Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

Typically, you'd use G when picking a variable name for a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_(mathematics)

The equivalent programmer joke might be something like "int str;" or "string array_length;"

It's kind of funny in the "oh that's a really bad joke" kind of way :)


A bit less concise but still my favorite: An infinite number of mathematicians walk into a bar (which I already think is funny) and the first orders a pint of ale, the second orders a half pint, the third orders a quarter pint. After this goes on for a bit the bartender looks disgusted, slams two pints on the counter and says "You mathematicians really have to get to know your limits!"


"Let ε<0."

Or a similar but more blatant telling of the original joke would be "Let ℵ₀ be a group."


For what real values of i does the sum of ε^i, taken ε=1 to infinity, converge?

Our real analysis lecturer once put this question on the blackboard (with sum as the proper scientific sum notation).

Even though we all knew the answer as trivial it took most of us some time to figure it out in such screwy notation (his point was that our mind is not invariant WRT notation, do not make up monsters when the normal schemas exist)


"Let ε<0." There goes the neighborhood!


Excellent. Thankyou very much.

I teach basic Maths to adults in the UK, so I tend to use these old faves...

"What did the zero say to the eight?"

"Nice belt"

(even my sister has heard that one)

"Why does noone talk to circles?"

"There's no point"

Thankyou and goodnight


Why is six afraid of seven?

Because seven eight nine.

Never grep a yacc by the inode.


In 2005, which had a very bad hurricane season in the Atlantic, (that was the year of Katrina, Rita, and Wilma) they ran out of names for hurricanes and had to use Greek letters. The last hurricane of the season was called Epsilon. Due to my mathematical training I found it very hard to be scared of it.


Due to my training in parser theory, this hurricane is unnamed.


Due to my training in automata theory, this hurricane may trigger state changes without consuming input symbols.


Which is intuitive since only tornados are known to consume input symbols.


The average speed is kinda fast but not insane, especially if most of the ride is on a stretch without many intersections (which you'd expect to be true of a 9 mile ride). I average around 15 mph in a mostly flat area where I stop every few blocks. TBF I'm probably riding a bit more aggressively than a typical Milanese bike commuter.

I wouldn't be at all surprised if the average American bike commuter averages 15 mph. But I'd also expect the average American bike commuter to be much faster than the average Milanese bike commuter because in the USA most bike commuters are dedicated enthusiasts.

18.7 miles per day seems like a really high average, but is entirely believable. I used to do something close to that, and our summers were also hot.


I can add something about Milan that could explain those data. Milan has some water channels going at least halfway into the city. Some bicycle roads follow the channels and they don't have many intersections. Some 10 miles each way are believable. People doing 10+10 miles each day on those roads could be the kind of people that also record their commutes with Strava. However people that have to commute on normal roads shared with cars probably can't be that fast.

I live inside the city and I never mount my bike computer when moving around in there. The normal cyclists that use a bicycle to go shopping probably don't do more than 12 km/h, twice as much as a fast pedestrian. Obviously they don't record their journeys.

So, still skewed data but with an explanation.


> With his academic expertise, what kind of industry jobs would fit his skill sets?

I would imagine his pick among the various industry research labs, if he wanted them.

> He wouldn't fit the typical tech security job.

Nor would he be a good fit as a line cook or as a surgeon...


> I find it incredibly disrespectful and lacking in basic scientific integrity to go into a paper with the assumption that it is a false belief

In this context, the belief is that a spell and magical powder/paste, combined with ritual, can protect from gunfire.

Science isn't free. Also, how on earth does one go about such an experiment humanely and in a financially prudent manner? I'd love to see the reviews on the grant proposal and IRB request to shoot 10 goats in order to test the effectiveness of gri gri...

> "duh...because they are superstitious barbarians"

The authors specifically discuss monotheistic religions and miracles in the introduction.

It's possible the authors believe all religious people are "superstitious barbarians", but that seems like an awfully uncharitable assumption to make about the authors. Even if all the authors are atheists, there's still a huge gap between "person who believes in unfalsifiable religious claims" and "superstitious barbarians".

> Whether the belief is false or not seems to be totally irrelevant in trying to show that the authors' conclusions are valid. Clearly, the members of the village believed that it was true. Because of their belief in the effectiveness of the "treatment" the results were x, y, and z.

The authors come to exactly the same conclusion -- at base, gri gri is effective; its efficacy is explained by its effect on communal behavior rather than magical powers.

> Why should I automatically assume it is invalid? That strikes me as the opposite of scientific enquiry.

Tea pots in space and all that.

> The cultural hubris contained in this paper overshadows the conclusion.

You and the author seem to have come to approximately the same conclusion...


> Science isn't free. Also, how on earth does one go about such an experiment humanely and in a financially prudent manner?

I think it is outside the scope of this paper. But that is part of the thing that struck me as being so bizarre. This isn't a paper about the efficacy of the spell on an individual level. It seems to be a paper that is discussing how a belief in X may have high potential risk to the holder of belief X and, yet, be beneficial to a group of believers in X. That is an interesting but counterintuitive idea. I could see the same model being applied to experimental cancer treatments on a purely conceptual level.

> "duh...because they are superstitious barbarians"

This is admittedly 100% rhetoric on my part and may be "too much". However, there is really the way that authors' view of these villagers came across to me. I'm sure that is partly due to spending time in Africa and the very positive impression of the people that I came away with.

As you said the authors start by mentioning: "unfalsifiable religious claims". So, they seem to start the paper by classifying this a one of those "unfalsifiable religious claims". But, they then immediately classify it as a "false belief" without any evidence for such being the case AND the "false" modifier being irrelevant within the context of the paper.

> The authors come to exactly the same conclusion

Once again, that is what I find so bizarre about the article. I guess it is just me. But, it doesn't sound like a scientist conducting a study; it sounds like one part cultural commentary and one part science. The conclusion doesn't seem to require the cultural inferences about belief systems and their falsifiability or lack thereof. Hence, it struck the wrong chord with me.

I guess I would like to believe that we (i.e. all science lovers) are really looking for a better understanding of the world and that we can do so without pre-conceived judgements of something that is foreign to us.


Bullets cannot be stopped by culture. They're the same everywhere.

The closest explanation I'd allow of how this bullet-proofing is supposed to work is that the smell is so bad the attackers get confused. Really, that would be my first hypothesis if it could be shown that the ingredients matter.


> As you said the authors start by mentioning: "unfalsifiable religious claims". So, they seem to start the paper by classifying this a one of those "unfalsifiable religious claims". But, they then immediately classify it as a "false belief"...

I noticed that, too. The first sentence says that many people hold unfalsifiable beliefs. The second says that many of these unfalsifiable beliefs are false. Which is it?


One of the great things about the practice of magic is that disbelievers never know when magic has been worked upon them.


None-the-less, I don't want my tax money funding studies on the efficacy of gri gri...


Fuck that, I do, and it'd be pretty goddamn cheap. Likely benefits are training / practice, unlikely benefits are deeper anthropological and jungle-life (why those plants?) understanding, and the Pascal's Mugger benefit is "huh magic...?". And then there's the weird side-benefit of encouraging scientific investigation of all things.

Seriously, the biggest expense is going to be shipping the researchers.


Would it be cheaper to send soldiers out with vests or gri-gri? Probably in the west at least, vests are more cost effective. If a soldier is worth a million, one in hundred soldiers is saved by a vest during their career and a vest costs a thousand dollars, it's a ten to one return. But somewhere else, the inputs might be quite different.


> Makes me wonder if there is a more optimal training path for training students.

A CS degree with at least 2 summer internships building real software ticks both boxes.


So does a bootcamp grad with 6 months experience that studies computer science in their free time.


So does a completely self-taught computer scientist.

Why throw your money away on expensive bootcamps when you can just teach yourself everything?!

My first programming gig was before college, and I was completely self-taught (this was before CS was offered in 99% of high schools).

Learning how to program was easy. I was probably a better web developer in middle school than I am now (although JQuery happened at the tail end of my web programming days, so there was a lot less complexity. Or at least a different type of complexity).

I needed the formal structure of a degree program to learn CS. Past Linear Algebra or so, the math became too difficult to learn on my own.

I expect I'm pretty typical in that respect.

If someone tells me they taught themselves how to program, I usually don't think twice about it. Just a "me too, aint it grand!" If someone tells me they taught themselves CS, I'm much more impressed (and therefore, in the case of hiring, incredulous).


What's so different about self-teaching programming that makes it possible when self-teaching CS isn't?


Not sure. My hypotheses:

1. Executable code provides a fast feedback loop that doesn't require instruction. That's hard to find especially for mathematics.

2. You don't really have to understand what you're doing in order to build something. So you can do useful stuff -- which is great for motivation etc. -- and then use that stuff to probe and gain a greater understanding.

3. The psychology is favorable to self-study because there aren't long periods of self-study before the material becomes truly useful.

4. A lot of CS is just more difficult. No one asks why Analysis is more difficult than Calculus -- it seems like a silly question on face. Maybe programming vs CS is similar.

2 and 3 are kind of a function of 1.


WT... wow. You really have CS in 99% of high schools?


Probably a huge over-statement on my part.

4,310 schools had a college credit CS course as of 2015 (cf 14,183 for calculus.) My anecdotal experience is that this number is increasing pretty rapidly. All the high schools in my area have a cs course.


> studies computer science in their free time.

Let's be realistic. Most people won't do this. People can barely teach themselves the bootcamp programming part.


Ok, then most people won't become software engineers without going to school or attending a bootcamp.

It doesn't have to be a thing that everyone does to be possible.


What does "made up" mean?

Someone who launders money for a hitman or human trafficker is enabling the hitman/trafficker's business.

If you help bury a body, you're guilty of something. If you help clean a violent criminal's money, you're guilty of something.

The launderer's guilt is only "made up" in-so-far as murder or human trafficking are "made up".

(Re: Drugs, sure. The correct solution here is to legalize drugs.)


The problem with this sort of poll is that rhetoric, for a huge number of voters, has a much greater impact than facts about issues. Even and especially if they aren't aware this is the case.

This poll reminds me of those ACA polls which concluded overwhelming support by focusing on particular aspects of the Act instead of just coming right out an asking "Obamacare: repeal or keep?" with no preface.

If you truly want to gauge public opinion as it will matter in election years -- which is pretty much the only way it matters -- you shouldn't define net neutrality and you definitely shouldn't ask a sequence of potentially priming questions. Instead, you should just ask: "Do you support Net Neutrality?" and nothing else!

Of course, the results of this survey are still important. But they might not be predictive of how the average person really feels when asked, over a beer, whether we should "keep internet Obamacare" or "let Comcast censor our speech"


"Obamacare: repeal or keep?" with no preface.

Unfortunately, it's not that easy, because if you change Obamacare to the Affordable Care Act, the answer changes.

http://fm.cnbc.com/applications/cnbc.com/resources/editorial...

Search "11a"


It works on hacker news too:

>Facebook should not be allowed to...

"It is Facebook's business! Don't like it? Go start your own!"

>Comcast should not be allowed to...

"Right on! Stick it to those price gouging monopolists!"


I upvote things like this because it's a rare challenge that will leave everyone more enlightened. (sounds sarcastic but isn't) The internet is a utility now, and America doesn't have a variety of providers. But facebook is also pretty ubiquitous, to the point of employers thinking you're weird if you don't have a page.


Customers have ample alternatives to facebook, and avoidance of that entire product category is not debilitating. Neither are true of comcast's internet services.


what is an alternative to facebook (besides abstention, which I agree is viable in this product category)? the network effect is overwhelmingly strong.


Depends on how you define the product category. What teenagers used Facebook for 10 years ago, they use Snapchat for today. But what adults used Facebook for 10 years ago, adults still use Facebook for today.


> But what adults used Facebook for 10 years ago, adults still use Facebook for today.

I am a twenty-something without a Facebook account (used to have one, though). IMO, there isn't much I would want to do with Facebook that I can't do with email or texting.


Snapchat didn't exist 10 years ago, so I don't see your point.


I was answering the parent's question: if by "alternative to Facebook" you mean that you want the thing that made teenagers use Facebook in 2007, then the answer is that Snapchat is a viable Facebook... somehow. (I'm not too clear on how exactly myself, but it seems to work for them.)


Two different companies with two different types of businesses. I support Facebook's right to decide what's on their site, buto condemn any attempt of Comcast to screw with internet traffic. Especially given the lack of competition in the ISP space, I don't believe they should be anything more than dumb pipes.


"Obamacare" - ACA

Facebook - Comcast

Not.. even similar


How about:

Obamacare:ACA

is

Xfinity:Comcast

or (for many)

Spectrum:Time Warner


That's a little misleading. On the Obamacare question, only 11% said they didn't know what that was or that they didn't know enough about it, whereas on the Affordable Care Act question, 30% said that.

If you normalize those results to people who claimed to know about it, there is a small difference, but it comes close to falling within the margin of error (3.4%).

  ~~~  Obamacare   ACA
  ++     15.9      14.2
  +       17       17.1
  =      14.7      15.7
  -      12.5      18.5
  --     39.7      34.2


I don't think that's misleading, I think that's almost exactly the GP's point. People don't just vote on the issues, usually they vote one abstraction higher on the brand and the rhetoric around it.


It'd be intriguing to see what people would think if you made them decide whether they agreed/disagreed with the language of the bill itself (or a summary—by, say, a supreme-court justice—of the implications of the bill), with no mention of the name of the bill.


Annecdotes from my life suggest there is no easier way to make someone angry with you.


The specific point where they get angry is when you do a sweeping reveal that, gasp, "it was [hated bill] after all!", though, right? The question doesn't have to come with a "punchline"; you can just poll people once for their opinions about named bills, and then again separately for their opinions about un-named bill contents, and correlate these, without ever revealing to the second group what bills the quoted language comes from.

Or do you mean to suggest that people get angry immediately when they realize they're being asked for their genuine opinion about something which might turn out to be something they're expected to toe a party line about? If so, that's a very interesting effect, possibly a chilling effect to any potential for genuine informal conversation about these bills.


In my limited experience, people get angry when they feel tricked, so the former of those two suggestions. I agree that you could not tell them and get some good info.


Or, for non-bipartisan legislation, of the party that sponsored it.


Almost no one votes on the issues.

Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government

https://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Realists-Elections-Responsi...

"...show that the familiar ideal of thoughtful citizens steering the ship of state from the voting booth is fundamentally misguided. They demonstrate that voters--even those who are well informed and politically engaged--mostly choose parties and candidates on the basis of social identities and partisan loyalties, not political issues. They also show that voters adjust their policy views and even their perceptions of basic matters of fact to match those loyalties. When parties are roughly evenly matched, elections often turn on irrelevant or misleading considerations such as economic spurts or downturns beyond the incumbents' control; the outcomes are essentially random. Thus, voters do not control the course of public policy, even indirectly."

Those of us doing policy work using educate and persuade strategies need to adapt, up our game.


I think you're normalizing where you shouldn't. The commenter above said, "just coming right out an asking "Obamacare: repeal or keep?" with no preface.".

If that was the question asked, and we take the poll numbers as a proxy, then you end up with:

Obamacare:

29% - keep (very positive + somewhat positive)

46% - repeal (somewhat negative + very negative)

25% - unsure (neutral + don't know enough)

ACA:

22% - keep (very positive + somewhat positive)

37% - repeal (somewhat negative + very negative)

41% - unsure (neutral + don't know enough)

So in other words, even though the original poster was trying to say "cut the crap and just ask people", the difference by just changing Obamacare to ACA is a 7% swing in keep, and a 9% swing in repeal.

It's not like we normalize votes in the real world. We don't say "more people didn't know what that thing was, so we'll just fudge the numbers a bit". If people don't vote, then people don't vote. That's exactly why phrasing matters, and exactly why something like advice "asking Obamacare: repeal or keep" is so worrying.


I think what's misleading here is some people want to repeal the ACA for single-payer and some want to repeal it for a less regulated healthcare market. So having a high repeal value doesn't really tell you what people want instead and likely shouldn't be taken as support for repeal and replace with effectively nothing.


With apologies for the extremely unscientific anecdata, I've seen too many examples of individuals who profess to support the ACA while opposing Obamacare to believe that there isn't something here.


That's exactly the point being made.


A true testament to how much ill informed the American voter is


On top of that I think hardly anyone has a good idea of what net neutrality is or what specific actions would be affected.

Should an ISP be allowed to throttle or block data from a competing service?

Should an ISP be allowed to throttle or block data from a politically controversial site? From a suspected piracy site? From ip addresses involved in DOS attacks?

And then on top of that what is in the actual proposed legislation purporting to be supporting net neutrality? Even if politicians make an honest effort to do right (could happen....) how confident can we be that it will actually be for the better? My main point is we need to be vigilant in the details and not get caught up in a tribal fight over a label.


I'm not certain the details are problematic. If you rephrase the hypotheticals in the context of common carriers the detailed application is clear. So would a telco be allowed to block incoming calls from a competitor? [no] Would an airline refuse to ticket members of politically controversial groups? [no] How about from known hijackers? [yes]

Common carrier doctrine carries a lot of unfortunate historical baggage regarding regulation.

EDIT - added [answers]


> Instead, you should just ask: "Do you support Net Neutrality?" and nothing else!

If you aren't going to define the term, I would think it would be useful to ask the question but also add an extra checkbox, as follows:

1. Do you support Net Neutrality? [yes] [no]

2. Did you feel confident in your knowledge of what "Net Neutrality" means, when answering the above question? [yes] [no]

There's no option to answer #1 with anything other than "yes" or "no"—just like there wouldn't be when trying to decide what candidate to support and seeing it listed as part of their platform.

But it'd be great to know who really believes in a certain stance on an issue, and who's answering based on what even they're aware is uninformed speculation as to what "supporting" a given thing means.


#2 needs to be a knowledge test to be useful.


Which is a great way of determining the level of knowledge people have about a bill. Simply ask them if they support he soundbite position, then start asking them about the details. Particularly telling is if you start asking them to prioritize one thing over the other.

I think a few the obamacare surveys did this, but people were frequently too partisan to change their minds about it, even when presented with the fact that it wasn't going to kill all the babies, or OTOH, create cheap wonderful helthcare for all.


Eh, the classic version of this is a late 1960s experiment that asked people to sign a petition... which happened to be the Declaration of Independence. The overwhelming majority of Americans who started reading it didn't recognize it, and thought it was too radical.


I mean, that shouldn't really be a surprise. It would be a very bad sign if people today thought signing something like the declaration of independence (presumably independence from the USA, in this case) wasn't too radical. In theory, we should have a better relationship with our govt today than the colonists did with England back then. Although the way things are going, I wouldn't rule it out in the not too distant future, sadly.


That's fascinating. Do you have more information on that experiment? A few minutes searching did not turn up anything.


I wrote a term paper about the Students for a Democratic Society (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Students_for_a_Democratic_Soci...) in high school, and this is something I recall from it. I did a little googling and don't see a reference to it. Sorry.


Just found it!

After 36 Years, More Recognize Historic Documents, Survey Finds http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1987/After-36-Years-More-Recogn...

50 years ago, fear ruled Fourth: Reporter's petition measured effect of McCarthy http://host.madison.com/ct/news/local/govt-and-politics/year...

Plain Talk: Would people sign ‘subversive’ petition today? http://host.madison.com/ct/news/opinion/column/dave_zweifel/...


I don't even know if that works. If late-night comedy has taught me anything, it's that if you take an un(der)informed Obama or Trump supporter[1], attribute the [policy|activity|event] to the contra, and ask if they support it, they typically will not.

[1] Not suggesting that the average Obama or Trump supporter is uninformed or underinformed, but there are un(der)informed constituents to both.


Yes.

In the context of this poll, Q3 could've been asked first with no definition provided, and without a "back" button. Then, after the top-level question, you can start honing in on potentially-priming questions aimed at figuring out people's policy preferences and perceptions.


If you lead with the soundbite question, you end up distorting responses to all subsequent questions.

Designing meaningful/informative polls is very hard.


> Instead, you should just ask: "Do you support Net Neutrality?" and nothing else!

That might tell you who will favor a candidate who says "I support Net Neutrality" as a sound bite. It won't tell you if they mean the same thing that you have in mind. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If-by-whiskey .

"If by net neutrality you mean ..."


"Obamacare: repeal or keep?" with no preface

Among the problems with this is that many millions would respond as if the question were "Obama: like or dislike?"

It would boil "approval" down to namecraft: how well did the authors of the initiative accurately or deceptively name it? For the millions who know little to nothing about it, how effective is it from a trigger-word/dog-whistle perspective? What kind of group signaling is implied by the response options? (N.B. "Obamacare" is, of course, using what began as a derogatory term among the opposition to the plan).


I think it depends entirely on your goal. If you are trying to understand the political repercussions of something, then I agree the rhetoric is what is important. However I think that is one of the biggest problems with the current political climate. We are always focusing on the political aftermath of these decisions and not the decisions themselves. If the goal is to actually understand the views of the general population then the more details and the less buzzwords the better.

An "Obamacare: repeal or keep?" poll question might help some politicians stay in office, but why should I care about that? It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people.


> It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people.

Even this is incredibly leading. It presumes that:

* All preexisting conditions are equivalent, despite the fact that some are truly out of the person's control and others are the direct result of one's known actions

* A lack of fairness implies it should be corrected

* That correction should be done by legislation

* That legislation should be at the federal level

* The things that would need to be done as part of insuring people with preexisting conditions aren't relevant

The "belief" of the American people that "it's not fair" is pointless. It can only be resolved with policy, and if that policy is disliked, it's intellectually dishonest to hide behind individual portions of the bill being popular out of context.


I'm not going to quibble over the exact wording I chose for my off the cuff example, but I will concede I could have phrased it better.

>It can only be resolved with policy, and if that policy is disliked, it's intellectually dishonest to hide behind individual portions of the bill being popular out of context.

But that is exactly my point. It isn't the policy that is disliked, it is the name.

Many individual portions of the policy are liked. Those portions have to be paired with less favorable portions in order to create a functional law. Overall that collection of policies is generally liked. However if you throw the "Obamacare" label on it the popularity of the bill decreases compared to the same policies labeled as "The Affordable Care Act". The label is enough to cloud the the public's true feelings on the policy. Knowing the clouded opinions might help someone get elected but it isn't going to help them write a new healthcare bill that represents the will of the people.


> Many individual portions of the policy are liked. Those portions have to be paired with less favorable portions in order to create a functional law.

You're basically acknowledging is that a functional policy has to balance benefits against costs. But what you're proposing is inferring support for a policy (i.e. a particular point in the cost-benefit space) from a poll that just asks about the benefits. That's irrational.


It's not that many individual portions of the policy are liked. It's that individual presumed outcomes are liked.

The problem is that outcomes come bundled together, often in undesirable or unexpected ways.

Almost everyone in principle wants perfect fair outcomes for all. But reality requires tradeoffs (which many political actors don't realize, can't understand, or actively conceal). This complicates the whole business.


> But that is exactly my point. It isn't the policy that is disliked, it is the name.

It is the policy that is disliked. If you ask them how much they like higher premiums, they will tell you. You can't just ask about the positive goals and pretend that means they like it. The policy is the entire package, and it includes both.

> However if you throw the "Obamacare" label on it the popularity of the bill decreases compared to the same policies labeled as "The Affordable Care Act". The label is enough to cloud the the public's true feelings on the policy.

Obamacare is not a derogatory name. It's what it was called all throughout the debate and afterward by the news media and politicians. That some people react less negatively to a name that's less well-known and less widely-used doesn't justify what you're claiming.

> Knowing the clouded opinions might help someone get elected but it isn't going to help them write a new healthcare bill that represents the will of the people.

These aren't clouded opinions. They're reactions to actual liberal policy in action, and they're not positive.

We don't need more affirming of things we already know. What is needed is some retrospection on what happens when tens of thousands of pages of legislation is passed because people like a few bullet points of it when taken out of context.


> It is the policy that is disliked. If you ask them how much they like higher premiums, they will tell you. You can't just ask about the positive goals and pretend that means they like it. The policy is the entire package, and it includes both.

If that was true the reaction would be the same to Obamacare and ACA, which it isn't.


If it were called Obamacare and ACA in the news media and politics equally, then yes.

...but that wasn't the case. You can't just ask them questions about a less popular name and expect less-informed people to know it's the same thing.

Likewise, renaming it something else may even gain you even fewer unfavorables. Wow, they must really like the "Affordable Healthcare and America is the Best Act." Nevermind that it's the same as Obamacare--but that name does sound better and people aren't sure it's the same thing, so it'll poll better.

...or maybe if they're the same thing, it's most reasonable to just call it what it's called most often. That won't give you the answer you want, though.


> If it were called Obamacare and ACA in the news media and politics equally, then yes.

> ...but that wasn't the case. You can't just ask them questions about a less popular name and expect less-informed people to know it's the same thing.

But that was the point. "Less-informed people" aren't disliking something based on its content, which was what you originally claimed, but based on its branding and ads (attack or otherwise).

Yes, people don't want higher premiums, but they do want all the other stuff that comes with it. The results of similar polls will change dramatically once people experience what the effects of a repeal means.

Which is proof that they don't answer to polls about the policies in it, but its brand.


> Which is proof that they don't answer to polls about the policies in it, but its brand.

It's proof that you can confuse people by calling something one thing for a few years and then ask them about something else and telling them good things about it. Virtually any policy can be made more popular this way.


I guess we agree on the concept, but differ in assumption of whether ACA is unpopular due to smear or favorable in polls due to phrasing.

I'm convinced that (while it having many flaws) no one in the poorer 80% of the country would prefer the AHCA over the ACA if informed on both.

Which might seem obvious economically, but it's also clear that polling or voting doesn't turn out that way, which I take to mean that obfuscation through attack ads and aimed media is doing effective work.


"The "belief" of the American people that "it's not fair" is pointless. It can only be resolved with policy, and if that policy is disliked, it's intellectually dishonest to hide behind individual portions of the bill being popular out of context."

I disagree. I think it's intellectually dishonest to claim that a policy is unpopular when the provisions of it actually are popular. And I think it really is telling that so many people claim to dislike the ACA, yet really like the provisions of it.


"Nobody knew healthcare could be this complicated"


The basic problem is that people are not educated, sophisticated -- whatever term we choose, they don't possess enough of it to have any sort of nuanced understanding of an issue. Politicians simply noted that fact and use it to their advantage.

You ask, "Do you think it's fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?", and I'll just ask, "Do you think it's fair that people should be forced to pay for the health care of others?" As long as I can ask the question to get the answer I want, polling is worthless for driving policy.

What we'll end up with is the notion that Americans want free healthcare, free college, the best military, every veteran to have a $60k a year pension, and to save the planet, while they also want to pay no taxes and suffer no inconvenience to their daily lives. Good luck making that into policy.


I agree with you about what should matter most. I'm just not convinced that it does matter most.

> ...but why should I care about that?

"Elections have consequences" and all that.

> It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people.

Maybe. But if identity politics are important enough to take priority over policy opinions, then knowing what policies people prefer doesn't really tell you anything.

Which, I agree, is very unfortunate!


>"Elections have consequences" and all that.

Except they don't. The person who occupies the 3rd Congressional seat in Georgia has no impact on my life. I shouldn't care about it and the media should spend less time focusing on it. What matters are the actual actions of Congress. Asking about "Obamacare" is a question about politics. Asking about "preexisting conditions" is a question about what actions Congress should take.

>But if identity politics are important enough to take priority over policy opinions, then knowing what policies people prefer doesn't really tell you anything.

It isn't identity politics. It is marketing. If a particular policy is popular when it is described but unpopular by name, the only thing it means is that the message about that policy has not been properly communicated.


How's this for actionable polling?

"Do you support Congress passing a law mandating you to pay for other people's preexisting conditions?"


In a direct democracy, maybe this would matter, but we have a republic. Politicians aren't machines that would collate the beliefs of the American people and act accordingly if only they had the information. They are individuals with their own agendas and incentives. So, the only way to get a law passed is to prove that passing it will result in positive outcomes for enough politicians to get a passing vote, which unfortunately tends to boil down to how voters react to the sound bite version of the issue, because not enough voters to matter will actually be thinking about a fully informed (or even marginally informed) version of the issue when it comes to voting day.

So, yeah, while there are some uses for polls to find out what the beliefs of the American people actually are, they are mostly academic, not practical. National elections are popularity contests and tribal pissing contests more than anything. Or maybe I'm just in a cynical mood.


> If you truly want to gauge public opinion as it will matter in election years -- which is pretty much the only way it matters -- you shouldn't define net neutrality and you definitely shouldn't ask a sequence of potentially priming questions. Instead, you should just ask: "Do you support Net Neutrality?" and nothing else!

Well, "would you change your vote" or "would you stay home rather than vote for a candidate who disagrees with you" are even more meaningful questions, if you think they'll answer honestly.


> The problem with this sort of poll is that rhetoric, for a huge number of voters, has a much greater impact than facts about issues. Even and especially if they aren't aware this is the case.

It's not just an issue of rhetoric. It's that policymaking of this sort is an exercise in cost-benefit analysis, and that's very difficult to capture in a poll.

For example, when British Telecom was privatized in the 1980s, there was an economic analysis into how to craft the regulatory structure to balance consumer prices against investment incentives: http://www.econ.cam.ac.uk/people/emeritus/dmgn/files/palgrav... (pages 4-7); http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTFINANCIALSECTOR/Resour.... How do you craft a poll that intelligently asks voters to weigh in on these choices?

Imagine asking people: "should sewage/water rates be cut?" One can imagine a majority of people supporting the position. After all, who doesn't want lower prices? But of course that ignores the enormous cost of cheap water (both in terms of environmental impact, and depriving utilities or revenue needed for capital improvements and maintenance). Indeed, because water rates are generally set by public bodies beholden to voters, our water rates nationwide are far too low: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/15/business/economy/the-pric....


Phrasing matters. "Death taxes" vs "inheritance taxes".

I realized I don't know the origins of "net neutrality". Coined by Prof Tim Wu. It's pretty good marketing; nicely done Prof Wu!

Nor has Frank Luntz been paid to conjure it's evil twin. You can see the counter argument hasn't been weaponized yet.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality#Unnecessary_reg...

Aside: Thiel and Levchin arguing the internet has thrived despite the government is hysterical.


> These are findings from an Ipsos poll conducted May 24-25, 2017 on behalf of Mozilla. For the survey, a sample of roughly 1,008 adults age 18+ from the continental U.S., Alaska and Hawaii was interviewed online in English.

I wonder if the online polling affects the kind of people who are selected for the sample.

Would it make a difference if the people involved own their own computers, have their own broadband, or has to go to the library to access the internet?

What about people who don't use the internet?

Does age group or other socioeconomic factors matter in this? What about people who accesses the internet primarily from a mobile device?


It matters. Anything except a truly random sample of the population (essentially impossible) invalidates the statistical guarantees of polling. Consequently, polling involves a large number of processes to both get the most representative sample possible, then adjusts the results to reflect the biases they are aware of. This is something of an artistic process, and is one reason why pollsters have house effects/biases: they each do things slightly differently.

Having said that, the general feeling is that online polls are as reliable as offline polls nowadays after these adjustments have been made, partly because polling by telephone has a well-established set of biases associated with it too.


> Instead, you should just ask: "Do you support Net Neutrality?" and nothing else!

Even that phrasing would give biased results, since "Net Neutrality" has a positive and virtuous ring to it.

That's probably why the phrase "Net Neutrality" is preferred by its supporters, instead of something like "Government Mandated Internet Usage Restrictions". ;)


> That's probably why the phrase "Net Neutrality" is preferred by its supporters, instead of something like "Government Mandated Internet Usage Restrictions". ;)

Especially since that would be blatantly false. The entire thing revolves around enforcing that your internet usage ISN'T restricted. Which is why the phrasing is both positive AND accurate.


Net Neutrality is "positive AND accurate", sure. But for a useful survey the phrasing should be just accurate, and neither positive or negative, if you don't want bias.

The example of negative phrasing I provided is intentionally over the top, just to illustrate the point.


> Net Neutrality is "positive AND accurate", sure. But for a useful survey the phrasing should be just accurate, and neither positive or negative, if you don't want bias.

Is it bias if the accurate description naturally leans to one direction?

Isn't that like saying I'm biased if I describe Earth as an oblate spheroid instead of "roundish shape up to interpretation"?

I'm firmly opposed to the notion that you need to cater to both sides of an issue and meet in the middle, when the legitimacy of both sides are clearly assymetric.


> Is it bias if the accurate description naturally leans to one direction?

No, but you should be confident about that.

> I'm firmly opposed to the notion that you need to cater to both sides of an issue and meet in the middle, when the legitimacy of both sides are clearly assymetric.

Sure, if you feel it's clear.


>> If you truly want to gauge public opinion

That probably shouldn't be the goal of all polls. Some polls are supposed to predict the outcome of elections, but I'd like to see more polls that get at the root of why people support different things - so I'd like a poll that gauges people's motivation for a certain stance.


If anything the 2016 election has shown, it's that polls are often done to influence instead of to measure.


Rhetoric changes, though. Now that Obamacare is at risk of repeal, people are paying a lot more attention to the details of what it does. That's why GOP members, who thought they would be heroes back home for finally repealing it, are instead getting screamed at.


It's certainly involuntary servitude, and I'm not sure there's a meaningful difference between that and slavery.

Also, the word "except" is our key hint here.


It is involuntary (all punishment is!), but it's not servitude in the same sense that slavery is. If you want to call that "slavery" nonetheless, that's up to you, but you'd be equivocating. There is a difference between slavery as an institution of unjust forced submission and "slavery" as just punishment for crimes committed.


The fundamental issue is that the majority (or the oligarchy) decide what is "wrong".

I seriously doubt (and see no evidence for the idea) that the US is so lawless that we can have almost a quarter of all prisoners in the entire world while only having a fraction of its population.

This speaks strongly to the idea that huge amounts of wrongful imprisonment occurs and (as a logical consequence) these people are slaves against their will without their having done anything worthy of punishment.


> There is a difference between slavery as an institution of unjust forced submission and "slavery" as just punishment for crimes committed.

The difference is solely the standing law. During the nazi regimen (godwin's law, but really) many of the appalling things they did were legal. It was legal to execute, and it was legal to do forced labor.

Slavery was always legal, that was the problem all along! A slave could not physically escape without the fear of unpunished retribution.


Slavery doesn't mean "unjust forced submission", it means "forced submission". There was slavery before 16th C Atlantic triangular slave trading, there's legal and illegal slavery, and maybe there's ethical slavery too (or maybe not).

Redefining the word so that prison slavery doesn't qualify seems obtuse, counterproductive, and doesn't even have the defense of being historical.


The Fast Company story is weird.

It lists Scala and Go as "MOST SOUGHT AFTER" skills.

First, IMO it's weird to consider particular languages as "skills" when talking at a sort of macro level about educational preparedness. "Go schools" and "Scala schools" won't fare much better than "Java schools", and we'll be having this same conversation but replacing Scala with Haskell and Go with Rust (etc. -- you get the idea). (And if you need to go to a finishing school to learn Scala or Go after college, the college has fundamentally failed at its primary task.)

Second, Ctrl-F for Scala in the latest Who's Hiring thread -- some Javascript frameworks are more in demand. And I'd imagine Who's Hiring threads are more representative of the sort of companies hiring FP programmers than a generic jobs board.

The Forbes article is more interesting -- communication, interpersonal skills, teamwork, data analysis (which, if we step outside the zeitgeist and generalize across several generations of in-demand technical skills, we should really just read as "mathematical maturity" and "ability to self-learn").

Those are all the sorts of things you don't simply teach in a single course. They require prolonged situational exposure, of the sort that colleges readily provide. The problem is that students don't avail themselves of challenging course work and extra-curricular activities, and universities don't demand it.


> ...is a stoic enough soul to live on truck drivers' wages for 24 years

Truck drivers make decent money. $40k, usually closer to $50k+ if you're experienced without accidents. Much more importantly, you don't need to be in an office building in a high rent area every morning. If your spouse also works, those salaries buy a REALLY nice house in Nowhere, MS/WI/KS!

"Has the nerve and patience" might be a better way of saying it for truck drivers, at least. The job's downsides are the stress, risk of death/injury, and the crap hours.

> The temptation to start plucking out money from the S&P honeypot -- in the name of having a better life

And "temptation for a better life" isn't the only source of risk.

A lot of low-skill but decent-paying jobs are extremely vulnerable to economic cycles.

"Making the mortgage that was comfortable before the market crash / paying for medical bills that accrued while my insurance lapsed" can make a life time's worth of savings disappear in a matter of months.


Possibly true, but I cannot think of a worse occupation to get into right now, with self-driving trucks on the horizon.

(Also, I have a trucker in the family, and the financials are harder than they look.)


> but I cannot think of a worse occupation to get into right now, with self-driving trucks on the horizon

I don't think this is necessarily true. Fully self-driving trucks are at least a generation out. I wouldn't seek a huge multi-decade capital investment into trucking for sure, but individual drivers aren't terribly exposed to such long-term risks.

And even if SDF gets here sooner than expected, if you work for a company it's kinda whatever. Getting a CDL is a pretty small up-front investment compared to most jobs that both pay well and are in demand. As long as you're not an independent operator (=capital investment), you're not really making a huge investment aside from your time (for which you're well-compensated after the first year or so).

> (Also, I have a trucker in the family, and the financials are harder than they look.)

Certainly for OTR and especially for independent operators. And like I mentioned, injury/accident/economic downturn are huge threats. Trucking with a second family income remains a viable path to a middle class lifestyle, but you're right -- there's a good reason a lot of people choose other paths.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: