> it is not obvious that you can "haul some one before a real court" should they wrong you in some way... the laws of the crypto-systems are the extent of the laws they are operating under
Tell that to Ross Ulbricht. Anonymity is not a guarantee of immunity from the long arm and unforgiving memory of the law. Especially in the United States.
For all the hate that lawyers and judges receive, they are as good as mathematicians at coming up with (or at least recognizing and choosing) concise and simple definitions.
As this point you've already lost everyone who doesn't already ready the same pamphlets you read and agree. Either because they have read those pamphlets and eye-roll, or because they haven't and figure you're a rambling extremist. It's literally equivalent to communists beginning propaganda pieces with "Attention all Comrades!"
That said, I disagree with you, so feel free to keep talking this way.
> ever progressing political system
Literally no one claims politics is monotonically improving. Unless Clinton has been singing Trump's praises recently, you're attacking a straw-man.
> the average voter has an extremely limited understanding of what their government is doing
Appealing to this fact in a thread about cryptocurrency is beyond ironic.
Seriously, even most early adopters don't understand what their crypto currency is doing. And certainly don't have any hope of understanding even a mildly complex contract. Code comprehension is difficult for trained software engineers!.
All of the serious proposals in this thread call for some sort of formal verification, which even most trained software engineers aren't currently capable of using.
And hell, if we learned anything form this, it's that even the ostensible experts don't have an air-tight understanding!
So, what? Instead of teaching every citizen how to read and interpret legislation and regulation, we'll just train them all as professional software engineers with formal methods expertise?!?! And even that's no silver bullet. Contracts can and will grow just as complex as e.g., current tax law. Because the underlying humans won't have changed!
In the long run, you're merely adding complexity. Now I have to understand software and also tax policy. Things get strictly worse.
> This opens the door to manipulation by demagogues and special interests
As opposed to manipulation by "whichever guy finds a bug in the cryptocurrency". You can argue that these are equivalently bad things (I'd disagree), but you'll be hard-pressed to convince most rational folks that "rando dude" is better. Stick to the devils you know and all that.
> limits the Kafkaesque tendencies of collective society.
I'll end my comment in the same way I started it: you're preaching to the choir.
Besides which, what're you going to do when it turns out the majority of people still don't agree with you about how society should be, and still control all the guns and natural resources? Because that's what will happen.
Political power will flow from the arrangement of bits only when the arrangement of bits determines who controls overwhelming military force. And not a moment before.
>As this point you've already lost everyone who doesn't already ready the same pamphlets you read and agree.
Usage of the term "Whig history" is not confined adherents of a particular ideology, and does not require one to have/not-have any particular set of beliefs to use it (other than believing that the history of some institution is not a story of progress)..
In other words, it's not comparable to "comrade".
>Appealing to this fact in a thread about cryptocurrency is beyond ironic.
There's a subtext that you're missing here, which is that the political system doesn't work when voters don't understand the system, which is unlike most domains, which manage complexity effectively.
For example, most people don't understand how microprocessors work. But this is addressed through an effective and spontaneous process of delegating responsibility.
The political process differs in this respect. The delegation process is baked in, as a result of built-in mechanisms that actively resist change. This prevents the kind of readjustment that occurs in other institutions. Meanwhile, those affected by policy are a captive audience, which eliminates a major feedback mechanism that exists in market-based systems.
These two factors result in the system as a whole not evolving toward greater efficacy. On the contrary, it has the potential to evolve toward greater exploitation.
>Political power will flow from the arrangement of bits only when the arrangement of bits determines who controls overwhelming military force. And not a moment before.
> Usage of the term "Whig history" is not confined adherents of a particular ideology, and does not require one to have/not-have any particular set of beliefs to use it
While this is true, outside of some specialized historical critique fields the most common usages of this term are in forums/literature of the libertarian and free market anarchist bent.
In those places its a short hand for the idea that government as currently practiced in the west is clearly bloated and corrupt beyond repair, and the only reason every doesn't agree is that they are bamboozled by some Polly-Anna version of history.
That statement is not clear and needs further backing up to many of us, who do not subscribe to the "Whig History" model but also don't think governments are objectively bad in all instances.
Whether you knew that subtext or not, you used the term in the same way, to argue a similar philosophy, so it's not at all surprising that someone called you on it.
>While this is true, outside of some specialized historical critique fields the most common usages of this term are in forums/literature of the libertarian and free market anarchist bent.
I didn't know that. I haven't seen this term associated with libertarian thought.
I am referring to the state-backed political process, not the general variety of politics one sees in private institutions. The former is qualitatively different from other institutions in our society.
If you cannot implement people's political preferences in your contract language, then your contract language will not be used for anything of substantive governmental or political importance unless you have the guns needed to impose your crypto-dictatorship.
If you can implement people's political preferences in your contract language, and your contract language is used for political or governmental purposes, then people's political preferences will be codified -- as far as possible -- in your contract language.
Which means that in order to participate in governance, people will have to understand both their preferences and also the contract programming language and its underlying runtime. Being an active citizen becomes strictly more difficult. To be very clear about it, people's preferences will not have changed. Consensus will remain a messy, complicated web of compromises that are difficult to reason about and implement via judge, let along codify for a computer.
And all of this won't even achieve your political motives, unless you're planning on building some sort of anti-Whig-ideology static analysis into your contract language, I guess.
(Which, frankly, I hope you do, because that would be kind of funny and cool.)
>If you cannot implement people's political preferences in your contract language, then your contract language will not be used for anything of substantive governmental or political importance unless you have the guns needed to impose your crypto-dictatorship.
Can you elaborate on this? I don't understand the reasoning behind this. Why do smart contracts have to implement political ideologies in order to have a substantive impact on the world? Why can't they have an impact by raising the cost of legal enforcement of over-reaching tax mandates and regulatory restrictions, and of mass-surveillance, and thus shifting the balance of power between the individual and the state, toward the individual?
> Why do smart contracts have to implement political ideologies in order to have a substantive impact on the world?
They don't. The can -- and almost certainly will -- remain primarily a speculative investment vehicle for technophile speculators and occasional currency for black markets. Maybe, even probably, crypto-currencies will turn out to be useful technological tool for some non-speculative businesses as well.
However, you claimed:
>>> Societies have gradually grown more unfair as the political system has strained under their growing complexity... This opens the door to manipulation by demagogues and special interests
I'm simply responding to that claim.
> Why can't they have an impact by raising the cost of legal enforcement of over-reaching tax mandates and regulatory restrictions
Because -- believe it or not -- some people actually approve of some or all of those mandates and regulations.
This idea that regulation and taxation is an objective negative result of a broken process is impressive self-delusion.
Not everyone shares you political preferences or beliefs. Your political beliefs are not objective moral truth.
So. Why in god's name would people who disagree with you agree to use a system that actively undermines their genuine political preferences?
>Because -- believe it or not -- some people actually approve of some or all of those mandates and regulations.
How does people approving of these mandates/regulations (which I dispute, but let's go with it) invalidate my claim?
If the cost of enforcement increases, regardless of the popularity of the law in question, it stands to reason such laws would become less common and/or less effective.
>So. Why in god's name would people who disagree with you agree to use a system that actively undermines their genuine political preferences?
Just to clarify: you're suggesting people will actively avoid adopting cryptocurrency in order to ensure the laws and taxes they support remain effective? If that's your opinion, we should agree to disagree. Time will tell who is right.
Seriously? You realize that's delusional, right? Most people -- even most right wing folks! -- aren't libertarians.
The set of people who think that blockchain is the right way to organize society is astonishingly small, and they're basically all speculators.
People may not agree on which regulations they want (environmental regulations? drug regulations?)
Or what taxes should be spend on (education? infrastructure? protectionist tariffs? military?)
Or how taxes should be leveraged (regressive? progressive? on capital or income earners?).
But for each regulation, each tax, and each thing taxes are spent on, you can find many people -- in many cases, even a majority of people -- who support that regulation or tax.
People like to talk about how they don't like regulation or taxation. And maybe their empty rhetoric has you confused. But in fact, people are self-interested. They will crucify you for doing what they say they want if you stop paying their teachers, or let their roads erode, or take away their social security, or close the military base their best friend's local economy revolves around, or build a sewage treatment plant in their backyard.
Once you get past empty rhetoric and into specific contracts, building consensus is enormously difficult. Much of the complexity in modern laws and taxation policy is essential, not accidental, and arises from millions of varying opinions and priorities and emotional investments.
My neighbor was a hard core anarcho-libertarian. Hated the police state and thought all taxation was theft. But he also called the police to have them write tickets every time we parked in the street even a minute past the time when street cleaning started. People aren't rational; they're self-interested. Everyday comforts always dominate broad ideological "beliefs". "The state is evil, but I hate dirty streets".
If you want to use computer-implemented contracts for law, you'll need to be able to describe this essential complexity. IMO that's going to be difficult or impossible, and laws will change often enough that the overhead will become enormously expensive. Orders of magnitude more expensive.
> Just to clarify: you're suggesting people will actively avoid adopting cryptocurrency in order to ensure the laws and taxes they support remain effective?
Well, vacuously.
I don't think that we'll ever have occasion to even test this claim, because no sovereign state in its right mind would ever adopt a legal or financial system in which a computer bug or Chinese supercomputer could result in constitutional crisis.
You really think the average American would be OK with throwing out the constitution for some computer program they don't understand? Or ditto for any other country? To be blunt, you're completely out of touch.
What I'm actually claiming is that your claim -- that piling complex (and apparently buggy!) software on top of contractual law somehow reduces the complexity of the legal system -- is terribly ignorant of the essential complexity that laws codify. Sorry to blunt. 99.9999% of people really don't give a fuck about what your gpu says.
(The fact that contract languages can't even come close to expressing many of the common private sector agreements and financial transactions that aren't so addled with political concerns should be more than enough evidence that this approach won't skill to the level of nation-states.)
> Time will tell who is right.
Several millennia of time already has.
We've had contracts and ledgers for ages. When a majority of people find themselves in a situation they don't like, they rarely shrug it off and say "oh well, that's the contract". They go to ballot boxes or, more commonly in the arc of history, start shooting people.
What makes you think people would resign themselves to subjugation to objectionable instructions from your GPUs when they're clearly unwilling to subjugate themselves to objectionable instructions from other people's graphite and pulp?
If anything, crpytocurrencies have negative rhetorical appeal for the vast majority of the population. And when the largest examples are hacky javascript interfaces to speculators' bank accounts, I can't really blame them.
Comments of this nature aren't constructive. It's better to restrain the urge to tell your correspondent that their belief is delusional, and simply explain why you disagree with it.
>Most people -- even most right wing folks! -- aren't libertarians.
I think most people don't think deeply about the policies they support, and the implications of those policies. Most people don't think much about the nature of the law, for example. [1]
The complexity of the political system results in people supporting policies that if they had the time to closely examine, they would not. Our political system is geared toward decision making based on shallow assessments and emotional gut-reactions, because it does not give the average person the ability to meaningful analyze the issues that they base their vote on.
But in any case, I already said that for the sake our debate, let's accept your claim as correct. There's no need to try to expand this debate more than is necessary.
>I don't think that we'll ever have occasion to even test this claim, because no sovereign state in its right mind would ever adopt a legal or financial system in which a computer bug or Chinese supercomputer could result in constitutional crisis.
I have no idea where this suggestion that a sovereign state would replace its Constitution with a smart contract came from. Can you please go back to my comment and re-read what I suggested would happen?
How are bitcoin or ethereum not highly resistant to change.
Explain to me how you would go about changing either of those protocols?
And yes there are lots of altcoins but ethereum very quickly is going to replace a good chunk of how things are transacted. And a non-profit without some kind of policy for baked in leadership change sounds a lot like a dictatorship to me.
By design, they enshrine the rights of the individual participant to freely interact in a free market, by preventing the majority from creating any rules to limit access to the platform. So they don't have the same need to adapt as an interventionist government, that imposes itself on the economy through majority dictate, does.
In the case of Ethereum, the Turing Completeness also makes it so that each contract is like a government in and of itself, which any party is free to design to meet their own preferences.
I don't believe such hard forks will be practical when the ecosystem is larger and more diverse. The DAO happened in a unique point in Ethereum's history, when the community was very small (and thus cohesive) and activity on the network was very little.
You don't perform "addition, multiplication, addition, and subtraction of rational expressions" in your every-day life?
You don't "Identify key features of and sketch graphs" when e.g. planning an expensive purchase or reading the news?
No business owner is going to survive if they don't understand how to solve a system of equations (aka figure out feasible pricing before losing all their money). Although we are on a tech VC's news site, so I stand corrected ;-)
Being an informed citizen capable of taking care of yourself does require most of the things taught in middle/high school algebra. (Which are the same exact things taught in CC algebra.) A surprising amount of financial suffering is self-imposed by people who can't or won't do very basic math.
Indeed! Requiring _less_ math is a frightening idea to me, in a system of government in which nearly everyone has the right to vote. Properly understanding even the most basic information that informs policy decisions often requires a more advanced understanding than algebra.
Definitely. Math is typically taught really, really poorly until at least university. It's not uncommon to find STEM phds who "hated math" before making it to or even past calculus.
It's really funny how helpful the "_" or "cloud" trick is for kids. Even high school kids in AP Calculus find it helpful.
There is a "hump" where "_" vs. "x" doesn't seem to help much, e.g. where we start working with polynomials as more abstract things and so on. I think the right approach there is to make a lot more use of computer algebra.
The point is "here's a generic tool that's useful in lots of specific circumstances", but students get lost during hours of practicing the "useless generic tool" before seeing why that general tool is useful. Computer algebra systems can help there.
FWIW that "simple arithmetic and statistics" is the sort of stuff that's taught in college algebra.
We're not talking about teaching everyone Calculus or Group Theory. We're talking about making sure everyone knows what they should've learned in their middle and high school algebra course.
> People should be forced to take [A financial planning course]
No one should be forced to take such a useless course. Learn algebra and all the non-ephemeral aspects of basic financial planning comes basically for free.
> Knowing how to save money on tax returns
Talk about ephemeral knowledge!
> how to calculate a budget
...is literally the first example used in a lot of college algebra courses.
All of these are literally the sorts of things you'd find on homework assignments and final exams in a community college algebra course... You do need algebra, and don't realize how difficult this "trivial" algebra is for some students because you can do it without even realizing you're doing it.
I mean, there will be some FOIL and quadratic equation examples as well. And a bunch of stuff in-between like identifying graphs of functions.
But CC Algebra is super bimodal, so it's probably not the case that students are nailing these word problems and only failing with the other stuff.
> However, if I had to pick one mathematical subject everyone should learn, it wouldn't be algebra, it would be statistics.
This isn't algebra in the "groups and rings" sense, it's algebra in the "use the quadratic equation", "is this a graph of x or x^2 or x^3?", "FOIL" sense. Think middle school or early high school.
It's basically impossible to do any statistics past a bit of hand waving if your students can't identify the difference between a graph of x and a graph of x^2...
We're not talking about "strong" math skills. IME most kids who will go on to take AP Calculus mastered at least half of the material covered in a CC Algebra course before even starting high school.
> People are far more likely to benefit economically from strong communication skills than strong math skills
I'm not entirely sure this is true in many local economies. Especially outside of cities, communication isn't as important as competency in skills/trades. And a lot of those skills/trades require a functional understanding of elementary mathematical objects -- understanding ratios, functions, some useful trig properties, and the ability to follow complicated directions (algorithms) precisely are all basic core competencies for most trades.
The article is probably correct -- we could stand to have alternatives to the standard CC algebra course. But an effectively similar level of quantitative skill is required for most trades. And no amount of "pretty talkin'" will prep you for, e.g., CNC machining.
And a lot of those skills/trades require a functional understanding of elementary mathematical objects -- understanding ratios, functions, some useful trig properties, and the ability to follow complicated directions (algorithms) precisely are all basic core competencies for most trades.
Which trades are you referring to? Truck driving? Retail? Cashiers? Secretaries? Managers, sales reps, school teachers, janitors, waiters, cooks, customer service, freight laborers, stock clerks, maids, receptionists, construction laborers, child care workers, grounds maintenance?
None of those require a wit of algebra. Yet they represent tens of millions of jobs.
It's not good to divorce ourselves too far from the reality of most normal peoples' lives.
None of those are skills (except maybe truck driving). And none of them require a CC degree. Those are all things you do with a GED or less.
I'm thinking of the sorts of things people go to CC for. Dental Hygiene, Paramedics, EMTs, Morgue work, Respiratory therapists et al, various medical diagnostic technicians, vet techs, nursing, CNC, Engineering technicians, etc. Visit your local CC website and look through their programs of study.
> Managers
Depends. Engineering? Construction? Absolutely.
Again, we're not talk about groups and rings. We're talking about stuff like knowing the difference between x and x^2.
> sales reps ... customer service
Outside of cities there are a lot fewer sales jobs... and a lot of them require BA/BS just because they can.
> school teachers
STEM teachers need a LOT more than just CC algebra. At least Calculus. The algebra taught in CC's was once taught in high school, but is now often taught in middle school. Middle school science curricula have kept pace. So, yes, any STEM teacher -- even at the elementary level these days -- needs to know basic algebra.
> janitors, waiters, cooks
Not skills and/or don't require CC, and so irrelevant to this conversation.
> freight laborers, stock clerks, maids, receptionists, construction laborers, child care workers, grounds maintenance?
Again, not skills, and for the most part don't require CC.
I think we're both throwing a bit at the wall to see what sticks. :)
It's sobering to see all of the job types listed out like that though, isn't it? Our combined lists represent most peoples' options. Kind of strange to think about.
I think we'll have to agree to disagree that morgue keepers or dental hygienicists benefit from even a little bit of algebra, though.
> Our combined lists represent most peoples' options. Kind of strange to think about.
To re-iterate, most of the jobs you listed do not require a Community College degree!
Whether a truck driver or store clerk needs algebra is utterly irrelevant. People doing those jobs are not required to have -- and usually do not have -- community college degrees. Their needs are irrelevant in a discussion about community college curricula.
Regarding my examples, I'm not "seeing what sticks". I'm literally just listing what are pretty much uniformly the most popular programs at most community colleges. Again, look up enrollment and funding statistics for some of your local CC's.
> dental hygienicists
Again, I think you're over-estimating the difficulty of the material that students need to master in order to pass community college algebra.
As I said in my original post:
>>> The article is probably correct -- we could stand to have alternatives to the standard CC algebra course. But an effectively similar level of quantitative skill is required for most trades.
I think that's spot on for dental hygenists. They absolutely have to understand ratios, for example, and that's one major stumbling block for CC Algebra students.
So do they need CC Algebra? Maybe, maybe not. But IMO a course covering only the portions they do absolutely need is going to be just as much a stumbling block for these students.
Tell that to Ross Ulbricht. Anonymity is not a guarantee of immunity from the long arm and unforgiving memory of the law. Especially in the United States.