Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

FWIW I think this is a very fair question. Parent's post veers a bit further toward defeatism than I think Smith's paper advocates for or justifies. In particular, of course the DAO hack wasn't inevitable -- a more careful programmer could've foreseen and prevented that attack and whole other classes of attack.


Part of the linked paper's point is that because computer systems involve many "levels of failure", even a more careful programmer cannot usually rule out every class of programs. The DAO hack, yes, possibly.

But, for example, people have also lost money due to bugs in the Solidity compiler: https://np.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/5foa5p/daily_disc... How many "more careful" Ethereum programmers also check the compiler for correctness?

Another paper in this vein is James Fetzer's "Program Verification: The Very Idea". http://lore.ua.ac.be/Teaching/SSPEC2LIC/critique2.pdf


> Part of the linked paper's point is that because computer systems involve many "levels of failure", even a more careful programmer cannot usually rule out every class of programs.

But -- and this is the crucial point -- that doesn't mean we shouldn't strive to be better than we are now.

The impossibility of perfectly modeling the world hasn't prevented us from making enormous progress on software safety and security over the past 30 odd years. Today, if you care to, you can easily write code that is free of buffer overflows and command injection attacks. In the 00's SQL injection attacks were extremely easy to find; now they're comparatively rare.

Smith's paper tells us that code-as-law is probably a bad idea. But it is not -- and wasn't intended to be -- an indict of static analysis or model-based engineering more generally. Every structural engineer knows the difference between a bridge and a model of a bridge; a paper pointing out the difference without substantively critiquing the practical usefulness of a particular type of model would probably elicit eye-rolls. I'm not sure why these mundane observations receive such attention in computer science. Maybe because with software the model and the system look so similar.

But to be sure, the impossibility of codifying human morality is a pretty lame excuse for failing to use static analysis tools or better languages or quality frameworks to prevent known classes of attacks. So I doubt that's what Smith is advocating.

> How many "more careful" Ethereum programmers also check the compiler for correctness?

Yes, we should obviously check compilers for correctness, and we're making slow but sure progress toward a world where our critical infrastructure comes with strong -- of course, never perfect -- correctness guarantees.


> But -- and this is the crucial point -- that doesn't mean we shouldn't strive to be better than we are now.

Agreed! And I also agree that we are really making progress. But we're far from a world where people can crank out provably correct code (let alone the proofs).

> I'm not sure why these mundane observations receive such attention in computer science. Maybe because with software the model and the system look so similar.

Excellent point, and yes, I think that is the problem. Modeling the world in code is not much different from... er... modeling the world in code :-)


> Part of the linked paper's point is that because computer systems involve many "levels of failure", even a more careful programmer cannot usually rule out every class of programs.

The programmer only has to comply with the specification. The specification is a finite syntactic entity. If the specification doesn't capture what the user really wants, or compliance is undecidable, or <insert problem beyond the programmer's control here>, then the one at fault is the specification writer, not the programmer.


Given how bad the tooling is for Eth right now, it probably was inevitable. Their tooling isn't just a mess semantically and syntactically, it's was riddled with double-operation bugs.


> Do you not see the inherent difference...

No. Things that get banned almost always have significant political content.

Homosexual content (not necc. porn) comes to mind as a perfect example of "whole classes of goods and services" that are also very much political speech. "obscene speech" (see The Howl trial) is another famous example of an attempt to re-brand "political speech" as an apolitical "whole class of goods and services".

Taking some class of controversial goods and services and branding it as "not political" is just begging the question. It's saying "this thing is so obviously bad that discussion of its acceptability is beyond the scope of our current politics." IMO saying something is "beyond politics" is the ultimate political judgement.


> No. Things that get banned almost always have significant political content.

If you look at list of banned goods and services, most of them are not politically related, but are related to liability, abuse potential and (probably) payment processor restrictions.

I'm not saying that banning whole classes of goods doesn't have an impact on free speech.

Yet there is still a fundamental difference between having a list of prohibited goods / services and removing a member selling allowed goods and services because you don't like their politics.

The first one is banning the sale of pornographic products on your platform, the second is banning the sale of (otherwise permissible) t-shirts by pornography companies on your platform.



From your link: "The law, however, never took effect, as three separate rounds of litigation led to a permanent injunction against the law in 2009."


> big internet companies are the utilities of today

IMO this is a dangerous conflation.

Many large internet companies are monopolies. Anti-trust mechanisms should be used to force competitive market places. But there are substantive differences between being the far-and-away best option in a competitive market place, and the sorts of things we typically call utilities.

This comment on a story about Shopify is even more disturbing. Amazon or Facebook or Google... okay. But Shopify?! Nothing about Shopify is utility-like. Shopify isn't even a monopoly, let alone a natural one.


> I just think it's fair for them to set terms of service that lay out what you can and can't do, and for those terms of service to have some moral backing to them, beyond simple legality.

This would make a great piece of cyberpunk dystopian fiction. Humanity in a far off future finds its codified moral compass not in religious texts, not in the spoken words of religious leaders, and certainly not in books written by philosophers. But rather, in corporate contracts copy-pasted together by Employee #5 at some hyper-growth startups during the Early Years.


The "top tier" has three options that are all basically equivalent in terms of quality:

google.com

bing.com

baidu.com

Other less popular but in many cases still excellent options include:

yandex.com

gigablast.com

lycos.com

askjeeves.com

duckduckgo.com

qwant.com

And the list goes on and on and on... these are just the "similar to google" search engines. There are also search engines for particular topics, search engines that take a different paradigm ("semantic search"), and with beer money you can even buy search engine+crawler software packages and build your own search engine for the portion of the web you care about.

And major sites like Wikipedia and Amazon and all the social sites have their own search features so you don't even need a third party search engine within most of the big silos.

If you're using google it's because either a) you want to use google; or b) you're monumentally lazy. Not because there aren't other options.

You can also write your own crawler and search engine. In fact, as literally all of these options demonstrate, with a surprisingly small amount of VC cash you could build your own "more than good enough" search engine. The same amount of cash probably wouldn't be nearly enough to build out a Verizon or Comcast competitor in even one city.

Conversely, I have exactly 3 options for ISPs in my area. One of them is the local equivalent of "build your own search engine" (and about similar quality). So actually 2 options -- Comcast and Verizon. There is no long tail of other providers, and what's more, there almost certainly never will be because acquiring the land rights would be enormously expensive. Oh and BTW I live in a major city; outside of cities you're even more screwed.

And even if we just limit ourselves to the "big best in class" search engines -- google, bing, baidu, duckduckgo -- that's still twice the number of options that most people have for ISP in the US.


> We're lucky there isn't much history of corporations having state-like scale + monopoly on legitimate violence. Super lucky.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company


I tend to not worry too much about situations where politicians take people's money and then say "FU" when those people ask for favors. (Which isn't always that case with democrats and NN, of course, just saying...)


Let's put the issue of Nazi speech being illegal in Germany aside for a moment.

If my lawyer yelled "Heil Hitler" and claimed the judge in my case should be murdered, while ostensibly defending me, I'd want them at the very least disbarred and wouldn't mind a bit of jail time.

BTW, I highly doubt a judge exhibiting this behavior in the USA would keep their law license, and they'd probably end up slapped with a contempt charge as well.

> The inside of a courtroom needs MORE protections for speech, not fewer

Perhaps for the defendant. But actually, in every country -- including the USA -- lawyers have extremely strong and often vague constraints on their speech.

And even then, what you're saying just isn't true, even in the USA. There are far more constraints on your speech during a trial than in the public square. Judges in the USA have extremely wide latitude in determining what can and cannot be said, how those things should be said, etc. Those are constraints that judges can enforce in their courtroom but cannot enforce in the public square.

Also, FWIW, knowingly committing libel during a trial is probably a bad idea. Even in the USA.

> disclaimer: in the US. Can't speak for how they do it in failed states like Germany

Well, if you consider Germany a failed state then I'm not really sure what to say. They have their problems, but then so does the USA. No place is perfect.

E.g., using your metric, the USA has THREE TIMES more rape than Germany. So if you put your identity politics aside for a second and look at the data, you come to a far different conclusion.

Also, IMO German citizens have a lot more practically useful freedoms than US citizens, even speech-related freedoms. "Don't be a Nazi" is something the Germans are pretty serious about, but they're a lot more lax about a lot of other speech that is de facto prohibited in many parts of the US. Eg, I seriously doubt Damore would've lost his job in Germany. And the Germans I talk to claim it'd be unambiguously illegal. And cultural self-censorship matters as well -- I'm much more comfortable discussing Christianity in Bavaria than in Alabama.

Germany draws their lines differently from the USA, but we're talking more about delineations at the fuzzy edges than actual differences in kind.

So again, if Germany is a failed state, I'm not really sure what a non-failed state looks like. At this point it's kind of hard for me to take you seriously.


> what you're saying just isn't true

Except that it is.

https://www.casamo.com/can-you-sue-for-defamation-during-tri...


The full quote is:

>> what you're saying just isn't true. There are far more constraints on your speech during a trial than in the public square.

Which, OBVIOUSLY, is responding to:

> The inside of a courtroom needs MORE protections for speech, not fewer, than the outside.

and NOT responding to:

> Laws like libel simply don't apply there

The object-level claim is that even with exceptions like that one you link to, speech is MORE LIMITED in court rooms than in the public square everywhere -- including the USA.

And yes, yelling that a judge should be murdered in open court would land a US lawyer in jail.

You're nit-picking (and what's more, nit-picking over a willful misinterpretation of the argument I'm making), not responding to the substantive object-level claim.


> In your opinion, how are the two situations different (CloudFlare vs The Florist)?

I think there are at least two distinctions.

The first and most important distinction is that it's actually very feasible to write laws that protect LGBT people. You can't discriminate on that basis, and it's very clear what discriminating on that basis means (well actually all discrimination is thorny and hard to prove/disprove, but LGBT and race exhibit the same set of issues, and we seem to be in agreement that we should figure out how to make racial discrimination illegal.)

Conversely, political belief is an almost impossibly fuzzy line, since at the end of the day pretty much everything is political.

For example, I think we can all agree that I should be allowed to refuse to serve customers who are being completely unreasonable and hostile assholes to me. This happens every Friday night at bars across the country.

But what if those people are being assholes by coming into my Jewish-owned-and-operated pharmacy and loudly talking about exterminating the Jews while buying a bar of soap? Clearly they are being assholes, but they're being assholes by being political. So, can I discriminate and tell them to leave? And if not, is it the case that now any asshole can talk about raunchy sex is a family restaurant or be a complete dick to the bar keep as long as they find a way to weave politics into their speech?

(BTW, apparently the turning point in this case was Daily Stormer or whatever claiming that CloudFlare secretly supports them. So in my mind this was closer to kicking someone out of the bar for being an asshole to management, rather than political discrimination. "You can be a nazi in my bar, but if you go around telling people that just because I let you talk about killing jews in my bar I'm somehow in on the neo-nazi movement, then you need to never come back here.")

So, the first distinction is that protecting LGBT is about as difficult as protecting racial classes but protecting political speech seems pretty intractable, form a legal perspective, without turning public spaces into unusable cesspools.

The second distinction -- and I do think this is a distinction that a free and just society is capable of making -- is the obvious difference between being gay and being a Nazi. E.g., Germany doesn't tolerate public support of Nazis and it's a fairly free and open society -- in some ways more free than the USA, even with respect to certain forms of speech. So for me the jury is out on whether that's a good or a bad idea, but we should at least stop treating "silencing Nazis leads to a terrible unfree society" like an axiom, since there are clear and obvious empirical counter-examples. This assertion without qualification is just false, end of story.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: