But the hypothetical breaks down once you consider it as a proposal, which makes for a dubious social commentary. Hypothesis testing is far more valuable than pure hypothetical!
Governments are willing to subsidize loans for education but not investing for at least two entirely rational reasons.
First, an educated populous -- especially college educated, and especially in STEM fields -- is in the public interest. We need doctors, lawyers, engineers, and, yes, even well-rounded marketing/sales teams. Could we get all of those things without subsidizing education? Probably not in the quantities needed by American firms.
Second, consider the sheer mass of each college-aged adult reliably pouring six figures into investment vehicles on their 18th birthday. It would take on a force of its own. In small quantities, this works out well for the non-student. In large quantities, the tail wags the dog. And anyways, where are all these lucrative investments that pay out decade after decade and that require nothing but cash money, quality of labor market be damned? I mean, they exist, but surely not in large enough quantities to sustain an entire society of passive income earners...
> ...again, that's why you don't do that with hypotheticals intended to be social commentary.
Good social commentary helps us identify and solve problems.
I don't think this particular commentary puts us in a good mindset for understanding or solving the problems with higher education funding in the united states.
> The article is saying "wow, college is sure overpriced for the amount of money you invest."
The article suggests thinking about the cost of college in terms of payouts to single individuals without any systems-level analysis. On the basis of this perspective, we conclude college is absurdly overpriced.
Perhaps college is overpriced. But not nearly as overpriced as this mindset would have us believe.
That 7% ROI from the S&P 500 isn't powered by pixie dust. It'd powered by mostly degreed people using their degrees.
Social commentary that distracts from the need for an educated populace and instead focuses solely on ROI to individual students is not good social commentary, IMO.
So even if we consider this as pure social commentary, my critique is the same: it identifies a problem, but does so in a way that doesn't emphasize the most important root causes of that problem.
(edit: also, I stand by my previous statement: IMO unreasonable hypotheses are almost always not useful hypotheticals.)
I don't know how to convey to you any more that this is a hypothetical rather than a real thing worth considering as much as you are doing.
Like your entire argument is "the S&P is pushed forward by people who go to college." Not to be rude, but that has no relevance whatsoever to the article. The article could have said to invest in real estate or god forbid bitcoin. The specifics don't matter.
Again not to be rude but I often feel like people on here have this disease that doesn't allow them to generalize from specifics. ;-)
Ok. And it's a bad hypothetical because it emphasizes individual roi instead of systems-level effects when discussing a problem where all the interesting action is in the systems-level effects.
I understand it's a hypothetical. I think it's a distracting hypothetical.
> Not to be rude, but that has no relevance whatsoever to the article
It has every bit of relevance to the article because college is more than just an individual investment opportunity. The benefits of a large college educated population are enjoyed by an entire society.
The real take-away from the article is that we apparently don't tax capital well enough because there's an absurd arbitrage opportunity for lazy people who have 200k in the bank. Or that the benefits of a college educated populace are high enough, and the cost also high enough, that we should be subsidizing college more than we currently are. Not that college is over-priced. The fact that your jump to the latter conclusion instead of the former is exactly the problem with this hypothetical.
> The specifics don't matter.. Again not to be rude but I often feel like people on here have this disease that doesn't allow them to generalize from specifics. ;-)
Look. Either I'm not supposed to generalize from this specific case, or else your entire complaint is really confusing. Generalizing from this specific leads to all the wrong conclusions.
That's assuming that these degrees are actually necessary for these people to do their jobs, which isn't the case the majority of the time in my opinion
Almost none of those companies could exist -- especially at their current scale -- without a huge pool of college-educated engineers/scientists/doctors.
There may be a lot of employees there not using their degrees. But the true value creators at S&P 500 companies are certainly not those people.
I just don't think scientists and engineers necessarily need a college education to be scientists and engineers. Some of them, maybe, but now we're talking about a fraction of a fraction of the output of these institutions. We can do better than just making all college education free.
But air quality degeneration does have a lot of basis on per capita pollution. The per capita argument was good enough to set the tone at Paris, for an agreement between all the nations on this planet. The argument against per capita pollution contribution is just willful ignorance.
Besides, none of you have even bothered to look at the figures. India's current coal consumption is less than 30% of the US, for a population 4-5 times larger. Even if we double our coal consumption, it wouldn't outstrip US at their current levels.
Neither is worth anything if we as a society kill the planet we call home so this isn't about race or worth. It is about us as a planet deciding to keep our planet healthy. Like I said, just because one country does it doesn't make it right for others. The others should be scolding the US not following in their naive ignorant foot steps.
Exactly the opposite. Typed languages without parametric/generic code result in extraordinarily verbose and bug-prone code. You end up constantly casting to/from void* or Object.
That's why all popular typed languages after C provide a facility for writing parametric code.
And without exception, the standard libraries for those languages using single-variable names (S,T) for types. Because when you have 1-3 type variables, and you're writing generic code, "Type" doesn't really communicate anything that "T" doesn't.
> My definition of an object is "an ADT that gets to 'decide', using private runtime state, what to do in response to any/all attempts to interact with it."
Which makes for a very simple test: if something is an object, you should be able to send it a message that makes it change its mind about what messages it accepts after that.
I'm not sure these are equivalent criterion.
In Java and C++, the "dispatch matrix" is defined at compile time, and it is stored at runtime, and the object itself does determine the contents of that matrix. So these languages do clearly meet your first criterion. But also, clearly, not the second.
I guess the objection you might raise is "any/all messages", with "modify your dispatch matrix" being a reasonable message. But there will always be some message that cannot be implemented by the object; we can certainly code up some Goedelian thing inside of a core OO calculus. But for any concrete OO language, something more reasonable than that probable exists.
So then the question is where -- not if -- we draw the line on "any/all messages". And I'm not sure that drawing that line south of Ruby but north of Java makes a lot of sense.
Governments are willing to subsidize loans for education but not investing for at least two entirely rational reasons.
First, an educated populous -- especially college educated, and especially in STEM fields -- is in the public interest. We need doctors, lawyers, engineers, and, yes, even well-rounded marketing/sales teams. Could we get all of those things without subsidizing education? Probably not in the quantities needed by American firms.
Second, consider the sheer mass of each college-aged adult reliably pouring six figures into investment vehicles on their 18th birthday. It would take on a force of its own. In small quantities, this works out well for the non-student. In large quantities, the tail wags the dog. And anyways, where are all these lucrative investments that pay out decade after decade and that require nothing but cash money, quality of labor market be damned? I mean, they exist, but surely not in large enough quantities to sustain an entire society of passive income earners...