Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

Just to be clear, this is LITERALLY equating business success with ethical/legal conduct.


> Just to be clear, this is LITERALLY equating business success with ethical/legal conduct.

No, it's equating restitution and intent with lenient sentencing.

Even if I grant that he intended to defraud people initially (which doesn't appear to be the case), that's still analogous to if someone stole your car, but later had a change of conscience, returned it, and had also fixed your dents and given it a new paint job to make amends. Are they guilty of theft? Yes. Should they be punished? Probably. Should they get the same punishment as someone who stole your car and crashed it, or stole it and sold it? I don't think so. That's leniency. You may have a different opinion.


> It was kinda sleazy to see the congress question him about his price increases when they knew damn well it was perfectly legal and they haven't done anything to stop it

Lots of things are legal uses of taxpayer money.

Lots of things aren't illegal but are worthy of public condemnation.

The intersection of those things are EXACTLY the sorts of things I want my congress people going after.

Do you disagree, or do you just like seeing things burn?


The point is that the system should be fixed, not just "condemn" someone for abusing it. If it's legal to do something unconscionable then that legality should change.


> armed robbery (30 years... his friends... all got probation

Those are both extremely inappropriate, tbf...


I used to say stuff like this, but honestly... don't. If you're mentoring a young impressionable mathematician, explain the trade-offs in pure vs applied work, and explain how to determine which pure math is likely to be helpful in their useful lifetime.

Besides, "pure" and "applied" distinction is hilariously subjective and stupid. IME a lot of theoretical CS is more-or-less accurately characterized "pure math" and also far more financially remunerative than the bullshitty pointless PDE hacking lots of "applied math" folks do. Pure vs. applied is a stupid perspective these days because it almost exclusively defines a delineation among communities of mathematicians during the late 20th century; "useful in the next 3 years to ad tech folks" vs. "long-term/foundational importance in science and engineering" is a more useful and relevant distinction.

But once people choose to focus on pure mathematics, don't shit on them for making that choice. They KNOW it's not a great financial commitment. It's like telling a committed humanist that "no one pays for poetry". Like, they get it already... (and besides, sometimes you're wrong and then you're that asshole that always doubted them.)

Plus, plenty of pure mathematicians make high five/low six figures working 12 months with free trips all over the world. Or 9 months without the trips but with 3 months of freetime every year. And in both cases with near perfect job security. They don't have any social currency in the startup $$$$$$ obsessed world, but I bet they spend a fuckload more time with their kids and enjoy a lot more sunsets than any of startup founders. And probably make more money than the 90% of "failure cases" in the startup world too...

This article is great case-in-point. All the profiled folks are sure to live very comfortable lives doing work they love patronized by lovers of the mathematical arts (or anyways live off of rich endowments one way or the other) without ever having to figure out how to nickle and dime customers.

And none of this is to say that building businesses isn't valuable, since that's more-or-less taken for granted by the current venue. But it takes all types.


I was not really running down pure math. Indeed, see my post below where I explained that some pure math is crucial to my startup.

I was saying that I, personally, find foundations as in the OP down in the basement, dark and too far from applications in any sense.

For making money as a full prof of math, first have to get there, and that usually takes over 10 years if make it at all. Yes, it's possible to play the academic game; heck one paper in math I published is pretty, surprising, etc. but I can't imagine that it will ever be useful directly or even indirectly even by several steps of indirection for the foreseeable future if ever. I've seen people publish such things and make some progress in an academic career; to me that's playing an academic game; I chose not to do that.

When I was a prof (I didn't want to be but did it for a while trying to help my wife in her illness), it seemed to me that I was getting paid by students, pizza parlor owners and workers, auto dealership owners and workers, farmers, etc., and for them I wanted my work and teaching to be useful -- to me, personal curiosity, art, etc. didn't count. I really wanted the department to be clinical, professional, practical, like law and medicine, i.e., welcome people from outside academics with real problems and then seek to solve those problems. When can't solve a problem, then maybe that will be a good research direction; if make good progress, then already have one application!

For applied math, determine that not by PDEs but by what can find that is useful. Early in my career around DC for mostly US national security, I found lots of such applied math. And my startup, while more focused, is basically some applied math. PDEs? I had very little to do with those; the one case was the Navier-Stokes equations, and they were so difficult to work with that the project wasn't making much progress and I was pleased to move on to other topics.

It's not easy to see what pure math is the more useful. For the pure math I do respect, especially for utility, it appears that in some vague, large sense the results are fundamental, important broadly, and, eventually, inescapably relevant, but that is a difficult judgment call. Functional analysis? Sure. Algebraic geometry? Less sure. Foundations? Slim chance.

I was not trying to give career advice to other people possibly interested in math but just commenting that I found the foundations as deep as in the OP just too far down in a dark basement. In math, that's an old remark about foundations -- "Drop what you are doing trying to be useful and come with me down into the dark basement and wrestle with really subtle issues down there." Standard, old remark in math.

You read lots of stuff between the lines I wrote, stuff not really there.


Who gets to decide what is and isn't useful? Number theory was the most useless of mathematics for a long time; interesting for sure, but not applicable in any sense. Then we discovered applications to crypto, and now the security and privacy of the entire digital world depends on number theory. You mention the questionable applicability of algebraic geometry, yet elliptic curves are incredibly important for efficient crypto.

Let's take an example from TCS: Quantum computers. Initially, they were only a theoretical exploration of the the additional power (if any) that Quantum mechanics can give in computing things. Then Shor came around and shook up our understanding of the world.

Many such examples abound in the world of mathematics. And lastly, even if a subfield provides no use to "common" humans, how should that matter? People should be free to study what they want.


I was giving my opinion for myself and not "deciding" for anyone else.

> Who gets to decide what is and isn't useful?

There is a recipe for rabbit stew that starts out "First catch a rabbit". Well my own recipe for applied math starts out "First find an application."

I don't define applied math as just mathematical physics or its connections with, say, mechanical or electrical engineering.

For me, applied math is math that has been applied. Sure, you mention number theory and cryptography; so, now at least in part they are applied math. There is also finite fields and error correcting codes -- I took a whole grad course on coding theory. I had a good background in abstract algebra and was torqued that the prof was sloppy with the math. But coding theory is important, and for me that makes abstract algebra applied math. Just how R. Hamming saw to use finite field theory I don't know -- curious insight. My undergraduate honors paper was on group representation theory, and that is applied math at least for its connections with molecular spectroscopy. In fact, my work was stimulated by some people from the chemistry department that came to the math department for help with group representation theory. IIRC, the quantum mechanics part was in part from E. Wigner.

> And lastly, even if a subfield provides no use to "common" humans, how should that matter?

If the work is being paid for, then commonly it matters a LOT to some of the people paying for it.

> People should be free to study what they want.

Of course. For some years, I studied violin. I made some progress but set violin aside to have more time for my startup. Ah, but, no one paid me for studying violiin!

People misread my post: First, the only math I was criticizing was foundations as deep as in the OP. Second, my criticism was only for my own personal values and opinion. Sure, maybe work in Ramsey theory will be as important in applications as the Riemann integral -- I doubt it, but maybe.

I spent some months in that dark basement; others are welcome to do that if they wish; I wish I hadn't and wouldn't do it again.


Defining "applied math" as mathematics that has found applications is disingenous, IMO; what is and isn't applied can change rapidly in the course of a few years. A number theorist can go from pure to applied because someone else found an application of work done by other people in his field?

Taking an example from TCS: Probabilistically checkable proofs. They allow you to encode a proof for a statement so that you checking the proof requires looking at in only a few locations. Back when they were conceived, in the early 90s, all constructions were efficient only asymptotically, with galactic constants. Only in the past 2 years have constructions of PCPs been realized that are sufficiently efficient for (some) applications to checking program executions.

PCPs were for years what most theorists would consider a core theoretical object with not many hopes of finding application, and indeed 99% of research in the field focused on "negative" uses of PCPs for finding hardness of approximation results.

> If the work is being paid for, then commonly it matters a LOT to some of the people paying for it.

What makes an industry with a lot of money in it, like online advertising, worth more than study of something completely theoretical?


> Defining "applied math" as mathematics that has found applications is disingenuous, IMO; what is and isn't applied can change rapidly in the course of a few years.

Not "disingenuous" at all: I want to apply math, especially to making money. To make money is the main reason I studied math; I wanted math to help my career, to make money, to support a family. If not math, then maybe physics, some part of engineering, etc.

> what is and isn't applied can change rapidly in the course of a few years.

My experience is that that doesn't happen very often. But again, once again, over again, yet again, I am not, Not, NOT, N.O.T. -- clear enough -- running down pure math. NOT doing that. I just wrote that foundations as in the OP was too far from applications for me. I have been totally, overwhelmingly, crystal clear about this point in this thread, and there was nothing in my first post that ran down pure math. Again, yet again, ..., I was talking about my view for me of foundations such as in the OP. You misread my first post and didn't read my other posts.

If someone found some applications for PCPs, then good for them, and that makes PCPs applied math.

Better techniques for proofs of correctness obviously would be good work in computer science with plenty of valuable applications.

> What makes an industry with a lot of money in it, like online advertising, worth more than study of something completely theoretical?

Nothing, but most sources of financial investment want a financial return. That's much of how our economy works.

To be blunt and frank, Congress votes money for math mostly for US national security and because of the role of math in WWII and off and on since then. If some people at the NIH tells Congress that they like math, too, then that will help. But the remark at the beginning of the movie on Nash is basically correct: "Mathematics won WWII". Congress can be slow on the uptake, but they tend to believe that math did win WWII and had a big role in GPS, Keyhole, stealth, design of the core of fission and fusion bombs, etc. Congress takes US national security quite seriously. The other biggie for Congress is the NIH -- if only because most people in Congress have gray hair and want research that will help them if they get sick.

It remains, if you want a job in math, especially connected with computing, then those jobs are still where I started my career (and should have stayed there) within 100 miles of the Washington Monument.


> not so the reverse

That big grey text on the right of each arxiv paper is actually a link you can click form the pdf. Took make like N->\inf years to figure that out...

I used to complain about how heavy pdf docs are and therefore preferred websites that contained some metadata with a link to actual content, but websites these days... and at least the .pdf honestly downloads on anroid/iPhone, which are the only two platforms where I honestly care about bandwidth (and even then...)


I think the most interesting way to sort this data is not by "total atmospheric reduction" but rather by "savings". I.e., where do the economic and ecological incentives align?

EVs and Wind & Solar are unsurprising gold/silver/bronze winners.

District Heating is an interesting idea I had never thought of. And it synthesizes well with other top winners outside of the energy production space, most of which boil down to "improved density and less moving around".

IMO these are all big wins from a lifestyle perspective as well, all other things equal (of course, not all other things are equal in most places -- schooling, safety, etc.)


I think the traffic sign example was a nice setting for explaining the research. But of course really good examples always risk interfering with communication as much as they assist communication. I think that might've happened here.

Concretely, I have a hard time believing that adversarial traffic signs will be the Achilles heel of self-driving cars. Vandalizing signs is already illegal, and if doing so causes or was intended to cause a crash, law enforcement will throw the book at the culprit. And this already happens to human drivers. See e.g., http://globegazette.com/news/local/prank-turns-to-peril-vand... or http://articles.latimes.com/1997-06-11/news/mn-2303_1_one-st...

Besides which, you can also just rip the sign out of the ground or replace the stop sign with an actual speed limit sign. From a SDC perspective, this is kind of the equivalent of using super clever software vulnerabilities when you have physical access to an un-encrypted HDD. Impressive technical tour de force, but misses the forest for the trees if your goal is security.

Traffic sign vandalism is a social problem with a social solution. The first person who tries something like this in production with malicious intent toward SDCs will be charged with some variation of attempted or actual manslaughter/murder and opponents of SDCs will switch to strategies other than domestic terrorism to advance their agenda.

This research is still very interesting and useful, of course, but primarily for other reasons. I just don't see traffic sign vandalism intended to confuse DNNs as a serious -- or unique -- threat to self-driving cars.


> Traffic sign vandalism is a social problem with a social solution. The first person who tries something like this in production with malicious intent toward SDCs will be charged with some variation of attempted or actual manslaughter/murder and opponents of SDCs will switch to strategies other than domestic terrorism to advance their agenda.

It's tunnelvision to assume that the only attackers would be individual radical luddites. There do exist terrorist organizations and state actors who intend to run risks to do damage. And unless you're planning to monitor and respond quickly to all potential threats to all stop signs at all times (and all other possible attacks), what's to stop a group of 40 terrorists from covering their faces, stealing motorcycles, and putting 10,000 stickers on 10,000 signs in 10,000 intersections in 20 different cities in 1 night?


What's to stop 40 terrorists from covering their faces, stealing motorcycles, and clipping brake cables (whatever you get the point...) on 10,000 cars parked along 10,000 streets in 20 different cities in 1 night?

...Or just blowing up a shitload of random houses or whatever.

Basically, the exact same thing as what would stop your scenario. Is it perfect? Even good? Again, no. But striving for good security in a public setting is how you get TSA.

If there are 40 committed and sophisticated terrorists willing to act, there are a lot of easier targets...

Again, I think the "clever localhost software vuln" analogy is apt. It's not that this isn't one possible attack vector. And no attack vector should be ignored. But... really?


I think there is a point here that is being overlooked. The vandalism, a couple of small stickers, would be less detectable compared with a whole missing sign.

I can see such attack methods evolving to produce undetectetable (to humans without software) adversarial images.


I'm not saying we shouldn't practice defense in depth where it's possible.

It's just that I don't think preventing this style of attack is actually the most relevant/impactful application of this style of research.

Again, I'm not saying this research is irrelevant. I'm saying it's way more relevant than this particular example implies.

> would be less detectable compared with a whole missing sign.

This kind of assumes that the attack wouldn't work in the first place, no? If cars are crashing people are going to investigate to figure out why, and even the most thick-skulled beat cop can figure out that stop signs with rando weird ass stickers on them are probably worth running up the chain...


> This kind of assumes that the attack wouldn't work in the first place, no? If cars are crashing people are going to investigate to figure out why, and even the most thick-skulled beat cop can figure out that stop signs with rando weird ass stickers on them are probably worth running up the chain...

1. That attack may not target only self-driving cars.

2. Imagine someone driving around with some random picture on their car at the back. Except that the picture is an attack.


> neoliberal

Rorty was not a neoliberal in any honest sense of the word. He was a liberal and a progressive, to be sure, but was decidedly not a neoliberal.

If you're confused about what "neoliberal" means, think "the intersection of things that Clinton and Reagan had in common", not "the things right-wing US commentators call liberal". Most true neoliberals in Congress are on the red team, for example.

Literally the only place I can find Rorty himself described as a neoliberal is in some Marxist critique of something or other. And those authors doesn't even make it through their criticism of Rorty without a blatant grammatical error, leading me to believe they don't take their characterization very seriously.


I mean, all warehouse work sucks. It's $12-15/hr work with literally zero educational requirements and no people skills required. Any warehouse job paying more than $10 is going to be fairly miserable.

Is Amazon evil? Maybe. But no more or less evil than most every other organization that runs a large warehouse.


Appaling thinking.

Firstly, I don't know that all warehouse work sucks. Post an assessment that shows this are the widespread conditions in the industry, or at least other examples of companies doing the same.

Secondly, if that were the case, it would be only more reason to be outraged! What, companies paying workers under minimum wage (as low as 2.70£ an hour), treating their employees as cattle without the bare minimum conditions of dignity, all the while making its CEO the richest man on earth? We're supposed to be okay with this?? Shrug our shoulders and say "eh maybe they're evil, so what", say "a company that makes 150,000,000,000$ a year can't pay its workers minimum wage, their work will be miserable but that's life"?

What an appalling way to see things.


> Post an assessment that shows this are the widespread conditions in the industry, or at least other examples of companies doing the same.

What? Hot summers with lots of heavy lifting and long shifts for low pay, all while being treated by management as a completely replaceable cog (because at-will employment, union busting, and the low-skill nature of the job means YOU ACTUALLY ARE a replaceable cog)? That's warehouse work.

I'm not even sure if there are studies about this because it's just... completely common knowledge among the populations who work these jobs. Here's a blog post for example from 2011, describing exactly this conditions at probably-not-amazon from a former employee. Note he talks in broad strokes -- not "my employer sucked", but "warehouse work sucks". https://warehousetomarketer.wordpress.com/2011/07/03/warehou...

> What an appalling way to see things.

I'm not making a moral judgement. I'm describing reality. I don't think positive descriptions of reality can ever be appalling, unless your goal is to bury your head in the sand.

Focusing on Amazon doesn't solve the problem because Amazon is not the problem. They're just one more employer behaving the same way as all the other employers, in a system that explicitly allows and even incentivizes this behavior.

Realizing that working conditions for low-skill blue collar folk are systematically crappy, and that we need a systematic solution, is not "appalling". It's realistic and pragmatic.

Besides which, counting on the beneficence of particular corporations and/or particular instances of PR pressure has never been a sustainable method for producing good working conditions or livable wages.

Focusing on specific company's workers instead of focusing on systematic improvements to the negotiating power of labor is what's appalling. It takes a serious political problem and turns it into a corporate PR problem that's solvable without addressing the underlying problems. Because the empirically effective PR expenditures -- installing air conditioning, clamping down on loud mouths, token improvements to workplace culture, marginally shorter shifts... none of this makes manual labor on $12/hr with zero workplace protections and a minimal social safety net any less dehumanizing.

(And Bezos's net work has absolutely nothing to do with whether working conditions in warehouses suck -- IDC if the CEO is making 100K or 100B, and neither do the employees working in the warehouse because their job sucks just as much either way.(


>Focusing on Amazon doesn't solve the problem because Amazon is not the problem. They're just one more employer behaving the same way as all the other employers, in a system that explicitly allows and even incentivizes this behavior.

Fair enough, you changed my mind in that regard (if indeed it is the case that this is the widespread situation in the warehouse industry, which, again, I'm not convinced of based on word-of-mouth or one single blog post; nonetheless I will look into it).

What I was referring to as appalling, though, is the idea that this is somehow okay, somehow excusable, somehow not scandalous, either because "everyone does it", or because "it's unqualified labour", or any other excuse. There is no excuse. A company, furthermore one so obscenely profitable for its owners, absolutely cannot be allowed to operate this way and to treat their workers this way. That is what I classify as appalling. We the people cannot indifferently let that slide. We can give no rest, else the balance shifts entirely to their favour.


> the news with his name stops the day he was arrested.

That's usually a good sign that nothing exciting happened; business as usual.

He was arrested in early June and by early July was on parole with family in Seattle:

http://databank.isranet.org/article.asp?article=64465

After which terror charges were never filed and the gov't began seeking deportation on extraordinarily pedestrian grounds, with his lawyer speaking publicly about the case:

http://www.kolkenandkolken.com/index.php?src=news&srctype=de...

Can't find anything after that, but he's not listed in the USCIS's Online Detainee Locator System and AFAIK could not have been legally deported to Somalia.

WikiLeaks documents on him, combined with other sources, paint a picture that he's either a) a somewhat prolific terrorist/human trafficker; or b) a politically active Muslim immigrant in the USA who might be kinda sorta guilty of some clerical crimes and may've acted a teensy bit dodgy when returning to the USA. (b) is probably way more likely given that DHS was apparently OK releasing him on parole.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: