Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

This is really great. All the existing "program in minecraft" solutions were pretty hacky IMO; lots of cruft to work around, which is really bad for my target audience of middle school students.


Adopt.


> It a requirement for becoming an adult leader within the BSA

Religious belief is also sometimes required to become an Eagle Scout. See e.g.,

https://blog.scoutingmagazine.org/2014/10/03/belief-in-god-s...

"We have all likely heard horror stories of boys being asked in their Eagle Scout board of review about how they have done their “duty to God,” only to have the youth say they don’t believe in God. Equally disappointing is the example I heard of recently of an Eagle Scout who publicly admitted that he simply lied when asked about “duty to God” in his board of review."

The position that "you can define god however you want!" is common, and I'm not really sure how that position is any less dishonest than just straight up lying about believing in God. It's also not the case that you can always take on a leadership position -- any leadership position -- in the scouts without belief in God. There seems to be a myriad of opinions and practices, ranging from openly accepting to openly hostile. But the assertion that you can be always be a scout -- let alone take on leadership positions -- while being openly atheist doesn't match my experience.

> As a former scout (an Eagle Scout)

As a former scout who dropped out well before becoming an Eagle Scout in large part because my religious beliefs were unambiguously unwelcome locally, and IMO also nationally, I disagree.


> As a former scout who dropped out well before becoming an Eagle Scout in large part because my religious beliefs were unambiguously unwelcome locally, and IMO also nationally, I disagree.

Sorry to hear that was your experience. I started scouting in the midwest (where everyone assumed you were a christian weather you were or not) and moved to the Seattle area (where nobody cared). I never had anyone shove a bible in my face and demand I witness.


> The position that "you can define god however you want!" is common

It's very common in 12 step methods. The text uses the term "higher power" - I think most people have their God as their higher power, others use their sober self, or something else they care greatly about.


> Science is about observation and deriving insights and rules from what you see

Is mathematics a science?

How about mathematics within a pre-defined discipline (e.g., doing novel work on group theory without inventing new axioms/structures)? Is that science?

If you include mathematics in the sciences, which I think we should, then it's hard to see how video game development is non-scientific.

(Besides which, the old trope about AI applies also to science. AI is AI until it becomes useful, then it's no longer AI and becomes some other branch of CS. All of engineering is science until it becomes useful, then it's no longer science but some branch of engineering.)

> video games is largely more of an engineering problem that typical science/exploration.

For one, video games are a great way to understand the strengths and limitations of simulation in science. And basically all fields of science these days have a corresponding field of computational science focused on using simulations to better understand the underlying science. So, it's important.


> Is mathematics a science?

No, it's purely analytical, not empirical. Mathematics provides essential tools used in science, but is not science.


Well then ekianjo's argument is even weaker, because "STEM" now clearly includes at least one thing that is unambiguously not "science"...

(besides which, there are some obvious problems here -- not least of which is that many sciences rely on mathematical objects in probability and statistics to determine what is and is not true about observations. IMO modern science is inseparable from mathematics, and concrete mathematical objects form most of the philosophical substrate of modern scientific practice... so, if "science" is separated from "mathematics", that's only the case in some primitive high school understanding of how modern science is actually performed in reality. Maybe that's a problem with how science is performed in reality, but AFAICT it seems to be working pretty well in most areas with some notable huge exceptions.)


It would be kind of silly to say “Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math” if the latter three were subsets of the former rather than related (and sometimes overlapping) but distinct categories.


Sure, I think we're agreeing on the question at hand.


FWIW there's a huge difference between "sorry, but this is a safe space for religious people" and "if you're not a religious person then you can't be a good American".

I don't think anyone has a problem with the former. But yes, the latter is... worthy of criticism, especially from engineers and scientists who pay attention to things like empirical counter-examples. Maybe not bigoted, but also clearly false.


As a scout I agreed to it vacuously. No God, no obligation, and it's not that hard to fulfill a vacuous obligation. I'm sure that's not what they meant, but I figured "be friendly" and "tell kids that homosexuals are unclean rapists" [1,2,3] were also obviously contradictory in spirit.

If they get political cop-outs from their pledges, then so do I.

[1] unclean: "We believe that homosexual conduct is inconsistent with the requirement in the Scout Oath that a Scout be morally straight and in the Scout Law that a Scout be clean in word and deed, and that homosexuals do not provide a desirable role model for Scouts.” https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/99-699.ZO.html

[2] rapists: E.g., http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/gordon-klingenschmitt-bo...

[3] To their credit, BSA has since modernized its policy and, hopefully, this remains a minority voice. But still, a large and vocal minority IME.


This. A long-weekend backpacking trip can easily cost between $20 and $100 per person, depending on: distance traveled and size of cars, tolls, number of days on the trail, whether you need perishables such as fuel for cooking and water filters (often weather and trail dependent), meals eaten on the road, trail passes or campground fees, rental fees if you're planning on floating a portion of the trip, etc. Up-front purchases (e.g., backpack, boots) need to be accounted for as well. Also really basic stuff like "do we have enough cash to pay for campsites along the way".

It's a great opportunity to teach basic accounting skills. Simple stuff: summing costs, figuring out which costs are shared by the group and which ones individuals should be responsible for, planning ahead for forms of payment. More advanced: amortization of big expenses across N years of trips (and related cash flow issues), parameterizing cost calculations over weather conditions and terrain, doing all of this in a spreadsheet so that when we do the trip next year we can change some values and know immediately how much it'll cost, etc.


Noticeably, neither organization mentions "outdoorsy skills" in its vision. Both discuss good citizenship, but exactly what that means is only stated in very subjective terms. And once you go past the platitudes, all the subjective details start dominating.

If you read through the BSA oath and law, you'll find a lot of subjective words. "Loyal" (to who?). Friendly (to who?). Obedient (to what law/rules?). Brave (in the face of which adversities?). Clean (holy shit is this a loaded word in Christendom... official BSA position as recent as 2012 was that homosexuality is "unclean" -- a position that IMO completely undermines the entire oath by opening every entirely subjective word up to politically motivated interpretation). "mentally awake and morally straight" are obviously totally subjective.

GSA uses similar words, but do they mean the same thing? I don't think so. As national organizations, I think the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts are trying to support/develop/foster fundamentally different types of people. These national politics are often, but not always, mirrored in local troops.

FWIW, I do agree that scouting should primarily focus on outdoors activities and irrefutable moral goods mostly disconnected from the culture wars (don't lie/cheat/steal as a general rule; understand how your government works; be a helpful force in your community).

And it does seem like things are slowly moving that way, as national organizations realize it's not in their best interest to inject themselves into culture wars. And a lot of troops have always managed to do exactly that. But others (e.g., my bsa troop as a child) spend a lot of time on religious and social indoctrination.

So, BSA and GSA really are different organizations with different goals, because all the words their missions share are totally subjective, and each organization interprets those subjective words differently. At least at the national level. And those differences are mirrored in many localities.


For me, this is the most interesting question. I suspect this was illegal, though. CFAA is pretty broad for exactly this reason -- the effect and intent, not the vector -- is what matters.


Why would the CFAA[1] apply? I don't think US law is the governing law for everything that happens on the Internet (though they'd probably love that...).

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act


You mean jurisdictionally? E.g. if the hacker was located in the US, or in one of the many, many countries with an extradition agreement since some of those distributed computations almost certainly occurred in the us. Or in one of the many, many countries whose hacking laws are explicitly modeled on cfaa...


> that formal proofs are not mandatory tools in this space

The stakes are extraordinarily low relative to situations where formal proofs are mandatory. For references, the list price of a single new 737 runs in the 50 million range, and the cost of the software for the 737 is amortized across many thousands of planes.

1. That's actual hard money. Real US dollars you can use to buy yachts and houses and avocado toast. Given the level of hype and amount of speculation, the true value of all the ether in the world is obviously considerably less than Ethereum's market cap. The hacker stole $30M 'worth' of ether, not 30M actual dollars

2. The cost of a plane crash is easily 10x the price of the plane, and of course you can't put a price on the lost souls.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: