countries doing better tend to have less poverty and less issues related to it.


There's a huge middle ground between WW3 and allowing Iran to fund and coordinate terrorism.

A strike on them to correct their malicious behavior is far away from a global war.

I didn't see much concern about Ukraine leading to WW3 until Trump allowed peace talks to start.

During the Biden administration peace was not discussed and not even considered an option by many.


>I didn't see much concern about Ukraine leading to WW3 until Trump allowed peace talks to start.

Trump has regularly used WW3 rhetoric about Ukraine:

2022: https://www.foxnews.com/media/trump-warns-world-war-3-accide...

2023: https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-world-war-iowa-waterlo...

2024: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...


Obviously the person who started the peace talks was talking about Ukraine leading to WW3.

I was talking about everyone that said the gist of "if we allow peace talks, Russia wins", mainly here.

It's the sentiment that led to the war persisting for these last few years.

No talks from the Biden admin, no public outrage, just support. And constant funding to continue it.


> I was talking about everyone that said the gist of "if we allow peace talks, Russia wins", mainly here.

I have never seen this... anywhere.


Any type of action has a reaction. Iran can target US military bases all around Middle East. They can damage tankers passing the Persian Gulf causing havoc to worldwide markets.


They already are damaging ships via proxy support of Houthis.

Deterrence sometimes means applying force.

Iran won't be able to do anything if the US actually applies force to them.

And I highly doubt anyone will actually come to their defense, which is an ingredient for WW3.


Houthis had stopped their attacks on ships during the ceasefire.

I think forcing Israel to maintaining their ceasefire is a significantly easier way of unblocking the water passageways.

You know, with a bonus of preventing hundreds of people being killed everyday in Gaza too.


Iran has to be worried about being carpet bombed into nothingness though, so theres only so much they can escalate


B-2s come in after threatening air defense is destroyed.

In this case, they can just roll right in.

Whether they are stealth or not, they are B-2 bombers, their purpose is to bomb.

Whatever can drop the payload. The more the merrier.

All that and the fact that we know that B2 stealth bombers have already been used against Yemen, even during the Biden admin.

Article author doesn't seem to be well-informed of this making that statement.

When it comes to striking fear in the enemy, overkill is practical.


A mic and lights can be cheaper than a department store suit.

Wouldn't really call it an investment.


An investment of time and effort.

Audio gear is surprisingly complicated for non-experts to research, evaluate and monitor. (Like even making sure your app is using it, and didn't reset to your laptop mic when you accidentally unplugged it for a minute.)

And fixing your lighting can require rearranging your entire office if you have a window behind you. Or investing in expensive blinds, etc.


Biased trash article w/ no substance.


Could you point out which parts of the article were incorrect?


> Nothing had changed about the plane’s performance. It’s just that, in the eyes of some international customers, the F-35 can’t fully be trusted anymore because of who is the commander-in-chief. Donald Trump has an affinity for authoritarianism, has exhibited poor treatment of NATO (whose Article 5 obligates collective defense), and, in particular, has threatened to annex Greenland and Canada.

Ignoring the biased language (affinity for authoritarianism.. lol), those reasons are not supported by their sources.

The qualms have been from the trade wars in particular, so leaders are using purchases of the F35 as a negotiating tactic.

Then the article attempts to intertwine software updates as reasoning, which is true, but has nothing to with Trump, as nothing has changed regarding that since previous admins.

I am glad to see people concerned about US military sales overseas though. Very important we keep that up /s


What about the famous “We like to tone them down about 10 percent, which probably makes sense because someday maybe they’re not our allies, right?” and the fact that USA recently withheld software updates for Ukrainian F16s? Is that not enough of a reason to think twice before buying advanced american weapons? Everything trump has been doing since he took the office aligns with russia’s long term goals. He is a traitor to freedom, democracy and his country.


Nor has the US aligned with Russia. Choosing to stop wasting billions of dollars propping up a Ukrainian dictator is hardly aligning with Russia. The US should be auditing the money dumped in Ukraine.


In the eyes of Europe you are most certainly aligned more with russia than with us now. Just a traitor country.


Europe doesn't dictate US policy. As for being aligned with Russia? It's Europe that is abandoning the foundations of Western Civilization, not the US. Further, the US has always been Europe's big brother that insured that no bad guys picked on them. It's time for Europe to grow up and defend itself or at least pay for what the US provides.


Can you tell me what the foundations of western culture civilization are in your opinion? And what is that US provides that Europe needs to start paying for? Europe paid for all military hardware purchased from US and the promise of protection has always been paid for with numerous military bases on European soil that are used by US to project force over the rest of the world. Especially the middle east.


I don't know, it seems pretty clear to me that it's the US that has departed Western civilisation and become just another repressive country with a big military like Russia or China.

To some extent it's fine if you want become a shithole country like those mentioned, but to insist at the same time that you maintain membership of the West and retain its mantle as its leader (or even more laughable, as "leader of the free world", that's far too much. You're not a Western country. Culturally far, far closer to an eastern despotic one, these days.

> US has always been Europe's big brother

History began in 1945 to you?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: